-
Benchmarking Quantum Processor Performance at Scale
Authors:
David C. McKay,
Ian Hincks,
Emily J. Pritchett,
Malcolm Carroll,
Luke C. G. Govia,
Seth T. Merkel
Abstract:
As quantum processors grow, new performance benchmarks are required to capture the full quality of the devices at scale. While quantum volume is an excellent benchmark, it focuses on the highest quality subset of the device and so is unable to indicate the average performance over a large number of connected qubits. Furthermore, it is a discrete pass/fail and so is not reflective of continuous imp…
▽ More
As quantum processors grow, new performance benchmarks are required to capture the full quality of the devices at scale. While quantum volume is an excellent benchmark, it focuses on the highest quality subset of the device and so is unable to indicate the average performance over a large number of connected qubits. Furthermore, it is a discrete pass/fail and so is not reflective of continuous improvements in hardware nor does it provide quantitative direction to large-scale algorithms. For example, there may be value in error mitigated Hamiltonian simulation at scale with devices unable to pass strict quantum volume tests. Here we discuss a scalable benchmark which measures the fidelity of a connecting set of two-qubit gates over $N$ qubits by measuring gate errors using simultaneous direct randomized benchmarking in disjoint layers. Our layer fidelity can be easily related to algorithmic run time, via $γ$ defined in Ref.\cite{berg2022probabilistic} that can be used to estimate the number of circuits required for error mitigation. The protocol is efficient and obtains all the pair rates in the layered structure. Compared to regular (isolated) RB this approach is sensitive to crosstalk. As an example we measure a $N=80~(100)$ qubit layer fidelity on a 127 qubit fixed-coupling "Eagle" processor (ibm\_sherbrooke) of 0.26(0.19) and on the 133 qubit tunable-coupling "Heron" processor (ibm\_montecarlo) of 0.61(0.26). This can easily be expressed as a layer size independent quantity, error per layered gate (EPLG), which is here $1.7\times10^{-2}(1.7\times10^{-2})$ for ibm\_sherbrooke and $6.2\times10^{-3}(1.2\times10^{-2})$ for ibm\_montecarlo.
△ Less
Submitted 10 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Encoding a magic state with beyond break-even fidelity
Authors:
Riddhi S. Gupta,
Neereja Sundaresan,
Thomas Alexander,
Christopher J. Wood,
Seth T. Merkel,
Michael B. Healy,
Marius Hillenbrand,
Tomas Jochym-O'Connor,
James R. Wootton,
Theodore J. Yoder,
Andrew W. Cross,
Maika Takita,
Benjamin J. Brown
Abstract:
To run large-scale algorithms on a quantum computer, error-correcting codes must be able to perform a fundamental set of operations, called logic gates, while isolating the encoded information from noise~\cite{Harper2019,Ryan-Anderson2021,Egan2021fault, Chen2022calibrated, Sundaresan2022matching, ryananderson2022implementing, Postler2022demonstration, GoogleAI2023}. We can complete a universal set…
▽ More
To run large-scale algorithms on a quantum computer, error-correcting codes must be able to perform a fundamental set of operations, called logic gates, while isolating the encoded information from noise~\cite{Harper2019,Ryan-Anderson2021,Egan2021fault, Chen2022calibrated, Sundaresan2022matching, ryananderson2022implementing, Postler2022demonstration, GoogleAI2023}. We can complete a universal set of logic gates by producing special resources called magic states~\cite{Bravyi2005universal,Maier2013magic, Chamberland2022building}. It is therefore important to produce high-fidelity magic states to conduct algorithms while introducing a minimal amount of noise to the computation. Here, we propose and implement a scheme to prepare a magic state on a superconducting qubit array using error correction. We find that our scheme produces better magic states than those we can prepare using the individual qubits of the device. This demonstrates a fundamental principle of fault-tolerant quantum computing~\cite{Shor96}, namely, that we can use error correction to improve the quality of logic gates with noisy qubits. Additionally, we show we can increase the yield of magic states using adaptive circuits, where circuit elements are changed depending on the outcome of mid-circuit measurements. This demonstrates an essential capability we will need for many error-correction subroutines. Our prototype will be invaluable in the future as it can reduce the number of physical qubits needed to produce high-fidelity magic states in large-scale quantum-computing architectures.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024; v1 submitted 22 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Floquet Analysis of Frequency Collisions
Authors:
Kentaro Heya,
Moein Malekakhlagh,
Seth Merkel,
Naoki Kanazawa,
Emily Pritchett
Abstract:
Implementation of high-fidelity gate operations on integrated-qubit systems is of vital importance for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Qubit frequency allocation is an essential part of improving control fidelity. A metric for qubit frequency allocation, frequency collision, has been proposed on simple systems of only a few qubits driven by a mono-modal microwave drive. However, frequency allo…
▽ More
Implementation of high-fidelity gate operations on integrated-qubit systems is of vital importance for fault-tolerant quantum computation. Qubit frequency allocation is an essential part of improving control fidelity. A metric for qubit frequency allocation, frequency collision, has been proposed on simple systems of only a few qubits driven by a mono-modal microwave drive. However, frequency allocation for quantum processors for more advanced purposes, such as quantum error correction, needs further investigation. In this study, we propose a Floquet analysis of frequency collisions. The key to our proposed method is a reinterpretation of frequency collisions as an unintended degeneracy of Floquet states, which allows a collision analysis on more complex systems with many qubits driven by multi-modal microwave drives. Although the Floquet state is defined in an infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, we develop algorithms, based on operation perturbation theory, to truncate the Hilbert space down to the optimal computational complexity. In particular, we show that the computational complexity of the collision analysis for a sparse qubit lattice is linear with the number of qubits. Finally, we demonstrate our proposed method on Cross-Resonance based experimental protocols. We first study the Cross-Resonance gate in an isolated three-qubit system, where the effectiveness of our method is verified by comparing it with previous studies. We next consider the more complex problem of syndrome extraction in the heavy-hexagon code. Our proposed method advances our understanding of quantum control for quantum processors and contributes to their improved design and control.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Characterizing non-Markovian Off-Resonant Errors in Quantum Gates
Authors:
Ken Xuan Wei,
Emily Pritchett,
David M. Zajac,
David C. McKay,
Seth Merkel
Abstract:
As quantum gates improve, it becomes increasingly difficult to characterize the remaining errors. Here we describe a class of coherent non-Markovian errors -- excitations due to an off-resonant drive -- that occur naturally in quantum devices that use time-dependent fields to generate gate operations. We show how these errors are mischaracterized using standard Quantum Computer Verification and Va…
▽ More
As quantum gates improve, it becomes increasingly difficult to characterize the remaining errors. Here we describe a class of coherent non-Markovian errors -- excitations due to an off-resonant drive -- that occur naturally in quantum devices that use time-dependent fields to generate gate operations. We show how these errors are mischaracterized using standard Quantum Computer Verification and Validation (QCVV) techniques that rely on Markovianity and are therefore often overlooked or assumed to be incoherent. We first demonstrate off-resonant errors within a simple toy model of Z-gates created by the AC Stark effect, then show how off-resonant errors manifest in all gates driven on a fixed-frequency transmon architecture, a prominent example being incidental cross-resonance interaction driven during single-qubit gates. Furthermore, the same methodology can access the errors caused by two-level systems (TLS), showing evidence of coherent, off-resonant interactions with subsystems that are not intentional qubits. While we explore these results and their impact on gate error for fixed-frequency devices, we note that off-resonant excitations potentially limit any architectures that use frequency selectivity.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2024; v1 submitted 21 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
A randomized benchmarking suite for mid-circuit measurements
Authors:
L. C. G. Govia,
P. Jurcevic,
C. J. Wood,
N. Kanazawa,
S. T. Merkel,
D. C. McKay
Abstract:
Mid-circuit measurements are a key component in many quantum information computing protocols, including quantum error correction, fault-tolerant logical operations, and measurement based quantum computing. As such, techniques to quickly and efficiently characterize or benchmark their performance are of great interest. Beyond the measured qubit, it is also relevant to determine what, if any, impact…
▽ More
Mid-circuit measurements are a key component in many quantum information computing protocols, including quantum error correction, fault-tolerant logical operations, and measurement based quantum computing. As such, techniques to quickly and efficiently characterize or benchmark their performance are of great interest. Beyond the measured qubit, it is also relevant to determine what, if any, impact mid-circuit measurement has on adjacent, unmeasured, spectator qubits. Here, we present a mid-circuit measurement benchmarking suite developed from the ubiquitous paradigm of randomized benchmarking. We show how our benchmarking suite can be used to both detect as well as quantify errors on both measured and spectator qubits, including measurement-induced errors on spectator qubits and entangling errors between measured and spectator qubits. We demonstrate the scalability of our suite by simultaneously characterizing mid-circuit measurement on multiple qubits from an IBM Quantum Falcon device, and support our experimental results with numerical simulations. Further, using a mid-circuit measurement tomography protocol we establish the nature of the errors identified by our benchmarking suite.
△ Less
Submitted 12 April, 2024; v1 submitted 11 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Scalable error mitigation for noisy quantum circuits produces competitive expectation values
Authors:
Youngseok Kim,
Christopher J. Wood,
Theodore J. Yoder,
Seth T. Merkel,
Jay M. Gambetta,
Kristan Temme,
Abhinav Kandala
Abstract:
Noise in existing quantum processors only enables an approximation to ideal quantum computation. However, these approximations can be vastly improved by error mitigation, for the computation of expectation values, as shown by small-scale experimental demonstrations. However, the practical scaling of these methods to larger system sizes remains unknown. Here, we demonstrate the utility of zero-nois…
▽ More
Noise in existing quantum processors only enables an approximation to ideal quantum computation. However, these approximations can be vastly improved by error mitigation, for the computation of expectation values, as shown by small-scale experimental demonstrations. However, the practical scaling of these methods to larger system sizes remains unknown. Here, we demonstrate the utility of zero-noise extrapolation for relevant quantum circuits using up to 26 qubits, circuit depths of 60, and 1080 CNOT gates. We study the scaling of the method for canonical examples of product states and entangling Clifford circuits of increasing size, and extend it to the quench dynamics of 2-D Ising spin lattices with varying couplings. We show that the efficacy of the error mitigation is greatly enhanced by additional error suppression techniques and native gate decomposition that reduce the circuit time. By combining these methods, we demonstrate an accuracy in the approximate quantum simulation of the quench dynamics that surpasses the classical approximations obtained from a state-of-the-art 2-D tensor network method. These results reveal a path to a relevant quantum advantage with noisy, digital, quantum processors.
△ Less
Submitted 20 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Hardware-efficient random circuits to classify noise in a multi-qubit system
Authors:
**-Sung Kim,
Lev S. Bishop,
Antonio D. Corcoles,
Seth Merkel,
John A. Smolin,
Sarah Sheldon
Abstract:
In this work we extend a multi-qubit benchmarking technique known as the Binned Output Generation (BOG) in order to discriminate between coherent and incoherent noise sources in the multi-qubit regime. While methods exist to discriminate coherent from incoherent noise at the single and few-qubit level, these methods scale poorly beyond a few qubits or must make assumptions about the form of the no…
▽ More
In this work we extend a multi-qubit benchmarking technique known as the Binned Output Generation (BOG) in order to discriminate between coherent and incoherent noise sources in the multi-qubit regime. While methods exist to discriminate coherent from incoherent noise at the single and few-qubit level, these methods scale poorly beyond a few qubits or must make assumptions about the form of the noise. On the other end of the spectrum, system-level benchmarking techniques exist, but fail to discriminate between coherent and incoherent noise sources. We experimentally verify the BOG against Randomized Benchmarking (RB) (the industry standard benchmarking technique) in the two-qubit regime, then apply this technique to a six qubit linear chain, a regime currently inaccessible to RB. In this experiment we inject an instantaneous coherent Z-type noise on each qubit and demonstrate that the measured coherent noise scales correctly with the magnitude of the injected noise, while the measured incoherent noise remains unchanged as expected. This demonstrates a robust technique to measure coherent errors in a variety of hardware.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2021; v1 submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Experimental accreditation of outputs of noisy quantum computers
Authors:
Samuele Ferracin,
Seth T. Merkel,
David McKay,
Animesh Datta
Abstract:
We provide and experimentally demonstrate an accreditation protocol that upper-bounds the variation distance between noisy and noiseless probability distributions of the outputs of arbitrary quantum computations. We accredit the outputs of twenty-four quantum circuits executed on programmable superconducting hardware, ranging from depth nine circuits on ten qubits to depth twenty-one circuits on f…
▽ More
We provide and experimentally demonstrate an accreditation protocol that upper-bounds the variation distance between noisy and noiseless probability distributions of the outputs of arbitrary quantum computations. We accredit the outputs of twenty-four quantum circuits executed on programmable superconducting hardware, ranging from depth nine circuits on ten qubits to depth twenty-one circuits on four qubits. Our protocol requires implementing the "target" quantum circuit along with a number of random Clifford circuits and subsequently post-processing the outputs of these Clifford circuits. Importantly, the number of Clifford circuits is chosen to obtain the bound with the desired confidence and accuracy, and is independent of the size and nature of the target circuit. We thus demonstrate a practical and scalable method of ascertaining the correctness of the outputs of arbitrary-sized noisy quantum computers--the ultimate arbiter of the utility of the computer itself.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2021; v1 submitted 11 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Quantifying error and leakage in an encoded Si/SiGe triple-dot qubit
Authors:
R. W. Andrews,
C. Jones,
M. D. Reed,
A. M. Jones,
S. D. Ha,
M. P. Jura,
J. Kerckhoff,
M. Levendorf,
S. Meenehan,
S. T. Merkel,
A. Smith,
B. Sun,
A. J. Weinstein,
M. T. Rakher,
T. D. Ladd,
M. G. Borselli
Abstract:
Quantum computation requires qubits that satisfy often-conflicting criteria, including scalable control and long-lasting coherence. One approach to creating a suitable qubit is to operate in an encoded subspace of several physical qubits. Though such encoded qubits may be particularly susceptible to leakage out of their computational subspace, they can be insensitive to certain noise processes and…
▽ More
Quantum computation requires qubits that satisfy often-conflicting criteria, including scalable control and long-lasting coherence. One approach to creating a suitable qubit is to operate in an encoded subspace of several physical qubits. Though such encoded qubits may be particularly susceptible to leakage out of their computational subspace, they can be insensitive to certain noise processes and can also allow logical control with a single type of entangling interaction while maintaining favorable features of the underlying physical system. Here we demonstrate a qubit encoded in a subsystem of three coupled electron spins confined in gated, isotopically enhanced silicon quantum dots. Using a modified "blind" randomized benchmarking protocol that determines both computational and leakage errors, we show that unitary operations have an average total error of 0.35%, with 0.17% of that coming from leakage driven by interactions with substrate nuclear spins. This demonstration utilizes only the voltage-controlled exchange interaction for qubit manipulation and highlights the operational benefits of encoded subsystems, heralding the realization of high-quality encoded multi-qubit operations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Spin-Blockade Spectroscopy of Si/SiGe Quantum Dots
Authors:
A. M. Jones,
E. J. Pritchett,
E. H. Chen,
T. E. Keating,
R. W. Andrews,
J. Z. Blumoff,
L. A. De Lorenzo,
K. Eng,
S. D. Ha,
A. A. Kiselev,
S. M. Meenehan,
S. T. Merkel,
J. A. Wright,
L. F. Edge,
R. S. Ross,
M. T. Rakher,
M. G. Borselli,
A. Hunter
Abstract:
We implement a technique for measuring the singlet-triplet energy splitting responsible for spin-to-charge conversion in semiconductor quantum dots. This method, which requires fast, single-shot charge measurement, reliably extracts an energy in the limits of both large and small splittings. We perform this technique on an undoped, accumulation-mode Si/SiGe triple-quantum dot and find that the mea…
▽ More
We implement a technique for measuring the singlet-triplet energy splitting responsible for spin-to-charge conversion in semiconductor quantum dots. This method, which requires fast, single-shot charge measurement, reliably extracts an energy in the limits of both large and small splittings. We perform this technique on an undoped, accumulation-mode Si/SiGe triple-quantum dot and find that the measured splitting varies smoothly as a function of confinement gate biases. Not only does this demonstration prove the value of having an $in~situ$ excited-state measurement technique as part of a standard tune-up procedure, it also suggests that in typical Si/SiGe quantum dot devices, spin-blockade can be limited by lateral orbital excitation energy rather than valley splitting.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
Randomized Benchmarking as Convolution: Fourier Analysis of Gate Dependent Errors
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Emily J. Pritchett,
Bryan H. Fong
Abstract:
We show that the Randomized Benchmarking (RB) protocol is a convolution amenable to Fourier space analysis. By adopting the mathematical framework of Fourier transforms of matrix-valued functions on groups established in recent work from Gowers and Hatami [Sbornik: Mathematics 208, 1784 (2017)], we provide an alternative proof of Wallman's [Quantum 2, 47 (2018)] and Proctor's [Phys. Rev. Lett. 119…
▽ More
We show that the Randomized Benchmarking (RB) protocol is a convolution amenable to Fourier space analysis. By adopting the mathematical framework of Fourier transforms of matrix-valued functions on groups established in recent work from Gowers and Hatami [Sbornik: Mathematics 208, 1784 (2017)], we provide an alternative proof of Wallman's [Quantum 2, 47 (2018)] and Proctor's [Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 130502 (2017)] bounds on the effect of gate-dependent noise on randomized benchmarking. We show explicitly that as long as our faulty gate-set is close to the targeted representation of the Clifford group, an RB sequence is described by the exponential decay of a process that has exactly two eigenvalues close to one and the rest close to zero. This framework also allows us to construct a gauge in which the average gate-set error is a depolarizing channel parameterized by the RB decay rates, as well as a gauge which maximizes the fidelity with respect to the ideal gate-set.
△ Less
Submitted 11 August, 2021; v1 submitted 16 April, 2018;
originally announced April 2018.
-
Randomized Benchmarking, Correlated Noise, and Ising Models
Authors:
Bryan H. Fong,
Seth T. Merkel
Abstract:
We compute the expected randomized benchmarking sequence fidelity for a system subject to Gaussian time-correlated noise. For single qubit benchmarking we show that the expected sequence fidelity is given by the partition function of a long-range coupled spin-one Ising model, with each site in the Ising model corresponding to a free evolution interval. For d-state systems, the expected sequence fi…
▽ More
We compute the expected randomized benchmarking sequence fidelity for a system subject to Gaussian time-correlated noise. For single qubit benchmarking we show that the expected sequence fidelity is given by the partition function of a long-range coupled spin-one Ising model, with each site in the Ising model corresponding to a free evolution interval. For d-state systems, the expected sequence fidelity is given by an Ising-like model partition function whose site variables are given by the weights of the adjoint representation of SU(d). A high effective temperature expansion for the partition function in the single qubit case shows decay of sequence fidelity varying from exponential for uncorrelated noise to a power law for quasistatic noise. Fitting an exponential to the sequence fidelity decay under correlated noise gives unreliable estimates of the average gate error rate.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Reduced sensitivity to charge noise in semiconductor spin qubits via symmetric operation
Authors:
M. D. Reed,
B. M. Maune,
R. W. Andrews,
M. G. Borselli,
K. Eng,
M. P. Jura,
A. A. Kiselev,
T. D. Ladd,
S. T. Merkel,
I. Milosavljevic,
E. J. Pritchett,
M. T. Rakher,
R. S. Ross,
A. E. Schmitz,
A. Smith,
J. A. Wright,
M. F. Gyure,
A. T. Hunter
Abstract:
We demonstrate improved operation of exchange-coupled semiconductor quantum dots by substantially reducing the sensitivity of exchange operations to charge noise. The method involves biasing a double-dot symmetrically between the charge-state anti-crossings, where the derivative of the exchange energy with respect to gate voltages is minimized. Exchange remains highly tunable by adjusting the tunn…
▽ More
We demonstrate improved operation of exchange-coupled semiconductor quantum dots by substantially reducing the sensitivity of exchange operations to charge noise. The method involves biasing a double-dot symmetrically between the charge-state anti-crossings, where the derivative of the exchange energy with respect to gate voltages is minimized. Exchange remains highly tunable by adjusting the tunnel coupling. We find that this method reduces the dephasing effect of charge noise by more than a factor of five in comparison to operation near a charge-state anti-crossing, increasing the number of observable exchange oscillations in our qubit by a similar factor. Performance also improves with exchange rate, favoring fast quantum operations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2016; v1 submitted 5 August, 2015;
originally announced August 2015.
-
Microwave-activated conditional-phase gate for superconducting qubits
Authors:
Jerry M. Chow,
Jay M. Gambetta,
Andrew W. Cross,
Seth T. Merkel,
Chad Rigetti,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
We introduce a new entangling gate between two fixed-frequency qubits statically coupled via a microwave resonator bus which combines the following desirable qualities: all-microwave control, appreciable qubit separation for reduction of crosstalk and leakage errors, and the ability to function as a two-qubit conditional-phase gate. A fixed, always-on interaction is explicitly designed between hig…
▽ More
We introduce a new entangling gate between two fixed-frequency qubits statically coupled via a microwave resonator bus which combines the following desirable qualities: all-microwave control, appreciable qubit separation for reduction of crosstalk and leakage errors, and the ability to function as a two-qubit conditional-phase gate. A fixed, always-on interaction is explicitly designed between higher energy (non-computational) states of two transmon qubits, and then a conditional-phase gate is `activated' on the otherwise unperturbed qubit subspace via a microwave drive. We implement this microwave-activated conditional-phase gate with a fidelity from quantum process tomography of 87%.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2013;
originally announced July 2013.
-
Self-Consistent Quantum Process Tomography
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Jay M. Gambetta,
John A. Smolin,
S. Poletto,
A. D. Córcoles,
B. R. Johnson,
Colm A. Ryan,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
Quantum process tomography is a necessary tool for verifying quantum gates and diagnosing faults in architectures and gate design. We show that the standard approach of process tomography is grossly inaccurate in the case where the states and measurement operators used to interrogate the system are generated by gates that have some systematic error, a situation all but unavoidable in any practical…
▽ More
Quantum process tomography is a necessary tool for verifying quantum gates and diagnosing faults in architectures and gate design. We show that the standard approach of process tomography is grossly inaccurate in the case where the states and measurement operators used to interrogate the system are generated by gates that have some systematic error, a situation all but unavoidable in any practical setting. These errors in tomography can not be fully corrected through oversampling or by performing a larger set of experiments. We present an alternative method for tomography to reconstruct an entire library of gates in a self-consistent manner. The essential ingredient is to define a likelihood function that assumes nothing about the gates used for preparation and measurement. In order to make the resulting optimization tractable we linearize about the target, a reasonable approximation when benchmarking a quantum computer as opposed to probing a black-box function.
△ Less
Submitted 1 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
-
Entanglement of two superconducting qubits in a waveguide cavity via monochromatic two-photon excitation
Authors:
S. Poletto,
Jay M. Gambetta,
Seth T. Merkel,
John A. Smolin,
Jerry M. Chow,
A. D. Corcoles,
George A. Keefe,
Mary B. Rothwell,
J. R. Rozen,
D. W. Abraham,
Chad Rigetti,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
We report a system where fixed interactions between non-computational levels make bright the otherwise forbidden two-photon 00 --> 11 transition. The system is formed by hand selection and assembly of two discrete component transmon-style superconducting qubits inside a rectangular microwave cavity. The application of a monochromatic drive tuned to this transition induces two-photon Rabi-like osci…
▽ More
We report a system where fixed interactions between non-computational levels make bright the otherwise forbidden two-photon 00 --> 11 transition. The system is formed by hand selection and assembly of two discrete component transmon-style superconducting qubits inside a rectangular microwave cavity. The application of a monochromatic drive tuned to this transition induces two-photon Rabi-like oscillations between the ground and doubly-excited states via the Bell basis. The system therefore allows all-microwave two-qubit universal control with the same techniques and hardware required for single qubit control. We report Ramsey-like and spin echo sequences with the generated Bell states, and measure a two-qubit gate fidelity of 90% (unconstrained) and 86% (maximum likelihood estimator).
△ Less
Submitted 12 November, 2012; v1 submitted 6 August, 2012;
originally announced August 2012.
-
Theory of Josephson Photomultipliers: Optimal Working Conditions and Back Action
Authors:
Luke C. G. Govia,
Emily J. Pritchett,
Seth T. Merkel,
Deanna Pineau,
Frank K. Wilhelm
Abstract:
We describe the back action of microwave-photon detection via a Josephson photomultiplier (JPM), a superconducting qubit coupled strongly to a high-quality microwave cavity. The back action operator depends qualitatively on the duration of the measurement interval, resembling the regular photon annihilation operator at short interaction times and approaching a variant of the photon subtraction ope…
▽ More
We describe the back action of microwave-photon detection via a Josephson photomultiplier (JPM), a superconducting qubit coupled strongly to a high-quality microwave cavity. The back action operator depends qualitatively on the duration of the measurement interval, resembling the regular photon annihilation operator at short interaction times and approaching a variant of the photon subtraction operator at long times. The optimal operating conditions of the JPM differ from those considered optimal for processing and storing of quantum information, in that a short $T_2$ of the JPM suppresses the cavity dephasing incurred during measurement. Understanding this back action opens the possibility to perform multiple JPM measurements on the same state, hence performing efficient state tomography.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2012;
originally announced June 2012.
-
Characterization of addressability by simultaneous randomized benchmarking
Authors:
Jay M. Gambetta,
A. D. Corcoles,
S. T. Merkel,
B. R. Johnson,
John A. Smolin,
Jerry M. Chow,
Colm A. Ryan,
Chad Rigetti,
S. Poletto,
Thomas A. Ohki,
Mark B. Ketchen,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
The control and handling of errors arising from cross-talk and unwanted interactions in multi-qubit systems is an important issue in quantum information processing architectures. We introduce a benchmarking protocol that provides information about the amount of addressability present in the system and implement it on coupled superconducting qubits. The protocol consists of randomized benchmarking…
▽ More
The control and handling of errors arising from cross-talk and unwanted interactions in multi-qubit systems is an important issue in quantum information processing architectures. We introduce a benchmarking protocol that provides information about the amount of addressability present in the system and implement it on coupled superconducting qubits. The protocol consists of randomized benchmarking each qubit individually and then simultaneously, and the amount of addressability is related to the difference of the average gate fidelities of those experiments. We present the results on two similar samples with different amounts of cross-talk and unwanted interactions, which agree with predictions based on simple models for the amount of residual coupling.
△ Less
Submitted 2 January, 2013; v1 submitted 27 April, 2012;
originally announced April 2012.
-
Efficient measurement of quantum gate error by interleaved randomized benchmarking
Authors:
Easwar Magesan,
Jay M. Gambetta,
B. R. Johnson,
Colm A. Ryan,
Jerry M. Chow,
Seth T. Merkel,
Marcus P. da Silva,
George A. Keefe,
Mary B. Rothwell,
Thomas A. Ohki,
Mark B. Ketchen,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
We describe a scalable experimental protocol for obtaining estimates of the error rate of individual quantum computational gates. This protocol, in which random Clifford gates are interleaved between a gate of interest, provides a bounded estimate of the average error of the gate under test so long as the average variation of the noise affecting the full set of Clifford gates is small. This techni…
▽ More
We describe a scalable experimental protocol for obtaining estimates of the error rate of individual quantum computational gates. This protocol, in which random Clifford gates are interleaved between a gate of interest, provides a bounded estimate of the average error of the gate under test so long as the average variation of the noise affecting the full set of Clifford gates is small. This technique takes into account both state preparation and measurement errors and is scalable in the number of qubits. We apply this protocol to a superconducting qubit system and find gate errors that compare favorably with the gate errors extracted via quantum process tomography.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2014; v1 submitted 20 March, 2012;
originally announced March 2012.
-
Superconducting qubit in waveguide cavity with coherence time approaching 0.1ms
Authors:
Chad Rigetti,
Stefano Poletto,
Jay M. Gambetta,
B. L. T. Plourde,
Jerry M. Chow,
A. D. Corcoles,
John A. Smolin,
Seth T. Merkel,
J. R. Rozen,
George A. Keefe,
Mary B. Rothwell,
Mark B. Ketchen,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
We report a superconducting artificial atom with an observed quantum coherence time of T2*=95us and energy relaxation time T1=70us. The system consists of a single Josephson junction transmon qubit embedded in an otherwise empty copper waveguide cavity whose lowest eigenmode is dispersively coupled to the qubit transition. We attribute the factor of four increase in the coherence quality factor re…
▽ More
We report a superconducting artificial atom with an observed quantum coherence time of T2*=95us and energy relaxation time T1=70us. The system consists of a single Josephson junction transmon qubit embedded in an otherwise empty copper waveguide cavity whose lowest eigenmode is dispersively coupled to the qubit transition. We attribute the factor of four increase in the coherence quality factor relative to previous reports to device modifications aimed at reducing qubit dephasing from residual cavity photons. This simple device holds great promise as a robust and easily produced artificial quantum system whose intrinsic coherence properties are sufficient to allow tests of quantum error correction.
△ Less
Submitted 24 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
Complete universal quantum gate set approaching fault-tolerant thresholds with superconducting qubits
Authors:
Jerry M. Chow,
Jay M. Gambetta,
A. D. Corcoles,
Seth T. Merkel,
John A. Smolin,
Chad Rigetti,
S. Poletto,
George A. Keefe,
Mary B. Rothwell,
J. R. Rozen,
Mark B. Ketchen,
M. Steffen
Abstract:
We use quantum process tomography to characterize a full universal set of all-microwave gates on two superconducting single-frequency single-junction transmon qubits. All extracted gate fidelities, including those for Clifford group generators, single-qubit pi/4 and pi/8 rotations, and a two-qubit controlled-NOT, exceed 95% (98%), without (with) accounting for state preparation and measurement err…
▽ More
We use quantum process tomography to characterize a full universal set of all-microwave gates on two superconducting single-frequency single-junction transmon qubits. All extracted gate fidelities, including those for Clifford group generators, single-qubit pi/4 and pi/8 rotations, and a two-qubit controlled-NOT, exceed 95% (98%), without (with) accounting for state preparation and measurement errors. Furthermore, we introduce a process map representation in the Pauli basis which is visually efficient and informative. This high-fidelity gate set serves as another critical building block towards scalable architectures of superconducting qubits for error correction schemes.
△ Less
Submitted 23 February, 2012;
originally announced February 2012.
-
High Fidelity Quantum Gates in the Presence of Dispersion
Authors:
Botan Khani,
Seth T. Merkel,
Felix Motzoi,
Jay M. Gambetta,
Frank K. Wilhelm
Abstract:
We numerically demonstrate the control of motional degrees of freedom of an ensemble of neutral atoms in an optical lattice with a shallow trap** potential. Taking into account the range of quasimomenta across different Brillouin zones results in an ensemble whose members effectively have inhomogeneous control fields as well as spectrally distinct control Hamiltonians. We present an ensemble-ave…
▽ More
We numerically demonstrate the control of motional degrees of freedom of an ensemble of neutral atoms in an optical lattice with a shallow trap** potential. Taking into account the range of quasimomenta across different Brillouin zones results in an ensemble whose members effectively have inhomogeneous control fields as well as spectrally distinct control Hamiltonians. We present an ensemble-averaged optimal control technique that yields high fidelity control pulses, irrespective of quasimomentum, with average fidelities above 98%. The resulting controls show a broadband spectrum with gate times in the order of several free oscillations to optimize gates with up to 13.2% dispersion in the energies from the band structure. This can be seen as a model system for the prospects of robust quantum control. This result explores the limits of discretizing a continuous ensemble for control theory.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2011;
originally announced November 2011.
-
Control of inhomogeneous atomic ensembles of hyperfine qudits
Authors:
Brian E. Mischuck,
Seth T. Merkel,
Ivan H. Deutsch
Abstract:
We study the ability to control d-dimensional quantum systems (qudits) encoded in the hyperfine spin of alkali-metal atoms through the application of radio- and microwave-frequency magnetic fields in the presence of inhomogeneities in amplitude and detuning. Such a capability is essential to the design of robust pulses that mitigate the effects of experimental uncertainty and also for application…
▽ More
We study the ability to control d-dimensional quantum systems (qudits) encoded in the hyperfine spin of alkali-metal atoms through the application of radio- and microwave-frequency magnetic fields in the presence of inhomogeneities in amplitude and detuning. Such a capability is essential to the design of robust pulses that mitigate the effects of experimental uncertainty and also for application to tomographic addressing of particular members of an extended ensemble. We study the problem of preparing an arbitrary state in the Hilbert space from an initial fiducial state. We prove that inhomogeneous control of qudit ensembles is possible based on a semi-analytic protocol that synthesizes the target through a sequence of alternating rf and microwave-driven SU(2) rotations in overlap** irreducible subspaces. Several examples of robust control are studied, and the semi-analytic protocol is compared to a brute force, full numerical search. For small inhomogeneities, < 1%, both approaches achieve average fidelities greater than 0.99, but the brute force approach performs superiorly, reaching high fidelities in shorter times and capable of handling inhomogeneities well beyond experimental uncertainty. The full numerical search is also applied to tomographic addressing whereby two different nonclassical states of the spin are produced in two halves of the ensemble.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2011;
originally announced September 2011.
-
Optimal control methods for fast time-varying Hamiltonians
Authors:
F. Motzoi,
J. M. Gambetta,
S. T. Merkel,
F. K. Wilhelm
Abstract:
In this article, we develop a numerical method to find optimal control pulses that accounts for the separation of timescales between the variation of the input control fields and the applied Hamiltonian. In traditional numerical optimization methods, these timescales are treated as being the same. While this approximation has had much success, in applications where the input controls are filtered…
▽ More
In this article, we develop a numerical method to find optimal control pulses that accounts for the separation of timescales between the variation of the input control fields and the applied Hamiltonian. In traditional numerical optimization methods, these timescales are treated as being the same. While this approximation has had much success, in applications where the input controls are filtered substantially or mixed with a fast carrier, the resulting optimized pulses have little relation to the applied physical fields. Our technique remains numerically efficient in that the dimension of our search space is only dependent on the variation of the input control fields, while our simulation of the quantum evolution is accurate on the timescale of the fast variation in the applied Hamiltonian.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2011; v1 submitted 2 February, 2011;
originally announced February 2011.
-
Microwave Photon Counter Based on Josephson Junctions
Authors:
Y. -F. Chen,
D. Hover,
S. Sendelbach,
L. Maurer,
S. T. Merkel,
E. J. Pritchett,
F. K. Wilhelm,
R. McDermott
Abstract:
We describe a microwave photon counter based on the current-biased Josephson junction. The junction is tuned to absorb single microwave photons from the incident field, after which it tunnels into a classically observable voltage state. Using two such detectors, we have performed a microwave version of the Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment at 4 GHz and demonstrated a clear signature of photon bun…
▽ More
We describe a microwave photon counter based on the current-biased Josephson junction. The junction is tuned to absorb single microwave photons from the incident field, after which it tunnels into a classically observable voltage state. Using two such detectors, we have performed a microwave version of the Hanbury Brown and Twiss experiment at 4 GHz and demonstrated a clear signature of photon bunching for a thermal source. The design is readily scalable to tens of parallelized junctions, a configuration that would allow number-resolved counting of microwave photons.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2011; v1 submitted 18 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Analytic control methods for high fidelity unitary operations in a weakly nonlinear oscillator
Authors:
J. M. Gambetta,
F. Motzoi,
S. T. Merkel,
F. K. Wilhelm
Abstract:
In qubits made from a weakly anharmonic oscillator the leading source of error at short gate times is leakage of population out of the two dimensional Hilbert space that forms the qubit. In this paper we develop a general scheme based on an adiabatic expansion to find pulse shapes that correct this type of error. We find a family of solutions that allows tailoring to what is practical to implement…
▽ More
In qubits made from a weakly anharmonic oscillator the leading source of error at short gate times is leakage of population out of the two dimensional Hilbert space that forms the qubit. In this paper we develop a general scheme based on an adiabatic expansion to find pulse shapes that correct this type of error. We find a family of solutions that allows tailoring to what is practical to implement for a specific application. Our result contains and improves the previously developed DRAG technique [F. Motzoi, et. al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 110501 (2009)] and allows a generalization to other non-linear oscillators with more than one leakage transition.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2011; v1 submitted 8 November, 2010;
originally announced November 2010.
-
Generation and detection of NOON states in superconducting circuits
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Frank K. Wilhelm
Abstract:
NOON states, states between two modes of light of the form $|N,0\rangle+e^{iφ}|0,N\rangle$ allow for super-resolution interformetry. We show how NOON states can be efficiently produced in circuit quntum electrodynamics using superconducting phase qubits and resonators. We propose a protocol where only one interaction between the two modes is required, creating all the necessary entanglement at the…
▽ More
NOON states, states between two modes of light of the form $|N,0\rangle+e^{iφ}|0,N\rangle$ allow for super-resolution interformetry. We show how NOON states can be efficiently produced in circuit quntum electrodynamics using superconducting phase qubits and resonators. We propose a protocol where only one interaction between the two modes is required, creating all the necessary entanglement at the start of the procedure. This protocol makes active use of the first three states of the phase qubits. Additionally, we show how to efficiently verify the success of such an experiment, even for large NOON states, using randomly sampled measurements and semidefinite programming techniques.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2010;
originally announced June 2010.
-
Random unitary maps for quantum state reconstruction
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Carlos A. Riofrio,
Steven T. Flammia,
Ivan H. Deutsch
Abstract:
We study the possibility of performing quantum state reconstruction from a measurement record that is obtained as a sequence of expectation values of a Hermitian operator evolving under repeated application of a single random unitary map, U_0. We show that while this single-parameter orbit in operator space is not informationally complete, it can be used to yield surprisingly high-fidelity recon…
▽ More
We study the possibility of performing quantum state reconstruction from a measurement record that is obtained as a sequence of expectation values of a Hermitian operator evolving under repeated application of a single random unitary map, U_0. We show that while this single-parameter orbit in operator space is not informationally complete, it can be used to yield surprisingly high-fidelity reconstruction. For a d-dimensional Hilbert space with the initial observable in su(d), the measurement record lacks information about a matrix subspace of dimension > d-2 out of the total dimension d^2-1. We determine the conditions on U_0 such that the bound is saturated, and show they are achieved by almost all pseudorandom unitary matrices. When we further impose the constraint that the physical density matrix must be positive, we obtain even higher fidelity than that predicted from the missing subspace. With prior knowledge that the state is pure, the reconstruction will be perfect (in the limit of vanishing noise) and for arbitrary mixed states, the fidelity is over 0.96, even for small d, and reaching F > 0.99 for d > 9. We also study the implementation of this protocol based on the relationship between random matrices and quantum chaos. We show that the Floquet operator of the quantum kicked top provides a means of generating the required type of measurement record, with implications on the relationship between quantum chaos and information gain.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2009;
originally announced December 2009.
-
Quantum Control of d-Dimensional Quantum Systems with Application to Alkali Atomic Spins
Authors:
Seth Merkel
Abstract:
In this dissertation I analyze Hamiltonian control of $d$-dimensional quantum systems as realized in alkali atomic spins. Alkali atoms provide an ideal platform for studies of quantum control due to the extreme precision with which the control fields are characterized as well as their isolation from their environment. In chapter 2, I review some background material on open-loop quantum control t…
▽ More
In this dissertation I analyze Hamiltonian control of $d$-dimensional quantum systems as realized in alkali atomic spins. Alkali atoms provide an ideal platform for studies of quantum control due to the extreme precision with which the control fields are characterized as well as their isolation from their environment. In chapter 2, I review some background material on open-loop quantum control theory. Chapter 3 provides a derivation of the Hamiltonians arising from electromagnetic fields that we use to control our alkali atomic spins. In chapter 4, I develop an algorithm for state preparation, that is map** a fiducial state to some arbitrary target state, and show numerical and experimental implementations for making arbitrary superpositions of hyperfine states in $^{133}Cs. Finally, chapter 5 presents a protocol for generating full unitary maps efficiently by utilizing the ability to construct state map**s.
△ Less
Submitted 25 June, 2009;
originally announced June 2009.
-
Constructing General Unitary Maps from State Preparations
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Gavin Brennen,
Poul S. Jessen,
Ivan H. Deutsch
Abstract:
We present an efficient algorithm for generating unitary maps on a $d$-dimensional Hilbert space from a time-dependent Hamiltonian through a combination of stochastic searches and geometric construction. The protocol is based on the eigen-decomposition of the map. A unitary matrix can be implemented by sequentially map** each eigenvector to a fiducial state, imprinting the eigenphase on that s…
▽ More
We present an efficient algorithm for generating unitary maps on a $d$-dimensional Hilbert space from a time-dependent Hamiltonian through a combination of stochastic searches and geometric construction. The protocol is based on the eigen-decomposition of the map. A unitary matrix can be implemented by sequentially map** each eigenvector to a fiducial state, imprinting the eigenphase on that state, and map** it back to the eigenvector. This requires the design of only $d$ state-to-state maps generated by control waveforms that are efficiently found by a gradient search with computational resources that scale polynomially in $d$. In contrast, the complexity of a stochastic search for a single waveform that simultaneously acts as desired on all eigenvectors scales exponentially in $d$. We extend this construction to design maps on an $n$-dimensional subspace of the Hilbert space using only $n$ stochastic searches. Additionally, we show how these techniques can be used to control atomic spins in the ground electronic hyperfine manifold of alkali atoms in order to implement general qudit logic gates as well to perform a simple form of error correction on an embedded qubit.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2009;
originally announced February 2009.
-
Quantum control of the hyperfine-coupled electron and nuclear spins in alkali atoms
Authors:
Seth T. Merkel,
Poul S. Jessen,
Ivan H. Deutsch
Abstract:
We study quantum control of the full hyperfine manifold in the ground-electronic state of alkali atoms based on applied radio frequency and microwave fields. Such interactions should allow essentially decoherence-free dynamics and the application of techniques for robust control developed for NMR spectroscopy. We establish the conditions under which the system is controllable in the sense that o…
▽ More
We study quantum control of the full hyperfine manifold in the ground-electronic state of alkali atoms based on applied radio frequency and microwave fields. Such interactions should allow essentially decoherence-free dynamics and the application of techniques for robust control developed for NMR spectroscopy. We establish the conditions under which the system is controllable in the sense that one can generate an arbitrary unitary on the system. We apply this to the case of $^{133}$Cs with its $d=16$ dimensional Hilbert space of magnetic sublevels in the $6S_{1/2}$ state, and design control waveforms that generate an arbitrary target state from an initial fiducial state. We develop a generalized Wigner function representation for this space consisting of the direct sum of two irreducible representation of SU(2), allowing us to visualize these states. The performance of different control scenarios is evaluated based on the ability to generate high-fidelity operation in an allotted time with the available resources. We find good operating points commensurate with modest laboratory requirements.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2008; v1 submitted 17 April, 2008;
originally announced April 2008.
-
Phase transition of computational power in the resource states for one-way quantum computation
Authors:
Daniel E. Browne,
Matthew B. Elliott,
Steven T. Flammia,
Seth T. Merkel,
Akimasa Miyake,
Anthony J. Short
Abstract:
We study how heralded qubit losses during the preparation of a two-dimensional cluster state, a universal resource state for one-way quantum computation, affect its computational power. Above the percolation threshold we present a polynomial-time algorithm that concentrates a universal cluster state, using resources that scale optimally in the size of the original lattice. On the other hand, bel…
▽ More
We study how heralded qubit losses during the preparation of a two-dimensional cluster state, a universal resource state for one-way quantum computation, affect its computational power. Above the percolation threshold we present a polynomial-time algorithm that concentrates a universal cluster state, using resources that scale optimally in the size of the original lattice. On the other hand, below the percolation threshold, we show that single qubit measurements on the faulty lattice can be efficiently simulated classically. We observe a phase transition at the threshold when the amount of entanglement in the faulty lattice directly relevant to the computational power changes exponentially.
△ Less
Submitted 4 February, 2008; v1 submitted 11 September, 2007;
originally announced September 2007.
-
Quantum Control of the Hyperfine Spin of a Cs Atom Ensemble
Authors:
Souma Chaudhury,
Seth Merkel,
Tobias Herr,
Andrew Silberfarb,
Ivan H. Deutsch,
Poul S. Jessen
Abstract:
We demonstrate quantum control of a large spin-angular momentum associated with the F=3 hyperfine ground state of 133Cs. A combination of time dependent magnetic fields and a static tensor light shift is used to implement near-optimal controls and map a fiducial state to a broad range of target states, with yields in the range 0.8-0.9. Squeezed states are produced also by an adiabatic scheme tha…
▽ More
We demonstrate quantum control of a large spin-angular momentum associated with the F=3 hyperfine ground state of 133Cs. A combination of time dependent magnetic fields and a static tensor light shift is used to implement near-optimal controls and map a fiducial state to a broad range of target states, with yields in the range 0.8-0.9. Squeezed states are produced also by an adiabatic scheme that is more robust against errors. Universal control facilitates the encoding and manipulation of qubits and qudits in atomic ground states, and may lead to improvement of some precision measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2007;
originally announced June 2007.
