-
Network reduction and absence of Hopf Bifurcations in dual phosphorylation networks with three Intermediates
Authors:
Elisenda Feliu,
Nidhi Kaihnsa
Abstract:
Phosphorylation networks, representing the mechanisms by which proteins are phosphorylated at one or multiple sites, are ubiquitous in cell signalling and display rich dynamics such as unlimited multistability. Dual-site phosphorylation networks are known to exhibit oscillations in the form of periodic trajectories, when phosphorylation and dephosphorylation occurs as a mixed mechanism: phosphoryl…
▽ More
Phosphorylation networks, representing the mechanisms by which proteins are phosphorylated at one or multiple sites, are ubiquitous in cell signalling and display rich dynamics such as unlimited multistability. Dual-site phosphorylation networks are known to exhibit oscillations in the form of periodic trajectories, when phosphorylation and dephosphorylation occurs as a mixed mechanism: phosphorylation of the two sites requires one encounter of the kinase, while dephosphorylation of the two sites requires two encounters with the phosphatase. A still open question is whether a mechanism requiring two encounters for both phosphorylation and dephosphorylation also admits oscillations. In this work we provide evidence in favor of the absence of oscillations of this network by precluding Hopf bifurcations in any reduced network comprising three out of its four intermediate protein complexes. Our argument relies on a novel network reduction step that preserves the absence of Hopf bifurcations, and on a detailed analysis of the semi-algebraic conditions precluding Hopf bifurcations obtained from Hurwitz determinants of the characteristic polynomial of the Jacobian of the system. We conjecture that the removal of certain reverse reactions appearing in Michaelis-Menten-type mechanisms does not have an impact on the presence or absence of Hopf bifurcations. We prove an implication of the conjecture under certain favorable scenarios and support the conjecture with additional example-based evidence.
△ Less
Submitted 25 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Connectivity of Parameter Regions of Multistationarity for Multisite Phosphorylation Networks
Authors:
Nidhi Kaihnsa,
Máté L. Telek
Abstract:
The parameter region of multistationarity of a reaction network contains all the parameters for which the associated dynamical system exhibits multiple steady states. Describing this region is challenging and remains an active area of research. In this paper, we concentrate on two biologically relevant families of reaction networks that model multisite phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of a su…
▽ More
The parameter region of multistationarity of a reaction network contains all the parameters for which the associated dynamical system exhibits multiple steady states. Describing this region is challenging and remains an active area of research. In this paper, we concentrate on two biologically relevant families of reaction networks that model multisite phosphorylation and dephosphorylation of a substrate at $n$ sites. For small values of $n$, it had previously been shown that the parameter region of multistationarity is connected. Here, we extend these results and provide a proof that applies to all values of $n$. Our techniques are based on the study of the critical polynomial associated with these reaction networks together with polyhedral geometric conditions of the signed support of this polynomial.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Absolute Concentration Robustness and Multistationarity in Reaction Networks: Conditions for Coexistence
Authors:
Nidhi Kaihnsa,
Tung Nguyen,
Anne Shiu
Abstract:
Many reaction networks arising in applications are multistationary, that is, they have the capacity for more than one steady state; while some networks exhibit absolute concentration robustness (ACR), which means that some species concentration is the same at all steady states. Both multistationarity and ACR are significant in biological settings, but only recently has attention focused on the pos…
▽ More
Many reaction networks arising in applications are multistationary, that is, they have the capacity for more than one steady state; while some networks exhibit absolute concentration robustness (ACR), which means that some species concentration is the same at all steady states. Both multistationarity and ACR are significant in biological settings, but only recently has attention focused on the possibility for these properties to coexist. Our main result states that such coexistence in at-most-bimolecular networks (which encompass most networks arising in biology) requires at least $3$ species, $5$ complexes, and $3$ reactions. We prove additional bounds on the number of reactions for general networks based on the number of linear conservation laws. Finally, we prove that, outside of a few exceptional cases, ACR is equivalent to non-multistationarity for bimolecular networks that are small (more precisely, one-dimensional or up to two species). Our proofs involve analyses of systems of sparse polynomials, and we also use classical results from chemical reaction network theory.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Prevalence of multistationarity and absolute concentration robustness in reaction networks
Authors:
Badal Joshi,
Nidhi Kaihnsa,
Tung D. Nguyen,
Anne Shiu
Abstract:
For reaction networks arising in systems biology, the capacity for two or more steady states, that is, multistationarity, is an important property that underlies biochemical switches. Another property receiving much attention recently is absolute concentration robustness (ACR), which means that some species concentration is the same at all positive steady states. In this work, we investigate the p…
▽ More
For reaction networks arising in systems biology, the capacity for two or more steady states, that is, multistationarity, is an important property that underlies biochemical switches. Another property receiving much attention recently is absolute concentration robustness (ACR), which means that some species concentration is the same at all positive steady states. In this work, we investigate the prevalence of each property while paying close attention to when the properties occur together. Specifically, we consider a stochastic block framework for generating random networks, and prove edge-probability thresholds at which - with high probability - multistationarity appears and ACR becomes rare. We also show that the small window in which both properties occur only appears in networks with many species. Taken together, our results confirm that, in random reversible networks, ACR and multistationarity together, or even ACR on its own, is highly atypical. Our proofs rely on two prior results, one pertaining to the prevalence of networks with deficiency zero, and the other "lifting" multistationarity from small networks to larger ones.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Parameter region for multistationarity in $n-$site phosphorylation networks
Authors:
Elisenda Feliu,
Nidhi Kaihnsa,
Timo de Wolff,
Oğuzhan Yürük
Abstract:
Multisite phosphorylation is a signaling mechanism well known to give rise to multiple steady states, a property termed multistationarity. When phosphorylation occurs in a sequential and distributive manner, we obtain a family of networks indexed by the number of phosphorylation sites $n$. This work addresses the problem of understanding the parameter region where this family of networks displays…
▽ More
Multisite phosphorylation is a signaling mechanism well known to give rise to multiple steady states, a property termed multistationarity. When phosphorylation occurs in a sequential and distributive manner, we obtain a family of networks indexed by the number of phosphorylation sites $n$. This work addresses the problem of understanding the parameter region where this family of networks displays multistationarity, by focusing on the projection of this region onto the set of kinetic parameters. The problem is phrased in the context of real algebraic geometry and reduced to studying whether a polynomial, defined as the determinant of a parametric matrix of size three, attains negative values over the positive orthant. The coefficients of the polynomial are functions of the kinetic parameters. For any $n$, we provide sufficient conditions for the polynomial to be positive and hence, preclude multistationarity, and also sufficient conditions for it to attain negative values and hence, enable multistationarity. These conditions are derived by exploiting the structure of the polynomial, its Newton polytope, and employing circuit polynomials. A relevant consequence of our results is that the set of kinetic parameters that enable or preclude multistationarity are both connected for all $n$.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2023; v1 submitted 17 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
The kinetic space of multistationarity in dual phosphorylation
Authors:
E. Feliu,
N. Kaihnsa,
T. de Wolff,
O. Yürük
Abstract:
Multistationarity in molecular systems underlies switch-like responses in cellular decision making. Determining whether and when a system displays multistationarity is in general a difficult problem. In this work we completely determine the set of kinetic parameters that enable multistationarity in a ubiquitous motif involved in cell signaling, namely a dual phosphorylation cycle. In addition we s…
▽ More
Multistationarity in molecular systems underlies switch-like responses in cellular decision making. Determining whether and when a system displays multistationarity is in general a difficult problem. In this work we completely determine the set of kinetic parameters that enable multistationarity in a ubiquitous motif involved in cell signaling, namely a dual phosphorylation cycle. In addition we show that the regions of multistationarity and monostationarity are both path connected.
We model the dynamics of the concentrations of the proteins over time by means of a parametrized polynomial ordinary differential equation (ODE) system arising from the mass-action assumption. Since this system has three linear first integrals defined by the total amounts of the substrate and the two enzymes, we study for what parameter values the ODE system has at least two positive steady states after suitably choosing the total amounts. We employ a suite of techniques from (real) algebraic geometry, which in particular concern the study of the signs of a multivariate polynomial over the positive orthant and sums of nonnegative circuit polynomials.
△ Less
Submitted 14 April, 2020; v1 submitted 22 January, 2020;
originally announced January 2020.
-
Cooperativity, Absolute Interaction, and Algebraic Optimization
Authors:
Nidhi Kaihnsa,
Yue Ren,
Mohab Safey El Din,
Johannes W. R. Martini
Abstract:
We consider a measure of cooperativity based on the minimal absolute interaction required to generate an observed titration behavior. We describe the corresponding algebraic optimization problem and show how it can be solved using the nonlinear algebra tool \texttt{SCIP}. Moreover, we compute the minimal absolute interactions for various binding polynomials that describe the oxygen binding of vari…
▽ More
We consider a measure of cooperativity based on the minimal absolute interaction required to generate an observed titration behavior. We describe the corresponding algebraic optimization problem and show how it can be solved using the nonlinear algebra tool \texttt{SCIP}. Moreover, we compute the minimal absolute interactions for various binding polynomials that describe the oxygen binding of various hemoglobins under different conditions. While calculated minimal absolute interactions are consistent with the expected outcome of the chemical modifications, it ranks the cooperativity of the molecules differently than the maximal Hill slope.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
