-
Clapton: Clifford-Assisted Problem Transformation for Error Mitigation in Variational Quantum Algorithms
Authors:
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Siddharth Dangwal,
Frederic T. Chong,
Gokul Subramanian Ravi
Abstract:
Variational quantum algorithms (VQAs) show potential for quantum advantage in the near term of quantum computing, but demand a level of accuracy that surpasses the current capabilities of NISQ devices. To systematically mitigate the impact of quantum device error on VQAs, we propose Clapton: Clifford-Assisted Problem Transformation for Error Mitigation in Variational Quantum Algorithms. Clapton le…
▽ More
Variational quantum algorithms (VQAs) show potential for quantum advantage in the near term of quantum computing, but demand a level of accuracy that surpasses the current capabilities of NISQ devices. To systematically mitigate the impact of quantum device error on VQAs, we propose Clapton: Clifford-Assisted Problem Transformation for Error Mitigation in Variational Quantum Algorithms. Clapton leverages classically estimated good quantum states for a given VQA problem, classical simulable models of device noise, and the variational principle for VQAs. It applies transformations on the VQA problem's Hamiltonian to lower the energy estimates of known good VQA states in the presence of the modeled device noise. The Clapton hypothesis is that as long as the known good states of the VQA problem are close to the problem's ideal ground state and the device noise modeling is reasonably accurate (both of which are generally true), then the Clapton transformation substantially decreases the impact of device noise on the ground state of the VQA problem, thereby increasing the accuracy of the VQA solution. Clapton is built as an end-to-end application-to-device framework and achieves mean VQA initialization improvements of 1.7x to 3.7x, and up to a maximum of 13.3x, over the state-of-the-art baseline when evaluated for a variety of scientific applications from physics and chemistry on noise models and real quantum devices.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Clifford Assisted Optimal Pass Selection for Quantum Transpilation
Authors:
Siddharth Dangwal,
Gokul Subramanian Ravi,
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Frederic T. Chong
Abstract:
The fidelity of quantum programs in the NISQ era is limited by high levels of device noise. To increase the fidelity of quantum programs running on NISQ devices, a variety of optimizations have been proposed. These include map** passes, routing passes, scheduling methods and standalone optimisations which are usually incorporated into a transpiler as passes. Popular transpilers such as those pro…
▽ More
The fidelity of quantum programs in the NISQ era is limited by high levels of device noise. To increase the fidelity of quantum programs running on NISQ devices, a variety of optimizations have been proposed. These include map** passes, routing passes, scheduling methods and standalone optimisations which are usually incorporated into a transpiler as passes. Popular transpilers such as those proposed by Qiskit, Cirq and Cambridge Quantum Computing make use of these extensively. However, choosing the right set of transpiler passes and the right configuration for each pass is a challenging problem. Transpilers often make critical decisions using heuristics since the ideal choices are impossible to identify without knowing the target application outcome. Further, the transpiler also makes simplifying assumptions about device noise that often do not hold in the real world. As a result, we often see effects where the fidelity of a target application decreases despite using state-of-the-art optimisations. To overcome this challenge, we propose OPTRAN, a framework for Choosing an Optimal Pass Set for Quantum Transpilation. OPTRAN uses classically simulable quantum circuits composed entirely of Clifford gates, that resemble the target application, to estimate how different passes interact with each other in the context of the target application. OPTRAN then uses this information to choose the optimal combination of passes that maximizes the target application's fidelity when run on the actual device. Our experiments on IBM machines show that OPTRAN improves fidelity by 87.66% of the maximum possible limit over the baseline used by IBM Qiskit. We also propose low-cost variants of OPTRAN, called OPTRAN-E-3 and OPTRAN-E-1 that improve fidelity by 78.33% and 76.66% of the maximum permissible limit over the baseline at a 58.33% and 69.44% reduction in cost compared to OPTRAN respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Exploring Ququart Computation on a Transmon using Optimal Control
Authors:
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Ziqian Li,
Tanay Roy,
David I. Schuster,
Frederic T. Chong,
Jonathan M. Baker
Abstract:
Contemporary quantum computers encode and process quantum information in binary qubits (d = 2). However, many architectures include higher energy levels that are left as unused computational resources. We demonstrate a superconducting ququart (d = 4) processor and combine quantum optimal control with efficient gate decompositions to implement high-fidelity ququart gates. We distinguish between vie…
▽ More
Contemporary quantum computers encode and process quantum information in binary qubits (d = 2). However, many architectures include higher energy levels that are left as unused computational resources. We demonstrate a superconducting ququart (d = 4) processor and combine quantum optimal control with efficient gate decompositions to implement high-fidelity ququart gates. We distinguish between viewing the ququart as a generalized four-level qubit and an encoded pair of qubits, and characterize the resulting gates in each case. In randomized benchmarking experiments we observe gate fidelities greater 95% and identify coherence as the primary limiting factor. Our results validate ququarts as a viable tool for quantum information processing.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Dancing the Quantum Waltz: Compiling Three-Qubit Gates on Four Level Architectures
Authors:
Andrew Litteken,
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Jason D. Chadwick,
Natalia Nottingham,
Tanay Roy,
Ziqian Li,
David Schuster,
Frederic T. Chong,
Jonathan M. Baker
Abstract:
Superconducting quantum devices are a leading technology for quantum computation, but they suffer from several challenges. Gate errors, coherence errors and a lack of connectivity all contribute to low fidelity results. In particular, connectivity restrictions enforce a gate set that requires three-qubit gates to be decomposed into one- or two-qubit gates. This substantially increases the number o…
▽ More
Superconducting quantum devices are a leading technology for quantum computation, but they suffer from several challenges. Gate errors, coherence errors and a lack of connectivity all contribute to low fidelity results. In particular, connectivity restrictions enforce a gate set that requires three-qubit gates to be decomposed into one- or two-qubit gates. This substantially increases the number of two-qubit gates that need to be executed. However, many quantum devices have access to higher energy levels. We can expand the qubit abstraction of $|0\rangle$ and $|1\rangle$ to a ququart which has access to the $|2\rangle$ and $|3\rangle$ state, but with shorter coherence times. This allows for two qubits to be encoded in one ququart, enabling increased virtual connectivity between physical units from two adjacent qubits to four fully connected qubits. This connectivity scheme allows us to more efficiently execute three-qubit gates natively between two physical devices.
We present direct-to-pulse implementations of several three-qubit gates, synthesized via optimal control, for compilation of three-qubit gates onto a superconducting-based architecture with access to four-level devices with the first experimental demonstration of four-level ququart gates designed through optimal control. We demonstrate strategies that temporarily use higher level states to perform Toffoli gates and always use higher level states to improve fidelities for quantum circuits. We find that these methods improve expected fidelities with increases of 2x across circuit sizes using intermediate encoding, and increases of 3x for fully-encoded ququart compilation.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024; v1 submitted 24 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Qompress: Efficient Compilation for Ququarts Exploiting Partial and Mixed Radix Operations for Communication Reduction
Authors:
Andrew Litteken,
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Jason Chadwick,
Natalia Nottingham,
Fredric T. Chong,
Jonathan M. Baker
Abstract:
Quantum computing is in an era of limited resources. Current hardware lacks high fidelity gates, long coherence times, and the number of computational units required to perform meaningful computation. Contemporary quantum devices typically use a binary system, where each qubit exists in a superposition of the $\ket{0}$ and $\ket{1}$ states. However, it is often possible to access the $\ket{2}$ or…
▽ More
Quantum computing is in an era of limited resources. Current hardware lacks high fidelity gates, long coherence times, and the number of computational units required to perform meaningful computation. Contemporary quantum devices typically use a binary system, where each qubit exists in a superposition of the $\ket{0}$ and $\ket{1}$ states. However, it is often possible to access the $\ket{2}$ or even $\ket{3}$ states in the same physical unit by manipulating the system in different ways. In this work, we consider automatically encoding two qubits into one four-state qu\emph{quart} via a \emph{compression scheme}. We use quantum optimal control to design efficient proof-of-concept gates that fully replicate standard qubit computation on these encoded qubits.
We extend qubit compilation schemes to efficiently route qubits on an arbitrary mixed-radix system consisting of both qubits and ququarts, reducing communication and minimizing excess circuit execution time introduced by longer-duration ququart gates. In conjunction with these compilation strategies, we introduce several methods to find beneficial compressions, reducing circuit error due to computation and communication by up to 50\%. These methods can increase the computational space available on a limited near-term machine by up to 2x while maintaining circuit fidelity.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Fast Fingerprinting of Cloud-based NISQ Quantum Computers
Authors:
Kaitlin N. Smith,
Joshua Viszlai,
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Jonathan M. Baker,
Jakub Szefer,
Frederic T. Chong
Abstract:
Cloud-based quantum computers have become a reality with a number of companies allowing for cloud-based access to their machines with tens to more than 100 qubits. With easy access to quantum computers, quantum information processing will potentially revolutionize computation, and superconducting transmon-based quantum computers are among some of the more promising devices available. Cloud service…
▽ More
Cloud-based quantum computers have become a reality with a number of companies allowing for cloud-based access to their machines with tens to more than 100 qubits. With easy access to quantum computers, quantum information processing will potentially revolutionize computation, and superconducting transmon-based quantum computers are among some of the more promising devices available. Cloud service providers today host a variety of these and other prototype quantum computers with highly diverse device properties, sizes, and performances. The variation that exists in today's quantum computers, even among those of the same underlying hardware, motivate the study of how one device can be clearly differentiated and identified from the next. As a case study, this work focuses on the properties of 25 IBM superconducting, fixed-frequency transmon-based quantum computers that range in age from a few months to approximately 2.5 years. Through the analysis of current and historical quantum computer calibration data, this work uncovers key features within the machines that can serve as basis for unique hardware fingerprint of each quantum computer. This work demonstrates a new and fast method to reliably fingerprint cloud-based quantum computers based on unique frequency characteristics of transmon qubits. Both enrollment and recall operations are very fast as fingerprint data can be generated with minimal executions on the quantum machine. The qubit frequency-based fingerprints also have excellent inter-device separation and intra-device stability.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Time-Efficient Qudit Gates through Incremental Pulse Re-seeding
Authors:
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Jason Chadwick,
Andrew Litteken,
Frederic T. Chong,
Jonathan M. Baker
Abstract:
Current efforts to build quantum computers focus mainly on the two-state qubit, which often involves suppressing readily-available higher states. In this work, we break this abstraction and synthesize short-duration control pulses for gates on generalized d-state qudits. We present Incremental Pulse Re-seeding, a practical scheme to guide optimal control software to the lowest-duration pulse by it…
▽ More
Current efforts to build quantum computers focus mainly on the two-state qubit, which often involves suppressing readily-available higher states. In this work, we break this abstraction and synthesize short-duration control pulses for gates on generalized d-state qudits. We present Incremental Pulse Re-seeding, a practical scheme to guide optimal control software to the lowest-duration pulse by iteratively seeding the optimizer with previous results. We find a near-linear relationship between Hilbert space dimension and gate duration through explicit pulse optimization for one- and two-qudit gates on transmons. Our results suggest that qudit operations are much more efficient than previously expected in the practical regime of interest and have the potential to significantly increase the computational power of current hardware.
△ Less
Submitted 27 February, 2024; v1 submitted 29 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Quantum Steering on IBMQ
Authors:
Lennart Maximilian Seifert,
Konstantin Beyer,
Kimmo Luoma,
Walter T. Strunz
Abstract:
We use contemporary quantum computers to experimentally investigate quantum steering ofan open quantum system by measurements on its environment. On three IBMQ processors wedistinguish a qubit as the open system and perform pairwise interactions with multiple environmentancillas, following a collision model approach. Different measurement strategies on the ancillaslead to different state ensembles…
▽ More
We use contemporary quantum computers to experimentally investigate quantum steering ofan open quantum system by measurements on its environment. On three IBMQ processors wedistinguish a qubit as the open system and perform pairwise interactions with multiple environmentancillas, following a collision model approach. Different measurement strategies on the ancillaslead to different state ensembles of the open system, which are reconstructed by employing statetomography. The amount of steering within the resulting assemblages is quantified with the help of asemidefinite program. We successfully observe the presence of quantum steering in our experimentalsimulations, and can discriminate the different performance qualities and noise levels of the selectedquantum devices.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2022; v1 submitted 29 October, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.