-
Estimating Metocean Environments Associated with Extreme Structural Response to Demonstrate the Dangers of Environmental Contour Methods
Authors:
Matthew Speers,
David Randell,
Jonathan Angus Tawn,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Extreme value analysis (EVA) uses data to estimate long-term extreme environmental conditions for variables such as significant wave height and period, for the design of marine structures. Together with models for the short-term evolution of the ocean environment and for wave-structure interaction, EVA provides a basis for full probabilistic design analysis. Alternatively, environmental contours p…
▽ More
Extreme value analysis (EVA) uses data to estimate long-term extreme environmental conditions for variables such as significant wave height and period, for the design of marine structures. Together with models for the short-term evolution of the ocean environment and for wave-structure interaction, EVA provides a basis for full probabilistic design analysis. Alternatively, environmental contours provide an approximate approach to estimating structural integrity, without requiring structural knowledge. These contour methods also exploit statistical models, including EVA, but avoid the need for structural modelling by making what are believed to be conservative assumptions about the shape of the structural failure boundary in the environment space. These assumptions, however, may not always be appropriate, or may lead to unnecessary wasted resources from over design. We demonstrate a methodology for efficient fully probabilistic analysis of structural failure. From this, we estimate the joint conditional probability density of the environment (CDE), given the occurrence of an extreme structural response. We use CDE as a diagnostic to highlight the deficiencies of environmental contour methods for design; none of the IFORM environmental contours considered characterise CDE well for three example structures.
△ Less
Submitted 1 July, 2024; v1 submitted 25 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Inference for multivariate extremes via a semi-parametric angular-radial model
Authors:
Callum John Rowlandson Murphy-Barltrop,
Ed Mackay,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
The modelling of multivariate extreme events is important in a wide variety of applications, including flood risk analysis, metocean engineering and financial modelling. A wide variety of statistical techniques have been proposed in the literature; however, many such methods are limited in the forms of dependence they can capture, or make strong parametric assumptions about data structures. In thi…
▽ More
The modelling of multivariate extreme events is important in a wide variety of applications, including flood risk analysis, metocean engineering and financial modelling. A wide variety of statistical techniques have been proposed in the literature; however, many such methods are limited in the forms of dependence they can capture, or make strong parametric assumptions about data structures. In this article, we introduce a novel inference framework for multivariate extremes based on a semi-parametric angular-radial model. This model overcomes the limitations of many existing approaches and provides a unified paradigm for assessing joint tail behaviour. Alongside inferential tools, we also introduce techniques for assessing uncertainty and goodness of fit. Our proposed technique is tested on simulated data sets alongside observed metocean time series', with results indicating generally good performance.
△ Less
Submitted 14 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Modelling multivariate extremes through angular-radial decomposition of the density function
Authors:
Ed Mackay,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
We present a new framework for modelling multivariate extremes, based on an angular-radial representation of the probability density function. Under this representation, the problem of modelling multivariate extremes is transformed to that of modelling an angular density and the tail of the radial variable, conditional on angle. Motivated by univariate theory, we assume that the tail of the condit…
▽ More
We present a new framework for modelling multivariate extremes, based on an angular-radial representation of the probability density function. Under this representation, the problem of modelling multivariate extremes is transformed to that of modelling an angular density and the tail of the radial variable, conditional on angle. Motivated by univariate theory, we assume that the tail of the conditional radial distribution converges to a generalised Pareto (GP) distribution. To simplify inference, we also assume that the angular density is continuous and finite and the GP parameter functions are continuous with angle. We refer to the resulting model as the semi-parametric angular-radial (SPAR) model for multivariate extremes. We consider the effect of the choice of polar coordinate system and introduce generalised concepts of angular-radial coordinate systems and generalised scalar angles in two dimensions. We show that under certain conditions, the choice of polar coordinate system does not affect the validity of the SPAR assumptions. However, some choices of coordinate system lead to simpler representations. In contrast, we show that the choice of margin does affect whether the model assumptions are satisfied. In particular, the use of Laplace margins results in a form of the density function for which the SPAR assumptions are satisfied for many common families of copula, with various dependence classes. We show that the SPAR model provides a more versatile framework for characterising multivariate extremes than provided by existing approaches, and that several commonly-used approaches are special cases of the SPAR model.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2024; v1 submitted 19 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
covXtreme : MATLAB software for non-stationary penalised piecewise constant marginal and conditional extreme value models
Authors:
Ross Towe,
Emma Ross,
David Randell,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
The covXtreme software provides functionality for estimation of marginal and conditional extreme value models, non-stationary with respect to covariates, and environmental design contours. Generalised Pareto (GP) marginal models of peaks over threshold are estimated, using a piecewise-constant representation for the variation of GP threshold and scale parameters on the (potentially multidimensiona…
▽ More
The covXtreme software provides functionality for estimation of marginal and conditional extreme value models, non-stationary with respect to covariates, and environmental design contours. Generalised Pareto (GP) marginal models of peaks over threshold are estimated, using a piecewise-constant representation for the variation of GP threshold and scale parameters on the (potentially multidimensional) covariate domain of interest. The conditional variation of one or more associated variates, given a large value of a single conditioning variate, is described using the conditional extremes model of Heffernan and Tawn (2004), the slope term of which is also assumed to vary in a piecewise constant manner with covariates. Optimal smoothness of marginal and conditional extreme value model parameters with respect to covariates is estimated using cross-validated roughness-penalised maximum likelihood estimation. Uncertainties in model parameter estimates due to marginal and conditional extreme value threshold choice, and sample size, are quantified using a bootstrap resampling scheme. Estimates of environmental contours using various schemes, including the direct sampling approach of Huseby et al. 2013, are calculated by simulation or numerical integration under fitted models. The software was developed in MATLAB for metocean applications, but is applicable generally to multivariate samples of peaks over threshold. The software and case study data can be downloaded from GitHub, with an accompanying user guide.
△ Less
Submitted 25 April, 2024; v1 submitted 29 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Avoiding methane emission rate underestimates when using the divergence method
Authors:
Clayton Roberts,
Rutger IJzermans,
David Randell,
Matthew Jones,
Philip Jonathan,
Kaisey Mandel,
Bill Hirst,
Oliver Shorttle
Abstract:
Methane is a powerful greenhouse gas, and a primary target for mitigating climate change in the short-term future due to its relatively short atmospheric lifetime and greater ability to trap heat in Earth's atmosphere compared to carbon dioxide. Top-down observations of atmospheric methane are possible via drone and aircraft surveys as well as satellites such as the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrum…
▽ More
Methane is a powerful greenhouse gas, and a primary target for mitigating climate change in the short-term future due to its relatively short atmospheric lifetime and greater ability to trap heat in Earth's atmosphere compared to carbon dioxide. Top-down observations of atmospheric methane are possible via drone and aircraft surveys as well as satellites such as the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI). Recent work has begun to apply the divergence method to produce regional methane emission rate estimates. Here we show that when the divergence method is applied to spatially incomplete observations of methane, it can result in negatively biased time-averaged regional emission rates. We show that this effect can be counteracted by adopting a procedure in which daily advective fluxes of methane are time-averaged before the divergence method is applied. Using such a procedure with TROPOMI methane observations, we calculate yearly Permian emission rates of 3.1, 2.4 and 2.7 million tonnes per year for the years 2019 through 2021. We also show that highly-resolved plumes of methane can have negatively biased estimated emission rates by the divergence method due to the presence of turbulent diffusion in the plume, but this is unlikely to affect regional methane emission budgets constructed from TROPOMI observations of methane. The results from this work are expected to provide useful guidance for future implementations of the divergence method for emission rate estimation from satellite data -- be it for methane or other gaseous species in the atmosphere.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2023; v1 submitted 20 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Temporal evolution of the extreme excursions of multivariate $k$th order Markov processes with application to oceanographic data
Authors:
Stan Tendijck,
Philip Jonathan,
David Randell,
Jonathan Tawn
Abstract:
We develop two models for the temporal evolution of extreme events of multivariate $k$th order Markov processes. The foundation of our methodology lies in the conditional extremes model of Heffernan & Tawn (2004), and it naturally extends the work of Winter & Tawn (2016,2017) and Tendijck et al. (2019) to include multivariate random variables. We use cross-validation-type techniques to develop a m…
▽ More
We develop two models for the temporal evolution of extreme events of multivariate $k$th order Markov processes. The foundation of our methodology lies in the conditional extremes model of Heffernan & Tawn (2004), and it naturally extends the work of Winter & Tawn (2016,2017) and Tendijck et al. (2019) to include multivariate random variables. We use cross-validation-type techniques to develop a model order selection procedure, and we test our models on two-dimensional meteorological-oceanographic data with directional covariates for a location in the northern North Sea. We conclude that the newly-developed models perform better than the widely used historical matching methodology for these data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Uncertainties in estimating the effect of climate change on 100-year return value for significant wave height
Authors:
Kevin Ewans,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Estimating climate effects on future ocean storm severity is plagued by large uncertainties, yet for safe design and operation of offshore structures, best possible estimates of climate effects are required given available data. We explore the variability in estimates of 100-year return value of significant wave height (Hs) over time, for output of WAVEWATCHIII models from 7 representative CMIP5 G…
▽ More
Estimating climate effects on future ocean storm severity is plagued by large uncertainties, yet for safe design and operation of offshore structures, best possible estimates of climate effects are required given available data. We explore the variability in estimates of 100-year return value of significant wave height (Hs) over time, for output of WAVEWATCHIII models from 7 representative CMIP5 GCMs, and the FIO-ESM v2.0 CMIP6 GCM, for neighbourhoods of locations east of Madagascar and south of Australia. Non-stationary extreme value analysis of peaks-over-threshold and block maxima using Bayesian inference provide posterior estimates of return values as a function of time; MATLAB software is provided. There is large variation between return value estimates from different GCMs, and with longitude and latitude within each neighbourhood. These sources of uncertainty tend to be larger than that due to typical modelling choices (such as choice of threshold for POT, or block length for BM). However, careful threshold and block length are critical east of Madagascar, because of the presence of a mixed population of storms there. The long 700-year pre-industrial control (piControl) output of the CMIP6 GCM allows quantification of the apparent inherent variability in return value as a function of time.
△ Less
Submitted 21 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Statistical estimation of spatial wave extremes for tropical cyclones from small data samples: validation of the STM-E approach using long-term synthetic cyclone data for the Caribbean Sea
Authors:
Ryota Wada,
Jeremy Rohmer,
Yann Krien,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Occurrences of tropical cyclones at a location are rare, and for many locations, only short periods of observations or hindcasts are available. Hence, estimation of return values (corresponding to a period considerably longer than that for which data is available) for cyclone-induced significant wave height (SWH) from small samples is challenging. The STM-E (space-time maximum and exposure) model…
▽ More
Occurrences of tropical cyclones at a location are rare, and for many locations, only short periods of observations or hindcasts are available. Hence, estimation of return values (corresponding to a period considerably longer than that for which data is available) for cyclone-induced significant wave height (SWH) from small samples is challenging. The STM-E (space-time maximum and exposure) model was developed to provide reduced bias in estimates of return values compared to competitor approaches in such situations, and realistic estimates of return value uncertainty. STM-E exploits data from a spatial neighbourhood satisfying certain conditions, rather than data from a single location, for return value estimation.
This article provides critical assessment of the STM-E model for tropical cyclones in the Caribbean Sea near Guadeloupe for which a large database of synthetic cyclones is available, corresponding to more than 3,000 years of observation. Results indicate that STM-E yields values for the 500-year return value of SWH and its variability, estimated from 200 years of cyclone data, consistent with direct empirical estimates obtained by sampling 500 years of data from the full synthetic cyclone database; similar results were found for estimation of the 100-year return value from samples corresponding to approximately 50 years of data. In general, STM-E also provides reduced bias and more realistic uncertainty estimates for return values relative to single location analysis.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A multivariate pseudo-likelihood approach to estimating directional ocean wave models
Authors:
Jake P. Grainger,
Adam M. Sykulski,
Kevin Ewans,
Hans F. Hansen,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Ocean buoy data in the form of high frequency multivariate time series are routinely recorded at many locations in the world's oceans. Such data can be used to characterise the ocean wavefield, which is important for numerous socio-economic and scientific reasons. This characterisation is typically achieved by modelling the frequency-direction spectrum, which decomposes spatiotemporal variability…
▽ More
Ocean buoy data in the form of high frequency multivariate time series are routinely recorded at many locations in the world's oceans. Such data can be used to characterise the ocean wavefield, which is important for numerous socio-economic and scientific reasons. This characterisation is typically achieved by modelling the frequency-direction spectrum, which decomposes spatiotemporal variability by both frequency and direction. State-of-the-art methods for estimating the parameters of such models do not make use of the full spatiotemporal content of the buoy observations due to unnecessary assumptions and smoothing steps. We explain how the multivariate debiased Whittle likelihood can be used to jointly estimate all parameters of such frequency-direction spectra directly from the recorded time series. When applied to North Sea buoy data, debiased Whittle likelihood inference reveals smooth evolution of spectral parameters over time. We discuss challenging practical issues including model misspecification, and provide guidelines for future application of the method.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Multivariate spatial conditional extremes for extreme ocean environments
Authors:
Rob Shooter,
Emma Ross,
Agustinus Ribal,
Ian R. Young,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
The joint extremal spatial dependence of wind speed and significant wave height in the North East Atlantic is quantified using Metop satellite scatterometer and hindcast observations for the period 2007-2018, and a multivariate spatial conditional extremes (MSCE) model, ultimately motivated by the work of Heffernan and Tawn (2004). The analysis involves (a) registering individual satellite swaths…
▽ More
The joint extremal spatial dependence of wind speed and significant wave height in the North East Atlantic is quantified using Metop satellite scatterometer and hindcast observations for the period 2007-2018, and a multivariate spatial conditional extremes (MSCE) model, ultimately motivated by the work of Heffernan and Tawn (2004). The analysis involves (a) registering individual satellite swaths and corresponding hindcast data onto a template transect (running approximately north-east to south-west, between the British Isles and Iceland), (b) non-stationary directional-seasonal marginal extreme value analysis at a set of registration locations on the transect, (c) transformation from physical to standard Laplace scale using the fitted marginal model, (d) estimation of the MSCE model on the set of registration locations, and assessment of quality of model fit. A joint model is estimated for three spatial quantities: Metop wind speed, hindcast wind speed and hindcast significant wave height. Results suggest that, when conditioning on extreme Metop wind speed, extremal spatial dependence for all three quantities decays over approximately 600-800 km.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
A penalised piecewise-linear model for non-stationary extreme value analysis of peaks over threshold
Authors:
Anna Maria Barlow,
Ed Mackay,
Emma Eastoe,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Metocean extremes often vary systematically with covariates such as direction and season. In this work, we present non-stationary models for the size and rate of occurrence of peaks over threshold of metocean variables with respect to one- or two-dimensional covariates. The variation of model parameters with covariate is described using a piecewise-linear function in one or two dimensions defined…
▽ More
Metocean extremes often vary systematically with covariates such as direction and season. In this work, we present non-stationary models for the size and rate of occurrence of peaks over threshold of metocean variables with respect to one- or two-dimensional covariates. The variation of model parameters with covariate is described using a piecewise-linear function in one or two dimensions defined with respect to pre-specified node locations on the covariate domain. Parameter roughness is regulated to provide optimal predictive performance, assessed using cross-validation, within a penalised likelihood framework for inference. Parameter uncertainty is quantified using bootstrap resampling. The models are used to estimate extremes of storm peak significant wave height with respect to direction and season for a site in the northern North Sea. A covariate representation based on a triangulation of the direction-season domain with six nodes gives good predictive performance. The penalised piecewise-linear framework provides a flexible representation of covariate effects at reasonable computational cost.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Enhanced monitoring of atmospheric methane from space over the Permian basin with hierarchical Bayesian inference
Authors:
Clayton Roberts,
Oliver Shorttle,
Kaisey Mandel,
Matthew Jones,
Rutger Ijzermans,
Bill Hirst,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Methane is a strong greenhouse gas, with a higher radiative forcing per unit mass and shorter atmospheric lifetime than carbon dioxide. The remote sensing of methane in regions of industrial activity is a key step toward the accurate monitoring of emissions that drive climate change. Whilst the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI) on board the Sentinal-5P satellite is capable of providing…
▽ More
Methane is a strong greenhouse gas, with a higher radiative forcing per unit mass and shorter atmospheric lifetime than carbon dioxide. The remote sensing of methane in regions of industrial activity is a key step toward the accurate monitoring of emissions that drive climate change. Whilst the TROPOspheric Monitoring Instrument (TROPOMI) on board the Sentinal-5P satellite is capable of providing daily global measurement of methane columns, data are often compromised by cloud cover. Here, we develop a statistical model which uses nitrogen dioxide concentration data from TROPOMI to efficiently predict values of methane columns, expanding the average daily spatial coverage of observations of the Permian basin from 16% to 88% in the year 2019. The addition of predicted methane abundances at locations where direct observations are not available will support inversion methods for estimating methane emission rates at shorter timescales than is currently possible.
△ Less
Submitted 19 May, 2022; v1 submitted 24 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Estimating the parameters of ocean wave spectra
Authors:
Jake P. Grainger,
Adam M. Sykulski,
Philip Jonathan,
Kevin Ewans
Abstract:
Wind-generated waves are often treated as stochastic processes. There is particular interest in their spectral density functions, which are often expressed in some parametric form. Such spectral density functions are used as inputs when modelling structural response or other engineering concerns. Therefore, accurate and precise recovery of the parameters of such a form, from observed wave records,…
▽ More
Wind-generated waves are often treated as stochastic processes. There is particular interest in their spectral density functions, which are often expressed in some parametric form. Such spectral density functions are used as inputs when modelling structural response or other engineering concerns. Therefore, accurate and precise recovery of the parameters of such a form, from observed wave records, is important. Current techniques are known to struggle with recovering certain parameters, especially the peak enhancement factor and spectral tail decay. We introduce an approach from the statistical literature, known as the de-biased Whittle likelihood, and address some practical concerns regarding its implementation in the context of wind-generated waves. We demonstrate, through numerical simulation, that the de-biased Whittle likelihood outperforms current techniques, such as least squares fitting, both in terms of accuracy and precision of the recovered parameters. We also provide a method for estimating the uncertainty of parameter estimates. We perform an example analysis on a data-set recorded off the coast of New Zealand, to illustrate some of the extra practical concerns that arise when estimating the parameters of spectra from observed data.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2021; v1 submitted 24 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Modelling non-stationary extremes of storm severity: a tale of two approaches
Authors:
Evandro Konzen,
Claudia Neves,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Models for extreme values accommodating non-stationarity have been amply studied and evaluated from a parametric perspective. Whilst these models are flexible, in the sense that many parametrizations can be explored, they assume an asymptotic distribution as the proper fit to observations from the tail. This paper provides a holistic approach to the modelling of non-stationary extreme events by it…
▽ More
Models for extreme values accommodating non-stationarity have been amply studied and evaluated from a parametric perspective. Whilst these models are flexible, in the sense that many parametrizations can be explored, they assume an asymptotic distribution as the proper fit to observations from the tail. This paper provides a holistic approach to the modelling of non-stationary extreme events by iterating between parametric and semi-parametric approaches, thus providing an automatic procedure to estimate a moving threshold with respect to a periodic covariate in circular data. By exploiting advantages and mitigating pitfalls of each approach, a unified framework is provided as the backbone for estimating extreme quantiles, including that of the $T$-year level and finite right endpoint, which seeks to optimize bias-variance trade-off. To this end, two tuning parameters related to the spread of peaks over threshold are introduced. We provide guidance for applying the methodology to the directional modelling of hindcast storm peak significant wave heights recorded in the North Sea. Although the theoretical underpinning for adaptation of well-known estimators in statistics of extremes to circular data is given in some detail, the derivation of their asymptotic properties lays beyond the scope of this paper. A bootstrap technique is implemented for obtaining direction-driven confidence bounds in such a way as to account for the relevant boundary restrictions with minimal sensitivity to initial point. This provides a template for other applications where the analysis of directional extremes is of importance.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
On environmental contours for marine and coastal design
Authors:
Emma Ross,
Ole Christian Astrup,
Elzbieta Bitner-Gregersen,
Nigel Bunn,
Graham Feld,
Ben Gouldby,
Arne Huseby,
Ye Liu,
David Randell,
Erik Vanem,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Environmental contours are used in structural reliability analysis of marine and coastal structures as an approximate means to locate the boundary of the distribution of environmental variables, and hence sets of environmental conditions giving rise to extreme structural loads and responses. Outline guidance concerning the application of environmental contour methods is given in recent design guid…
▽ More
Environmental contours are used in structural reliability analysis of marine and coastal structures as an approximate means to locate the boundary of the distribution of environmental variables, and hence sets of environmental conditions giving rise to extreme structural loads and responses. Outline guidance concerning the application of environmental contour methods is given in recent design guidelines from many organisations. However there is lack of clarity concerning the differences between approaches to environmental contour estimation reported in the literature, and regarding the relationship between the environmental contour, corresponding to some return period, and the extreme structural response for the same period. Hence there is uncertainty about precisely when environmental contours should be used, and how they should be used well. This article seeks to provide some assistance in understanding the fundamental issues regarding environmental contours and their use in structural reliability analysis. Approaches to estimating the joint distribution of environmental variables, and to estimating environmental contours based on that distribution, are described. Simple software for estimation of the joint distribution, and hence environmental contours, is illustrated (and is freely available from the authors). Extra assumptions required to relate the characteristics of environmental contour to structural failure are outlined. Alternative response-based methods not requiring environmental contours are summarised. The results of an informal survey of the metocean user community regarding environmental contours are presented. Finally, recommendations about when and how environmental contour methods should be used are made.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Statistics of extreme ocean environments: Non-stationary inference for directionality and other covariate effects
Authors:
Matthew Jones,
David Randell,
Kevin Ewans,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Numerous approaches are proposed in the literature for non-stationarity marginal extreme value inference, including different model parameterisations with respect to covariate, and different inference schemes. The objective of this article is to compare some of these procedures critically. We generate sample realisations from generalised Pareto distributions, the parameters of which are smooth fun…
▽ More
Numerous approaches are proposed in the literature for non-stationarity marginal extreme value inference, including different model parameterisations with respect to covariate, and different inference schemes. The objective of this article is to compare some of these procedures critically. We generate sample realisations from generalised Pareto distributions, the parameters of which are smooth functions of a single smooth periodic covariate, specified to reflect the characteristics of actual samples from the tail of the distribution of significant wave height with direction, considered in the literature in the recent past. We estimate extreme values models (a) using Constant, Fourier, B-spline and Gaussian Process parameterisations for the functional forms of generalised Pareto shape and (adjusted) scale with respect to covariate and (b) maximum likelihood and Bayesian inference procedures. We evaluate the relative quality of inferences by estimating return value distributions for the response corresponding to a time period of $10 \times$ the (assumed) period of the original sample, and compare estimated return values distributions with the truth using Kullback-Leibler, Cramer-von Mises and Kolmogorov-Smirnov statistics. We find that Spline and Gaussian Process parameterisations estimated by Markov chain Monte Carlo inference using the mMALA algorithm, perform equally well in terms of quality of inference and computational efficiency, and generally perform better than alternatives in those respects.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Cross-validatory extreme value threshold selection and uncertainty with application to ocean storm severity
Authors:
Paul Northrop,
Nicolas Attalides,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Designs conditions for marine structures are typically informed by threshold-based extreme value analyses of oceanographic variables, in which excesses of a high threshold are modelled by a generalized Pareto (GP) distribution. Too low a threshold leads to bias from model mis-specification; raising the threshold increases the variance of estimators: a bias-variance trade-off. Many existing thresho…
▽ More
Designs conditions for marine structures are typically informed by threshold-based extreme value analyses of oceanographic variables, in which excesses of a high threshold are modelled by a generalized Pareto (GP) distribution. Too low a threshold leads to bias from model mis-specification; raising the threshold increases the variance of estimators: a bias-variance trade-off. Many existing threshold selection methods do not address this trade-off directly, but rather aim to select the lowest threshold above which the GP model is judged to hold approximately. In this paper Bayesian cross-validation is used to address the trade-off by comparing thresholds based on predictive ability at extreme levels. Extremal inferences can be sensitive to the choice of a single threshold. We use Bayesian model-averaging to combine inferences from many thresholds, thereby reducing sensitivity to the choice of a single threshold. The methodology is applied to significant wave height datasets from the northern North Sea and the Gulf of Mexico.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2016; v1 submitted 24 April, 2015;
originally announced April 2015.
-
Bayes linear variance structure learning for inspection of large scale physical systems
Authors:
David Randell,
Michael Goldstein,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Modelling of inspection data for large scale physical systems is critical to assessment of their integrity. We present a general method for inference about system state and associated model variance structure from spatially distributed time series which are typically short, irregular, incomplete and not directly observable. Bayes linear analysis simplifies parameter estimation and avoids often-unr…
▽ More
Modelling of inspection data for large scale physical systems is critical to assessment of their integrity. We present a general method for inference about system state and associated model variance structure from spatially distributed time series which are typically short, irregular, incomplete and not directly observable. Bayes linear analysis simplifies parameter estimation and avoids often-unrealistic distributional assumptions. Second-order exchangeability judgements facilitate variance learning for sparse inspection time-series. The model is applied to inspection data for minimum wall thickness from corroding pipe-work networks on a full-scale offshore platform, and shown to give materially different forecasts of remnant life compared to an equivalent model neglecting variance learning.
△ Less
Submitted 22 February, 2013;
originally announced February 2013.
-
Locating and quantifying gas emission sources using remotely obtained concentration data
Authors:
Bill Hirst,
Philip Jonathan,
Fernando Gonzalez del Cueto,
David Randell,
Oliver Kosut
Abstract:
We describe a method for detecting, locating and quantifying sources of gas emissions to the atmosphere using remotely obtained gas concentration data; the method is applicable to gases of environmental concern. We demonstrate its performance using methane data collected from aircraft. Atmospheric point concentration measurements are modelled as the sum of a spatially and temporally smooth atmosph…
▽ More
We describe a method for detecting, locating and quantifying sources of gas emissions to the atmosphere using remotely obtained gas concentration data; the method is applicable to gases of environmental concern. We demonstrate its performance using methane data collected from aircraft. Atmospheric point concentration measurements are modelled as the sum of a spatially and temporally smooth atmospheric background concentration, augmented by concentrations due to local sources. We model source emission rates with a Gaussian mixture model and use a Markov random field to represent the atmospheric background concentration component of the measurements. A Gaussian plume atmospheric eddy dispersion model represents gas dispersion between sources and measurement locations. Initial point estimates of background concentrations and source emission rates are obtained using mixed L2-L1 optimisation over a discretised grid of potential source locations. Subsequent reversible jump Markov chain Monte Carlo inference provides estimated values and uncertainties for the number, emission rates and locations of sources unconstrained by a grid. Source area, atmospheric background concentrations and other model parameters are also estimated. We investigate the performance of the approach first using a synthetic problem, then apply the method to real data collected from an aircraft flying over: a 1600 km^2 area containing two landfills, then a 225 km^2 area containing a gas flare stack.
△ Less
Submitted 7 February, 2013; v1 submitted 6 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Evaluating environmental joint extremes for the offshore industry
Authors:
Kevin Ewans,
Philip Jonathan
Abstract:
Understanding extreme ocean environments and their interaction with fixed and floating structures is critical for the design of offshore and coastal facilities. The joint effect of various ocean variables on extreme responses of offshore structures is fundamental in determining the design loads. For example, it is known that mean values of wave periods tend to increase with increasing storm intens…
▽ More
Understanding extreme ocean environments and their interaction with fixed and floating structures is critical for the design of offshore and coastal facilities. The joint effect of various ocean variables on extreme responses of offshore structures is fundamental in determining the design loads. For example, it is known that mean values of wave periods tend to increase with increasing storm intensity, and a floating system responds in a complex way to both variables.
However, specification of joint extremes in design criteria has often been somewhat \textit{ad hoc}, being based on fairly arbitrary combinations of extremes of variables estimated independently. Such approaches are even outlined in design guidelines. Mathematically more consistent estimates of the joint occurrence of extreme environmental variables fall into two camps in the offshore industry -- response-based and response-independent. Both are outlined here, with emphasis on response-independent methods, particularly those based on the conditional extremes model recently introduced by Heffernan and Tawn (2004) which has a solid theoretical motivation. Several applications using the new methods are presented.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Accounting for choice of measurement scale in extreme value modeling
Authors:
J. L. Wadsworth,
J. A. Tawn,
P. Jonathan
Abstract:
We investigate the effect that the choice of measurement scale has upon inference and extrapolation in extreme value analysis. Separate analyses of variables from a single process on scales which are linked by a nonlinear transformation may lead to discrepant conclusions concerning the tail behavior of the process. We propose the use of a Box--Cox power transformation incorporated as part of the i…
▽ More
We investigate the effect that the choice of measurement scale has upon inference and extrapolation in extreme value analysis. Separate analyses of variables from a single process on scales which are linked by a nonlinear transformation may lead to discrepant conclusions concerning the tail behavior of the process. We propose the use of a Box--Cox power transformation incorporated as part of the inference procedure to account parametrically for the uncertainty surrounding the scale of extrapolation. This has the additional feature of increasing the rate of convergence of the distribution tails to an extreme value form in certain cases and thus reducing bias in the model estimation. Inference without reparameterization is practicably infeasible, so we explore a reparameterization which exploits the asymptotic theory of normalizing constants required for nondegenerate limit distributions. Inference is carried out in a Bayesian setting, an advantage of this being the availability of posterior predictive return levels. The methodology is illustrated on both simulated data and significant wave height data from the North Sea.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.