-
A Theoretical Analysis of Catastrophic Forgetting through the NTK Overlap Matrix
Authors:
Thang Doan,
Mehdi Bennani,
Bogdan Mazoure,
Guillaume Rabusseau,
Pierre Alquier
Abstract:
Continual learning (CL) is a setting in which an agent has to learn from an incoming stream of data during its entire lifetime. Although major advances have been made in the field, one recurring problem which remains unsolved is that of Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). While the issue has been extensively studied empirically, little attention has been paid from a theoretical angle. In this paper, we…
▽ More
Continual learning (CL) is a setting in which an agent has to learn from an incoming stream of data during its entire lifetime. Although major advances have been made in the field, one recurring problem which remains unsolved is that of Catastrophic Forgetting (CF). While the issue has been extensively studied empirically, little attention has been paid from a theoretical angle. In this paper, we show that the impact of CF increases as two tasks increasingly align. We introduce a measure of task similarity called the NTK overlap matrix which is at the core of CF. We analyze common projected gradient algorithms and demonstrate how they mitigate forgetting. Then, we propose a variant of Orthogonal Gradient Descent (OGD) which leverages structure of the data through Principal Component Analysis (PCA). Experiments support our theoretical findings and show how our method can help reduce CF on classical CL datasets.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2021; v1 submitted 7 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Local Stochastic Approximation: A Unified View of Federated Learning and Distributed Multi-Task Reinforcement Learning Algorithms
Authors:
Thinh T. Doan
Abstract:
Motivated by broad applications in reinforcement learning and federated learning, we study local stochastic approximation over a network of agents, where their goal is to find the root of an operator composed of the local operators at the agents. Our focus is to characterize the finite-time performance of this method when the data at each agent are generated from Markov processes, and hence they a…
▽ More
Motivated by broad applications in reinforcement learning and federated learning, we study local stochastic approximation over a network of agents, where their goal is to find the root of an operator composed of the local operators at the agents. Our focus is to characterize the finite-time performance of this method when the data at each agent are generated from Markov processes, and hence they are dependent. In particular, we provide the convergence rates of local stochastic approximation for both constant and time-varying step sizes. Our results show that these rates are within a logarithmic factor of the ones under independent data. We then illustrate the applications of these results to different interesting problems in multi-task reinforcement learning and federated learning.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Generalisation Guarantees for Continual Learning with Orthogonal Gradient Descent
Authors:
Mehdi Abbana Bennani,
Thang Doan,
Masashi Sugiyama
Abstract:
In Continual Learning settings, deep neural networks are prone to Catastrophic Forgetting. Orthogonal Gradient Descent was proposed to tackle the challenge. However, no theoretical guarantees have been proven yet. We present a theoretical framework to study Continual Learning algorithms in the Neural Tangent Kernel regime. This framework comprises closed form expression of the model through tasks…
▽ More
In Continual Learning settings, deep neural networks are prone to Catastrophic Forgetting. Orthogonal Gradient Descent was proposed to tackle the challenge. However, no theoretical guarantees have been proven yet. We present a theoretical framework to study Continual Learning algorithms in the Neural Tangent Kernel regime. This framework comprises closed form expression of the model through tasks and proxies for Transfer Learning, generalisation and tasks similarity. In this framework, we prove that OGD is robust to Catastrophic Forgetting then derive the first generalisation bound for SGD and OGD for Continual Learning. Finally, we study the limits of this framework in practice for OGD and highlight the importance of the Neural Tangent Kernel variation for Continual Learning with OGD.
△ Less
Submitted 4 December, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Deep Reinforcement and InfoMax Learning
Authors:
Bogdan Mazoure,
Remi Tachet des Combes,
Thang Doan,
Philip Bachman,
R Devon Hjelm
Abstract:
We begin with the hypothesis that a model-free agent whose representations are predictive of properties of future states (beyond expected rewards) will be more capable of solving and adapting to new RL problems. To test that hypothesis, we introduce an objective based on Deep InfoMax (DIM) which trains the agent to predict the future by maximizing the mutual information between its internal repres…
▽ More
We begin with the hypothesis that a model-free agent whose representations are predictive of properties of future states (beyond expected rewards) will be more capable of solving and adapting to new RL problems. To test that hypothesis, we introduce an objective based on Deep InfoMax (DIM) which trains the agent to predict the future by maximizing the mutual information between its internal representation of successive timesteps. We test our approach in several synthetic settings, where it successfully learns representations that are predictive of the future. Finally, we augment C51, a strong RL baseline, with our temporal DIM objective and demonstrate improved performance on a continual learning task and on the recently introduced Procgen environment.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A Decentralized Policy Gradient Approach to Multi-task Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Sihan Zeng,
Aqeel Anwar,
Thinh Doan,
Arijit Raychowdhury,
Justin Romberg
Abstract:
We develop a mathematical framework for solving multi-task reinforcement learning (MTRL) problems based on a type of policy gradient method. The goal in MTRL is to learn a common policy that operates effectively in different environments; these environments have similar (or overlap**) state spaces, but have different rewards and dynamics. We highlight two fundamental challenges in MTRL that are…
▽ More
We develop a mathematical framework for solving multi-task reinforcement learning (MTRL) problems based on a type of policy gradient method. The goal in MTRL is to learn a common policy that operates effectively in different environments; these environments have similar (or overlap**) state spaces, but have different rewards and dynamics. We highlight two fundamental challenges in MTRL that are not present in its single task counterpart, and illustrate them with simple examples. We then develop a decentralized entropy-regularized policy gradient method for solving the MTRL problem, and study its finite-time convergence rate. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed method using a series of numerical experiments. These experiments range from small-scale "GridWorld" problems that readily demonstrate the trade-offs involved in multi-task learning to large-scale problems, where common policies are learned to navigate an airborne drone in multiple (simulated) environments.
△ Less
Submitted 27 May, 2021; v1 submitted 7 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Representation of Reinforcement Learning Policies in Reproducing Kernel Hilbert Spaces
Authors:
Bogdan Mazoure,
Thang Doan,
Tianyu Li,
Vladimir Makarenkov,
Joelle Pineau,
Doina Precup,
Guillaume Rabusseau
Abstract:
We propose a general framework for policy representation for reinforcement learning tasks. This framework involves finding a low-dimensional embedding of the policy on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). The usage of RKHS based methods allows us to derive strong theoretical guarantees on the expected return of the reconstructed policy. Such guarantees are typically lacking in black-box mode…
▽ More
We propose a general framework for policy representation for reinforcement learning tasks. This framework involves finding a low-dimensional embedding of the policy on a reproducing kernel Hilbert space (RKHS). The usage of RKHS based methods allows us to derive strong theoretical guarantees on the expected return of the reconstructed policy. Such guarantees are typically lacking in black-box models, but are very desirable in tasks requiring stability. We conduct several experiments on classic RL domains. The results confirm that the policies can be robustly embedded in a low-dimensional space while the embedded policy incurs almost no decrease in return.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2020; v1 submitted 7 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Finite-Time Analysis and Restarting Scheme for Linear Two-Time-Scale Stochastic Approximation
Authors:
Thinh T. Doan
Abstract:
Motivated by their broad applications in reinforcement learning, we study the linear two-time-scale stochastic approximation, an iterative method using two different step sizes for finding the solutions of a system of two equations. Our main focus is to characterize the finite-time complexity of this method under time-varying step sizes and Markovian noise. In particular, we show that the mean squ…
▽ More
Motivated by their broad applications in reinforcement learning, we study the linear two-time-scale stochastic approximation, an iterative method using two different step sizes for finding the solutions of a system of two equations. Our main focus is to characterize the finite-time complexity of this method under time-varying step sizes and Markovian noise. In particular, we show that the mean square errors of the variables generated by the method converge to zero at a sublinear rate $\Ocal(k^{2/3})$, where $k$ is the number of iterations. We then improve the performance of this method by considering the restarting scheme, where we restart the algorithm after every predetermined number of iterations. We show that using this restarting method the complexity of the algorithm under time-varying step sizes is as good as the one using constant step sizes, but still achieving an exact converge to the desired solution. Moreover, the restarting scheme also helps to prevent the step sizes from getting too small, which is useful for the practical implementation of the linear two-time-scale stochastic approximation.
△ Less
Submitted 9 January, 2020; v1 submitted 22 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Attraction-Repulsion Actor-Critic for Continuous Control Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Thang Doan,
Bogdan Mazoure,
Moloud Abdar,
Audrey Durand,
Joelle Pineau,
R Devon Hjelm
Abstract:
Continuous control tasks in reinforcement learning are important because they provide an important framework for learning in high-dimensional state spaces with deceptive rewards, where the agent can easily become trapped into suboptimal solutions. One way to avoid local optima is to use a population of agents to ensure coverage of the policy space, yet learning a population with the "best" coverag…
▽ More
Continuous control tasks in reinforcement learning are important because they provide an important framework for learning in high-dimensional state spaces with deceptive rewards, where the agent can easily become trapped into suboptimal solutions. One way to avoid local optima is to use a population of agents to ensure coverage of the policy space, yet learning a population with the "best" coverage is still an open problem. In this work, we present a novel approach to population-based RL in continuous control that leverages properties of normalizing flows to perform attractive and repulsive operations between current members of the population and previously observed policies. Empirical results on the MuJoCo suite demonstrate a high performance gain for our algorithm compared to prior work, including Soft-Actor Critic (SAC).
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2020; v1 submitted 16 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Self-supervised Learning of Distance Functions for Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Srinivas Venkattaramanujam,
Eric Crawford,
Thang Doan,
Doina Precup
Abstract:
Goal-conditioned policies are used in order to break down complex reinforcement learning (RL) problems by using subgoals, which can be defined either in state space or in a latent feature space. This can increase the efficiency of learning by using a curriculum, and also enables simultaneous learning and generalization across goals. A crucial requirement of goal-conditioned policies is to be able…
▽ More
Goal-conditioned policies are used in order to break down complex reinforcement learning (RL) problems by using subgoals, which can be defined either in state space or in a latent feature space. This can increase the efficiency of learning by using a curriculum, and also enables simultaneous learning and generalization across goals. A crucial requirement of goal-conditioned policies is to be able to determine whether the goal has been achieved. Having a notion of distance to a goal is thus a crucial component of this approach. However, it is not straightforward to come up with an appropriate distance, and in some tasks, the goal space may not even be known a priori. In this work we learn a distance-to-goal estimate which is computed in terms of the number of actions that would need to be carried out in a self-supervised approach. Our method solves complex tasks without prior domain knowledge in the online setting in three different scenarios in the context of goal-conditioned policies a) the goal space is the same as the state space b) the goal space is given but an appropriate distance is unknown and c) the state space is accessible, but only a subset of the state space represents desired goals, and this subset is known a priori. We also propose a goal-generation mechanism as a secondary contribution.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2020; v1 submitted 5 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Leveraging exploration in off-policy algorithms via normalizing flows
Authors:
Bogdan Mazoure,
Thang Doan,
Audrey Durand,
R Devon Hjelm,
Joelle Pineau
Abstract:
The ability to discover approximately optimal policies in domains with sparse rewards is crucial to applying reinforcement learning (RL) in many real-world scenarios. Approaches such as neural density models and continuous exploration (e.g., Go-Explore) have been proposed to maintain the high exploration rate necessary to find high performing and generalizable policies. Soft actor-critic(SAC) is a…
▽ More
The ability to discover approximately optimal policies in domains with sparse rewards is crucial to applying reinforcement learning (RL) in many real-world scenarios. Approaches such as neural density models and continuous exploration (e.g., Go-Explore) have been proposed to maintain the high exploration rate necessary to find high performing and generalizable policies. Soft actor-critic(SAC) is another method for improving exploration that aims to combine efficient learning via off-policy updates while maximizing the policy entropy. In this work, we extend SAC to a richer class of probability distributions (e.g., multimodal) through normalizing flows (NF) and show that this significantly improves performance by accelerating the discovery of good policies while using much smaller policy representations. Our approach, which we call SAC-NF, is a simple, efficient,easy-to-implement modification and improvement to SAC on continuous control baselines such as MuJoCo and PyBullet Roboschool domains. Finally, SAC-NF does this while being significantly parameter efficient, using as few as 5.5% the parameters for an equivalent SAC model.
△ Less
Submitted 24 September, 2019; v1 submitted 16 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Multi-objective training of Generative Adversarial Networks with multiple discriminators
Authors:
Isabela Albuquerque,
João Monteiro,
Thang Doan,
Breandan Considine,
Tiago Falk,
Ioannis Mitliagkas
Abstract:
Recent literature has demonstrated promising results for training Generative Adversarial Networks by employing a set of discriminators, in contrast to the traditional game involving one generator against a single adversary. Such methods perform single-objective optimization on some simple consolidation of the losses, e.g. an arithmetic average. In this work, we revisit the multiple-discriminator s…
▽ More
Recent literature has demonstrated promising results for training Generative Adversarial Networks by employing a set of discriminators, in contrast to the traditional game involving one generator against a single adversary. Such methods perform single-objective optimization on some simple consolidation of the losses, e.g. an arithmetic average. In this work, we revisit the multiple-discriminator setting by framing the simultaneous minimization of losses provided by different models as a multi-objective optimization problem. Specifically, we evaluate the performance of multiple gradient descent and the hypervolume maximization algorithm on a number of different datasets. Moreover, we argue that the previously proposed methods and hypervolume maximization can all be seen as variations of multiple gradient descent in which the update direction can be computed efficiently. Our results indicate that hypervolume maximization presents a better compromise between sample quality and computational cost than previous methods.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Generating Realistic Sequences of Customer-level Transactions for Retail Datasets
Authors:
Thang Doan,
Neil Veira,
Saibal Ray,
Brian Keng
Abstract:
In order to better engage with customers, retailers rely on extensive customer and product databases which allows them to better understand customer behaviour and purchasing patterns. This has long been a challenging task as customer modelling is a multi-faceted, noisy and time-dependent problem. The most common way to tackle this problem is indirectly through task-specific supervised learning pre…
▽ More
In order to better engage with customers, retailers rely on extensive customer and product databases which allows them to better understand customer behaviour and purchasing patterns. This has long been a challenging task as customer modelling is a multi-faceted, noisy and time-dependent problem. The most common way to tackle this problem is indirectly through task-specific supervised learning prediction problems, with relatively little literature on modelling a customer by directly simulating their future transactions. In this paper we propose a method for generating realistic sequences of baskets that a given customer is likely to purchase over a period of time. Customer embedding representations are learned using a Recurrent Neural Network (RNN) which takes into account the entire sequence of transaction data. Given the customer state at a specific point in time, a Generative Adversarial Network (GAN) is trained to generate a plausible basket of products for the following week. The newly generated basket is then fed back into the RNN to update the customer's state. The GAN is thus used in tandem with the RNN module in a pipeline alternating between basket generation and customer state updating steps. This allows for sampling over a distribution of a customer's future sequence of baskets, which then can be used to gain insight into how to service the customer more effectively. The methodology is empirically shown to produce baskets that appear similar to real baskets and enjoy many common properties, including frequencies of different product types, brands, and prices. Furthermore, the generated data is able to replicate most of the strongest sequential patterns that exist between product types in the real data.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2019; v1 submitted 16 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Scalable Bottom-up Subspace Clustering using FP-Trees for High Dimensional Data
Authors:
Minh Tuan Doan,
Jianzhong Qi,
Sutharshan Rajasegarar,
Christopher Leckie
Abstract:
Subspace clustering aims to find groups of similar objects (clusters) that exist in lower dimensional subspaces from a high dimensional dataset. It has a wide range of applications, such as analysing high dimensional sensor data or DNA sequences. However, existing algorithms have limitations in finding clusters in non-disjoint subspaces and scaling to large data, which im**e their applicability…
▽ More
Subspace clustering aims to find groups of similar objects (clusters) that exist in lower dimensional subspaces from a high dimensional dataset. It has a wide range of applications, such as analysing high dimensional sensor data or DNA sequences. However, existing algorithms have limitations in finding clusters in non-disjoint subspaces and scaling to large data, which im**e their applicability in areas such as bioinformatics and the Internet of Things. We aim to address such limitations by proposing a subspace clustering algorithm using a bottom-up strategy. Our algorithm first searches for base clusters in low dimensional subspaces. It then forms clusters in higher-dimensional subspaces using these base clusters, which we formulate as a frequent pattern mining problem. This formulation enables efficient search for clusters in higher-dimensional subspaces, which is done using FP-trees. The proposed algorithm is evaluated against traditional bottom-up clustering algorithms and state-of-the-art subspace clustering algorithms. The experimental results show that the proposed algorithm produces clusters with high accuracy, and scales well to large volumes of data. We also demonstrate the algorithm's performance using real-life data, including ten genomic datasets and a car parking occupancy dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2018;
originally announced November 2018.
-
On-line Adaptative Curriculum Learning for GANs
Authors:
Thang Doan,
Joao Monteiro,
Isabela Albuquerque,
Bogdan Mazoure,
Audrey Durand,
Joelle Pineau,
R Devon Hjelm
Abstract:
Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) can successfully approximate a probability distribution and produce realistic samples. However, open questions such as sufficient convergence conditions and mode collapse still persist. In this paper, we build on existing work in the area by proposing a novel framework for training the generator against an ensemble of discriminator networks, which can be seen…
▽ More
Generative Adversarial Networks (GANs) can successfully approximate a probability distribution and produce realistic samples. However, open questions such as sufficient convergence conditions and mode collapse still persist. In this paper, we build on existing work in the area by proposing a novel framework for training the generator against an ensemble of discriminator networks, which can be seen as a one-student/multiple-teachers setting. We formalize this problem within the full-information adversarial bandit framework, where we evaluate the capability of an algorithm to select mixtures of discriminators for providing the generator with feedback during learning. To this end, we propose a reward function which reflects the progress made by the generator and dynamically update the mixture weights allocated to each discriminator. We also draw connections between our algorithm and stochastic optimization methods and then show that existing approaches using multiple discriminators in literature can be recovered from our framework. We argue that less expressive discriminators are smoother and have a general coarse grained view of the modes map, which enforces the generator to cover a wide portion of the data distribution support. On the other hand, highly expressive discriminators ensure samples quality. Finally, experimental results show that our approach improves samples quality and diversity over existing baselines by effectively learning a curriculum. These results also support the claim that weaker discriminators have higher entropy improving modes coverage. Keywords: multiple discriminators, curriculum learning, multiple resolutions discriminators, multi-armed bandits, generative adversarial networks, smooth discriminators, multi-discriminator gan training, multiple experts.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2019; v1 submitted 31 July, 2018;
originally announced August 2018.
-
GAN Q-learning
Authors:
Thang Doan,
Bogdan Mazoure,
Clare Lyle
Abstract:
Distributional reinforcement learning (distributional RL) has seen empirical success in complex Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) in the setting of nonlinear function approximation. However, there are many different ways in which one can leverage the distributional approach to reinforcement learning. In this paper, we propose GAN Q-learning, a novel distributional RL method based on generative adve…
▽ More
Distributional reinforcement learning (distributional RL) has seen empirical success in complex Markov Decision Processes (MDPs) in the setting of nonlinear function approximation. However, there are many different ways in which one can leverage the distributional approach to reinforcement learning. In this paper, we propose GAN Q-learning, a novel distributional RL method based on generative adversarial networks (GANs) and analyze its performance in simple tabular environments, as well as OpenAI Gym. We empirically show that our algorithm leverages the flexibility and blackbox approach of deep learning models while providing a viable alternative to traditional methods.
△ Less
Submitted 20 July, 2018; v1 submitted 13 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Guaranteed inference in topic models
Authors:
Khoat Than,
Tung Doan
Abstract:
One of the core problems in statistical models is the estimation of a posterior distribution. For topic models, the problem of posterior inference for individual texts is particularly important, especially when dealing with data streams, but is often intractable in the worst case. As a consequence, existing methods for posterior inference are approximate and do not have any guarantee on neither qu…
▽ More
One of the core problems in statistical models is the estimation of a posterior distribution. For topic models, the problem of posterior inference for individual texts is particularly important, especially when dealing with data streams, but is often intractable in the worst case. As a consequence, existing methods for posterior inference are approximate and do not have any guarantee on neither quality nor convergence rate. In this paper, we introduce a provably fast algorithm, namely Online Maximum a Posteriori Estimation (OPE), for posterior inference in topic models. OPE has more attractive properties than existing inference approaches, including theoretical guarantees on quality and fast rate of convergence to a local maximal/stationary point of the inference problem. The discussions about OPE are very general and hence can be easily employed in a wide range of contexts. Finally, we employ OPE to design three methods for learning Latent Dirichlet Allocation from text streams or large corpora. Extensive experiments demonstrate some superior behaviors of OPE and of our new learning methods.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2016; v1 submitted 10 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
-
Joint Inference of Misaligned Irregular Time Series with Application to Greenland Ice Core Data
Authors:
Thinh K. Doan,
Andrew C. Parnell,
John Haslett
Abstract:
Ice cores provide insight into the past climate over many millennia. Due to ice compaction, the raw data for any single core are irregular in time. Multiple cores have different irregularities; jointly these series are misaligned. After processing, such data are made available to researchers as regular time series: a data product. Typically, these cores are independently processed. In this paper,…
▽ More
Ice cores provide insight into the past climate over many millennia. Due to ice compaction, the raw data for any single core are irregular in time. Multiple cores have different irregularities; jointly these series are misaligned. After processing, such data are made available to researchers as regular time series: a data product. Typically, these cores are independently processed. In this paper, we consider a fast Bayesian method for the joint processing of multiple irregular series. This is shown to be more efficient. Further, our approach permits a realistic modelling of the impact of the multiple sources of uncertainty. The methodology is illustrated with the analysis of a pair of ice cores (GISP2 and GRIP). Our data products, in the form of marginal posterior distributions on an arbitrary temporal grid, are finite Gaussian mixtures. We can also produce sample paths from the joint posterior distribution to study non-linear functionals of interest. More generally, the concept of joint analysis via hierarchical Gaussian process model can be widely extended as the models used can be viewed within the larger context of continuous space-time processes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2014; v1 submitted 12 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
On Bayesian Modelling of the Uncertainties in Palaeoclimate Reconstruction
Authors:
Andrew C. Parnell,
James Sweeney,
Thinh K. Doan,
Michael Salter-Townshend,
Judy R. M. Allen,
Brian Huntley,
John Haslett
Abstract:
We outline a model and algorithm to perform inference on the palaeoclimate and palaeoclimate volatility from pollen proxy data. We use a novel multivariate non-linear non-Gaussian state space model consisting of an observation equation linking climate to proxy data and an evolution equation driving climate change over time. The link from climate to proxy data is defined by a pre-calibrated forward…
▽ More
We outline a model and algorithm to perform inference on the palaeoclimate and palaeoclimate volatility from pollen proxy data. We use a novel multivariate non-linear non-Gaussian state space model consisting of an observation equation linking climate to proxy data and an evolution equation driving climate change over time. The link from climate to proxy data is defined by a pre-calibrated forward model, as developed in Salter-Townshend and Haslett (2012) and Sweeney (2012). Climatic change is represented by a temporally-uncertain Normal-Inverse Gaussian Levy process, being able to capture large jumps in multivariate climate whilst remaining temporally consistent. The pre-calibrated nature of the forward model allows us to cut feedback between the observation and evolution equations and thus integrate out the state variable entirely whilst making minimal simplifying assumptions. A key part of this approach is the creation of mixtures of marginal data posteriors representing the information obtained about climate from each individual time point. Our approach allows for an extremely efficient MCMC algorithm, which we demonstrate with a pollen core from Sluggan Bog, County Antrim, Northern Ireland.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
