Reducing the noise effects in Logan graphic analysis for PET receptor measurements
Authors:
Hongbin Guo,
Kewei Chen,
Rosemary A Renaut,
Eric M Reiman
Abstract:
Logan's graphical analysis (LGA) is a widely-used approach for quantification of biochemical and physiological processes from Positron emission tomography (PET) image data. A well-noted problem associated with the LGA method is the bias in the estimated parameters. We recently systematically evaluated the bias associated with the linear model approximation and developed an alternative to minimiz…
▽ More
Logan's graphical analysis (LGA) is a widely-used approach for quantification of biochemical and physiological processes from Positron emission tomography (PET) image data. A well-noted problem associated with the LGA method is the bias in the estimated parameters. We recently systematically evaluated the bias associated with the linear model approximation and developed an alternative to minimize the bias due to model error. In this study, we examined the noise structure in the equations defining linear quantification methods, including LGA. The noise structure conflicts with the conditions given by the Gauss-Markov theorem for the least squares (LS) solution to generate the best linear unbiased estimator. By carefully taking care of the data error structure, we propose to use structured total least squares (STLS) to obtain the solution using a one-dimensional optimization problem. Simulations of PET data for [11C] benzothiazole-aniline (Pittsburgh Compound-B [PIB]) show that the proposed method significantly reduces the bias. We conclude that the bias associated with noise is primarily due to the unusual structure of he correlated noise and it can be reduced with the proposed STLS method.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.
Model Error Correction for Linear Methods of Reversible Radioligand Binding Measurements in PET Studies
Authors:
Hongbin Guo,
Rosemary A Renaut,
Kewei Chen,
Eric M Reiman
Abstract:
Graphical analysis methods are widely used in positron emission tomography quantification because of their simplicity and model independence. But they may, particularly for reversible kinetics, lead to bias in the estimated parameters. The source of the bias is commonly attributed to noise in the data. Assuming a two-tissue compartmental model, we investigate the bias that originates from model…
▽ More
Graphical analysis methods are widely used in positron emission tomography quantification because of their simplicity and model independence. But they may, particularly for reversible kinetics, lead to bias in the estimated parameters. The source of the bias is commonly attributed to noise in the data. Assuming a two-tissue compartmental model, we investigate the bias that originates from model error. This bias is an intrinsic property of the simplified linear models used for limited scan durations, and it is exaggerated by random noise and numerical quadrature error. Conditions are derived under which Logan's graphical method either over- or under-estimates the distribution volume in the noise-free case. The bias caused by model error is quantified analytically. The presented analysis shows that the bias of graphical methods is inversely proportional to the dissociation rate. Furthermore, visual examination of the linearity of the Logan plot is not sufficient for guaranteeing that equilibrium has been reached. A new model which retains the elegant properties of graphical analysis methods is presented, along with a numerical algorithm for its solution. We perform simulations with the fibrillar amyloid-beta radioligand [11C] benzothiazole-aniline using published data from the University of Pittsburgh and Rotterdam groups. The results show that the proposed method significantly reduces the bias due to model error. Moreover, the results for data acquired over a 70 minutes scan duration are at least as good as those obtained using existing methods for data acquired over a 90 minutes scan duration.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2009;
originally announced April 2009.