-
Exact solution for heat transfer across the Sakiadis boundary layer
Authors:
W. Cade Reinberger,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Mohamed A. Samaha,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
We consider the problem of convective heat transfer across the laminar boundary-layer induced by an isothermal moving surface in a Newtonian fluid. In previous work (Barlow, Reinberger, and Weinstein, 2024, \textit{Physics of Fluids}, \textbf{36} (031703), 1-3) an exact power series solution was provided for the hydrodynamic flow, often referred to as the Sakiadis boundary layer. Here, we utilize…
▽ More
We consider the problem of convective heat transfer across the laminar boundary-layer induced by an isothermal moving surface in a Newtonian fluid. In previous work (Barlow, Reinberger, and Weinstein, 2024, \textit{Physics of Fluids}, \textbf{36} (031703), 1-3) an exact power series solution was provided for the hydrodynamic flow, often referred to as the Sakiadis boundary layer. Here, we utilize this expression to develop an exact solution for the associated thermal boundary layer as characterized by the Prandtl number ($\Pr$) and local Reynolds number along the surface. To extract the location-dependent heat-transfer coefficient (expressed in dimensionless form as the Nusselt number), the dimensionless temperature gradient at the wall is required; this gradient is solely a function of $\Pr$, and is expressed as an integral of the exact boundary layer flow solution. We find that the exact solution for the temperature gradient is computationally unstable at large $\Pr$, and a large $\Pr$ expansion for the temperature gradient is obtained using Laplace's method. A composite solution is obtained that is accurate to $O(10^{-10})$. Although divergent, the classical power series solution for the Sakiadis boundary layer -- expanded about the wall -- may be used to obtain all higher-order corrections in the asymptotic expansion. We show that this result is connected to the physics of large Prandtl number flows where the thickness of the hydrodynamic boundary layer is much larger than that of the thermal boundary layer. The present model is valid for all Prandtl numbers and attractive for ease of use.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Asymptotically-consistent analytical solutions for the non-Newtonian Sakiadis boundary layer
Authors:
Nastaran Naghshineh,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Mohamed A. Samaha,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
The Sakiadis boundary layer induced by a moving wall in a semi-infinite fluid domain is a fundamental laminar flow field relevant to high speed coating processes. This work provides an analytical solution to the boundary layer problem for Ostwald-de Waele power law fluids via a power series expansion, and extends the approach taken for Newtonian fluids [Naghshineh et al., "On the use of asymptotic…
▽ More
The Sakiadis boundary layer induced by a moving wall in a semi-infinite fluid domain is a fundamental laminar flow field relevant to high speed coating processes. This work provides an analytical solution to the boundary layer problem for Ostwald-de Waele power law fluids via a power series expansion, and extends the approach taken for Newtonian fluids [Naghshineh et al., "On the use of asymptotically motivated gauge functions to obtain convergent series solutions to nonlinear ODEs", IMA J. of Appl. Math., (2023)] in which variable substitutions (which naturally determine the gauge function in the power series) are chosen to be consistent with the large distance behavior away from the wall. Contrary to prior literature, the asymptotic behavior dictates that a solution only exists in the range of power law exponents, $α$, lying in the range $0.5 < α\leq 1$. An analytical solution is obtained in the range of approximately $0.74 \leq α< 1$, using a convergent power series with an asymptotically motivated gauge function. For power laws corresponding to $0.5 < α<0.74$, the gauge function becomes ill-defined over the full domain, and an approximate analytical solution is obtained using the method of asymptotic approximants [Barlow et al., "On the summation of divergent, truncated, and underspecified power series via asymptotic approximants", Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math., (2017)]. The approximant requires knowledge of two physical constants, which we compute a priori using a numerical shooting method on a finite domain. The utility of the power series solution is that it can be solved on the entire semi-infinite domain and--in contrast to a numerical solution--does not require a finite domain length approximation and subsequent domain length refinement.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2023; v1 submitted 8 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
On the shape of an axisymmetric meniscus rising from a static liquid pool
Authors:
Nastaran Naghshineh,
W. Cade Reinberger,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Mohamed A. Samaha,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
We examine the classical problem of the height of a static liquid interface that forms on the outside of a solid vertical cylinder in an unbounded stagnant pool exposed to air. Gravitational and surface tension effects compete to affect the interface shape as characterized by the Bond number, $B = ρg R^{2}/σ$, where $ρ$ is fluid density, $g$ is the gravitational constant, $R$ is the radius of the…
▽ More
We examine the classical problem of the height of a static liquid interface that forms on the outside of a solid vertical cylinder in an unbounded stagnant pool exposed to air. Gravitational and surface tension effects compete to affect the interface shape as characterized by the Bond number, $B = ρg R^{2}/σ$, where $ρ$ is fluid density, $g$ is the gravitational constant, $R$ is the radius of the cylinder, and $σ$ is surface tension. Here, we provide a convergent power series solution for interface shapes that rise above the horizontal pool as a function of Bond number. The power series solution is expressed in terms of a pre-factor that matches the large distance asymptotic behavior -- the modified Bessel function of zeroth order -- and an Euler transformation that moves the influence of convergence-limiting singularities out of the physical domain. The power series solution is validated through comparison with a numerical solution, and the $B\rightarrow0$ matched asymptotic solutions of Lo (1983, J. Fluid Mech., 132, p.65-78). For a benchmark static contact angle of $45$ degrees, the power series approach exceeds the accuracy of matched asymptotic solutions for $B>0.01$; this lower limit on $B$ arises from round-off error in the computation of the series coefficients in double precision arithmetic, and is reduced as the contact angle is increased.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2023; v1 submitted 19 July, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
On the response of neutrally stable flows to oscillatory forcing with application to liquid sheets
Authors:
Colin M. Huber,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
Industrial coating processes create thin liquid films with tight thickness tolerances, and thus models that predict the response to inevitable disturbances are essential. The mathematical modeling complexities are reduced through linearization as even small thickness variations in films can render a product unsalable. The signaling problem, considered in this paper, is perhaps the simplest model t…
▽ More
Industrial coating processes create thin liquid films with tight thickness tolerances, and thus models that predict the response to inevitable disturbances are essential. The mathematical modeling complexities are reduced through linearization as even small thickness variations in films can render a product unsalable. The signaling problem, considered in this paper, is perhaps the simplest model that incorporates the effects of repetitive (oscillatory) disturbances that are initiated, for example, by room vibrations and pump drives. In prior work, Gordillo and Pérez (Phys. Fluids 14, 2002) examined the structure of the signaling response for linear operators that admit exponentially growing or damped solutions, i.e., the medium is classified as unstable or stable via classical stability analysis. The signaling problem admits two portions of the solution, the transient behavior due to the start-up of the disturbance and the long-time behavior that is continually forced; the superposition reveals how the forced solution evolves through the passage of a transient. In this paper, we examine signaling for the linear operator examined by King et al. (King et al. 2016, Phys. Rev. Fluids 1(7)) that governs varicose waves in a thin liquid sheet and that can admit solutions having algebraic growth although the underlying medium is classified as being neutrally stable. Long-time asymptotic methods are used to extract critical velocities that partition the response into distinct regions having markedly different location-dependent responses, and the amplitudes of oscillatory responses in these regions are determined. Together, these characterize the magnitude and breadth of the solution response. Results indicate that the signaling response in neutrally stable flows (that admit algebraic growth) is significantly different from that in exponentially unstable systems.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
On the two-dimensional extension of one-dimensional algebraically growing waves at neutral stability
Authors:
Colin M. Huber,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
This work considers two linear operators which yield wave modes that are classified as neutrally stable, yet have responses that grow or decay in time. Previously, King et al. (Phys. Rev. Fluids, 1, 2016, 073604:1-19) and Huber et al. (IMA J. Appl. Math., 85, 2020, 309-340) examined the one-dimensional (1D) wave propagation governed by these operators. Here, we extend the linear operators to two s…
▽ More
This work considers two linear operators which yield wave modes that are classified as neutrally stable, yet have responses that grow or decay in time. Previously, King et al. (Phys. Rev. Fluids, 1, 2016, 073604:1-19) and Huber et al. (IMA J. Appl. Math., 85, 2020, 309-340) examined the one-dimensional (1D) wave propagation governed by these operators. Here, we extend the linear operators to two spatial dimensions (2D) and examine the resulting solutions. We find that the increase of dimension leads to long-time behaviour where the magnitude is reduced by a factor of $t^{\frac{-1}{2}}$ from the 1D solutions. Thus, regions of the solution which grew algebraically as $t^{\frac{1}{2}}$ in 1D now are algebraically neutral in 2D, whereas regions which decay (algebraically or exponentially) in 1D now decay more quickly in 2D. Additionally, we find that these two linear operators admit long-time solutions that are functions of the same similarity variable that contracts space and time.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
On the use of asymptotically motivated gauge functions to obtain convergent series solutions to nonlinear ODEs
Authors:
Nastaran Naghshineh,
W. Cade Reinberger,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Mohamed A. Samaha,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
We examine the power series solutions of two classical nonlinear ordinary differential equations of fluid mechanics that are mathematically related by their large-distance asymptotic behaviors in semi-infinite domains. The first problem is that of the "Sakiadis" boundary layer over a moving flat wall, for which no exact analytic solution has been put forward. The second problem is that of a static…
▽ More
We examine the power series solutions of two classical nonlinear ordinary differential equations of fluid mechanics that are mathematically related by their large-distance asymptotic behaviors in semi-infinite domains. The first problem is that of the "Sakiadis" boundary layer over a moving flat wall, for which no exact analytic solution has been put forward. The second problem is that of a static air-liquid meniscus with surface tension that intersects a flat wall at a given contact angle and limits to a flat pool away from the wall. For the latter problem, the exact analytic solution -- given as distance from the wall as function of meniscus height -- has long been known (Batchelor, 1967). Here, we provide an explicit solution as meniscus height vs. distance from the wall to elucidate structural similarities to the Sakiadis boundary layer. Although power series solutions are readily obtainable to the governing nonlinear ordinary differential equations, we show that -- in both problems -- the series diverge due to non-physical complex or negative real-valued singularities. In both cases, these singularities can be moved by expanding in exponential gauge functions motivated by their respective large distance asymptotic behaviors to enable series convergence over their full semi-infinite domains. For the Sakiadis problem, this not only provides a convergent Taylor series (and conjectured exact) solution to the ODE, but also a means to evaluate the wall shear parameter (and other properties) to within any desired precision. Although the nature of nonlinear ODEs precludes general conclusions, our results indicate that asymptotic behaviors can be useful when proposing variable transformations to overcome power series divergence.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2023; v1 submitted 19 May, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
On the shape of air-liquid interfaces with surface tension that bound rigidly-rotating liquids in partially filled containers
Authors:
Enrique Ramé,
Steven J. Weinstein,
Nathaniel S. Barlow
Abstract:
The interface shape of a fluid in rigid body rotation about its axis and partially filling the container is often the subject of a homework problem in the first graduate fluids class. In that problem, surface tension is neglected, the interface shape is parabolic and the contact angle boundary condition is not satisfied in general. When surface tension is accounted for, the shapes exhibit much ric…
▽ More
The interface shape of a fluid in rigid body rotation about its axis and partially filling the container is often the subject of a homework problem in the first graduate fluids class. In that problem, surface tension is neglected, the interface shape is parabolic and the contact angle boundary condition is not satisfied in general. When surface tension is accounted for, the shapes exhibit much richer dependencies as a function of rotation velocity. We analyze steady interface shapes in rotating right-circular cylindrical containers under rigid body rotation in zero gravity. We pay especial attention to shapes near criticality, in which the interface, or part thereof, becomes straight and parallel to the axis of rotation at certain specific rotational speeds. We examine geometries where the container is axially infinite and derive properties of their solutions. We then examine in detail two special cases of menisci in a cylindrical container: a meniscus spanning the cross section; and a meniscus forming a bubble. In each case we develop exact solutions for the respective axial lengths as infinite series in powers of appropriate rotation parameters; and we find the respective asymptotic behaviors as the shapes approach their critical configuration. Finally we apply the method of asymptotic approximants to yield analytical expressions for the axial lengths of menisci over the whole range of rotation speeds. In this application, the analytical solution is employed to examine errors introduced by the assumption that the interface is a right circular cylinder; this assumption is key to the spinning bubble method used to measure surface tension.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2021; v1 submitted 16 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The Rayleigh collapse of two spherical bubbles
Authors:
Anthony Harkin,
Adam Giammarese,
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
The inertial collapse of two interacting and non-translating spherical bubbles of equal size is considered. The exact analytic solution to the nonlinear ordinary differential equation that governs the bubble radii during collapse is first obtained via a slowly converging power series. An asymptotic approximant is then constructed that accelerates convergence of the series and imposes the asymptoti…
▽ More
The inertial collapse of two interacting and non-translating spherical bubbles of equal size is considered. The exact analytic solution to the nonlinear ordinary differential equation that governs the bubble radii during collapse is first obtained via a slowly converging power series. An asymptotic approximant is then constructed that accelerates convergence of the series and imposes the asymptotic collapse behavior when the radii are small. The solution generalizes the classical 1917 Rayleigh problem of single bubble collapse, as this configuration is recovered when the distance between the bubble centers far exceeds that of their radii.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
The effect of pressure fluctuations on the shapes of thinning liquid curtains
Authors:
Bridget M. Torsey,
Steven J. Weinstein,
David S. Ross,
Nathaniel S. Barlow
Abstract:
We consider the time-dependent response of a gravitationally-thinning inviscid liquid sheet (a coating curtain) leaving a vertical slot to sinusoidal ambient pressure disturbances. The theoretical investigation employs the hyperbolic partial differential equation developed by \cite{weinp1}. The response of the curtain is characterized by the slot Weber number, $W_{e_0} = ρq V/2σ$, where $V$ is the…
▽ More
We consider the time-dependent response of a gravitationally-thinning inviscid liquid sheet (a coating curtain) leaving a vertical slot to sinusoidal ambient pressure disturbances. The theoretical investigation employs the hyperbolic partial differential equation developed by \cite{weinp1}. The response of the curtain is characterized by the slot Weber number, $W_{e_0} = ρq V/2σ$, where $V$ is the speed of the curtain at the slot, $q$ is the volumetric flow rate per unit width, $σ$ is the surface tension, and $ρ$ is the fluid density. Flow disturbances travel along characteristics with speeds relative to the curtain of $\pm \sqrt{uV/W_{e_0}}$, where $u = \sqrt{V^2 + 2gx}$ is the curtain speed at a distance $x$ downstream from the slot. When the flow is subcritical ($W_{e_0} < 1$), upstream traveling disturbances near the slot affect the curtain centerline, and the slope of the curtain centerline at the slot oscillates with an amplitude that is a function of $W_{e_0}$. In contrast, all disturbances travel downstream in supercritical curtains ($W_{e_0} > 1$) and the slope of the curtain at the slot is vertical. Here, we specifically examine the curtain response under supercritical and subcritical flow conditions near $W_{e_0} = 1$ to deduce whether there is a substantial change in the overall shape and magnitude of the curtain responses. Despite the local differences in the curtain solution near the slot, we find that subcritical and supercritical curtains have similar responses for all imposed sinusoidal frequencies.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Analytic solution of the SEIR epidemic model via asymptotic approximant
Authors:
Steven J. Weinstein,
Morgan S. Holland,
Kelly E. Rogers,
Nathaniel S. Barlow
Abstract:
An analytic solution is obtained to the SEIR Epidemic Model. The solution is created by constructing a single second-order nonlinear differential equation in $\ln S$ and analytically continuing its divergent power series solution such that it matches the correct long-time exponential dam** of the epidemic model. This is achieved through an asymptotic approximant (Barlow et. al, 2017, Q. Jl Mech.…
▽ More
An analytic solution is obtained to the SEIR Epidemic Model. The solution is created by constructing a single second-order nonlinear differential equation in $\ln S$ and analytically continuing its divergent power series solution such that it matches the correct long-time exponential dam** of the epidemic model. This is achieved through an asymptotic approximant (Barlow et. al, 2017, Q. Jl Mech. Appl. Math, 70 (1), 21-48) in the form of a modified symmetric Padé approximant that incorporates this dam**. The utility of the analytical form is demonstrated through its application to the COVID-19 pandemic.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2020; v1 submitted 12 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Accurate closed-form solution of the SIR epidemic model
Authors:
Nathaniel S. Barlow,
Steven J. Weinstein
Abstract:
An accurate closed-form solution is obtained to the SIR Epidemic Model through the use of Asymptotic Approximants (Barlow et. al, 2017, Q. Jl Mech. Appl. Math, 70 (1), 21-48). The solution is created by analytically continuing the divergent power series solution such that it matches the long-time asymptotic behavior of the epidemic model. The utility of the analytical form is demonstrated through…
▽ More
An accurate closed-form solution is obtained to the SIR Epidemic Model through the use of Asymptotic Approximants (Barlow et. al, 2017, Q. Jl Mech. Appl. Math, 70 (1), 21-48). The solution is created by analytically continuing the divergent power series solution such that it matches the long-time asymptotic behavior of the epidemic model. The utility of the analytical form is demonstrated through its application to the COVID-19 pandemic.
△ Less
Submitted 4 January, 2021; v1 submitted 16 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
Asymptotic Approximant for the Falkner-Skan Boundary-Layer equation
Authors:
Elizabeth R. Belden,
Zachary A. Dickman,
Steven J. Weinstein,
Alex D. Archibee,
Ethan Burroughs,
Nathaniel S. Barlow
Abstract:
We demonstrate that the asymptotic approximant applied to the Blasius boundary layer flow over a flat plat (Barlow et al., 2017 Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math., 70(1): 21-48) yields accurate analytic closed-form solutions to the Falkner-Skan boundary layer equation for flow over a wedge having angle $βπ/2$ to the horizontal. A wide range of wedge angles satisfying $β\in[-0.198837735, 1]$ are considered, a…
▽ More
We demonstrate that the asymptotic approximant applied to the Blasius boundary layer flow over a flat plat (Barlow et al., 2017 Q. J. Mech. Appl. Math., 70(1): 21-48) yields accurate analytic closed-form solutions to the Falkner-Skan boundary layer equation for flow over a wedge having angle $βπ/2$ to the horizontal. A wide range of wedge angles satisfying $β\in[-0.198837735, 1]$ are considered, and the previously established non-unique solutions for $β<0$ having positive and negative shear rates along the wedge are accurately represented. The approximant is used to determine the singularities in the complex plane that prescribe the radius of convergence of the power series solution to the Falkner-Skan equation. An attractive feature of the approximant is that it may be constructed quickly by recursion compared with traditional Padé approximants that require a matrix inversion. The accuracy of the approximant is verified by numerical solutions, and benchmark numerical values are obtained that characterize the asymptotic behavior of the Falkner-Skan solution at large distances from the wedge.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
On the stability of waves in classically neutral flows
Authors:
Colin Huber,
Meaghan Hoitt,
Nicole Hill,
Kimberlee Keithley,
Steven J. Weinstein,
Nathaniel S. Barlow
Abstract:
This paper reports a breakdown in linear stability theory under conditions of neutral stability that is deduced by an examination of exponential modes of the form $h\approx {{e}^{i(kx-ωt)}}$, where $h$ is a response to a disturbance, $k$ is a real wavenumber, and $ω(k)$ is a wavelength-dependent complex frequency. In a previous paper, King et al (Stability of algebraically unstable dispersive flow…
▽ More
This paper reports a breakdown in linear stability theory under conditions of neutral stability that is deduced by an examination of exponential modes of the form $h\approx {{e}^{i(kx-ωt)}}$, where $h$ is a response to a disturbance, $k$ is a real wavenumber, and $ω(k)$ is a wavelength-dependent complex frequency. In a previous paper, King et al (Stability of algebraically unstable dispersive flows, \textit{Phys. Rev. Fluids}, 1(073604), 2016) demonstrates that when Im$[ω(k)]$=0 for all $k$, it is possible for a system response to grow or damp algebraically as $h\approx {{t}^{s}}$ where $s$ is a fractional power. The growth is deduced through an asymptotic analysis of the Fourier integral that inherently invokes the superposition of an infinite number of modes. In this paper, the more typical case associated with the transition from stability to instability is examined in which Im$[ω(k)]$=0 for a single mode (i.e., for one value of $k$) at neutral stability. Two partial differential equation systems are examined, one that has been constructed to elucidate key features of the stability threshold, and a second that models the well-studied problem of rectilinear Newtonian flow down an inclined plane. In both cases, algebraic growth/decay is deduced at the neutral stability boundary, and the propagation features of the responses are examined.
△ Less
Submitted 30 July, 2019; v1 submitted 21 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
