-
Asymptotic Equivalency of Two Different Approaches of L-statistics
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal
Abstract:
There are several ways to establish the asymptotic normality of $L$-statistics, depending upon the selection of the weights generating function and the cumulative distribution function of the underlying model. Here, in this paper it is shown that the two of the asymptotic approaches are equivalent/equal for a particular choice of the weights generating function.
There are several ways to establish the asymptotic normality of $L$-statistics, depending upon the selection of the weights generating function and the cumulative distribution function of the underlying model. Here, in this paper it is shown that the two of the asymptotic approaches are equivalent/equal for a particular choice of the weights generating function.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 11 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Robust Estimation of the Tail Index of a Single Parameter Pareto Distribution from Grouped Data
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal
Abstract:
Numerous robust estimators exist as alternatives to the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) when a completely observed ground-up loss severity sample dataset is available. However, the options for robust alternatives to MLE become significantly limited when dealing with grouped loss severity data, with only a handful of methods like least squares, minimum Hellinger distance, and optimal bounded inf…
▽ More
Numerous robust estimators exist as alternatives to the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) when a completely observed ground-up loss severity sample dataset is available. However, the options for robust alternatives to MLE become significantly limited when dealing with grouped loss severity data, with only a handful of methods like least squares, minimum Hellinger distance, and optimal bounded influence function available. This paper introduces a novel robust estimation technique, the Method of Truncated Moments (MTuM), specifically designed to estimate the tail index of a Pareto distribution from grouped data. Inferential justification of MTuM is established by employing the central limit theorem and validating them through a comprehensive simulation study.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 25 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Winsorized Robust Credibility Models
Authors:
Qian Zhao,
Chudamani Poudyal
Abstract:
The Bühlmann model, a branch of classical credibility theory, has been successively applied to the premium estimation for group insurance contracts and other insurance specifications. In this paper, we develop a robust Bühlmann credibility via the censored version of loss data, or the censored mean (a robust alternative to traditional individual mean). This framework yields explicit formulas of st…
▽ More
The Bühlmann model, a branch of classical credibility theory, has been successively applied to the premium estimation for group insurance contracts and other insurance specifications. In this paper, we develop a robust Bühlmann credibility via the censored version of loss data, or the censored mean (a robust alternative to traditional individual mean). This framework yields explicit formulas of structural parameters in credibility estimation for both scale-shape distribution families, location-scale distribution families, and their variants, which are commonly used to model insurance risks. The asymptotic properties of the proposed method are provided and corroborated through simulations, and their performance is compared to that of credibility based on the trimmed mean. By varying the censoring/trimming threshold level in several parametric models, we find all structural parameters via censoring are less volatile compared to the corresponding quantities via trimming, and using censored mean as a robust risk measure will reduce the influence of parametric loss assumptions on credibility estimation. Besides, the non-parametric estimations in credibility are discussed using the theory of $L-$estimators. And a numerical illustration from Wisconsin Local Government Property Insurance Fund indicates that the proposed robust credibility can prevent the effect caused by model mis-specification and capture the risk behavior of loss data in a broader viewpoint.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 15 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Method of Winsorized Moments for Robust Fitting of Truncated and Censored Lognormal Distributions
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal,
Qian Zhao,
Vytaras Brazauskas
Abstract:
When constructing parametric models to predict the cost of future claims, several important details have to be taken into account: (i) models should be designed to accommodate deductibles, policy limits, and coinsurance factors, (ii) parameters should be estimated robustly to control the influence of outliers on model predictions, and (iii) all point predictions should be augmented with estimates…
▽ More
When constructing parametric models to predict the cost of future claims, several important details have to be taken into account: (i) models should be designed to accommodate deductibles, policy limits, and coinsurance factors, (ii) parameters should be estimated robustly to control the influence of outliers on model predictions, and (iii) all point predictions should be augmented with estimates of their uncertainty. The methodology proposed in this paper provides a framework for addressing all these aspects simultaneously. Using payment-per-payment and payment-per-loss variables, we construct the adaptive version of method of winsorized moments (MWM) estimators for the parameters of truncated and censored lognormal distribution. Further, the asymptotic distributional properties of this approach are derived and compared with those of the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) and method of trimmed moments (MTM) estimators. The latter being a primary competitor to MWM. Moreover, the theoretical results are validated with extensive simulation studies and risk measure sensitivity analysis. Finally, practical performance of these methods is illustrated using the well-studied data set of 1500 U.S. indemnity losses. With this real data set, it is also demonstrated that the composite models do not provide much improvement in the quality of predictive models compared to a stand-alone fitted distribution specially for truncated and censored sample data.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 5 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Robust Estimation of Loss Models for Truncated and Censored Severity Data
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal,
Vytaras Brazauskas
Abstract:
In this paper, we consider robust estimation of claim severity models in insurance, when data are affected by truncation (due to deductibles), censoring (due to policy limits), and scaling (due to coinsurance). In particular, robust estimators based on the methods of trimmed moments (T-estimators) and winsorized moments (W-estimators) are pursued and fully developed. The general definitions of suc…
▽ More
In this paper, we consider robust estimation of claim severity models in insurance, when data are affected by truncation (due to deductibles), censoring (due to policy limits), and scaling (due to coinsurance). In particular, robust estimators based on the methods of trimmed moments (T-estimators) and winsorized moments (W-estimators) are pursued and fully developed. The general definitions of such estimators are formulated and their asymptotic properties are investigated. For illustrative purposes, specific formulas for T- and W-estimators of the tail parameter of a single-parameter Pareto distribution are derived. The practical performance of these estimators is then explored using the well-known Norwegian fire claims data. Our results demonstrate that T- and W-estimators offer a robust and computationally efficient alternative to the likelihood-based inference for models that are affected by deductibles, policy limits, and coinsurance.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 25 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Robust Estimation of Loss Models for Lognormal Insurance Payment Severity Data
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal
Abstract:
The primary objective of this scholarly work is to develop two estimation procedures - maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) and method of trimmed moments (MTM) - for the mean and variance of lognormal insurance payment severity data sets affected by different loss control mechanism, for example, truncation (due to deductibles), censoring (due to policy limits), and scaling (due to coinsurance propor…
▽ More
The primary objective of this scholarly work is to develop two estimation procedures - maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) and method of trimmed moments (MTM) - for the mean and variance of lognormal insurance payment severity data sets affected by different loss control mechanism, for example, truncation (due to deductibles), censoring (due to policy limits), and scaling (due to coinsurance proportions), in insurance and financial industries. Maximum likelihood estimating equations for both payment-per-payment and payment-per-loss data sets are derived which can be solved readily by any existing iterative numerical methods. The asymptotic distributions of those estimators are established via Fisher information matrices. Further, with a goal of balancing efficiency and robustness and to remove point masses at certain data points, we develop a dynamic MTM estimation procedures for lognormal claim severity models for the above-mentioned transformed data scenarios. The asymptotic distributional properties and the comparison with the corresponding MLEs of those MTM estimators are established along with extensive simulation studies. Purely for illustrative purpose, numerical examples for 1500 US indemnity losses are provided which illustrate the practical performance of the established results in this paper.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 2 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Truncated, Censored, and Actuarial Payment-type Moments for Robust Fitting of a Single-parameter Pareto Distribution
Authors:
Chudamani Poudyal
Abstract:
With some regularity conditions maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs) always produce asymptotically optimal (in the sense of consistency, efficiency, sufficiency, and unbiasedness) estimators. But in general, the MLEs lead to non-robust statistical inference, for example, pricing models and risk measures. Actuarial claim severity is continuous, right-skewed, and frequently heavy-tailed. The data se…
▽ More
With some regularity conditions maximum likelihood estimators (MLEs) always produce asymptotically optimal (in the sense of consistency, efficiency, sufficiency, and unbiasedness) estimators. But in general, the MLEs lead to non-robust statistical inference, for example, pricing models and risk measures. Actuarial claim severity is continuous, right-skewed, and frequently heavy-tailed. The data sets that such models are usually fitted to contain outliers that are difficult to identify and separate from genuine data. Moreover, due to commonly used actuarial "loss control strategies" in financial and insurance industries, the random variables we observe and wish to model are affected by truncation (due to deductibles), censoring (due to policy limits), scaling (due to coinsurance proportions) and other transformations. To alleviate the lack of robustness of MLE-based inference in risk modeling, here in this paper, we propose and develop a new method of estimation - method of truncated moments (MTuM) and generalize it for different scenarios of loss control mechanism. Various asymptotic properties of those estimates are established by using central limit theory. New connections between different estimators are found. A comparative study of newly-designed methods with the corresponding MLEs is performed. Detail investigation has been done for a single parameter Pareto loss model including a simulation study.
△ Less
Submitted 20 February, 2024; v1 submitted 19 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.