Estimating the theoretical error rate for prediction
Authors:
Herman Chernoff,
Shaw-Hwa Lo,
Tian Zheng,
Adeline Lo
Abstract:
Prediction for very large data sets is typically carried out in two stages, variable selection and pattern recognition. Ordinarily variable selection involves seeing how well individual explanatory variables are correlated with the dependent variable. This practice neglects the possible interactions among the variables. Simulations have shown that a statistic I, that we used for variable selection…
▽ More
Prediction for very large data sets is typically carried out in two stages, variable selection and pattern recognition. Ordinarily variable selection involves seeing how well individual explanatory variables are correlated with the dependent variable. This practice neglects the possible interactions among the variables. Simulations have shown that a statistic I, that we used for variable selection is much better correlated with predictivity than significance levels. We explain this by defining theoretical predictivity and show how I is related to predictivity. We calculate the biases of the overoptimistic training estimate of predictivity and of the pessimistic out of sample estimate. Corrections for the bias lead to improved estimates of the potential predictivity using small groups of possibly interacting variables. These results support the use of I in the variable selection phase of prediction for data sets such as in GWAS (Genome wide association studies) where there are very many explanatory variables and modest sample sizes. Reference is made to another publication using I, which led to a reduction in the error rate of prediction from 30% to 8%, for a data set with, 4,918 variables and 97 subjects. This data set had been previously studied by scientists for over 10 years.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
Discovering influential variables: A method of partitions
Authors:
Herman Chernoff,
Shaw-Hwa Lo,
Tian Zheng
Abstract:
A trend in all scientific disciplines, based on advances in technology, is the increasing availability of high dimensional data in which are buried important information. A current urgent challenge to statisticians is to develop effective methods of finding the useful information from the vast amounts of messy and noisy data available, most of which are noninformative. This paper presents a genera…
▽ More
A trend in all scientific disciplines, based on advances in technology, is the increasing availability of high dimensional data in which are buried important information. A current urgent challenge to statisticians is to develop effective methods of finding the useful information from the vast amounts of messy and noisy data available, most of which are noninformative. This paper presents a general computer intensive approach, based on a method pioneered by Lo and Zheng for detecting which, of many potential explanatory variables, have an influence on a dependent variable $Y$. This approach is suited to detect influential variables, where causal effects depend on the confluence of values of several variables. It has the advantage of avoiding a difficult direct analysis, involving possibly thousands of variables, by dealing with many randomly selected small subsets from which smaller subsets are selected, guided by a measure of influence $I$. The main objective is to discover the influential variables, rather than to measure their effects. Once they are detected, the problem of dealing with a much smaller group of influential variables should be vulnerable to appropriate analysis. In a sense, we are confining our attention to locating a few needles in a haystack.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.