-
Is Bland-Altman plot method useful without inference for accuracy, precision, and agreement?
Authors:
P. S. P. Silveira,
J. E. Vieira,
J. O. Siqueira
Abstract:
Objective: Bland and Altman plot method is a widely cited and applied graphical approach for assessing the equivalence of quantitative measurement techniques, usually aiming to replace a traditional technique with a new, less invasive, or less expensive one. Although easy to communicate, Bland and Altman plot is often misinterpreted by lacking suitable inferential statistical support. Usual altern…
▽ More
Objective: Bland and Altman plot method is a widely cited and applied graphical approach for assessing the equivalence of quantitative measurement techniques, usually aiming to replace a traditional technique with a new, less invasive, or less expensive one. Although easy to communicate, Bland and Altman plot is often misinterpreted by lacking suitable inferential statistical support. Usual alternatives, such as Pearson's correlation or ordinal least-square linear regression, also fail to locate the weakness of each measurement technique. Method: Here, inferential statistics support for equivalence between measurement techniques is proposed in three nested tests based on structural regressions to assess the equivalence of structural means (accuracy), the equivalence of structural variances (precision), and concordance with the structural bisector line (agreement in measurements obtained from the same subject), by analytical methods and robust approach by bootstrap**. Graphical outputs are also implemented to follow Bland and Altman's principles for easy communication. Results: The performance of this method is shown and confronted with five data sets from previously published articles that applied Bland and Altman's method. One case demonstrated strict equivalence, three cases showed partial equivalence, and one showed poor equivalence. The developed R package containing open codes and data are available with installation instructions for free distribution at Harvard Dataverse at https://doi.org/10.7910/DVN/AGJPZH. It is possible to test whether two techniques may have full equivalence, preserving graphical communication according to Bland and Altman's principles, but adding robust and suitable inferential statistics. Decomposing the equivalence in accuracy, precision, and agreement helps the location of the source of the problem in order to fix a new technique.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2023; v1 submitted 29 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Deep Convolutional Neural Networks for Massive MIMO Fingerprint-Based Positioning
Authors:
Joao Vieira,
Erik Leitinger,
Muris Sarajlic,
Xuhong Li,
Fredrik Tufvesson
Abstract:
This paper provides an initial investigation on the application of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for fingerprint-based positioning using measured massive MIMO channels. When represented in appropriate domains, massive MIMO channels have a sparse structure which can be efficiently learned by CNNs for positioning purposes. We evaluate the positioning accuracy of state-of-the-art CNNs with cha…
▽ More
This paper provides an initial investigation on the application of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) for fingerprint-based positioning using measured massive MIMO channels. When represented in appropriate domains, massive MIMO channels have a sparse structure which can be efficiently learned by CNNs for positioning purposes. We evaluate the positioning accuracy of state-of-the-art CNNs with channel fingerprints generated from a channel model with a rich clustered structure: the COST 2100 channel model. We find that moderately deep CNNs can achieve fractional-wavelength positioning accuracies, provided that an enough representative data set is available for training.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Reciprocity Calibration for Massive MIMO: Proposal, Modeling and Validation
Authors:
Joao Vieira,
Fredrik Rusek,
Ove Edfors,
Steffen Malkowsky,
Liang Liu,
Fredrik Tufvesson
Abstract:
This paper presents a mutual coupling based calibration method for time-division-duplex massive MIMO systems, which enables downlink precoding based on uplink channel estimates. The entire calibration procedure is carried out solely at the base station (BS) side by sounding all BS antenna pairs. An Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm is derived, which processes the measured channels in order t…
▽ More
This paper presents a mutual coupling based calibration method for time-division-duplex massive MIMO systems, which enables downlink precoding based on uplink channel estimates. The entire calibration procedure is carried out solely at the base station (BS) side by sounding all BS antenna pairs. An Expectation-Maximization (EM) algorithm is derived, which processes the measured channels in order to estimate calibration coefficients. The EM algorithm outperforms current state-of-the-art narrow-band calibration schemes in a mean squared error (MSE) and sum-rate capacity sense. Like its predecessors, the EM algorithm is general in the sense that it is not only suitable to calibrate a co-located massive MIMO BS, but also very suitable for calibrating multiple BSs in distributed MIMO systems.
The proposed method is validated with experimental evidence obtained from a massive MIMO testbed. In addition, we address the estimated narrow-band calibration coefficients as a stochastic process across frequency, and study the subspace of this process based on measurement data. With the insights of this study, we propose an estimator which exploits the structure of the process in order to reduce the calibration error across frequency. A model for the calibration error is also proposed based on the asymptotic properties of the estimator, and is validated with measurement results.
△ Less
Submitted 21 February, 2017; v1 submitted 16 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
