A Causal Machine Learning Framework for Predicting Preventable Hospital Readmissions
Authors:
Ben J. Marafino,
Alejandro Schuler,
Vincent X. Liu,
Gabriel J. Escobar,
Mike Baiocchi
Abstract:
Clinical predictive algorithms are increasingly being used to form the basis for optimal treatment policies--that is, to enable interventions to be targeted to the patients who will presumably benefit most. Despite taking advantage of recent advances in supervised machine learning, these algorithms remain, in a sense, blunt instruments--often being developed and deployed without a full accounting…
▽ More
Clinical predictive algorithms are increasingly being used to form the basis for optimal treatment policies--that is, to enable interventions to be targeted to the patients who will presumably benefit most. Despite taking advantage of recent advances in supervised machine learning, these algorithms remain, in a sense, blunt instruments--often being developed and deployed without a full accounting of the causal aspects of the prediction problems they are intended to solve. Indeed, in many settings, including among patients at risk of readmission, the riskiest patients may derive less benefit from a preventative intervention compared to those at lower risk. Moreover, targeting an intervention to a population, rather than limiting it to a small group of high-risk patients, may lead to far greater overall utility if the patients with the most modifiable (or preventable) outcomes across the population could be identified. Based on these insights, we introduce a causal machine learning framework that decouples this prediction problem into causal and predictive parts, which clearly delineates the complementary roles of causal inference and prediction in this problem. We estimate treatment effects using causal forests, and characterize treatment effect heterogeneity across levels of predicted risk using these estimates. Furthermore, we show how these effect estimates could be used in concert with the modeled "payoffs" associated with successful prevention of individual readmissions to maximize overall utility. Based on data taken from before and after the implementation of a readmissions prevention intervention at Kaiser Permanente Northern California, our results suggest that nearly four times as many readmissions could be prevented annually with this approach compared to targeting this intervention using predicted risk.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2020; v1 submitted 29 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
Robust Policies For Proactive ICU Transfers
Authors:
Julien Grand-Clement,
Carri W. Chan,
Vineet Goyal,
Gabriel Escobar
Abstract:
Patients whose transfer to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) is unplanned are prone to higher mortality rates than those who were admitted directly to the ICU. Recent advances in machine learning to predict patient deterioration have introduced the possibility of \emph{proactive transfer} from the ward to the ICU. In this work, we study the problem of finding \emph{robust} patient transfer policies wh…
▽ More
Patients whose transfer to the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) is unplanned are prone to higher mortality rates than those who were admitted directly to the ICU. Recent advances in machine learning to predict patient deterioration have introduced the possibility of \emph{proactive transfer} from the ward to the ICU. In this work, we study the problem of finding \emph{robust} patient transfer policies which account for uncertainty in statistical estimates due to data limitations when optimizing to improve overall patient care. We propose a Markov Decision Process model to capture the evolution of patient health, where the states represent a measure of patient severity. Under fairly general assumptions, we show that an optimal transfer policy has a threshold structure, i.e., that it transfers all patients above a certain severity level to the ICU (subject to available capacity). As model parameters are typically determined based on statistical estimations from real-world data, they are inherently subject to misspecification and estimation errors. We account for this parameter uncertainty by deriving a robust policy that optimizes the worst-case reward across all plausible values of the model parameters. We show that the robust policy also has a threshold structure under fairly general assumptions. Moreover, it is more aggressive in transferring patients than the optimal nominal policy, which does not take into account parameter uncertainty. We present computational experiments using a dataset of hospitalizations at 21 KNPC hospitals, and present empirical evidence of the sensitivity of various hospital metrics (mortality, length-of-stay, average ICU occupancy) to small changes in the parameters. Our work provides useful insights into the impact of parameter uncertainty on deriving simple policies for proactive ICU transfer that have strong empirical performance and theoretical guarantees.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021; v1 submitted 14 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.