Showing 1–17 of 17 results for author: Dieuleveut, A

Predictive Uncertainty Quantification with Missing Covariates

Authors: Margaux Zaffran, Julie Josse, Yaniv Romano, Aymeric Dieuleveut

Abstract: Predictive uncertainty quantification is crucial in decision-making problems. We investigate how to adequately quantify predictive uncertainty with missing covariates. A bottleneck is that missing values induce heteroskedasticity on the response's predictive distribution given the observed covariates. Thus, we focus on building predictive sets for the response that are valid conditionally to the m… ▽ More Predictive uncertainty quantification is crucial in decision-making problems. We investigate how to adequately quantify predictive uncertainty with missing covariates. A bottleneck is that missing values induce heteroskedasticity on the response's predictive distribution given the observed covariates. Thus, we focus on building predictive sets for the response that are valid conditionally to the missing values pattern. We show that this goal is impossible to achieve informatively in a distribution-free fashion, and we propose useful restrictions on the distribution class. Motivated by these hardness results, we characterize how missing values and predictive uncertainty intertwine. Particularly, we rigorously formalize the idea that the more missing values, the higher the predictive uncertainty. Then, we introduce a generalized framework, coined CP-MDA-Nested*, outputting predictive sets in both regression and classification. Under independence between the missing value pattern and both the features and the response (an assumption justified by our hardness results), these predictive sets are valid conditionally to any pattern of missing values. Moreover, it provides great flexibility in the trade-off between statistical variability and efficiency. Finally, we experimentally assess the performances of CP-MDA-Nested* beyond its scope of theoretical validity, demonstrating promising outcomes in more challenging configurations than independence. △ Less

Submitted 24 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Byzantine-Robust Gossip: Insights from a Dual Approach

Authors: Renaud Gaucher, Hadrien Hendrikx, Aymeric Dieuleveut

Abstract: Distributed approaches have many computational benefits, but they are vulnerable to attacks from a subset of devices transmitting incorrect information. This paper investigates Byzantine-resilient algorithms in a decentralized setting, where devices communicate directly with one another. We leverage the so-called dual approach to design a general robust decentralized optimization method. We provid… ▽ More Distributed approaches have many computational benefits, but they are vulnerable to attacks from a subset of devices transmitting incorrect information. This paper investigates Byzantine-resilient algorithms in a decentralized setting, where devices communicate directly with one another. We leverage the so-called dual approach to design a general robust decentralized optimization method. We provide both global and local clip** rules in the special case of average consensus, with tight convergence guarantees. These clip** rules are practical, and yield results that finely characterize the impact of Byzantine nodes, highlighting for instance a qualitative difference in convergence between global and local clip** thresholds. Lastly, we demonstrate that they can serve as a basis for designing efficient attacks. △ Less

Submitted 6 May, 2024; originally announced May 2024.

Comments: 9 pages, 1 figure

Random features models: a way to study the success of naive imputation

Authors: Alexis Ayme, Claire Boyer, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Erwan Scornet

Abstract: Constant (naive) imputation is still widely used in practice as this is a first easy-to-use technique to deal with missing data. Yet, this simple method could be expected to induce a large bias for prediction purposes, as the imputed input may strongly differ from the true underlying data. However, recent works suggest that this bias is low in the context of high-dimensional linear predictors when… ▽ More Constant (naive) imputation is still widely used in practice as this is a first easy-to-use technique to deal with missing data. Yet, this simple method could be expected to induce a large bias for prediction purposes, as the imputed input may strongly differ from the true underlying data. However, recent works suggest that this bias is low in the context of high-dimensional linear predictors when data is supposed to be missing completely at random (MCAR). This paper completes the picture for linear predictors by confirming the intuition that the bias is negligible and that surprisingly naive imputation also remains relevant in very low dimension.To this aim, we consider a unique underlying random features model, which offers a rigorous framework for studying predictive performances, whilst the dimension of the observed features varies.Building on these theoretical results, we establish finite-sample bounds on stochastic gradient (SGD) predictors applied to zero-imputed data, a strategy particularly well suited for large-scale learning.If the MCAR assumption appears to be strong, we show that similar favorable behaviors occur for more complex missing data scenarios. △ Less

Submitted 6 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Sliced-Wasserstein Estimation with Spherical Harmonics as Control Variates

Authors: Rémi Leluc, Aymeric Dieuleveut, François Portier, Johan Segers, Aigerim Zhuman

Abstract: The Sliced-Wasserstein (SW) distance between probability measures is defined as the average of the Wasserstein distances resulting for the associated one-dimensional projections. As a consequence, the SW distance can be written as an integral with respect to the uniform measure on the sphere and the Monte Carlo framework can be employed for calculating the SW distance. Spherical harmonics are poly… ▽ More The Sliced-Wasserstein (SW) distance between probability measures is defined as the average of the Wasserstein distances resulting for the associated one-dimensional projections. As a consequence, the SW distance can be written as an integral with respect to the uniform measure on the sphere and the Monte Carlo framework can be employed for calculating the SW distance. Spherical harmonics are polynomials on the sphere that form an orthonormal basis of the set of square-integrable functions on the sphere. Putting these two facts together, a new Monte Carlo method, hereby referred to as Spherical Harmonics Control Variates (SHCV), is proposed for approximating the SW distance using spherical harmonics as control variates. The resulting approach is shown to have good theoretical properties, e.g., a no-error property for Gaussian measures under a certain form of linear dependency between the variables. Moreover, an improved rate of convergence, compared to Monte Carlo, is established for general measures. The convergence analysis relies on the Lipschitz property associated to the SW integrand. Several numerical experiments demonstrate the superior performance of SHCV against state-of-the-art methods for SW distance computation. △ Less

Submitted 15 May, 2024; v1 submitted 2 February, 2024; originally announced February 2024.

Comments: Accepted to ICML 2024

MSC Class: 65C05 (Primary) 65D30; 68Txx; 68Wxx (Secondary)

Compressed and distributed least-squares regression: convergence rates with applications to Federated Learning

Authors: Constantin Philippenko, Aymeric Dieuleveut

Abstract: In this paper, we investigate the impact of compression on stochastic gradient algorithms for machine learning, a technique widely used in distributed and federated learning. We underline differences in terms of convergence rates between several unbiased compression operators, that all satisfy the same condition on their variance, thus going beyond the classical worst-case analysis. To do so, we f… ▽ More In this paper, we investigate the impact of compression on stochastic gradient algorithms for machine learning, a technique widely used in distributed and federated learning. We underline differences in terms of convergence rates between several unbiased compression operators, that all satisfy the same condition on their variance, thus going beyond the classical worst-case analysis. To do so, we focus on the case of least-squares regression (LSR) and analyze a general stochastic approximation algorithm for minimizing quadratic functions relying on a random field. We consider weak assumptions on the random field, tailored to the analysis (specifically, expected Hölder regularity), and on the noise covariance, enabling the analysis of various randomizing mechanisms, including compression. We then extend our results to the case of federated learning. More formally, we highlight the impact on the convergence of the covariance $\mathfrak{C}_{\mathrm{ania}}$ of the additive noise induced by the algorithm. We demonstrate despite the non-regularity of the stochastic field, that the limit variance term scales with $\mathrm{Tr}(\mathfrak{C}_{\mathrm{ania}} H^{-1})/K$ (where $H$ is the Hessian of the optimization problem and $K$ the number of iterations) generalizing the rate for the vanilla LSR case where it is $σ^2 \mathrm{Tr}(H H^{-1}) / K = σ^2 d / K$ (Bach and Moulines, 2013). Then, we analyze the dependency of $\mathfrak{C}_{\mathrm{ania}}$ on the compression strategy and ultimately its impact on convergence, first in the centralized case, then in two heterogeneous FL frameworks. △ Less

Submitted 2 August, 2023; originally announced August 2023.

Conformal Prediction with Missing Values

Authors: Margaux Zaffran, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Julie Josse, Yaniv Romano

Abstract: Conformal prediction is a theoretically grounded framework for constructing predictive intervals. We study conformal prediction with missing values in the covariates -- a setting that brings new challenges to uncertainty quantification. We first show that the marginal coverage guarantee of conformal prediction holds on imputed data for any missingness distribution and almost all imputation functio… ▽ More Conformal prediction is a theoretically grounded framework for constructing predictive intervals. We study conformal prediction with missing values in the covariates -- a setting that brings new challenges to uncertainty quantification. We first show that the marginal coverage guarantee of conformal prediction holds on imputed data for any missingness distribution and almost all imputation functions. However, we emphasize that the average coverage varies depending on the pattern of missing values: conformal methods tend to construct prediction intervals that under-cover the response conditionally to some missing patterns. This motivates our novel generalized conformalized quantile regression framework, missing data augmentation, which yields prediction intervals that are valid conditionally to the patterns of missing values, despite their exponential number. We then show that a universally consistent quantile regression algorithm trained on the imputed data is Bayes optimal for the pinball risk, thus achieving valid coverage conditionally to any given data point. Moreover, we examine the case of a linear model, which demonstrates the importance of our proposal in overcoming the heteroskedasticity induced by missing values. Using synthetic and data from critical care, we corroborate our theory and report improved performance of our methods. △ Less

Submitted 5 June, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Comments: Code for our experiments can be found at https://github.com/mzaffran/ConformalPredictionMissingValues . To be published in the proceedings of the 40th International Conference on Machine Learning, Honolulu, Hawaii, USA

Stochastic Approximation Beyond Gradient for Signal Processing and Machine Learning

Authors: Aymeric Dieuleveut, Gersende Fort, Eric Moulines, Hoi-To Wai

Abstract: Stochastic Approximation (SA) is a classical algorithm that has had since the early days a huge impact on signal processing, and nowadays on machine learning, due to the necessity to deal with a large amount of data observed with uncertainties. An exemplar special case of SA pertains to the popular stochastic (sub)gradient algorithm which is the working horse behind many important applications. A… ▽ More Stochastic Approximation (SA) is a classical algorithm that has had since the early days a huge impact on signal processing, and nowadays on machine learning, due to the necessity to deal with a large amount of data observed with uncertainties. An exemplar special case of SA pertains to the popular stochastic (sub)gradient algorithm which is the working horse behind many important applications. A lesser-known fact is that the SA scheme also extends to non-stochastic-gradient algorithms such as compressed stochastic gradient, stochastic expectation-maximization, and a number of reinforcement learning algorithms. The aim of this article is to overview and introduce the non-stochastic-gradient perspectives of SA to the signal processing and machine learning audiences through presenting a design guideline of SA algorithms backed by theories. Our central theme is to propose a general framework that unifies existing theories of SA, including its non-asymptotic and asymptotic convergence results, and demonstrate their applications on popular non-stochastic-gradient algorithms. We build our analysis framework based on classes of Lyapunov functions that satisfy a variety of mild conditions. We draw connections between non-stochastic-gradient algorithms and scenarios when the Lyapunov function is smooth, convex, or strongly convex. Using the said framework, we illustrate the convergence properties of the non-stochastic-gradient algorithms using concrete examples. Extensions to the emerging variance reduction techniques for improved sample complexity will also be discussed. △ Less

Submitted 16 July, 2023; v1 submitted 22 February, 2023; originally announced February 2023.

Comments: Accepted for publication at IEEE Transactions on Signal Processing; 31 pages, 7 pages of supplementary materials

Adaptive Conformal Predictions for Time Series

Authors: Margaux Zaffran, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Olivier Féron, Yannig Goude, Julie Josse

Abstract: Uncertainty quantification of predictive models is crucial in decision-making problems. Conformal prediction is a general and theoretically sound answer. However, it requires exchangeable data, excluding time series. While recent works tackled this issue, we argue that Adaptive Conformal Inference (ACI, Gibbs and Cand{è}s, 2021), developed for distribution-shift time series, is a good procedure fo… ▽ More Uncertainty quantification of predictive models is crucial in decision-making problems. Conformal prediction is a general and theoretically sound answer. However, it requires exchangeable data, excluding time series. While recent works tackled this issue, we argue that Adaptive Conformal Inference (ACI, Gibbs and Cand{è}s, 2021), developed for distribution-shift time series, is a good procedure for time series with general dependency. We theoretically analyse the impact of the learning rate on its efficiency in the exchangeable and auto-regressive case. We propose a parameter-free method, AgACI, that adaptively builds upon ACI based on online expert aggregation. We lead extensive fair simulations against competing methods that advocate for ACI's use in time series. We conduct a real case study: electricity price forecasting. The proposed aggregation algorithm provides efficient prediction intervals for day-ahead forecasting. All the code and data to reproduce the experiments is made available. △ Less

Submitted 15 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

Minimax rate of consistency for linear models with missing values

Authors: Alexis Ayme, Claire Boyer, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Erwan Scornet

Abstract: Missing values arise in most real-world data sets due to the aggregation of multiple sources and intrinsically missing information (sensor failure, unanswered questions in surveys...). In fact, the very nature of missing values usually prevents us from running standard learning algorithms. In this paper, we focus on the extensively-studied linear models, but in presence of missing values, which tu… ▽ More Missing values arise in most real-world data sets due to the aggregation of multiple sources and intrinsically missing information (sensor failure, unanswered questions in surveys...). In fact, the very nature of missing values usually prevents us from running standard learning algorithms. In this paper, we focus on the extensively-studied linear models, but in presence of missing values, which turns out to be quite a challenging task. Indeed, the Bayes rule can be decomposed as a sum of predictors corresponding to each missing pattern. This eventually requires to solve a number of learning tasks, exponential in the number of input features, which makes predictions impossible for current real-world datasets. First, we propose a rigorous setting to analyze a least-square type estimator and establish a bound on the excess risk which increases exponentially in the dimension. Consequently, we leverage the missing data distribution to propose a new algorithm, andderive associated adaptive risk bounds that turn out to be minimax optimal. Numerical experiments highlight the benefits of our method compared to state-of-the-art algorithms used for predictions with missing values. △ Less

Submitted 3 February, 2022; originally announced February 2022.

QLSD: Quantised Langevin stochastic dynamics for Bayesian federated learning

Authors: Maxime Vono, Vincent Plassier, Alain Durmus, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Eric Moulines

Abstract: The objective of Federated Learning (FL) is to perform statistical inference for data which are decentralised and stored locally on networked clients. FL raises many constraints which include privacy and data ownership, communication overhead, statistical heterogeneity, and partial client participation. In this paper, we address these problems in the framework of the Bayesian paradigm. To this end… ▽ More The objective of Federated Learning (FL) is to perform statistical inference for data which are decentralised and stored locally on networked clients. FL raises many constraints which include privacy and data ownership, communication overhead, statistical heterogeneity, and partial client participation. In this paper, we address these problems in the framework of the Bayesian paradigm. To this end, we propose a novel federated Markov Chain Monte Carlo algorithm, referred to as Quantised Langevin Stochastic Dynamics which may be seen as an extension to the FL setting of Stochastic Gradient Langevin Dynamics, which handles the communication bottleneck using gradient compression. To improve performance, we then introduce variance reduction techniques, which lead to two improved versions coined \texttt{QLSD}$^{\star}$ and \texttt{QLSD}$^{++}$. We give both non-asymptotic and asymptotic convergence guarantees for the proposed algorithms. We illustrate their performances using various Bayesian Federated Learning benchmarks. △ Less

Submitted 31 May, 2022; v1 submitted 1 June, 2021; originally announced June 2021.

On Convergence-Diagnostic based Step Sizes for Stochastic Gradient Descent

Authors: Scott Pesme, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Nicolas Flammarion

Abstract: Constant step-size Stochastic Gradient Descent exhibits two phases: a transient phase during which iterates make fast progress towards the optimum, followed by a stationary phase during which iterates oscillate around the optimal point. In this paper, we show that efficiently detecting this transition and appropriately decreasing the step size can lead to fast convergence rates. We analyse the cla… ▽ More Constant step-size Stochastic Gradient Descent exhibits two phases: a transient phase during which iterates make fast progress towards the optimum, followed by a stationary phase during which iterates oscillate around the optimal point. In this paper, we show that efficiently detecting this transition and appropriately decreasing the step size can lead to fast convergence rates. We analyse the classical statistical test proposed by Pflug (1983), based on the inner product between consecutive stochastic gradients. Even in the simple case where the objective function is quadratic we show that this test cannot lead to an adequate convergence diagnostic. We then propose a novel and simple statistical procedure that accurately detects stationarity and we provide experimental results showing state-of-the-art performance on synthetic and real-world datasets. △ Less

Submitted 1 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Bidirectional compression in heterogeneous settings for distributed or federated learning with partial participation: tight convergence guarantees

Authors: Constantin Philippenko, Aymeric Dieuleveut

Abstract: We introduce a framework - Artemis - to tackle the problem of learning in a distributed or federated setting with communication constraints and device partial participation. Several workers (randomly sampled) perform the optimization process using a central server to aggregate their computations. To alleviate the communication cost, Artemis allows to compress the information sent in both direction… ▽ More We introduce a framework - Artemis - to tackle the problem of learning in a distributed or federated setting with communication constraints and device partial participation. Several workers (randomly sampled) perform the optimization process using a central server to aggregate their computations. To alleviate the communication cost, Artemis allows to compress the information sent in both directions (from the workers to the server and conversely) combined with a memory mechanism. It improves on existing algorithms that only consider unidirectional compression (to the server), or use very strong assumptions on the compression operator, and often do not take into account devices partial participation. We provide fast rates of convergence (linear up to a threshold) under weak assumptions on the stochastic gradients (noise's variance bounded only at optimal point) in non-i.i.d. setting, highlight the impact of memory for unidirectional and bidirectional compression, analyze Polyak-Ruppert averaging. We use convergence in distribution to obtain a lower bound of the asymptotic variance that highlights practical limits of compression. We propose two approaches to tackle the challenging case of devices partial participation and provide experimental results to demonstrate the validity of our analysis. △ Less

Submitted 19 June, 2022; v1 submitted 25 June, 2020; originally announced June 2020.

Comments: 54 pages, 4 theorems, 1 algorithm, code source on GitHub

Communication trade-offs for synchronized distributed SGD with large step size

Authors: Kumar Kshitij Patel, Aymeric Dieuleveut

Abstract: Synchronous mini-batch SGD is state-of-the-art for large-scale distributed machine learning. However, in practice, its convergence is bottlenecked by slow communication rounds between worker nodes. A natural solution to reduce communication is to use the \emph{`local-SGD'} model in which the workers train their model independently and synchronize every once in a while. This algorithm improves the… ▽ More Synchronous mini-batch SGD is state-of-the-art for large-scale distributed machine learning. However, in practice, its convergence is bottlenecked by slow communication rounds between worker nodes. A natural solution to reduce communication is to use the \emph{`local-SGD'} model in which the workers train their model independently and synchronize every once in a while. This algorithm improves the computation-communication trade-off but its convergence is not understood very well. We propose a non-asymptotic error analysis, which enables comparison to \emph{one-shot averaging} i.e., a single communication round among independent workers, and \emph{mini-batch averaging} i.e., communicating at every step. We also provide adaptive lower bounds on the communication frequency for large step-sizes ($ t^{-α} $, $ α\in (1/2 , 1 ) $) and show that \emph{Local-SGD} reduces communication by a factor of $O\Big(\frac{\sqrt{T}}{P^{3/2}}\Big)$, with $T$ the total number of gradients and $P$ machines. △ Less

Submitted 25 April, 2019; originally announced April 2019.

Unsupervised Scalable Representation Learning for Multivariate Time Series

Authors: Jean-Yves Franceschi, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Martin Jaggi

Abstract: Time series constitute a challenging data type for machine learning algorithms, due to their highly variable lengths and sparse labeling in practice. In this paper, we tackle this challenge by proposing an unsupervised method to learn universal embeddings of time series. Unlike previous works, it is scalable with respect to their length and we demonstrate the quality, transferability and practicab… ▽ More Time series constitute a challenging data type for machine learning algorithms, due to their highly variable lengths and sparse labeling in practice. In this paper, we tackle this challenge by proposing an unsupervised method to learn universal embeddings of time series. Unlike previous works, it is scalable with respect to their length and we demonstrate the quality, transferability and practicability of the learned representations with thorough experiments and comparisons. To this end, we combine an encoder based on causal dilated convolutions with a novel triplet loss employing time-based negative sampling, obtaining general-purpose representations for variable length and multivariate time series. △ Less

Submitted 3 January, 2020; v1 submitted 30 January, 2019; originally announced January 2019.

Journal ref: Thirty-third Conference on Neural Information Processing Systems, Neural Information Processing Systems Foundation, Dec 2019, Vancouver, Canada

Context Mover's Distance & Barycenters: Optimal Transport of Contexts for Building Representations

Authors: Sidak Pal Singh, Andreas Hug, Aymeric Dieuleveut, Martin Jaggi

Abstract: We present a framework for building unsupervised representations of entities and their compositions, where each entity is viewed as a probability distribution rather than a vector embedding. In particular, this distribution is supported over the contexts which co-occur with the entity and are embedded in a suitable low-dimensional space. This enables us to consider representation learning from the… ▽ More We present a framework for building unsupervised representations of entities and their compositions, where each entity is viewed as a probability distribution rather than a vector embedding. In particular, this distribution is supported over the contexts which co-occur with the entity and are embedded in a suitable low-dimensional space. This enables us to consider representation learning from the perspective of Optimal Transport and take advantage of its tools such as Wasserstein distance and barycenters. We elaborate how the method can be applied for obtaining unsupervised representations of text and illustrate the performance (quantitatively as well as qualitatively) on tasks such as measuring sentence similarity, word entailment and similarity, where we empirically observe significant gains (e.g., 4.1% relative improvement over Sent2vec, GenSen). The key benefits of the proposed approach include: (a) capturing uncertainty and polysemy via modeling the entities as distributions, (b) utilizing the underlying geometry of the particular task (with the ground cost), (c) simultaneously providing interpretability with the notion of optimal transport between contexts and (d) easy applicability on top of existing point embedding methods. The code, as well as prebuilt histograms, are available under https://github.com/context-mover/. △ Less

Submitted 29 February, 2020; v1 submitted 29 August, 2018; originally announced August 2018.

Comments: AISTATS 2020. Also, accepted previously at ICLR 2019 DeepGenStruct Workshop

Bridging the Gap between Constant Step Size Stochastic Gradient Descent and Markov Chains

Authors: Aymeric Dieuleveut, Alain Durmus, Francis Bach

Abstract: We consider the minimization of an objective function given access to unbiased estimates of its gradient through stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with constant step-size. While the detailed analysis was only performed for quadratic functions, we provide an explicit asymptotic expansion of the moments of the averaged SGD iterates that outlines the dependence on initial conditions, the effect of no… ▽ More We consider the minimization of an objective function given access to unbiased estimates of its gradient through stochastic gradient descent (SGD) with constant step-size. While the detailed analysis was only performed for quadratic functions, we provide an explicit asymptotic expansion of the moments of the averaged SGD iterates that outlines the dependence on initial conditions, the effect of noise and the step-size, as well as the lack of convergence in the general (non-quadratic) case. For this analysis, we bring tools from Markov chain theory into the analysis of stochastic gradient. We then show that Richardson-Romberg extrapolation may be used to get closer to the global optimum and we show empirical improvements of the new extrapolation scheme. △ Less

Submitted 11 April, 2018; v1 submitted 20 July, 2017; originally announced July 2017.

Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger Convergence Rates for Least-Squares Regression

Authors: Aymeric Dieuleveut, Nicolas Flammarion, Francis Bach

Abstract: We consider the optimization of a quadratic objective function whose gradients are only accessible through a stochastic oracle that returns the gradient at any given point plus a zero-mean finite variance random error. We present the first algorithm that achieves jointly the optimal prediction error rates for least-squares regression, both in terms of forgetting of initial conditions in O(1/n 2),… ▽ More We consider the optimization of a quadratic objective function whose gradients are only accessible through a stochastic oracle that returns the gradient at any given point plus a zero-mean finite variance random error. We present the first algorithm that achieves jointly the optimal prediction error rates for least-squares regression, both in terms of forgetting of initial conditions in O(1/n 2), and in terms of dependence on the noise and dimension d of the problem, as O(d/n). Our new algorithm is based on averaged accelerated regularized gradient descent, and may also be analyzed through finer assumptions on initial conditions and the Hessian matrix, leading to dimension-free quantities that may still be small while the " optimal " terms above are large. In order to characterize the tightness of these new bounds, we consider an application to non-parametric regression and use the known lower bounds on the statistical performance (without computational limits), which happen to match our bounds obtained from a single pass on the data and thus show optimality of our algorithm in a wide variety of particular trade-offs between bias and variance. △ Less

Submitted 24 February, 2016; v1 submitted 17 February, 2016; originally announced February 2016.