-
Calculation of Epidemic First Passage and Peak Time Probability Distributions
Authors:
Jacob Curran-Sebastian,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Ian Hall,
Thomas House
Abstract:
Understanding the timing of the peak of a disease outbreak forms an important part of epidemic forecasting. In many cases, such information is essential for planning increased hospital bed demand and for designing of public health interventions. The time taken for an outbreak to become large is inherently stochastic, and therefore uncertain, but after a sufficient number of infections has been rea…
▽ More
Understanding the timing of the peak of a disease outbreak forms an important part of epidemic forecasting. In many cases, such information is essential for planning increased hospital bed demand and for designing of public health interventions. The time taken for an outbreak to become large is inherently stochastic, and therefore uncertain, but after a sufficient number of infections has been reached the subsequent dynamics can be modelled accurately using ordinary differential equations. Here, we present analytical and numerical methods for approximating the time at which a stochastic model of a disease outbreak reaches a large number of cases and for quantifying the uncertainty arising from demographic stochasticity around that time. We then project this uncertainty forwards in time using an ordinary differential equation model in order to obtain a distribution for the peak timing of the epidemic that agrees closely with large simulations but that, for error tolerances relevant to most realistic applications, requires a fraction of the computational cost of full Monte Carlo approaches.
△ Less
Submitted 23 November, 2023; v1 submitted 17 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Novel methods for estimating the instantaneous and overall COVID-19 case fatality risk among care home residents in England
Authors:
Christopher E. Overton,
Luke Webb,
Uma Datta,
Mike Fursman,
Jo Hardstaff,
Iina Hiironen,
Karthik Paranthaman,
Heather Riley,
James Sedgwick,
Julia Verne,
Steve Willner,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Ian Hall
Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic has had high mortality rates in the elderly and frail worldwide, particularly in care homes. This is driven by the difficulty of isolating care homes from the wider community, the large population sizes within care facilities (relative to typical households), and the age/frailty of the residents. To quantify the mortality risk posed by disease, the case fatality risk (CFR) is…
▽ More
The COVID-19 pandemic has had high mortality rates in the elderly and frail worldwide, particularly in care homes. This is driven by the difficulty of isolating care homes from the wider community, the large population sizes within care facilities (relative to typical households), and the age/frailty of the residents. To quantify the mortality risk posed by disease, the case fatality risk (CFR) is an important tool. This quantifies the proportion of cases that result in death. Throughout the pandemic, CFR amongst care home residents in England has been monitored closely. To estimate CFR, we apply both novel and existing methods to data on deaths in care homes, collected by Public Health England and the Care Quality Commission. We compare these different methods, evaluating their relative strengths and weaknesses. Using these methods, we estimate temporal trends in the instantaneous CFR (at both daily and weekly resolutions) and the overall CFR across the whole of England, and dis-aggregated at regional level. We also investigate how the CFR varies based on age and on the type of care required, dis-aggregating by whether care homes include nursing staff and by age of residents. This work has contributed to the summary of measures used for monitoring the UK epidemic.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
A computational framework for modelling infectious disease policy based on age and household structure with applications to the COVID-19 pandemic
Authors:
Joe Hilton,
Heather Riley,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Rabia Aziza,
Samuel P. C. Brand,
Ivy K. Kombe,
John Ojal,
Andrea Parisi,
Matt J. Keeling,
D. James Nokes,
Robert Manson-Sawko,
Thomas House
Abstract:
The widespread, and in many countries unprecedented, use of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) during the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for mathematical models which can estimate the impact of these measures while accounting for the highly heterogeneous risk profile of COVID-19. Models accounting either for age structure or the household structure necessary to explicitly model ma…
▽ More
The widespread, and in many countries unprecedented, use of non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs) during the COVID-19 pandemic has highlighted the need for mathematical models which can estimate the impact of these measures while accounting for the highly heterogeneous risk profile of COVID-19. Models accounting either for age structure or the household structure necessary to explicitly model many NPIs are commonly used in infectious disease modelling, but models incorporating both levels of structure present substantial computational and mathematical challenges due to their high dimensionality. Here we present a modelling framework for the spread of an epidemic that includes explicit representation of age structure and household structure. Our model is formulated in terms of tractable systems of ordinary differential equations for which we provide an open-source Python implementation. Such tractability leads to significant benefits for model calibration, exhaustive evaluation of possible parameter values, and interpretability of results. We demonstrate the flexibility of our model through four policy case studies, where we quantify the likely benefits of the following measures which were either considered or implemented in the UK during the current COVID-19 pandemic: control of within- and between-household mixing through NPIs; formation of support bubbles during lockdown periods; out-of-household isolation (OOHI); and temporary relaxation of NPIs during holiday periods. Our ordinary differential equation formulation and associated analysis demonstrate that multiple dimensions of risk stratification and social structure can be incorporated into infectious disease models without sacrificing mathematical tractability. This model and its software implementation expand the range of tools available to infectious disease policy analysts.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2022; v1 submitted 14 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
EpiBeds: Data informed modelling of the COVID-19 hospital burden in England
Authors:
Christopher E. Overton,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Helena B. Stage,
Francesca Scarabel,
Joshua Burton,
Christophe Fraser,
Ian Hall,
Thomas A. House,
Chris Jewell,
Anel Nurtay,
Filippo Pagani,
Katrina A. Lythgoe
Abstract:
The first year of the COVID-19 pandemic put considerable strain on the national healthcare system in England. In order to predict the effect of the local epidemic on hospital capacity in England, we used a variety of data streams to inform the construction and parameterisation of a hospital progression model, which was coupled to a model of the generalised epidemic. We named this model EpiBeds. Da…
▽ More
The first year of the COVID-19 pandemic put considerable strain on the national healthcare system in England. In order to predict the effect of the local epidemic on hospital capacity in England, we used a variety of data streams to inform the construction and parameterisation of a hospital progression model, which was coupled to a model of the generalised epidemic. We named this model EpiBeds. Data from a partially complete patient-pathway line-list was used to provide initial estimates of the mean duration that individuals spend in the different hospital compartments. We then fitted EpiBeds using complete data on hospital occupancy and hospital deaths, enabling estimation of the proportion of individuals that follow different clinical pathways, and the reproduction number of the generalised epidemic. The construction of EpiBeds makes it straightforward to adapt to different patient pathways and settings beyond England. As part of the UK response to the pandemic, EpiBeds has provided weekly forecasts to the NHS for hospital bed occupancy and admissions in England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Total Effect Analysis of Vaccination on Household Transmission in the Office for National Statistics COVID-19 Infection Survey
Authors:
Thomas House,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Emma Pritchard,
Angela R. McLean,
A. Sarah Walker
Abstract:
We investigate the distribution of numbers of secondary cases in households in the Office for National Statistics COVID-19 Infection Survey (ONS CIS), stratified by timing of vaccination and infection in the households. This shows a total effect of a statistically significant approximate halving of the secondary attack rate in households following vaccination.
We investigate the distribution of numbers of secondary cases in households in the Office for National Statistics COVID-19 Infection Survey (ONS CIS), stratified by timing of vaccination and infection in the households. This shows a total effect of a statistically significant approximate halving of the secondary attack rate in households following vaccination.
△ Less
Submitted 14 July, 2021;
originally announced July 2021.
-
Inferring Risks of Coronavirus Transmission from Community Household Data
Authors:
Thomas House,
Heather Riley,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Koen B. Pouwels,
Sebastian Bacon,
Arturas Eidukas,
Kaveh Jahanshahi,
Rosalind M. Eggo,
A. Sarah Walker
Abstract:
The response of many governments to the COVID-19 pandemic has involved measures to control within- and between-household transmission, providing motivation to improve understanding of the absolute and relative risks in these contexts. Here, we perform exploratory, residual-based, and transmission-dynamic household analysis of the Office for National Statistics (ONS) COVID-19 Infection Survey (CIS)…
▽ More
The response of many governments to the COVID-19 pandemic has involved measures to control within- and between-household transmission, providing motivation to improve understanding of the absolute and relative risks in these contexts. Here, we perform exploratory, residual-based, and transmission-dynamic household analysis of the Office for National Statistics (ONS) COVID-19 Infection Survey (CIS) data from 26 April 2020 to 15 July 2021 in England. This provides evidence for: (i) temporally varying rates of introduction of infection into households broadly following the trajectory of the overall epidemic and vaccination programme; (ii) Susceptible-Infectious Transmission Probabilities (SITPs) of within-household transmission in the 15-35% range; (iii) the emergence of the Alpha and Delta variants, with the former being around 50% more infectious than wildtype and 35% less infectious than Delta within households; (iv) significantly (in the range 25-300%) more risk of bringing infection into the household for workers in patient-facing roles pre-vaccine; (v) increased risk for secondary school-age children of bringing the infection into the household when schools are open; (vi) increased risk for primary school-age children of bringing the infection into the household when schools were open since the emergence of new variants.
△ Less
Submitted 2 December, 2021; v1 submitted 9 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Shut and re-open: the role of schools in the spread of COVID-19 in Europe
Authors:
Helena B. Stage,
Joseph Shingleton,
Sanmitra Ghosh,
Francesca Scarabel,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Thomas Finnie
Abstract:
We investigate the effect of school closure and subsequent reopening on the transmission of COVID-19, by considering Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and German states as case studies. By comparing the growth rates in daily hospitalisations or confirmed cases under different interventions, we provide evidence that the effect of school closure is visible as a reduction in the growth rate approximately 9 da…
▽ More
We investigate the effect of school closure and subsequent reopening on the transmission of COVID-19, by considering Denmark, Norway, Sweden, and German states as case studies. By comparing the growth rates in daily hospitalisations or confirmed cases under different interventions, we provide evidence that the effect of school closure is visible as a reduction in the growth rate approximately 9 days after implementation. Limited school attendance, such as older students sitting exams or the partial return of younger year groups, does not appear to significantly affect community transmission. A large-scale reopening of schools while controlling or suppressing the epidemic appears feasible in countries such as Denmark or Norway, where community transmission is generally low. However, school reopening can contribute to significant increases in the growth rate in countries like Germany, where community transmission is relatively high. Our findings underscore the need for a cautious evaluation of reopening strategies that ensure low classroom occupancy and a solid infrastructure to quickly identify and isolate new infections.
△ Less
Submitted 26 April, 2021; v1 submitted 24 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Key Questions for Modelling COVID-19 Exit Strategies
Authors:
Robin N Thompson,
T Deirdre Hollingsworth,
Valerie Isham,
Daniel Arribas-Bel,
Ben Ashby,
Tom Britton,
Peter Challoner,
Lauren H K Chappell,
Hannah Clapham,
Nik J Cunniffe,
A Philip Dawid,
Christl A Donnelly,
Rosalind Eggo,
Sebastian Funk,
Nigel Gilbert,
Julia R Gog,
Paul Glendinning,
William S Hart,
Hans Heesterbeek,
Thomas House,
Matt Keeling,
Istvan Z Kiss,
Mirjam Kretzschmar,
Alun L Lloyd,
Emma S McBryde
, et al. (18 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Combinations of intense non-pharmaceutical interventions ('lockdowns') were introduced in countries worldwide to reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Many governments have begun to implement lockdown exit strategies that allow restrictions to be relaxed while attempting to control the risk of a surge in cases. Mathematical modelling has played a central role in guiding interventions, but the challenge…
▽ More
Combinations of intense non-pharmaceutical interventions ('lockdowns') were introduced in countries worldwide to reduce SARS-CoV-2 transmission. Many governments have begun to implement lockdown exit strategies that allow restrictions to be relaxed while attempting to control the risk of a surge in cases. Mathematical modelling has played a central role in guiding interventions, but the challenge of designing optimal exit strategies in the face of ongoing transmission is unprecedented. Here, we report discussions from the Isaac Newton Institute 'Models for an exit strategy' workshop (11-15 May 2020). A diverse community of modellers who are providing evidence to governments worldwide were asked to identify the main questions that, if answered, will allow for more accurate predictions of the effects of different exit strategies. Based on these questions, we propose a roadmap to facilitate the development of reliable models to guide exit strategies. The roadmap requires a global collaborative effort from the scientific community and policy-makers, and is made up of three parts: i) improve estimation of key epidemiological parameters; ii) understand sources of heterogeneity in populations; iii) focus on requirements for data collection, particularly in Low-to-Middle-Income countries. This will provide important information for planning exit strategies that balance socio-economic benefits with public health.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2020; v1 submitted 21 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Using statistics and mathematical modelling to understand infectious disease outbreaks: COVID-19 as an example
Authors:
Christopher E. Overton,
Helena B. Stage,
Shazaad Ahmad,
Jacob Curran-Sebastian,
Paul Dark,
Rajenki Das,
Elizabeth Fearon,
Timothy Felton,
Martyn Fyles,
Nick Gent,
Ian Hall,
Thomas House,
Hugo Lewkowicz,
Xiaoxi Pang,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Robert Sawko,
Andrew Ustianowski,
Bindu Vekaria,
Luke Webb
Abstract:
During an infectious disease outbreak, biases in the data and complexities of the underlying dynamics pose significant challenges in mathematically modelling the outbreak and designing policy. Motivated by the ongoing response to COVID-19, we provide a toolkit of statistical and mathematical models beyond the simple SIR-type differential equation models for analysing the early stages of an outbrea…
▽ More
During an infectious disease outbreak, biases in the data and complexities of the underlying dynamics pose significant challenges in mathematically modelling the outbreak and designing policy. Motivated by the ongoing response to COVID-19, we provide a toolkit of statistical and mathematical models beyond the simple SIR-type differential equation models for analysing the early stages of an outbreak and assessing interventions. In particular, we focus on parameter estimation in the presence of known biases in the data, and the effect of non-pharmaceutical interventions in enclosed subpopulations, such as households and care homes. We illustrate these methods by applying them to the COVID-19 pandemic.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Challenges in control of Covid-19: short doubling time and long delay to effect of interventions
Authors:
Lorenzo Pellis,
Francesca Scarabel,
Helena B. Stage,
Christopher E. Overton,
Lauren H. K. Chappell,
Katrina A. Lythgoe,
Elizabeth Fearon,
Emma Bennett,
Jacob Curran-Sebastian,
Rajenki Das,
Martyn Fyles,
Hugo Lewkowicz,
Xiaoxi Pang,
Bindu Vekaria,
Luke Webb,
Thomas House,
Ian Hall
Abstract:
Early assessments of the spreading rate of COVID-19 were subject to significant uncertainty, as expected with limited data and difficulties in case ascertainment, but more reliable inferences can now be made. Here, we estimate from European data that COVID-19 cases are expected to double initially every three days, until social distancing interventions slow this growth, and that the impact of such…
▽ More
Early assessments of the spreading rate of COVID-19 were subject to significant uncertainty, as expected with limited data and difficulties in case ascertainment, but more reliable inferences can now be made. Here, we estimate from European data that COVID-19 cases are expected to double initially every three days, until social distancing interventions slow this growth, and that the impact of such measures is typically only seen nine days - i.e. three doubling times - after their implementation. We argue that such temporal patterns are more critical than precise estimates of the basic reproduction number for initiating interventions. This observation has particular implications for the low- and middle-income countries currently in the early stages of their local epidemics.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Exact and approximate moment closures for non-Markovian network epidemics
Authors:
Lorenzo Pellis,
Thomas House,
Matt J. Keeling
Abstract:
Moment-closure techniques are commonly used to generate low-dimensional deterministic models to approximate the average dynamics of stochastic systems on networks. The quality of such closures is usually difficult to asses and the relationship between model assumptions and closure accuracy are often difficult, if not impossible, to quantify. Here we carefully examine some commonly used moment clos…
▽ More
Moment-closure techniques are commonly used to generate low-dimensional deterministic models to approximate the average dynamics of stochastic systems on networks. The quality of such closures is usually difficult to asses and the relationship between model assumptions and closure accuracy are often difficult, if not impossible, to quantify. Here we carefully examine some commonly used moment closures, in particular a new one based on the concept of maximum entropy, for approximating the spread of epidemics on networks by reconstructing the probability distributions over triplets based on those over pairs. We consider various models (SI, SIR, SEIR and Reed-Frost-type) under Markovian and non-Markovian assumption characterising the latent and infectious periods. We initially study two special networks, namely the open triplet and closed triangle, for which we can obtain analytical results. We then explore numerically the exactness of moment closures for a wide range of larger motifs, thus gaining understanding of the factors that introduce errors in the approximations, in particular the presence of a random duration of the infectious period and the presence of overlap** triangles in a network. We also derive a simpler and more intuitive proof than previously available concerning the known result that pair-based moment closure is exact for the Markovian SIR model on tree-like networks under pure initial conditions. We also extend such a result to all infectious models, Markovian and non-Markovian, in which susceptibles escape infection independently from each infected neighbour and for which infectives cannot regain susceptible status, provided the network is tree-like and initial conditions are pure. This works represent a valuable step in deepening understanding of the assumptions behind moment closure approximations and for putting them on a more rigorous mathematical footing.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Real-time growth rate for general stochastic SIR epidemics on unclustered networks
Authors:
Lorenzo Pellis,
Simon E. F. Spencer,
Thomas House
Abstract:
Networks have become an important tool for infectious disease epidemiology. Most previous theoretical studies of transmission network models have either considered simple Markovian dynamics at the individual level, or have focused on the invasion threshold and final outcome of the epidemic. Here, we provide a general theory for early real-time behaviour of epidemics on large configuration model ne…
▽ More
Networks have become an important tool for infectious disease epidemiology. Most previous theoretical studies of transmission network models have either considered simple Markovian dynamics at the individual level, or have focused on the invasion threshold and final outcome of the epidemic. Here, we provide a general theory for early real-time behaviour of epidemics on large configuration model networks (i.e. static and locally unclustered), in particular focusing on the computation of the Malthusian parameter that describes the early exponential epidemic growth. Analytical, numerical and Monte-Carlo methods under a wide variety of Markovian and non-Markovian assumptions about the infectivity profile are presented. Numerous examples provide explicit quantification of the impact of the network structure on the temporal dynamics of the spread of infection and provide a benchmark for validating results of large scale simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 20 April, 2015; v1 submitted 20 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
Reproduction numbers for epidemic models with households and other social structures II: comparisons and implications for vaccination
Authors:
Frank Ball,
Lorenzo Pellis,
Pieter Trapman
Abstract:
In this paper we consider epidemic models of directly transmissible SIR (susceptible $\to$ infective $\to$ recovered) and SEIR (with an additional latent class) infections in fully-susceptible populations with a social structure, consisting either of households or of households and workplaces. We review most reproduction numbers defined in the literature for these models, including the basic repro…
▽ More
In this paper we consider epidemic models of directly transmissible SIR (susceptible $\to$ infective $\to$ recovered) and SEIR (with an additional latent class) infections in fully-susceptible populations with a social structure, consisting either of households or of households and workplaces. We review most reproduction numbers defined in the literature for these models, including the basic reproduction number $R_0$ introduced in the companion paper of this, for which we provide a simpler, more elegant derivation. Extending previous work, we provide a complete overview of the inequalities among these reproduction numbers and resolve some open questions. Special focus is put on the exponential-growth-associated reproduction number $R_r$, which is loosely defined as the estimate of $R_0$ based on the observed exponential growth of an emerging epidemic obtained when the social structure is ignored. We show that for the vast majority of the models considered in the literature $R_r \geq R_0$ when $R_0 \ge 1$ and $R_r \leq R_0$ when $R_0 \le 1$. We show that, in contrast to models without social structure, vaccination of a fraction $1-1/R_0$ of the population, chosen uniformly at random, with a perfect vaccine is usually insufficient to prevent large epidemics. In addition, we provide significantly sharper bounds than the existing ones for bracketing the critical vaccination coverage between two analytically tractable quantities, which we illustrate by means of extensive numerical examples.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2015; v1 submitted 16 October, 2014;
originally announced October 2014.