-
The Wall Street Neophyte: A Zero-Shot Analysis of ChatGPT Over MultiModal Stock Movement Prediction Challenges
Authors:
Qianqian Xie,
Weiguang Han,
Yanzhao Lai,
Min Peng,
Jimin Huang
Abstract:
Recently, large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have demonstrated remarkable performance across a variety of natural language processing tasks. However, their effectiveness in the financial domain, specifically in predicting stock market movements, remains to be explored. In this paper, we conduct an extensive zero-shot analysis of ChatGPT's capabilities in multimodal stock movement prediction…
▽ More
Recently, large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT have demonstrated remarkable performance across a variety of natural language processing tasks. However, their effectiveness in the financial domain, specifically in predicting stock market movements, remains to be explored. In this paper, we conduct an extensive zero-shot analysis of ChatGPT's capabilities in multimodal stock movement prediction, on three tweets and historical stock price datasets. Our findings indicate that ChatGPT is a "Wall Street Neophyte" with limited success in predicting stock movements, as it underperforms not only state-of-the-art methods but also traditional methods like linear regression using price features. Despite the potential of Chain-of-Thought prompting strategies and the inclusion of tweets, ChatGPT's performance remains subpar. Furthermore, we observe limitations in its explainability and stability, suggesting the need for more specialized training or fine-tuning. This research provides insights into ChatGPT's capabilities and serves as a foundation for future work aimed at improving financial market analysis and prediction by leveraging social media sentiment and historical stock data.
△ Less
Submitted 28 April, 2023; v1 submitted 10 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Mastering Pair Trading with Risk-Aware Recurrent Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Weiguang Han,
Jimin Huang,
Qianqian Xie,
Boyi Zhang,
Yanzhao Lai,
Min Peng
Abstract:
Although pair trading is the simplest hedging strategy for an investor to eliminate market risk, it is still a great challenge for reinforcement learning (RL) methods to perform pair trading as human expertise. It requires RL methods to make thousands of correct actions that nevertheless have no obvious relations to the overall trading profit, and to reason over infinite states of the time-varying…
▽ More
Although pair trading is the simplest hedging strategy for an investor to eliminate market risk, it is still a great challenge for reinforcement learning (RL) methods to perform pair trading as human expertise. It requires RL methods to make thousands of correct actions that nevertheless have no obvious relations to the overall trading profit, and to reason over infinite states of the time-varying market most of which have never appeared in history. However, existing RL methods ignore the temporal connections between asset price movements and the risk of the performed trading. These lead to frequent tradings with high transaction costs and potential losses, which barely reach the human expertise level of trading. Therefore, we introduce CREDIT, a risk-aware agent capable of learning to exploit long-term trading opportunities in pair trading similar to a human expert. CREDIT is the first to apply bidirectional GRU along with the temporal attention mechanism to fully consider the temporal correlations embedded in the states, which allows CREDIT to capture long-term patterns of the price movements of two assets to earn higher profit. We also design the risk-aware reward inspired by the economic theory, that models both the profit and risk of the tradings during the trading period. It helps our agent to master pair trading with a robust trading preference that avoids risky trading with possible high returns and losses. Experiments show that it outperforms existing reinforcement learning methods in pair trading and achieves a significant profit over five years of U.S. stock data.
△ Less
Submitted 1 April, 2023;
originally announced April 2023.
-
Select and Trade: Towards Unified Pair Trading with Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning
Authors:
Weiguang Han,
Boyi Zhang,
Qianqian Xie,
Min Peng,
Yanzhao Lai,
Jimin Huang
Abstract:
Pair trading is one of the most effective statistical arbitrage strategies which seeks a neutral profit by hedging a pair of selected assets. Existing methods generally decompose the task into two separate steps: pair selection and trading. However, the decoupling of two closely related subtasks can block information propagation and lead to limited overall performance. For pair selection, ignoring…
▽ More
Pair trading is one of the most effective statistical arbitrage strategies which seeks a neutral profit by hedging a pair of selected assets. Existing methods generally decompose the task into two separate steps: pair selection and trading. However, the decoupling of two closely related subtasks can block information propagation and lead to limited overall performance. For pair selection, ignoring the trading performance results in the wrong assets being selected with irrelevant price movements, while the agent trained for trading can overfit to the selected assets without any historical information of other assets. To address it, in this paper, we propose a paradigm for automatic pair trading as a unified task rather than a two-step pipeline. We design a hierarchical reinforcement learning framework to jointly learn and optimize two subtasks. A high-level policy would select two assets from all possible combinations and a low-level policy would then perform a series of trading actions. Experimental results on real-world stock data demonstrate the effectiveness of our method on pair trading compared with both existing pair selection and trading methods.
△ Less
Submitted 5 February, 2023; v1 submitted 25 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Coherence and incoherence collective behavior in financial market
Authors:
Shangmei Zhao,
Qiuchao Xie,
Qing Lu,
Xin Jiang,
Wei Chen
Abstract:
Financial markets have been extensively studied as highly complex evolving systems. In this paper, we quantify financial price fluctuations through a coupled dynamical system composed of phase oscillators. We find a Financial Coherence and Incoherence (FCI) coexistence collective behavior emerges as the system evolves into the stable state, in which the stocks split into two groups: one is represe…
▽ More
Financial markets have been extensively studied as highly complex evolving systems. In this paper, we quantify financial price fluctuations through a coupled dynamical system composed of phase oscillators. We find a Financial Coherence and Incoherence (FCI) coexistence collective behavior emerges as the system evolves into the stable state, in which the stocks split into two groups: one is represented by coherent, phase-locked oscillators, the other is composed of incoherent, drifting oscillators. It is demonstrated that the size of the coherent stock groups fluctuates during the economic periods according to real-world financial instabilities or shocks. Further, we introduce the coherent characteristic matrix to characterize the involvement dynamics of stocks in the coherent groups. Clustering results on the matrix provides a novel manifestation of the correlations among stocks in the economic periods. Our analysis for components of the groups is consistent with the Global Industry Classification Standard (GICS) classification and can also figure out features for newly developed industries. These results can provide potentially implications on characterizing inner dynamical structure of financial markets and making optimal investment tragedies.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2016;
originally announced May 2016.
