-
Estimating Breakpoints between Climate States in Paleoclimate Data
Authors:
Mikkel Bennedsen,
Eric Hillebrand,
Siem Jan Koopman,
Kathrine By Larsen
Abstract:
This study presents a statistical approach for identifying transitions between climate states, referred to as breakpoints, using well-established econometric tools. We analyse a 67.1 million year record of the oxygen isotope ratio delta-O-18 derived from benthic foraminifera. The dataset is presented in Westerhold et al. (2020), where the authors use recurrence analysis to identify six climate sta…
▽ More
This study presents a statistical approach for identifying transitions between climate states, referred to as breakpoints, using well-established econometric tools. We analyse a 67.1 million year record of the oxygen isotope ratio delta-O-18 derived from benthic foraminifera. The dataset is presented in Westerhold et al. (2020), where the authors use recurrence analysis to identify six climate states. We consider several model specifications. Fixing the number of breakpoints to five, the resulting breakpoint estimates closely align with those identified by Westerhold et al. (2020) across various data binning frequencies and model specifications. Treating the number of breakpoints as a parameter to be estimated results in statistical justification for more than five breakpoints in the time series. Our approach offers the advantage of constructing confidence intervals for the breakpoints, and it allows testing for the number of breakpoints present in the time series.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2024; v1 submitted 12 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Continuous-time state-space methods for delta-O-18 and delta-C-13
Authors:
Mikkel Bennedsen,
Eric Hillebrand,
Siem Jan Koopman,
Kathrine By Larsen
Abstract:
Time series analysis of delta-O-18 and delta-C-13 measurements from benthic foraminifera for purposes of paleoclimatology is challenging. The time series reach back tens of millions of years, they are relatively sparse in the early record and relatively dense in the later, the time stamps of the observations are not evenly spaced, and there are instances of multiple different observations at the s…
▽ More
Time series analysis of delta-O-18 and delta-C-13 measurements from benthic foraminifera for purposes of paleoclimatology is challenging. The time series reach back tens of millions of years, they are relatively sparse in the early record and relatively dense in the later, the time stamps of the observations are not evenly spaced, and there are instances of multiple different observations at the same time stamp. The time series appear non-stationary over most of the historical record with clearly visible temporary trends of varying directions. In this paper, we propose a continuous-time state-space framework to analyze the time series. State space models are uniquely suited for this purpose, since they can accommodate all the challenging features mentioned above. We specify univariate models and joint bivariate models for the two time series of delta-O-18 and delta-C-13. The models are estimated using maximum likelihood by way of the Kalman filter recursions. The suite of models we consider has an interpretation as an application of the Butterworth filter. We propose model specifications that take the origin of the data from different studies into account and that allow for a partition of the total period into sub-periods reflecting different climate states. The models can be used, for example, to impute evenly time-stamped values by way of Kalman filtering. They can also be used, in future work, to analyze the relation to proxies for CO2 concentrations.
△ Less
Submitted 8 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
A Regression-Based Approach to the CO2 Airborne Fraction: Enhancing Statistical Precision and Tackling Zero Emissions
Authors:
Mikkel Bennedsen,
Eric Hillebrand,
Siem Jan Koopman
Abstract:
The global fraction of anthropogenically emitted carbon dioxide (CO$_2$) that stays in the atmosphere, the CO$_2$ airborne fraction, has been fluctuating around a constant value over the period 1959 to 2022. The consensus estimate of the airborne fraction is around $44\%$; the remaining $56\%$ is absorbed by the oceanic and terrestrials biospheres. In this study, we show that the conventional esti…
▽ More
The global fraction of anthropogenically emitted carbon dioxide (CO$_2$) that stays in the atmosphere, the CO$_2$ airborne fraction, has been fluctuating around a constant value over the period 1959 to 2022. The consensus estimate of the airborne fraction is around $44\%$; the remaining $56\%$ is absorbed by the oceanic and terrestrials biospheres. In this study, we show that the conventional estimator of the airborne fraction, based on a ratio of changes in atmospheric CO$_2$ concentrations and CO$_2$ emissions, suffers from a number of statistical deficiencies, such as non-existence of moments and a non-Gaussian limiting distribution. We propose an alternative regression-based estimator of the airborne fraction that does not suffer from these deficiencies. We show that the regression-based estimator has a Gaussian limiting distribution and reduces estimation uncertainty substantially. Our empirical analysis leads to an estimate of the airborne fraction over 1959--2022 of $47.0\%$ ($\pm 1.1\%$; $1 σ$), implying a higher, and better constrained, estimate than the current consensus. Using climate model output, we show that a regression-based approach provides sensible estimates of the airborne fraction, also in future scenarios where emissions are at or near zero.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2024; v1 submitted 2 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Is there evidence of a trend in the CO2 airborne fraction?
Authors:
Mikkel Bennedsen,
Eric Hillebrand,
Siem Jan Koopman
Abstract:
In a paper recently published in this journal, van Marle et al. (van Marle et al., 2022) introduce an interesting new data set for land use and land cover change CO2 emissions (LULCC) that they use to study whether a trend is present in the airborne fraction (AF), defined as the fraction of CO2 emissions remaining in the atmosphere. Testing the hypothesis of a trend in the AF has attracted much at…
▽ More
In a paper recently published in this journal, van Marle et al. (van Marle et al., 2022) introduce an interesting new data set for land use and land cover change CO2 emissions (LULCC) that they use to study whether a trend is present in the airborne fraction (AF), defined as the fraction of CO2 emissions remaining in the atmosphere. Testing the hypothesis of a trend in the AF has attracted much attention, with the overall consensus that no statistical evidence is found for a trend in the data (Knorr, 2009; Gloor et al., 2010; Raupach et al., 2014; Bennedsen et al., 2019). In their paper, van Marle et al. analyze the AF as implied by three different LULCC emissions time series (GCP, H&N, and their new data series). In a Monte Carlo simulation study based on their new LULCC emissions data, van Marle et al. find evidence of a declining trend in the AF.
In this note, we argue that the statistical analysis presented in van Marle et al. can be improved in several respects. Specifically, the Monte Carlo study presented in van Marle et al. is not conducive to determine whether there is a trend in the AF. Further, we re-examine the evidence for a trend in the AF by using a variety of different statistical tests. The statistical evidence for an uninterrupted (positive or negative) trend in the airborne fraction remains mixed at best. When allowing for a break in the trend, there is some evidence for upward trends in both subsamples.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2023; v1 submitted 25 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
