-
Estimating Causal Effects with Double Machine Learning -- A Method Evaluation
Authors:
Jonathan Fuhr,
Philipp Berens,
Dominik Papies
Abstract:
The estimation of causal effects with observational data continues to be a very active research area. In recent years, researchers have developed new frameworks which use machine learning to relax classical assumptions necessary for the estimation of causal effects. In this paper, we review one of the most prominent methods - "double/debiased machine learning" (DML) - and empirically evaluate it b…
▽ More
The estimation of causal effects with observational data continues to be a very active research area. In recent years, researchers have developed new frameworks which use machine learning to relax classical assumptions necessary for the estimation of causal effects. In this paper, we review one of the most prominent methods - "double/debiased machine learning" (DML) - and empirically evaluate it by comparing its performance on simulated data relative to more traditional statistical methods, before applying it to real-world data. Our findings indicate that the application of a suitably flexible machine learning algorithm within DML improves the adjustment for various nonlinear confounding relationships. This advantage enables a departure from traditional functional form assumptions typically necessary in causal effect estimation. However, we demonstrate that the method continues to critically depend on standard assumptions about causal structure and identification. When estimating the effects of air pollution on housing prices in our application, we find that DML estimates are consistently larger than estimates of less flexible methods. From our overall results, we provide actionable recommendations for specific choices researchers must make when applying DML in practice.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2024; v1 submitted 21 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Hierarchical mixtures of Gaussians for combined dimensionality reduction and clustering
Authors:
Sacha Sokoloski,
Philipp Berens
Abstract:
To avoid the curse of dimensionality, a common approach to clustering high-dimensional data is to first project the data into a space of reduced dimension, and then cluster the projected data. Although effective, this two-stage approach prevents joint optimization of the dimensionality-reduction and clustering models, and obscures how well the complete model describes the data. Here, we show how a…
▽ More
To avoid the curse of dimensionality, a common approach to clustering high-dimensional data is to first project the data into a space of reduced dimension, and then cluster the projected data. Although effective, this two-stage approach prevents joint optimization of the dimensionality-reduction and clustering models, and obscures how well the complete model describes the data. Here, we show how a family of such two-stage models can be combined into a single, hierarchical model that we call a hierarchical mixture of Gaussians (HMoG). An HMoG simultaneously captures both dimensionality-reduction and clustering, and its performance is quantified in closed-form by the likelihood function. By formulating and extending existing models with exponential family theory, we show how to maximize the likelihood of HMoGs with expectation-maximization. We apply HMoGs to synthetic data and RNA sequencing data, and demonstrate how they exceed the limitations of two-stage models. Ultimately, HMoGs are a rigorous generalization of a common statistical framework, and provide researchers with a method to improve model performance when clustering high-dimensional data.
△ Less
Submitted 9 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Attraction-Repulsion Spectrum in Neighbor Embeddings
Authors:
Jan Niklas Böhm,
Philipp Berens,
Dmitry Kobak
Abstract:
Neighbor embeddings are a family of methods for visualizing complex high-dimensional datasets using $k$NN graphs. To find the low-dimensional embedding, these algorithms combine an attractive force between neighboring pairs of points with a repulsive force between all points. One of the most popular examples of such algorithms is t-SNE. Here we empirically show that changing the balance between th…
▽ More
Neighbor embeddings are a family of methods for visualizing complex high-dimensional datasets using $k$NN graphs. To find the low-dimensional embedding, these algorithms combine an attractive force between neighboring pairs of points with a repulsive force between all points. One of the most popular examples of such algorithms is t-SNE. Here we empirically show that changing the balance between the attractive and the repulsive forces in t-SNE using the exaggeration parameter yields a spectrum of embeddings, which is characterized by a simple trade-off: stronger attraction can better represent continuous manifold structures, while stronger repulsion can better represent discrete cluster structures and yields higher $k$NN recall. We find that UMAP embeddings correspond to t-SNE with increased attraction; mathematical analysis shows that this is because the negative sampling optimisation strategy employed by UMAP strongly lowers the effective repulsion. Likewise, ForceAtlas2, commonly used for visualizing developmental single-cell transcriptomic data, yields embeddings corresponding to t-SNE with the attraction increased even more. At the extreme of this spectrum lie Laplacian Eigenmaps. Our results demonstrate that many prominent neighbor embedding algorithms can be placed onto the attraction-repulsion spectrum, and highlight the inherent trade-offs between them.
△ Less
Submitted 18 October, 2022; v1 submitted 17 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Sparse bottleneck neural networks for exploratory non-linear visualization of Patch-seq data
Authors:
Yves Bernaerts,
Philipp Berens,
Dmitry Kobak
Abstract:
Patch-seq, a recently developed experimental technique, allows neuroscientists to obtain transcriptomic and electrophysiological information from the same neurons. Efficiently analyzing and visualizing such paired multivariate data in order to extract biologically meaningful interpretations has, however, remained a challenge. Here, we use sparse deep neural networks with and without a two-dimensio…
▽ More
Patch-seq, a recently developed experimental technique, allows neuroscientists to obtain transcriptomic and electrophysiological information from the same neurons. Efficiently analyzing and visualizing such paired multivariate data in order to extract biologically meaningful interpretations has, however, remained a challenge. Here, we use sparse deep neural networks with and without a two-dimensional bottleneck to predict electrophysiological features from the transcriptomic ones using a group lasso penalty, yielding concise and biologically interpretable two-dimensional visualizations. In two large example data sets, this visualization reveals known neural classes and their marker genes without biological prior knowledge. We also demonstrate that our method is applicable to other kinds of multimodal data, such as paired transcriptomic and proteomic measurements provided by CITE-seq.
△ Less
Submitted 25 January, 2022; v1 submitted 18 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Heavy-tailed kernels reveal a finer cluster structure in t-SNE visualisations
Authors:
Dmitry Kobak,
George Linderman,
Stefan Steinerberger,
Yuval Kluger,
Philipp Berens
Abstract:
T-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding (t-SNE) is a widely used data visualisation technique. It differs from its predecessor SNE by the low-dimensional similarity kernel: the Gaussian kernel was replaced by the heavy-tailed Cauchy kernel, solving the "crowding problem" of SNE. Here, we develop an efficient implementation of t-SNE for a $t$-distribution kernel with an arbitrary degree of fre…
▽ More
T-distributed stochastic neighbour embedding (t-SNE) is a widely used data visualisation technique. It differs from its predecessor SNE by the low-dimensional similarity kernel: the Gaussian kernel was replaced by the heavy-tailed Cauchy kernel, solving the "crowding problem" of SNE. Here, we develop an efficient implementation of t-SNE for a $t$-distribution kernel with an arbitrary degree of freedom $ν$, with $ν\to\infty$ corresponding to SNE and $ν=1$ corresponding to the standard t-SNE. Using theoretical analysis and toy examples, we show that $ν<1$ can further reduce the crowding problem and reveal finer cluster structure that is invisible in standard t-SNE. We further demonstrate the striking effect of heavier-tailed kernels on large real-life data sets such as MNIST, single-cell RNA-sequencing data, and the HathiTrust library. We use domain knowledge to confirm that the revealed clusters are meaningful. Overall, we argue that modifying the tail heaviness of the t-SNE kernel can yield additional insight into the cluster structure of the data.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2019; v1 submitted 15 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
Supervised learning sets benchmark for robust spike detection from calcium imaging signals
Authors:
Lucas Theis,
Philipp Berens,
Emmanouil Froudarakis,
Jacob Reimer,
Miroslav Román Rosón,
Tom Baden,
Thomas Euler,
Andreas Tolias,
Matthias Bethge
Abstract:
A fundamental challenge in calcium imaging has been to infer the timing of action potentials from the measured noisy calcium fluorescence traces. We systematically evaluate a range of spike inference algorithms on a large benchmark dataset recorded from varying neural tissue (V1 and retina) using different calcium indicators (OGB-1 and GCamp6). We show that a new algorithm based on supervised lear…
▽ More
A fundamental challenge in calcium imaging has been to infer the timing of action potentials from the measured noisy calcium fluorescence traces. We systematically evaluate a range of spike inference algorithms on a large benchmark dataset recorded from varying neural tissue (V1 and retina) using different calcium indicators (OGB-1 and GCamp6). We show that a new algorithm based on supervised learning in flexible probabilistic models outperforms all previously published techniques, setting a new standard for spike inference from calcium signals. Importantly, it performs better than other algorithms even on datasets not seen during training. Future data acquired in new experimental conditions can easily be used to further improve its spike prediction accuracy and generalization performance. Finally, we show that comparing algorithms on artificial data is not informative about performance on real population imaging data, suggesting that a benchmark dataset may greatly facilitate future algorithmic developments.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
