-
Electro-osmotic Instability of Concentration Enrichment in Curved Geometries for an Aqueous Electrolyte
Authors:
Bingrui Xu,
Zhibo Gu,
Wei Liu,
Peng Huo,
Yueting Zhou,
S. M. Rubinstein,
M. Z. Bazant,
B. Zaltzman,
I. Rubinstein,
Daosheng Deng
Abstract:
We report that an electro-osmotic instability of concentration enrichment in curved geometries for an aqueous electrolyte, as opposed to the well-known one, is initiated exclusively at the enriched interface (anode), rather than at the depleted one (cathode). For this instability, the limitation of unrealistically high material Peclet number in planar geometry is eliminated by the strong electric…
▽ More
We report that an electro-osmotic instability of concentration enrichment in curved geometries for an aqueous electrolyte, as opposed to the well-known one, is initiated exclusively at the enriched interface (anode), rather than at the depleted one (cathode). For this instability, the limitation of unrealistically high material Peclet number in planar geometry is eliminated by the strong electric field arising from the line charge singularity. In a model setup of concentric circular electrodes, we show by stability analysis, numerical simulation, and experimental visualization that instability occurs at the inner anode, below a critical radius of curvature. The stability criterion is also formulated in terms of a critical electric field and extended to arbitrary (2d) geometries by conformal map**. This discovery suggests that transport may be enhanced in processes limited by salt enrichment, such as reverse osmosis, by triggering this instability with needle-like electrodes.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
The driving factors of electro-convective instability in concentration polarization
Authors:
Isaak Rubinstein,
Boris Zaltzman
Abstract:
Ionic current through a charge-selective interface in a binary electrolyte is a basic element of many electrochemical engineering and microfluidic processes. Such current passage is diffusion-limited: it induces a decrease of electrolyte concentration towards the interface (concentration polarization, CP), expressed in the saturation of current upon increasing voltage at some value (limiting curre…
▽ More
Ionic current through a charge-selective interface in a binary electrolyte is a basic element of many electrochemical engineering and microfluidic processes. Such current passage is diffusion-limited: it induces a decrease of electrolyte concentration towards the interface (concentration polarization, CP), expressed in the saturation of current upon increasing voltage at some value (limiting current, LC). With further increase of voltage, this saturation breaks down (overlimiting conductance, OLC). In open systems OLC is mediated by a microscale vortical flow which develops as a result of electroconvective instability (ECI) of quiescent CP near LC. Electroconvection (EC) is a flow driven by the electric force acting either upon the space charge of the interfacial EDL (electroosmosis, EO) or the residual space charge of the quasielectroneutral bulk (bulk EC). There are two types of EO, the equilibrium and the nonequilibrium one. The former relates to the action of the tangential electric field upon the space charge of the EDL, and the latter pertains to the similar action upon the extended space charge, forming next to the EDL near LC. For a perfectly charge-selective interface, CP is stable under the equilibrium EO or bulk EC, but nonequilibrium EO may cause ECI. For this reason until recently, ECI in CP was attributed to this latter mechanism. Lately, it was shown that imperfect charge-selectivity of the interface makes equilibrium ECI possible, driven by either equilibrium EO or bulk EC, or both. Here we identify and analyze the major surface and bulk factors affecting the ECI. These factors (diffusioosmosis, EO, bulk EC, and some newly identified ones) are manifestations of the electric force and pressure gradient, balanced by the viscous force acting in various locations in solution. The contribution of these factors to ECI in CP is analyzed for a varying interface permselectivity.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Equilibrium Electro-osmotic Instability
Authors:
Isaak Rubinstein,
Boris Zaltzman
Abstract:
Since its prediction fifteen years ago, electro-osmotic instability has been attributed to non-equilibrium electro-osmosis related to the extended space charge which develops at the limiting current in the course of concentration polarization at a charge-selective interface. This attribution had a double basis. Firstly, it has been recognized that equilibrium electro-osmosis cannot yield instabili…
▽ More
Since its prediction fifteen years ago, electro-osmotic instability has been attributed to non-equilibrium electro-osmosis related to the extended space charge which develops at the limiting current in the course of concentration polarization at a charge-selective interface. This attribution had a double basis. Firstly, it has been recognized that equilibrium electro-osmosis cannot yield instability for a perfectly charge-selective solid. Secondly, it has been shown that non-equilibrium electro-osmosis can. First theoretical studies in which electro-osmotic instability was predicted and analyzed employed the assumption of perfect charge-selectivity for the sake of simplicity and so did the subsequent numerical studies of various time-dependent and nonlinear features of electro-osmotic instability. In this letter, we show that relaxing the assumption of perfect charge-selectivity (tantamount to fixing the electrochemical potential in the solid) allows for equilibrium electro-osmotic instability. Moreover, we suggest a simple experimental test for determining the true, either equilibrium or non-equilibrium, origin of electro-osmotic instability.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2014;
originally announced March 2014.
-
Overlimiting Current and Shock Electrodialysis in Porous Media
Authors:
Daosheng Deng,
E. Victoria Dydek,
Ji-Hyung Han,
Sven Schlumpberger,
Ali Mani,
Boris Zaltzman,
Martin Z. Bazant
Abstract:
Most electrochemical processes, such as electrodialysis, are limited by diffusion, but in porous media, surface conduction and electro-osmotic flow also contribute to ionic fluxes. In this paper, we report experimental evidence for surface-driven over-limiting current (faster than diffusion) and deionization shocks (propagating salt removal) in a porous medium. The apparatus consists of a silica g…
▽ More
Most electrochemical processes, such as electrodialysis, are limited by diffusion, but in porous media, surface conduction and electro-osmotic flow also contribute to ionic fluxes. In this paper, we report experimental evidence for surface-driven over-limiting current (faster than diffusion) and deionization shocks (propagating salt removal) in a porous medium. The apparatus consists of a silica glass frit (1 mm thick with 500 nm mean pore size) in an aqueous electrolyte (CuSO$_4$ or AgNO$_3$) passing ionic current from a reservoir to a cation-selective membrane (Nafion). The current-voltage relation of the whole system is consistent with a proposed theory based on the electro-osmotic flow mechanism over a broad range of reservoir salt concentrations (0.1 mM - 1.0 M), after accounting for (Cu) electrode polarization and pH-regulated silica charge. Above the limiting current, deionized water ($\approx 10 μ$ $M$) can be continuously extracted from the frit, which implies the existence of a stable shock propagating against the flow, bordering a depleted region that extends more than 0.5mm across the outlet. The results suggest the feasibility of "shock electrodialysis" as a new approach to water desalination and other electrochemical separations.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Overlimiting current in a microchannel
Authors:
E. Victoria Dydek,
Boris Zaltzman,
Isaak Rubinstein,
D. S. Deng,
Ali Mani,
Martin Z. Bazant
Abstract:
We revisit the classical problem of diffusion-limited ion transport to a membrane (or electrode) by considering the effects of charged side walls. Using simple mathematical models and numerical simulations, we identify three basic mechanisms for over-limiting current in a microchannel: (i) {\it surface conduction} carried by excess counterions, which dominates for very thin channels, (ii) convecti…
▽ More
We revisit the classical problem of diffusion-limited ion transport to a membrane (or electrode) by considering the effects of charged side walls. Using simple mathematical models and numerical simulations, we identify three basic mechanisms for over-limiting current in a microchannel: (i) {\it surface conduction} carried by excess counterions, which dominates for very thin channels, (ii) convection by {\it electro-osmotic flow} on the side walls, which dominates for thicker channels and transitions to (iii) {\it electro-osmotic instability} on the membrane end in very thick channels. These intriguing electrokinetic phenomena may find applications in biological separations, water desalination, and electrochemical energy storage.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
