-
Data Needs and Challenges of Quantum Dot Devices Automation: Workshop Report
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Jacob M. Taylor,
Reed Andrews,
Jared Benson,
Garnett Bryant,
Donovan Buterakos,
Anasua Chatterjee,
Sankar Das Sarma,
Mark A. Eriksson,
Eliška Greplová,
Michael J. Gullans,
Fabian Hader,
Tyler J. Kovach,
Pranav S. Mundada,
Mick Ramsey,
Torbjoern Rasmussen,
Brandon Severin,
Anthony Sigillito,
Brennan Undseth,
Brian Weber
Abstract:
Gate-defined quantum dots are a promising candidate system to realize scalable, coupled qubit systems and serve as a fundamental building block for quantum computers. However, present-day quantum dot devices suffer from imperfections that must be accounted for, which hinders the characterization, tuning, and operation process. Moreover, with an increasing number of quantum dot qubits, the relevant…
▽ More
Gate-defined quantum dots are a promising candidate system to realize scalable, coupled qubit systems and serve as a fundamental building block for quantum computers. However, present-day quantum dot devices suffer from imperfections that must be accounted for, which hinders the characterization, tuning, and operation process. Moreover, with an increasing number of quantum dot qubits, the relevant parameter space grows sufficiently to make heuristic control infeasible. Thus, it is imperative that reliable and scalable autonomous tuning approaches are developed. In this report, we outline current challenges in automating quantum dot device tuning and operation with a particular focus on datasets, benchmarking, and standardization. We also present ideas put forward by the quantum dot community on how to overcome them.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2024; v1 submitted 21 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
QDA$^2$: A principled approach to automatically annotating charge stability diagrams
Authors:
Brian Weber,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
Gate-defined semiconductor quantum dot (QD) arrays are a promising platform for quantum computing. However, presently, the large configuration spaces and inherent noise make tuning of QD devices a nontrivial task and with the increasing number of QD qubits, the human-driven experimental control becomes unfeasible. Recently, researchers working with QD systems have begun putting considerable effort…
▽ More
Gate-defined semiconductor quantum dot (QD) arrays are a promising platform for quantum computing. However, presently, the large configuration spaces and inherent noise make tuning of QD devices a nontrivial task and with the increasing number of QD qubits, the human-driven experimental control becomes unfeasible. Recently, researchers working with QD systems have begun putting considerable effort into automating device control, with a particular focus on machine-learning-driven methods. Yet, the reported performance statistics vary substantially in both the meaning and the type of devices used for testing. While systematic benchmarking of the proposed tuning methods is necessary for develo** reliable and scalable tuning approaches, the lack of openly available standardized datasets of experimental data makes such testing impossible. The QD auto-annotator -- a classical algorithm for automatic interpretation and labeling of experimentally acquired data -- is a critical step toward rectifying this. QD auto-annotator leverages the principles of geometry to produce state labels for experimental double-QD charge stability diagrams and is a first step towards building a large public repository of labeled QD data.
△ Less
Submitted 18 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Automated extraction of capacitive coupling for quantum dot systems
Authors:
Joshua Ziegler,
Florian Luthi,
Mick Ramsey,
Felix Borjans,
Guoji Zheng,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
Gate-defined quantum dots (QDs) have appealing attributes as a quantum computing platform. However, near-term devices possess a range of possible imperfections that need to be accounted for during the tuning and operation of QD devices. One such problem is the capacitive cross-talk between the metallic gates that define and control QD qubits. A way to compensate for the capacitive cross-talk and e…
▽ More
Gate-defined quantum dots (QDs) have appealing attributes as a quantum computing platform. However, near-term devices possess a range of possible imperfections that need to be accounted for during the tuning and operation of QD devices. One such problem is the capacitive cross-talk between the metallic gates that define and control QD qubits. A way to compensate for the capacitive cross-talk and enable targeted control of specific QDs independent of coupling is by the use of virtual gates. Here, we demonstrate a reliable automated capacitive coupling identification method that combines machine learning with traditional fitting to take advantage of the desirable properties of each. We also show how the cross-capacitance measurement may be used for the identification of spurious QDs sometimes formed during tuning experimental devices. Our systems can autonomously flag devices with spurious dots near the operating regime, which is crucial information for reliable tuning to a regime suitable for qubit operations.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023; v1 submitted 20 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Tuning arrays with rays: Physics-informed tuning of quantum dot charge states
Authors:
Joshua Ziegler,
Florian Luthi,
Mick Ramsey,
Felix Borjans,
Guoji Zheng,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
Quantum computers based on gate-defined quantum dots (QDs) are expected to scale. However, as the number of qubits increases, the burden of manually calibrating these systems becomes unreasonable and autonomous tuning must be used. There has been a range of recent demonstrations of automated tuning of various QD parameters such as coarse gate ranges, global state topology (e.g. single QD, double Q…
▽ More
Quantum computers based on gate-defined quantum dots (QDs) are expected to scale. However, as the number of qubits increases, the burden of manually calibrating these systems becomes unreasonable and autonomous tuning must be used. There has been a range of recent demonstrations of automated tuning of various QD parameters such as coarse gate ranges, global state topology (e.g. single QD, double QD), charge, and tunnel coupling with a variety of methods. Here, we demonstrate an intuitive, reliable, and data-efficient set of tools for an automated global state and charge tuning in a framework deemed physics-informed tuning (PIT). The first module of PIT is an action-based algorithm that combines a machine learning classifier with physics knowledge to navigate to a target global state. The second module uses a series of one-dimensional measurements to tune to a target charge state by first emptying the QDs of charge, followed by calibrating capacitive couplings and navigating to the target charge state. The success rate for the action-based tuning consistently surpasses 95 % on both simulated and experimental data suitable for off-line testing. The success rate for charge setting is comparable when testing with simulated data, at 95.5(5.4) %, and only slightly worse for off-line experimental tests, with an average of 89.7(17.4) % (median 97.5 %). It is noteworthy that the high performance is demonstrated both on data from samples fabricated in an academic cleanroom as well as on an industrial 300 mm} process line, further underlining the device agnosticism of PIT. Together, these tests on a range of simulated and experimental devices demonstrate the effectiveness and robustness of PIT.
△ Less
Submitted 28 September, 2023; v1 submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Colloquium: Advances in automation of quantum dot devices control
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
Arrays of quantum dots (QDs) are a promising candidate system to realize scalable, coupled qubit systems and serve as a fundamental building block for quantum computers. In such semiconductor quantum systems, devices now have tens of individual electrostatic and dynamical voltages that must be carefully set to localize the system into the single-electron regime and to realize good qubit operationa…
▽ More
Arrays of quantum dots (QDs) are a promising candidate system to realize scalable, coupled qubit systems and serve as a fundamental building block for quantum computers. In such semiconductor quantum systems, devices now have tens of individual electrostatic and dynamical voltages that must be carefully set to localize the system into the single-electron regime and to realize good qubit operational performance. The map** of requisite QD locations and charges to gate voltages presents a challenging classical control problem. With an increasing number of QD qubits, the relevant parameter space grows sufficiently to make heuristic control unfeasible. In recent years, there has been considerable effort to automate device control that combines script-based algorithms with machine learning (ML) techniques. In this Colloquium, a comprehensive overview of the recent progress in the automation of QD device control is presented, with a particular emphasis on silicon- and GaAs-based QDs formed in two-dimensional electron gases. Combining physics-based modeling with modern numerical optimization and ML has proven effective in yielding efficient, scalable control. Further integration of theoretical, computational, and experimental efforts with computer science and ML holds vast potential in advancing semiconductor and other platforms for quantum computing.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2023; v1 submitted 17 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Combining machine learning with physics: A framework for tracking and sorting multiple dark solitons
Authors:
Shangjie Guo,
Sophia M. Koh,
Amilson R. Fritsch,
I. B. Spielman,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
In ultracold-atom experiments, data often comes in the form of images which suffer information loss inherent in the techniques used to prepare and measure the system. This is particularly problematic when the processes of interest are complicated, such as interactions among excitations in Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). In this paper, we describe a framework combining machine learning (ML) model…
▽ More
In ultracold-atom experiments, data often comes in the form of images which suffer information loss inherent in the techniques used to prepare and measure the system. This is particularly problematic when the processes of interest are complicated, such as interactions among excitations in Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs). In this paper, we describe a framework combining machine learning (ML) models with physics-based traditional analyses to identify and track multiple solitonic excitations in images of BECs. We use an ML-based object detector to locate the solitonic excitations and develop a physics-informed classifier to sort solitonic excitations into physically motivated subcategories. Lastly, we introduce a quality metric quantifying the likelihood that a specific feature is a longitudinal soliton. Our trained implementation of this framework, SolDet, is publicly available as an open-source python package. SolDet is broadly applicable to feature identification in cold-atom images when trained on a suitable user-provided dataset.
△ Less
Submitted 1 June, 2022; v1 submitted 8 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Toward Robust Autotuning of Noisy Quantum Dot Devices
Authors:
Joshua Ziegler,
Thomas McJunkin,
E. S. Joseph,
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
Benjamin Harpt,
D. E. Savage,
M. G. Lagally,
M. A. Eriksson,
Jacob M. Taylor,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
The current autotuning approaches for quantum dot (QD) devices, while showing some success, lack an assessment of data reliability. This leads to unexpected failures when noisy or otherwise low-quality data is processed by an autonomous system. In this work, we propose a framework for robust autotuning of QD devices that combines a machine learning (ML) state classifier with a data quality control…
▽ More
The current autotuning approaches for quantum dot (QD) devices, while showing some success, lack an assessment of data reliability. This leads to unexpected failures when noisy or otherwise low-quality data is processed by an autonomous system. In this work, we propose a framework for robust autotuning of QD devices that combines a machine learning (ML) state classifier with a data quality control module. The data quality control module acts as a "gatekeeper" system, ensuring that only reliable data are processed by the state classifier. Lower data quality results in either device recalibration or termination. To train both ML systems, we enhance the QD simulation by incorporating synthetic noise typical of QD experiments. We confirm that the inclusion of synthetic noise in the training of the state classifier significantly improves the performance, resulting in an accuracy of 95.0(9) % when tested on experimental data. We then validate the functionality of the data quality control module by showing that the state classifier performance deteriorates with decreasing data quality, as expected. Our results establish a robust and flexible ML framework for autonomous tuning of noisy QD devices.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2022; v1 submitted 30 July, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Ray-based framework for state identification in quantum dot devices
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Thomas McJunkin,
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
Samuel F. Neyens,
E. R. MacQuarrie,
Mark A. Eriksson,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
Quantum dots (QDs) defined with electrostatic gates are a leading platform for a scalable quantum computing implementation. However, with increasing numbers of qubits, the complexity of the control parameter space also grows. Traditional measurement techniques, relying on complete or near-complete exploration via two-parameter scans (images) of the device response, quickly become impractical with…
▽ More
Quantum dots (QDs) defined with electrostatic gates are a leading platform for a scalable quantum computing implementation. However, with increasing numbers of qubits, the complexity of the control parameter space also grows. Traditional measurement techniques, relying on complete or near-complete exploration via two-parameter scans (images) of the device response, quickly become impractical with increasing numbers of gates. Here we propose to circumvent this challenge by introducing a measurement technique relying on one-dimensional projections of the device response in the multidimensional parameter space. Dubbed the ``ray-based classification (RBC) framework,'' we use this machine learning approach to implement a classifier for QD states, enabling automated recognition of qubit-relevant parameter regimes. We show that RBC surpasses the 82 % accuracy benchmark from the experimental implementation of image-based classification techniques from prior work while reducing the number of measurement points needed by up to 70 %. The reduction in measurement cost is a significant gain for time-intensive QD measurements and is a step forward toward the scalability of these devices. We also discuss how the RBC-based optimizer, which tunes the device to a multiqubit regime, performs when tuning in the two-dimensional and three-dimensional parameter spaces defined by plunger and barrier gates that control the QDs.This work provides experimental validation of both efficient state identification and optimization with machine learning techniques for non-traditional measurements in quantum systems with high-dimensional parameter spaces and time-intensive measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2021; v1 submitted 23 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Machine-learning enhanced dark soliton detection in Bose-Einstein condensates
Authors:
Shangjie Guo,
Amilson R. Fritsch,
Craig Greenberg,
I. B. Spielman,
Justyna P. Zwolak
Abstract:
Most data in cold-atom experiments comes from images, the analysis of which is limited by our preconceptions of the patterns that could be present in the data. We focus on the well-defined case of detecting dark solitons -- appearing as local density depletions in a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) -- using a methodology that is extensible to the general task of pattern recognition in images of cold…
▽ More
Most data in cold-atom experiments comes from images, the analysis of which is limited by our preconceptions of the patterns that could be present in the data. We focus on the well-defined case of detecting dark solitons -- appearing as local density depletions in a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) -- using a methodology that is extensible to the general task of pattern recognition in images of cold atoms. Studying soliton dynamics over a wide range of parameters requires the analysis of large datasets, making the existing human-inspection-based methodology a significant bottleneck. Here we describe an automated classification and positioning system for identifying localized excitations in atomic BECs utilizing deep convolutional neural networks to eliminate the need for human image examination. Furthermore, we openly publish our labeled dataset of dark solitons, the first of its kind, for further machine learning research.
△ Less
Submitted 17 June, 2021; v1 submitted 13 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Ray-based classification framework for high-dimensional data
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
Thomas McJunkin,
Brian J. Weber,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
While classification of arbitrary structures in high dimensions may require complete quantitative information, for simple geometrical structures, low-dimensional qualitative information about the boundaries defining the structures can suffice. Rather than using dense, multi-dimensional data, we propose a deep neural network (DNN) classification framework that utilizes a minimal collection of one-d…
▽ More
While classification of arbitrary structures in high dimensions may require complete quantitative information, for simple geometrical structures, low-dimensional qualitative information about the boundaries defining the structures can suffice. Rather than using dense, multi-dimensional data, we propose a deep neural network (DNN) classification framework that utilizes a minimal collection of one-dimensional representations, called \emph{rays}, to construct the "fingerprint" of the structure(s) based on substantially reduced information. We empirically study this framework using a synthetic dataset of double and triple quantum dot devices and apply it to the classification problem of identifying the device state. We show that the performance of the ray-based classifier is already on par with traditional 2D images for low dimensional systems, while significantly cutting down the data acquisition cost.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2022; v1 submitted 1 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Auto-tuning of double dot devices in situ with machine learning
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Thomas McJunkin,
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
J. P. Dodson,
E. R. MacQuarrie,
D. E. Savage,
M. G. Lagally,
S. N. Coppersmith,
Mark A. Eriksson,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
The current practice of manually tuning quantum dots (QDs) for qubit operation is a relatively time-consuming procedure that is inherently impractical for scaling up and applications. In this work, we report on the {\it in situ} implementation of a recently proposed autotuning protocol that combines machine learning (ML) with an optimization routine to navigate the parameter space. In particular,…
▽ More
The current practice of manually tuning quantum dots (QDs) for qubit operation is a relatively time-consuming procedure that is inherently impractical for scaling up and applications. In this work, we report on the {\it in situ} implementation of a recently proposed autotuning protocol that combines machine learning (ML) with an optimization routine to navigate the parameter space. In particular, we show that a ML algorithm trained using exclusively simulated data to quantitatively classify the state of a double-QD device can be used to replace human heuristics in the tuning of gate voltages in real devices. We demonstrate active feedback of a functional double-dot device operated at millikelvin temperatures and discuss success rates as a function of the initial conditions and the device performance. Modifications to the training network, fitness function, and optimizer are discussed as a path toward further improvement in the success rate when starting both near and far detuned from the target double-dot range.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2020; v1 submitted 17 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
QFlow lite dataset: A machine-learning approach to the charge states in quantum dot experiments
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
Xingyao Wu,
Stephen Ragole,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
Over the past decade, machine learning techniques have revolutionized how research is done, from designing new materials and predicting their properties to assisting drug discovery to advancing cybersecurity. Recently, we added to this list by showing how a machine learning algorithm (a so-called learner) combined with an optimization routine can assist experimental efforts in the realm of tuning…
▽ More
Over the past decade, machine learning techniques have revolutionized how research is done, from designing new materials and predicting their properties to assisting drug discovery to advancing cybersecurity. Recently, we added to this list by showing how a machine learning algorithm (a so-called learner) combined with an optimization routine can assist experimental efforts in the realm of tuning semiconductor quantum dot (QD) devices. Among other applications, semiconductor QDs are a candidate system for building quantum computers. The present-day tuning techniques for bringing the QD devices into a desirable configuration suitable for quantum computing that rely on heuristics do not scale with the increasing size of the quantum dot arrays required for even near-term quantum computing demonstrations. Establishing a reliable protocol for tuning that does not rely on the gross-scale heuristics developed by experimentalists is thus of great importance. To implement the machine learning-based approach, we constructed a dataset of simulated QD device characteristics, such as the conductance and the charge sensor response versus the applied electrostatic gate voltages. Here, we describe the methodology for generating the dataset, as well as its validation in training convolutional neural networks. We show that the learner's accuracy in recognizing the state of a device is ~96.5 % in both current- and charge-sensor-based training. We also introduce a tool that enables other researchers to use this approach for further research: QFlow lite - a Python-based mini-software suite that uses the dataset to train neural networks to recognize the state of a device and differentiate between states in experimental data. This work gives the definitive reference for the new dataset that will help enable researchers to use it in their experiments or to develop new machine learning approaches and concepts.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Machine Learning techniques for state recognition and auto-tuning in quantum dots
Authors:
Sandesh S. Kalantre,
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Stephen Ragole,
Xingyao Wu,
Neil M. Zimmerman,
M. D. Stewart,
Jacob M. Taylor
Abstract:
Recent progress in building large-scale quantum devices for exploring quantum computing and simulation paradigms has relied upon effective tools for achieving and maintaining good experimental parameters, i.e. tuning up devices. In many cases, including in quantum-dot based architectures, the parameter space grows substantially with the number of qubits, and may become a limit to scalability. Fort…
▽ More
Recent progress in building large-scale quantum devices for exploring quantum computing and simulation paradigms has relied upon effective tools for achieving and maintaining good experimental parameters, i.e. tuning up devices. In many cases, including in quantum-dot based architectures, the parameter space grows substantially with the number of qubits, and may become a limit to scalability. Fortunately, machine learning techniques for pattern recognition and image classification using so-called deep neural networks have shown surprising successes for computer-aided understanding of complex systems. In this work, we use deep and convolutional neural networks to characterize states and charge configurations of semiconductor quantum dot arrays when one can only measure a current-voltage characteristic of transport (here conductance) through such a device. For simplicity, we model a semiconductor nanowire connected to leads and capacitively coupled to depletion gates using the Thomas-Fermi approximation and Coulomb blockade physics. We then generate labelled training data for the neural networks, and find at least $90\,\%$ accuracy for charge and state identification for single and double dots purely from the dependence of the nanowire's conductance upon gate voltages. Using these characterization networks, we can then optimize the parameter space to achieve a desired configuration of the array, a technique we call `auto-tuning'. Finally, we show how such techniques can be implemented in an experimental setting by applying our approach to an experimental data set, and outline further problems in this domain, from using charge sensing data to extensions to full one and two-dimensional arrays, that can be tackled with machine learning.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2018; v1 submitted 13 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Recurrent construction of optimal entanglement witnesses for 2N qubit systems
Authors:
Justyna P. Zwolak,
Dariusz Chruściński
Abstract:
We provide a recurrent construction of entanglement witnesses for a bipartite systems living in a Hilbert space corresponding to $2N$ qubits ($N$ qubits in each subsystem). Our construction provides a new method of generalization of the Robertson map that naturally meshes with $2N$ qubit systems, i.e., its structure respects the $2^{2N}$ growth of the state space. We prove that for $N>1$ these wit…
▽ More
We provide a recurrent construction of entanglement witnesses for a bipartite systems living in a Hilbert space corresponding to $2N$ qubits ($N$ qubits in each subsystem). Our construction provides a new method of generalization of the Robertson map that naturally meshes with $2N$ qubit systems, i.e., its structure respects the $2^{2N}$ growth of the state space. We prove that for $N>1$ these witnesses are indecomposable and optimal. As a byproduct we provide a new family of PPT (Positive Partial Transpose) entangled states.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2013;
originally announced November 2013.
-
New tools for investigating positive maps in matrix algebras
Authors:
Justyna Pytel Zwolak,
Dariusz Chruściński
Abstract:
We provide a novel tool which may be used to construct new examples of positive maps in matrix algebras (or, equivalently, entanglement witnesses). It turns out that this can be used to prove positivity of several well known maps (such as reduction map, generalized reduction, Robertson map, and many others). Furthermore, we use it to construct a new family of linear maps and prove that they are po…
▽ More
We provide a novel tool which may be used to construct new examples of positive maps in matrix algebras (or, equivalently, entanglement witnesses). It turns out that this can be used to prove positivity of several well known maps (such as reduction map, generalized reduction, Robertson map, and many others). Furthermore, we use it to construct a new family of linear maps and prove that they are positive, indecomposable and (nd)optimal.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
