-
Spurious reconstruction from brain activity
Authors:
Ken Shirakawa,
Yoshihiro Nagano,
Misato Tanaka,
Shuntaro C. Aoki,
Kei Majima,
Yusuke Muraki,
Yukiyasu Kamitani
Abstract:
Advances in brain decoding, particularly visual image reconstruction, have sparked discussions about the societal implications and ethical considerations of neurotechnology. As these methods aim to recover visual experiences from brain activity and achieve prediction beyond training samples (zero-shot prediction), it is crucial to assess their capabilities and limitations to inform public expectat…
▽ More
Advances in brain decoding, particularly visual image reconstruction, have sparked discussions about the societal implications and ethical considerations of neurotechnology. As these methods aim to recover visual experiences from brain activity and achieve prediction beyond training samples (zero-shot prediction), it is crucial to assess their capabilities and limitations to inform public expectations and regulations. Our case study of recent text-guided reconstruction methods, which leverage a large-scale dataset (NSD) and text-to-image diffusion models, reveals limitations in their generalizability. We found decreased performance when applying these methods to a different dataset designed to prevent category overlaps between training and test sets. UMAP visualization of the text features with NSD images showed limited diversity of semantic and visual clusters, with overlap between training and test sets. Formal analysis and simulations demonstrated that clustered training samples can lead to "output dimension collapse," restricting predictable output feature dimensions. Diversifying the training set improved generalizability. However, text features alone are insufficient for map** to the visual space. We argue that recent photo-like reconstructions may primarily be a blend of classification into trained categories and generation of inauthentic images through text-to-image diffusion (hallucination). Diverse datasets and compositional representations spanning the image space are essential for genuine zero-shot prediction. Interdisciplinary discussions grounded in understanding the current capabilities and limitations, as well as ethical considerations, of the technology are crucial for its responsible development.
△ Less
Submitted 16 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Inter-individual and inter-site neural code conversion and image reconstruction without shared stimuli
Authors:
Haibao Wang,
Jun Kai Ho,
Fan L. Cheng,
Shuntaro C. Aoki,
Yusuke Muraki,
Misato Tanaka,
Yukiyasu Kamitani
Abstract:
The human brain demonstrates substantial inter-individual variability in fine-grained functional topography, posing challenges in identifying common neural representations across individuals. Functional alignment has the potential to harmonize these individual differences. However, it typically requires an identical set of stimuli presented to different individuals, which is often unavailable. To…
▽ More
The human brain demonstrates substantial inter-individual variability in fine-grained functional topography, posing challenges in identifying common neural representations across individuals. Functional alignment has the potential to harmonize these individual differences. However, it typically requires an identical set of stimuli presented to different individuals, which is often unavailable. To address this, we propose a content loss-based neural code converter, designed to convert brain activity from one subject to another representing the same content. The converter is optimized so that the source subject's converted brain activity is decoded into a latent image representation that closely resembles that of the stimulus given to the source subject. We show that converters optimized using hierarchical image representations achieve conversion accuracy comparable to those optimized by paired brain activity as in conventional methods. The brain activity converted from a different individual and even from a different site sharing no stimuli produced reconstructions that approached the quality of within-individual reconstructions. The converted brain activity had a generalizable representation that can be read out by different decoding schemes. The converter required much fewer training samples than that typically required for decoder training to produce recognizable reconstructions. These results demonstrate that our method can effectively combine image representations to convert brain activity across individuals without the need for shared stimuli, providing a promising tool for flexibly aligning data from complex cognitive tasks and a basis for brain-to-brain communication.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Voluntary control of semantic neural representations by imagery with conflicting visual stimulation
Authors:
Ryohei Fukuma,
Takufumi Yanagisawa,
Shinji Nishimoto,
Hidenori Sugano,
Kentaro Tamura,
Shota Yamamoto,
Yasushi Iimura,
Yuya Fujita,
Satoru Oshino,
Naoki Tani,
Naoko Koide-Majima,
Yukiyasu Kamitani,
Haruhiko Kishima
Abstract:
Neural representations of visual perception are affected by mental imagery and attention. Although attention is known to modulate neural representations, it is unknown how imagery changes neural representations when imagined and perceived images semantically conflict. We hypothesized that imagining an image would activate a neural representation during its perception even while watching a conflict…
▽ More
Neural representations of visual perception are affected by mental imagery and attention. Although attention is known to modulate neural representations, it is unknown how imagery changes neural representations when imagined and perceived images semantically conflict. We hypothesized that imagining an image would activate a neural representation during its perception even while watching a conflicting image. To test this hypothesis, we developed a closed-loop system to show images inferred from electrocorticograms using a visual semantic space. The successful control of the feedback images demonstrated that the semantic vector inferred from electrocorticograms became closer to the vector of the imagined category, even while watching images from different categories. Moreover, modulation of the inferred vectors by mental imagery depended on both the image category and time from the initiation of imagery. The closed-loop control of the semantic vectors revealed an asymmetrical interaction between visual perception and imagery.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Hierarchical Neural Representation of Dreamed Objects Revealed by Brain Decoding with Deep Neural Network Features
Authors:
Tomoyasu Horikawa,
Yukiyasu Kamitani
Abstract:
Dreaming is generally thought to be generated by spontaneous brain activity during sleep with patterns common to waking experience. This view is supported by a recent study demonstrating that dreamed objects can be predicted from brain activity during sleep using statistical decoders trained with stimulus-induced brain activity. However, it remains unclear whether and how visual image features ass…
▽ More
Dreaming is generally thought to be generated by spontaneous brain activity during sleep with patterns common to waking experience. This view is supported by a recent study demonstrating that dreamed objects can be predicted from brain activity during sleep using statistical decoders trained with stimulus-induced brain activity. However, it remains unclear whether and how visual image features associated with dreamed objects are represented in the brain. In this study, we used a deep neural network (DNN) model for object recognition as a proxy for hierarchical visual feature representation, and DNN features for dreamed objects were analyzed with brain decoding of fMRI data collected during dreaming. The decoders were first trained with stimulus-induced brain activity labeled with the feature values of the stimulus image from multiple DNN layers. The decoders were then used to decode DNN features from the dream fMRI data, and the decoded features were compared with the averaged features of each object category calculated from a large-scale image database. We found that the feature values decoded from the dream fMRI data positively correlated with those associated with dreamed object categories at mid- to high-level DNN layers. Using the decoded features, the dreamed object category could be identified at above-chance levels by matching them to the averaged features for candidate categories. The results suggest that dreaming recruits hierarchical visual feature representations associated with objects, which may support phenomenal aspects of dream experience.
△ Less
Submitted 23 January, 2017; v1 submitted 29 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
Generic decoding of seen and imagined objects using hierarchical visual features
Authors:
Tomoyasu Horikawa,
Yukiyasu Kamitani
Abstract:
Object recognition is a key function in both human and machine vision. While recent studies have achieved fMRI decoding of seen and imagined contents, the prediction is limited to training examples. We present a decoding approach for arbitrary objects, using the machine vision principle that an object category is represented by a set of features rendered invariant through hierarchical processing.…
▽ More
Object recognition is a key function in both human and machine vision. While recent studies have achieved fMRI decoding of seen and imagined contents, the prediction is limited to training examples. We present a decoding approach for arbitrary objects, using the machine vision principle that an object category is represented by a set of features rendered invariant through hierarchical processing. We show that visual features including those from a convolutional neural network can be predicted from fMRI patterns and that greater accuracy is achieved for low/high-level features with lower/higher-level visual areas, respectively. Predicted features are used to identify seen/imagined object categories (extending beyond decoder training) from a set of computed features for numerous object images. Furthermore, the decoding of imagined objects reveals progressive recruitment of higher to lower visual representations. Our results demonstrate a homology between human and machine vision and its utility for brain-based information retrieval.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2016; v1 submitted 21 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
