-
Towards Causal Interpretation of Sexual Orientation in Regression Analysis: Applications and Challenges
Authors:
Junjie Lu,
Zhongyi Guo,
David H. Rehkopf
Abstract:
This study presents an approach to analyze health disparities in Sexual and Gender Minority (SGM) populations, with a focus on the role of social support levels as an example to allow causal interpretations of regression models. We advocate for precisely defining the exposure variable and incorporating mediators into analyses, to address the limitations of comparing counterfactual outcomes solely…
▽ More
This study presents an approach to analyze health disparities in Sexual and Gender Minority (SGM) populations, with a focus on the role of social support levels as an example to allow causal interpretations of regression models. We advocate for precisely defining the exposure variable and incorporating mediators into analyses, to address the limitations of comparing counterfactual outcomes solely between SGM and heterosexual populations. We define sexual orientation into domains (attraction, behavior, and identity), and emphasize a consideration of these elements either separately or together, depending on the research question. We also introduce social support measured before and after the disclosure of sexual orientation to facilitate inference. We illustrate this approach by examining the association between SGM status and depression diagnosis with data from the 2020 and 2021 National Health Interview Survey. We find a direct effect of SGM status on depression (OR: 3.07, 95% CI: 2.64 - 3.58) and no indirect effect through social support (OR: 1.07, 95% CI: 0.87-1.31). Our research emphasizes the necessity of the comprehensive measurement of sexual orientation and a focus on intervenable variables like social support in order to empower SGM communities and address SGM related health inequalities.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Potential for allocative harm in an environmental justice data tool
Authors:
Benjamin Q. Huynh,
Elizabeth T. Chin,
Allison Koenecke,
Derek Ouyang,
Daniel E. Ho,
Mathew V. Kiang,
David H. Rehkopf
Abstract:
Neighborhood-level screening algorithms are increasingly being deployed to inform policy decisions. We evaluate one such algorithm, CalEnviroScreen - designed to promote environmental justice and used to guide hundreds of millions of dollars in public funding annually - assessing its potential for allocative harm. We observe the model to be sensitive to subjective model decisions, with 16% of trac…
▽ More
Neighborhood-level screening algorithms are increasingly being deployed to inform policy decisions. We evaluate one such algorithm, CalEnviroScreen - designed to promote environmental justice and used to guide hundreds of millions of dollars in public funding annually - assessing its potential for allocative harm. We observe the model to be sensitive to subjective model decisions, with 16% of tracts potentially changing designation, as well as financially consequential, estimating the effect of its positive designations as a 104% (62-145%) increase in funding, equivalent to \$2.08 billion (\$1.56-2.41 billion) over four years. We also observe allocative tradeoffs and susceptibility to manipulation, raising ethical concerns. We recommend incorporating sensitivity analyses to mitigate allocative harm and accountability mechanisms to prevent misuse.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2023; v1 submitted 12 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
A data-driven prospective study of incident dementia among older adults in the United States
Authors:
Jordan Weiss,
Eli Puterman,
Aric A. Prather,
Erin B. Ware,
David H. Rehkopf
Abstract:
We conducted a prospective analysis of incident dementia and its association with 65 sociodemographic, early-life, economic, health and behavioral, social, and genetic risk factors in a sample of 7,908 adults over the age of 50 from the nationally representative US-based Health and Retirement Study. We used traditional survival analysis methods (Fine-Gray models) and a data-driven approach (random…
▽ More
We conducted a prospective analysis of incident dementia and its association with 65 sociodemographic, early-life, economic, health and behavioral, social, and genetic risk factors in a sample of 7,908 adults over the age of 50 from the nationally representative US-based Health and Retirement Study. We used traditional survival analysis methods (Fine-Gray models) and a data-driven approach (random survival forests for competing risks) which allowed us to account for the competing risk of death with up to 14 years of follow-up. Overall, the top five predictors across all groups were lower education, loneliness, lower wealth and income, and lower self-reported health. However, we observed variation in the leading predictors of dementia across racial/ethnic and gender groups. Our ranked lists may be useful for guiding future observational and quasi-experimental research that investigates understudied domains of risk and emphasizes life course economic and health conditions as well as disparities therein.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
