-
To ArXiv or not to ArXiv: A Study Quantifying Pros and Cons of Posting Preprints Online
Authors:
Charvi Rastogi,
Ivan Stelmakh,
Xinwei Shen,
Marina Meila,
Federico Echenique,
Shuchi Chawla,
Nihar B. Shah
Abstract:
Double-blind conferences have engaged in debates over whether to allow authors to post their papers online on arXiv or elsewhere during the review process. Independently, some authors of research papers face the dilemma of whether to put their papers on arXiv due to its pros and cons. We conduct a study to substantiate this debate and dilemma via quantitative measurements. Specifically, we conduct…
▽ More
Double-blind conferences have engaged in debates over whether to allow authors to post their papers online on arXiv or elsewhere during the review process. Independently, some authors of research papers face the dilemma of whether to put their papers on arXiv due to its pros and cons. We conduct a study to substantiate this debate and dilemma via quantitative measurements. Specifically, we conducted surveys of reviewers in two top-tier double-blind computer science conferences -- ICML 2021 (5361 submissions and 4699 reviewers) and EC 2021 (498 submissions and 190 reviewers). Our two main findings are as follows. First, more than a third of the reviewers self-report searching online for a paper they are assigned to review. Second, outside the review process, we find that preprints from better-ranked affiliations see a weakly higher visibility, with a correlation of 0.06 in ICML and 0.05 in EC. In particular, papers associated with the top-10-ranked affiliations had a visibility of approximately 11% in ICML and 22% in EC, whereas the remaining papers had a visibility of 7% and 18% respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2022; v1 submitted 31 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Cite-seeing and Reviewing: A Study on Citation Bias in Peer Review
Authors:
Ivan Stelmakh,
Charvi Rastogi,
Ryan Liu,
Shuchi Chawla,
Federico Echenique,
Nihar B. Shah
Abstract:
Citations play an important role in researchers' careers as a key factor in evaluation of scientific impact. Many anecdotes advice authors to exploit this fact and cite prospective reviewers to try obtaining a more positive evaluation for their submission. In this work, we investigate if such a citation bias actually exists: Does the citation of a reviewer's own work in a submission cause them to…
▽ More
Citations play an important role in researchers' careers as a key factor in evaluation of scientific impact. Many anecdotes advice authors to exploit this fact and cite prospective reviewers to try obtaining a more positive evaluation for their submission. In this work, we investigate if such a citation bias actually exists: Does the citation of a reviewer's own work in a submission cause them to be positively biased towards the submission? In conjunction with the review process of two flagship conferences in machine learning and algorithmic economics, we execute an observational study to test for citation bias in peer review. In our analysis, we carefully account for various confounding factors such as paper quality and reviewer expertise, and apply different modeling techniques to alleviate concerns regarding the model mismatch. Overall, our analysis involves 1,314 papers and 1,717 reviewers and detects citation bias in both venues we consider. In terms of the effect size, by citing a reviewer's work, a submission has a non-trivial chance of getting a higher score from the reviewer: an expected increase in the score is approximately 0.23 on a 5-point Likert item. For reference, a one-point increase of a score by a single reviewer improves the position of a submission by 11% on average.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Unravelling the Architecture of Membrane Proteins with Conditional Random Fields
Authors:
Lior Lukov,
Sanjay Chawla,
Wei Liu,
Brett Church,
Gaurav Pandey
Abstract:
In this paper, we will show that the recently introduced graphical model: Conditional Random Fields (CRF) provides a template to integrate micro-level information about biological entities into a mathematical model to understand their macro-level behavior. More specifically, we will apply the CRF model to an important classification problem in protein science, namely the secondary structure predic…
▽ More
In this paper, we will show that the recently introduced graphical model: Conditional Random Fields (CRF) provides a template to integrate micro-level information about biological entities into a mathematical model to understand their macro-level behavior. More specifically, we will apply the CRF model to an important classification problem in protein science, namely the secondary structure prediction of proteins based on the observed primary structure. A comparison on benchmark data sets against twenty-eight other methods shows that not only does the CRF model lead to extremely accurate predictions but the modular nature of the model and the freedom to integrate disparate, overlap** and non-independent sources of information, makes the model an extremely versatile tool to potentially solve many other problems in bioinformatics.
△ Less
Submitted 6 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Risk Aware Ranking for Top-$k$ Recommendations
Authors:
Shameem A Puthiya Parambath,
Nishant Vijayakumar,
Sanjay Chawla
Abstract:
Given an incomplete ratings data over a set of users and items, the preference completion problem aims to estimate a personalized total preference order over a subset of the items. In practical settings, a ranked list of top-$k$ items from the estimated preference order is recommended to the end user in the decreasing order of preference for final consumption. We analyze this model and observe tha…
▽ More
Given an incomplete ratings data over a set of users and items, the preference completion problem aims to estimate a personalized total preference order over a subset of the items. In practical settings, a ranked list of top-$k$ items from the estimated preference order is recommended to the end user in the decreasing order of preference for final consumption. We analyze this model and observe that such a ranking model results in suboptimal performance when the payoff associated with the recommended items is different. We propose a novel and very efficient algorithm for the preference ranking considering the uncertainty regarding the payoffs of the items. Once the preference scores for the users are obtained using any preference learning algorithm, we show that ranking the items using a risk seeking utility function results in the best ranking performance.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2019; v1 submitted 17 March, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Deep Learning for Anomaly Detection: A Survey
Authors:
Raghavendra Chalapathy,
Sanjay Chawla
Abstract:
Anomaly detection is an important problem that has been well-studied within diverse research areas and application domains. The aim of this survey is two-fold, firstly we present a structured and comprehensive overview of research methods in deep learning-based anomaly detection. Furthermore, we review the adoption of these methods for anomaly across various application domains and assess their ef…
▽ More
Anomaly detection is an important problem that has been well-studied within diverse research areas and application domains. The aim of this survey is two-fold, firstly we present a structured and comprehensive overview of research methods in deep learning-based anomaly detection. Furthermore, we review the adoption of these methods for anomaly across various application domains and assess their effectiveness. We have grouped state-of-the-art research techniques into different categories based on the underlying assumptions and approach adopted. Within each category we outline the basic anomaly detection technique, along with its variants and present key assumptions, to differentiate between normal and anomalous behavior. For each category, we present we also present the advantages and limitations and discuss the computational complexity of the techniques in real application domains. Finally, we outline open issues in research and challenges faced while adopting these techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2019; v1 submitted 10 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Wavelet spectral testing: application to nonstationary circadian rhythms
Authors:
Jessica Hargreaves,
Marina Knight,
Jon Pitchford,
Rachael Oakenfull,
Sangeeta Chawla,
Jack Munns,
Seth Davis
Abstract:
Rhythmic data are ubiquitous in the life sciences. Biologists need reliable statistical tests to identify whether a particular experimental treatment has caused a significant change in a rhythmic signal. When these signals display nonstationary behaviour, as is common in many biological systems, the established methodologies may be misleading. Therefore, there is a real need for new methodology th…
▽ More
Rhythmic data are ubiquitous in the life sciences. Biologists need reliable statistical tests to identify whether a particular experimental treatment has caused a significant change in a rhythmic signal. When these signals display nonstationary behaviour, as is common in many biological systems, the established methodologies may be misleading. Therefore, there is a real need for new methodology that enables the formal comparison of nonstationary processes. As circadian behaviour is best understood in the spectral domain, here we develop novel hypothesis testing procedures in the (wavelet) spectral domain, embedding replicate information when available. The data are modelled as realisations of locally stationary wavelet processes, allowing us to define and rigorously estimate their evolutionary wavelet spectra. Motivated by three complementary applications in circadian biology, our new methodology allows the identification of three specific types of spectral difference. We demonstrate the advantages of our methodology over alternative approaches, by means of a comprehensive simulation study and real data applications, using both published and newly generated circadian datasets. In contrast to the current standard methodologies, our method successfully identifies differences within the motivating circadian datasets, and facilitates wider ranging analyses of rhythmic biological data in general.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Anomaly Detection using One-Class Neural Networks
Authors:
Raghavendra Chalapathy,
Aditya Krishna Menon,
Sanjay Chawla
Abstract:
We propose a one-class neural network (OC-NN) model to detect anomalies in complex data sets. OC-NN combines the ability of deep networks to extract a progressively rich representation of data with the one-class objective of creating a tight envelope around normal data. The OC-NN approach breaks new ground for the following crucial reason: data representation in the hidden layer is driven by the O…
▽ More
We propose a one-class neural network (OC-NN) model to detect anomalies in complex data sets. OC-NN combines the ability of deep networks to extract a progressively rich representation of data with the one-class objective of creating a tight envelope around normal data. The OC-NN approach breaks new ground for the following crucial reason: data representation in the hidden layer is driven by the OC-NN objective and is thus customized for anomaly detection. This is a departure from other approaches which use a hybrid approach of learning deep features using an autoencoder and then feeding the features into a separate anomaly detection method like one-class SVM (OC-SVM). The hybrid OC-SVM approach is sub-optimal because it is unable to influence representational learning in the hidden layers. A comprehensive set of experiments demonstrate that on complex data sets (like CIFAR and GTSRB), OC-NN performs on par with state-of-the-art methods and outperformed conventional shallow methods in some scenarios.
△ Less
Submitted 10 January, 2019; v1 submitted 18 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Optimizing Non-decomposable Measures with Deep Networks
Authors:
Amartya Sanyal,
Pawan Kumar,
Purushottam Kar,
Sanjay Chawla,
Fabrizio Sebastiani
Abstract:
We present a class of algorithms capable of directly training deep neural networks with respect to large families of task-specific performance measures such as the F-measure and the Kullback-Leibler divergence that are structured and non-decomposable. This presents a departure from standard deep learning techniques that typically use squared or cross-entropy loss functions (that are decomposable)…
▽ More
We present a class of algorithms capable of directly training deep neural networks with respect to large families of task-specific performance measures such as the F-measure and the Kullback-Leibler divergence that are structured and non-decomposable. This presents a departure from standard deep learning techniques that typically use squared or cross-entropy loss functions (that are decomposable) to train neural networks. We demonstrate that directly training with task-specific loss functions yields much faster and more stable convergence across problems and datasets. Our proposed algorithms and implementations have several novel features including (i) convergence to first order stationary points despite optimizing complex objective functions; (ii) use of fewer training samples to achieve a desired level of convergence, (iii) a substantial reduction in training time, and (iv) a seamless integration of our implementation into existing symbolic gradient frameworks. We implement our techniques on a variety of deep architectures including multi-layer perceptrons and recurrent neural networks and show that on a variety of benchmark and real data sets, our algorithms outperform traditional approaches to training deep networks, as well as some recent approaches to task-specific training of neural networks.
△ Less
Submitted 31 January, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
SAGA: A Submodular Greedy Algorithm For Group Recommendation
Authors:
Shameem A Puthiya Parambath,
Nishant Vijayakumar,
Sanjay Chawla
Abstract:
In this paper, we propose a unified framework and an algorithm for the problem of group recommendation where a fixed number of items or alternatives can be recommended to a group of users. The problem of group recommendation arises naturally in many real world contexts, and is closely related to the budgeted social choice problem studied in economics. We frame the group recommendation problem as c…
▽ More
In this paper, we propose a unified framework and an algorithm for the problem of group recommendation where a fixed number of items or alternatives can be recommended to a group of users. The problem of group recommendation arises naturally in many real world contexts, and is closely related to the budgeted social choice problem studied in economics. We frame the group recommendation problem as choosing a subgraph with the largest group consensus score in a completely connected graph defined over the item affinity matrix. We propose a fast greedy algorithm with strong theoretical guarantees, and show that the proposed algorithm compares favorably to the state-of-the-art group recommendation algorithms according to commonly used relevance and coverage performance measures on benchmark dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 25 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Robust, Deep and Inductive Anomaly Detection
Authors:
Raghavendra Chalapathy,
Aditya Krishna Menon,
Sanjay Chawla
Abstract:
PCA is a classical statistical technique whose simplicity and maturity has seen it find widespread use as an anomaly detection technique. However, it is limited in this regard by being sensitive to gross perturbations of the input, and by seeking a linear subspace that captures normal behaviour. The first issue has been dealt with by robust PCA, a variant of PCA that explicitly allows for some dat…
▽ More
PCA is a classical statistical technique whose simplicity and maturity has seen it find widespread use as an anomaly detection technique. However, it is limited in this regard by being sensitive to gross perturbations of the input, and by seeking a linear subspace that captures normal behaviour. The first issue has been dealt with by robust PCA, a variant of PCA that explicitly allows for some data points to be arbitrarily corrupted, however, this does not resolve the second issue, and indeed introduces the new issue that one can no longer inductively find anomalies on a test set. This paper addresses both issues in a single model, the robust autoencoder. This method learns a nonlinear subspace that captures the majority of data points, while allowing for some data to have arbitrary corruption. The model is simple to train and leverages recent advances in the optimisation of deep neural networks. Experiments on a range of real-world datasets highlight the model's effectiveness.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2017; v1 submitted 22 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Online Optimization Methods for the Quantification Problem
Authors:
Purushottam Kar,
Shuai Li,
Harikrishna Narasimhan,
Sanjay Chawla,
Fabrizio Sebastiani
Abstract:
The estimation of class prevalence, i.e., the fraction of a population that belongs to a certain class, is a very useful tool in data analytics and learning, and finds applications in many domains such as sentiment analysis, epidemiology, etc. For example, in sentiment analysis, the objective is often not to estimate whether a specific text conveys a positive or a negative sentiment, but rather es…
▽ More
The estimation of class prevalence, i.e., the fraction of a population that belongs to a certain class, is a very useful tool in data analytics and learning, and finds applications in many domains such as sentiment analysis, epidemiology, etc. For example, in sentiment analysis, the objective is often not to estimate whether a specific text conveys a positive or a negative sentiment, but rather estimate the overall distribution of positive and negative sentiments during an event window. A popular way of performing the above task, often dubbed quantification, is to use supervised learning to train a prevalence estimator from labeled data.
Contemporary literature cites several performance measures used to measure the success of such prevalence estimators. In this paper we propose the first online stochastic algorithms for directly optimizing these quantification-specific performance measures. We also provide algorithms that optimize hybrid performance measures that seek to balance quantification and classification performance. Our algorithms present a significant advancement in the theory of multivariate optimization and we show, by a rigorous theoretical analysis, that they exhibit optimal convergence. We also report extensive experiments on benchmark and real data sets which demonstrate that our methods significantly outperform existing optimization techniques used for these performance measures.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2016; v1 submitted 13 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
