-
Spectroscopic measurements and models of energy deposition in the substrate of quantum circuits by natural ionizing radiation
Authors:
Joseph W. Fowler,
Paul Szypryt,
Raymond Bunker,
Ellen R. Edwards,
Ian Fogarty Florang,
Jiansong Gao,
Andrea Giachero,
Shannon F. Hoogerheide,
Ben Loer,
H. Pieter Mumm,
Nathan Nakamura,
Galen C. O'Neil,
John L. Orrell,
Elizabeth M. Scott,
Jason Stevens,
Daniel S. Swetz,
Brent A. VanDevender,
Michael Vissers,
Joel N. Ullom
Abstract:
Naturally occurring background radiation is a source of correlated decoherence events in superconducting qubits that will challenge error-correction schemes. To characterize the radiation environment in an unshielded laboratory, we performed broadband, spectroscopic measurements of background events in silicon substrates located inside a millikelvin refrigerator, an environment representative of s…
▽ More
Naturally occurring background radiation is a source of correlated decoherence events in superconducting qubits that will challenge error-correction schemes. To characterize the radiation environment in an unshielded laboratory, we performed broadband, spectroscopic measurements of background events in silicon substrates located inside a millikelvin refrigerator, an environment representative of superconducting qubit systems. We measured the background spectra in silicon substrates of two thicknesses, 0.5 mm and 1.5 mm, and obtained the average event rate and the integrated power deposition. In a 25 mm^2 area and the thinner substrate, these values are 0.023 events per second and 4.9 keV/s, counting events that deposit at least 40 keV. We find the background spectrum to be nearly featureless. Its intensity decreases by a factor of 40,000 between 100 keV and 3 MeV for silicon substrates 0.5 mm thick. We find the cryogenic measurements to be in good agreement with predictions based on measurements of the terrestrial gamma-ray flux, published models of cosmic-ray fluxes, a crude model of the cryostat, and radiation-transport simulations. No free parameters are required to predict the background spectra in the silicon substrates. The good agreement between measurements and predictions allow assessment of the relative contributions of terrestrial and cosmic background sources and their dependence on substrate thickness. Our spectroscopic measurements are performed with superconducting microresonators that transduce deposited energy to a readily detectable electrical signal. We find that gamma-ray emissions from radioisotopes are responsible for the majority of events depositing E<1.5 MeV, while nucleons among the cosmic-ray secondary particles cause most events that deposit more energy. These results suggest several paths to reducing the impact of background radiation on quantum circuits.
△ Less
Submitted 16 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Abatement of Ionizing Radiation for Superconducting Quantum Devices
Authors:
B. Loer,
P. M. Harrington,
B. Archambault,
E. Fuller,
B. Pierson,
I. Arnquist,
K. Harouaka,
T. D. Schlieder,
D. K. Kim,
A. J. Melville,
B. M. Niedzielski,
J. K. Yoder,
K. Serniak,
W. D. Oliver,
J. L. Orrell,
R. Bunker,
B. A. VanDevender,
M. Warner
Abstract:
Ionizing radiation has been shown to reduce the performance of superconducting quantum circuits. In this report, we evaluate the expected contributions of different sources of ambient radioactivity for typical superconducting qubit experiment platforms. Our assessment of radioactivity inside a typical cryostat highlights the importance of selecting appropriate materials for the experiment componen…
▽ More
Ionizing radiation has been shown to reduce the performance of superconducting quantum circuits. In this report, we evaluate the expected contributions of different sources of ambient radioactivity for typical superconducting qubit experiment platforms. Our assessment of radioactivity inside a typical cryostat highlights the importance of selecting appropriate materials for the experiment components nearest to qubit devices, such as packaging and electrical interconnects. We present a shallow underground facility (30-meter water equivalent) to reduce the flux of cosmic rays and a lead shielded cryostat to abate the naturally occurring radiogenic gamma-ray flux in the laboratory environment. We predict that superconducting qubit devices operated in this facility could experience a reduced rate of correlated multi-qubit errors by a factor of approximately 20 relative to the rate in a typical above-ground, unshielded facility. Finally, we outline overall design improvements that would be required to further reduce the residual ionizing radiation rate, down to the limit of current generation direct detection dark matter experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Quantum Sensors for High Energy Physics
Authors:
Aaron Chou,
Kent Irwin,
Reina H. Maruyama,
Oliver K. Baker,
Chelsea Bartram,
Karl K. Berggren,
Gustavo Cancelo,
Daniel Carney,
Clarence L. Chang,
Hsiao-Mei Cho,
Maurice Garcia-Sciveres,
Peter W. Graham,
Salman Habib,
Roni Harnik,
J. G. E. Harris,
Scott A. Hertel,
David B. Hume,
Rakshya Khatiwada,
Timothy L. Kovachy,
Noah Kurinsky,
Steve K. Lamoreaux,
Konrad W. Lehnert,
David R. Leibrandt,
Dale Li,
Ben Loer
, et al. (17 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Strong motivation for investing in quantum sensing arises from the need to investigate phenomena that are very weakly coupled to the matter and fields well described by the Standard Model. These can be related to the problems of dark matter, dark sectors not necessarily related to dark matter (for example sterile neutrinos), dark energy and gravity, fundamental constants, and problems with the Sta…
▽ More
Strong motivation for investing in quantum sensing arises from the need to investigate phenomena that are very weakly coupled to the matter and fields well described by the Standard Model. These can be related to the problems of dark matter, dark sectors not necessarily related to dark matter (for example sterile neutrinos), dark energy and gravity, fundamental constants, and problems with the Standard Model itself including the Strong CP problem in QCD. Resulting experimental needs typically involve the measurement of very low energy impulses or low power periodic signals that are normally buried under large backgrounds. This report documents the findings of the 2023 Quantum Sensors for High Energy Physics workshop which identified enabling quantum information science technologies that could be utilized in future particle physics experiments, targeting high energy physics science goals.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Quantum Information Science and Technology for Nuclear Physics. Input into U.S. Long-Range Planning, 2023
Authors:
Douglas Beck,
Joseph Carlson,
Zohreh Davoudi,
Joseph Formaggio,
Sofia Quaglioni,
Martin Savage,
Joao Barata,
Tanmoy Bhattacharya,
Michael Bishof,
Ian Cloet,
Andrea Delgado,
Michael DeMarco,
Caleb Fink,
Adrien Florio,
Marianne Francois,
Dorota Grabowska,
Shannon Hoogerheide,
Mengyao Huang,
Kazuki Ikeda,
Marc Illa,
Kyungseon Joo,
Dmitri Kharzeev,
Karol Kowalski,
Wai Kin Lai,
Kyle Leach
, et al. (76 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In preparation for the 2023 NSAC Long Range Plan (LRP), members of the Nuclear Science community gathered to discuss the current state of, and plans for further leveraging opportunities in, QIST in NP research at the Quantum Information Science for U.S. Nuclear Physics Long Range Planning workshop, held in Santa Fe, New Mexico on January 31 - February 1, 2023. The workshop included 45 in-person pa…
▽ More
In preparation for the 2023 NSAC Long Range Plan (LRP), members of the Nuclear Science community gathered to discuss the current state of, and plans for further leveraging opportunities in, QIST in NP research at the Quantum Information Science for U.S. Nuclear Physics Long Range Planning workshop, held in Santa Fe, New Mexico on January 31 - February 1, 2023. The workshop included 45 in-person participants and 53 remote attendees. The outcome of the workshop identified strategic plans and requirements for the next 5-10 years to advance quantum sensing and quantum simulations within NP, and to develop a diverse quantum-ready workforce. The plans include resolutions endorsed by the participants to address the compelling scientific opportunities at the intersections of NP and QIST. These endorsements are aligned with similar affirmations by the LRP Computational Nuclear Physics and AI/ML Workshop, the Nuclear Structure, Reactions, and Astrophysics LRP Town Hall, and the Fundamental Symmetries, Neutrons, and Neutrinos LRP Town Hall communities.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
G4CMP: Condensed Matter Physics Simulation Using the Geant4 Toolkit
Authors:
M. H. Kelsey,
R. Agnese,
Y. F. Alam,
I. Ataee Langroudy,
E. Azadbakht,
D. Brandt,
R. Bunker,
B. Cabrera,
Y. -Y. Chang,
H. Coombes,
R. M. Cormier,
M. D. Diamond,
E. R. Edwards,
E. Figueroa-Feliciano,
J. Gao,
P. M. Harrington,
Z. Hong,
M. Hui,
N. A. Kurinsky,
R. E. Lawrence,
B. Loer,
M. G. Masten,
E. Michaud,
E. Michielin,
J. Miller
, et al. (22 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
G4CMP simulates phonon and charge transport in cryogenic semiconductor crystals using the Geant4 toolkit. The transport code is capable of simulating the propagation of acoustic phonons as well as electron and hole charge carriers. Processes for anisotropic phonon propagation, oblique charge-carrier propagation, and phonon emission by accelerated charge carriers are included. The simulation reprod…
▽ More
G4CMP simulates phonon and charge transport in cryogenic semiconductor crystals using the Geant4 toolkit. The transport code is capable of simulating the propagation of acoustic phonons as well as electron and hole charge carriers. Processes for anisotropic phonon propagation, oblique charge-carrier propagation, and phonon emission by accelerated charge carriers are included. The simulation reproduces theoretical predictions and experimental observations such as phonon caustics, heat-pulse propagation times, and mean charge-carrier drift velocities. In addition to presenting the physics and features supported by G4CMP, this report outlines example applications from the dark matter and quantum information science communities. These communities are applying G4CMP to model and design devices for which the energy transported by phonons and charge carriers is germane to the performance of superconducting instruments and circuits placed on silicon and germanium substrates. The G4CMP package is available to download from GitHub: github.com/kelseymh/G4CMP.
△ Less
Submitted 12 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Sensor-assisted fault mitigation in quantum computation
Authors:
John L. Orrell,
Ben Loer
Abstract:
We propose a method to assist fault mitigation in quantum computation through the use of sensors co-located near physical qubits. Specifically, we consider using transition edge sensors co-located on silicon substrates hosting superconducting qubits to monitor for energy injection from ionizing radiation, which has been demonstrated to increase decoherence in transmon qubits. We generalize from th…
▽ More
We propose a method to assist fault mitigation in quantum computation through the use of sensors co-located near physical qubits. Specifically, we consider using transition edge sensors co-located on silicon substrates hosting superconducting qubits to monitor for energy injection from ionizing radiation, which has been demonstrated to increase decoherence in transmon qubits. We generalize from these two physical device concepts and explore the potential advantages of co-located sensors to assist fault mitigation in quantum computation. In the simplest scheme, co-located sensors beneficially assist rejection of calculations potentially affected by environmental disturbances. Investigating the potential computational advantage further required development of an extension to the standard formulation of quantum error correction. In a specific case of the standard three-qubit, bit-flip quantum error correction code, we show that given a 20% overall error probability per qubit, approximately 90% of repeated calculation attempts are correctable. However, when sensor-detectable errors account for 45% of overall error probability, the use of co-located sensors uniquely associated with independent qubits boosts the fraction of correct final-state calculations to 96%, at the cost of rejecting 7% of repeated calculation attempts.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Impact of ionizing radiation on superconducting qubit coherence
Authors:
Antti Vepsäläinen,
Amir H. Karamlou,
John L. Orrell,
Akshunna S. Dogra,
Ben Loer,
Francisca Vasconcelos,
David K. Kim,
Alexander J. Melville,
Bethany M. Niedzielski,
Jonilyn L. Yoder,
Simon Gustavsson,
Joseph A. Formaggio,
Brent A. VanDevender,
William D. Oliver
Abstract:
The practical viability of any qubit technology stands on long coherence times and high-fidelity operations, with the superconducting qubit modality being a leading example. However, superconducting qubit coherence is impacted by broken Cooper pairs, referred to as quasiparticles, with a density that is empirically observed to be orders of magnitude greater than the value predicted for thermal equ…
▽ More
The practical viability of any qubit technology stands on long coherence times and high-fidelity operations, with the superconducting qubit modality being a leading example. However, superconducting qubit coherence is impacted by broken Cooper pairs, referred to as quasiparticles, with a density that is empirically observed to be orders of magnitude greater than the value predicted for thermal equilibrium by the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) theory of superconductivity. Previous work has shown that infrared photons significantly increase the quasiparticle density, yet even in the best isolated systems, it still remains higher than expected, suggesting that another generation mechanism exists. In this Letter, we provide evidence that ionizing radiation from environmental radioactive materials and cosmic rays contributes to this observed difference, leading to an elevated quasiparticle density that would ultimately limit superconducting qubits of the type measured here to coherence times in the millisecond regime. We further demonstrate that introducing radiation shielding reduces the flux of ionizing radiation and positively correlates with increased coherence time. Albeit a small effect for today's qubits, reducing or otherwise mitigating the impact of ionizing radiation will be critical for realizing fault-tolerant superconducting quantum computers.
△ Less
Submitted 27 August, 2020; v1 submitted 24 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
