-
Applications of interpretable deep learning in neuroimaging: a comprehensive review
Authors:
Lindsay Munroe,
Mariana da Silva,
Faezeh Heidari,
Irina Grigorescu,
Simon Dahan,
Emma C. Robinson,
Maria Deprez,
Po-Wah So
Abstract:
Clinical adoption of deep learning models has been hindered, in part, because the black-box nature of neural networks leads to concerns regarding their trustworthiness and reliability. These concerns are particularly relevant in the field of neuroimaging due to the complex brain phenotypes and inter-subject heterogeneity often encountered. The challenge can be addressed by interpretable deep learn…
▽ More
Clinical adoption of deep learning models has been hindered, in part, because the black-box nature of neural networks leads to concerns regarding their trustworthiness and reliability. These concerns are particularly relevant in the field of neuroimaging due to the complex brain phenotypes and inter-subject heterogeneity often encountered. The challenge can be addressed by interpretable deep learning (iDL) methods that enable the visualisation and interpretation of the inner workings of deep learning models. This study systematically reviewed the literature on neuroimaging applications of iDL methods and critically analysed how iDL explanation properties were evaluated. Seventy-five studies were included, and ten categories of iDL methods were identified. We also reviewed five properties of iDL explanations that were analysed in the included studies: biological validity, robustness, continuity, selectivity, and downstream task performance. We found that the most popular iDL approaches used in the literature may be sub-optimal for neuroimaging data, and we discussed possible future directions for the field.
△ Less
Submitted 30 May, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Conditional Temporal Attention Networks for Neonatal Cortical Surface Reconstruction
Authors:
Qiang Ma,
Liu Li,
Vanessa Kyriakopoulou,
Joseph Hajnal,
Emma C. Robinson,
Bernhard Kainz,
Daniel Rueckert
Abstract:
Cortical surface reconstruction plays a fundamental role in modeling the rapid brain development during the perinatal period. In this work, we propose Conditional Temporal Attention Network (CoTAN), a fast end-to-end framework for diffeomorphic neonatal cortical surface reconstruction. CoTAN predicts multi-resolution stationary velocity fields (SVF) from neonatal brain magnetic resonance images (M…
▽ More
Cortical surface reconstruction plays a fundamental role in modeling the rapid brain development during the perinatal period. In this work, we propose Conditional Temporal Attention Network (CoTAN), a fast end-to-end framework for diffeomorphic neonatal cortical surface reconstruction. CoTAN predicts multi-resolution stationary velocity fields (SVF) from neonatal brain magnetic resonance images (MRI). Instead of integrating multiple SVFs, CoTAN introduces attention mechanisms to learn a conditional time-varying velocity field (CTVF) by computing the weighted sum of all SVFs at each integration step. The importance of each SVF, which is estimated by learned attention maps, is conditioned on the age of the neonates and varies with the time step of integration. The proposed CTVF defines a diffeomorphic surface deformation, which reduces mesh self-intersection errors effectively. It only requires 0.21 seconds to deform an initial template mesh to cortical white matter and pial surfaces for each brain hemisphere. CoTAN is validated on the Develo** Human Connectome Project (dHCP) dataset with 877 3D brain MR images acquired from preterm and term born neonates. Compared to state-of-the-art baselines, CoTAN achieves superior performance with only 0.12mm geometric error and 0.07% self-intersecting faces. The visualization of our attention maps illustrates that CoTAN indeed learns coarse-to-fine surface deformations automatically without intermediate supervision.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
The Multiscale Surface Vision Transformer
Authors:
Simon Dahan,
Logan Z. J. Williams,
Daniel Rueckert,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
Surface meshes are a favoured domain for representing structural and functional information on the human cortex, but their complex topology and geometry pose significant challenges for deep learning analysis. While Transformers have excelled as domain-agnostic architectures for sequence-to-sequence learning, the quadratic cost of the self-attention operation remains an obstacle for many dense pred…
▽ More
Surface meshes are a favoured domain for representing structural and functional information on the human cortex, but their complex topology and geometry pose significant challenges for deep learning analysis. While Transformers have excelled as domain-agnostic architectures for sequence-to-sequence learning, the quadratic cost of the self-attention operation remains an obstacle for many dense prediction tasks. Inspired by some of the latest advances in hierarchical modelling with vision transformers, we introduce the Multiscale Surface Vision Transformer (MS-SiT) as a backbone architecture for surface deep learning. The self-attention mechanism is applied within local-mesh-windows to allow for high-resolution sampling of the underlying data, while a shifted-window strategy improves the sharing of information between windows. Neighbouring patches are successively merged, allowing the MS-SiT to learn hierarchical representations suitable for any prediction task. Results demonstrate that the MS-SiT outperforms existing surface deep learning methods for neonatal phenoty** prediction tasks using the Develo** Human Connectome Project (dHCP) dataset. Furthermore, building the MS-SiT backbone into a U-shaped architecture for surface segmentation demonstrates competitive results on cortical parcellation using the UK Biobank (UKB) and manually-annotated MindBoggle datasets. Code and trained models are publicly available at https://github.com/metrics-lab/surface-vision-transformers.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2024; v1 submitted 21 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Surface Analysis with Vision Transformers
Authors:
Simon Dahan,
Logan Z. J. Williams,
Abdulah Fawaz,
Daniel Rueckert,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
The extension of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to non-Euclidean geometries has led to multiple frameworks for studying manifolds. Many of those methods have shown design limitations resulting in poor modelling of long-range associations, as the generalisation of convolutions to irregular surfaces is non-trivial. Recent state-of-the-art performance of Vision Transformers (ViTs) demonstrates…
▽ More
The extension of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to non-Euclidean geometries has led to multiple frameworks for studying manifolds. Many of those methods have shown design limitations resulting in poor modelling of long-range associations, as the generalisation of convolutions to irregular surfaces is non-trivial. Recent state-of-the-art performance of Vision Transformers (ViTs) demonstrates that a general-purpose architecture, which implements self-attention, could replace the local feature learning operations of CNNs. Motivated by the success of attention-modelling in computer vision, we extend ViTs to surfaces by reformulating the task of surface learning as a sequence-to-sequence problem and propose a patching mechanism for surface meshes. We validate the performance of the proposed Surface Vision Transformer (SiT) on two brain age prediction tasks in the develo** Human Connectome Project (dHCP) dataset and investigate the impact of pre-training on model performance. Experiments show that the SiT outperforms many surface CNNs, while indicating some evidence of general transformation invariance. Code available at https://github.com/metrics-lab/surface-vision-transformers
△ Less
Submitted 31 May, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Surface Vision Transformers: Flexible Attention-Based Modelling of Biomedical Surfaces
Authors:
Simon Dahan,
Hao Xu,
Logan Z. J. Williams,
Abdulah Fawaz,
Chunhui Yang,
Timothy S. Coalson,
Michelle C. Williams,
David E. Newby,
A. David Edwards,
Matthew F. Glasser,
Alistair A. Young,
Daniel Rueckert,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
Recent state-of-the-art performances of Vision Transformers (ViT) in computer vision tasks demonstrate that a general-purpose architecture, which implements long-range self-attention, could replace the local feature learning operations of convolutional neural networks. In this paper, we extend ViTs to surfaces by reformulating the task of surface learning as a sequence-to-sequence learning problem…
▽ More
Recent state-of-the-art performances of Vision Transformers (ViT) in computer vision tasks demonstrate that a general-purpose architecture, which implements long-range self-attention, could replace the local feature learning operations of convolutional neural networks. In this paper, we extend ViTs to surfaces by reformulating the task of surface learning as a sequence-to-sequence learning problem, by proposing patching mechanisms for general surface meshes. Sequences of patches are then processed by a transformer encoder and used for classification or regression. We validate our method on a range of different biomedical surface domains and tasks: brain age prediction in the develo** Human Connectome Project (dHCP), fluid intelligence prediction in the Human Connectome Project (HCP), and coronary artery calcium score classification using surfaces from the Scottish Computed Tomography of the Heart (SCOT-HEART) dataset, and investigate the impact of pretraining and data augmentation on model performance. Results suggest that Surface Vision Transformers (SiT) demonstrate consistent improvement over geometric deep learning methods for brain age and fluid intelligence prediction and achieve comparable performance on calcium score classification to standard metrics used in clinical practice. Furthermore, analysis of transformer attention maps offers clear and individualised predictions of the features driving each task. Code is available on Github: https://github.com/metrics-lab/surface-vision-transformers
△ Less
Submitted 7 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Surface Vision Transformers: Attention-Based Modelling applied to Cortical Analysis
Authors:
Simon Dahan,
Abdulah Fawaz,
Logan Z. J. Williams,
Chunhui Yang,
Timothy S. Coalson,
Matthew F. Glasser,
A. David Edwards,
Daniel Rueckert,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
The extension of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to non-Euclidean geometries has led to multiple frameworks for studying manifolds. Many of those methods have shown design limitations resulting in poor modelling of long-range associations, as the generalisation of convolutions to irregular surfaces is non-trivial. Motivated by the success of attention-modelling in computer vision, we translat…
▽ More
The extension of convolutional neural networks (CNNs) to non-Euclidean geometries has led to multiple frameworks for studying manifolds. Many of those methods have shown design limitations resulting in poor modelling of long-range associations, as the generalisation of convolutions to irregular surfaces is non-trivial. Motivated by the success of attention-modelling in computer vision, we translate convolution-free vision transformer approaches to surface data, to introduce a domain-agnostic architecture to study any surface data projected onto a spherical manifold. Here, surface patching is achieved by representing spherical data as a sequence of triangular patches, extracted from a subdivided icosphere. A transformer model encodes the sequence of patches via successive multi-head self-attention layers while preserving the sequence resolution. We validate the performance of the proposed Surface Vision Transformer (SiT) on the task of phenotype regression from cortical surface metrics derived from the Develo** Human Connectome Project (dHCP). Experiments show that the SiT generally outperforms surface CNNs, while performing comparably on registered and unregistered data. Analysis of transformer attention maps offers strong potential to characterise subtle cognitive developmental patterns.
△ Less
Submitted 30 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Improving Phenotype Prediction using Long-Range Spatio-Temporal Dynamics of Functional Connectivity
Authors:
Simon Dahan,
Logan Z. J. Williams,
Daniel Rueckert,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
The study of functional brain connectivity (FC) is important for understanding the underlying mechanisms of many psychiatric disorders. Many recent analyses adopt graph convolutional networks, to study non-linear interactions between functionally-correlated states. However, although patterns of brain activation are known to be hierarchically organised in both space and time, many methods have fail…
▽ More
The study of functional brain connectivity (FC) is important for understanding the underlying mechanisms of many psychiatric disorders. Many recent analyses adopt graph convolutional networks, to study non-linear interactions between functionally-correlated states. However, although patterns of brain activation are known to be hierarchically organised in both space and time, many methods have failed to extract powerful spatio-temporal features. To overcome those challenges, and improve understanding of long-range functional dynamics, we translate an approach, from the domain of skeleton-based action recognition, designed to model interactions across space and time. We evaluate this approach using the Human Connectome Project (HCP) dataset on sex classification and fluid intelligence prediction. To account for subject topographic variability of functional organisation, we modelled functional connectomes using multi-resolution dual-regressed (subject-specific) ICA nodes. Results show a prediction accuracy of 94.4% for sex classification (an increase of 6.2% compared to other methods), and an improvement of correlation with fluid intelligence of 0.325 vs 0.144, relative to a baseline model that encodes space and time separately. Results suggest that explicit encoding of spatio-temporal dynamics of brain functional activity may improve the precision with which behavioural and cognitive phenotypes may be predicted in the future.
△ Less
Submitted 7 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Distinguishing Healthy Ageing from Dementia: a Biomechanical Simulation of Brain Atrophy using Deep Networks
Authors:
Mariana Da Silva,
Carole H. Sudre,
Kara Garcia,
Cher Bass,
M. Jorge Cardoso,
Emma C. Robinson
Abstract:
Biomechanical modeling of tissue deformation can be used to simulate different scenarios of longitudinal brain evolution. In this work,we present a deep learning framework for hyper-elastic strain modelling of brain atrophy, during healthy ageing and in Alzheimer's Disease. The framework directly models the effects of age, disease status, and scan interval to regress regional patterns of atrophy,…
▽ More
Biomechanical modeling of tissue deformation can be used to simulate different scenarios of longitudinal brain evolution. In this work,we present a deep learning framework for hyper-elastic strain modelling of brain atrophy, during healthy ageing and in Alzheimer's Disease. The framework directly models the effects of age, disease status, and scan interval to regress regional patterns of atrophy, from which a strain-based model estimates deformations. This model is trained and validated using 3D structural magnetic resonance imaging data from the ADNI cohort. Results show that the framework can estimate realistic deformations, following the known course of Alzheimer's disease, that clearly differentiate between healthy and demented patterns of ageing. This suggests the framework has potential to be incorporated into explainable models of disease, for the exploration of interventions and counterfactual examples.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
