-
Universality and correlations in individuals wandering through an online extremist space
Authors:
Z. Cao,
M. Zheng,
Y. Vorobyeva,
C. Song,
N. F. Johnson
Abstract:
The 'out of the blue' nature of recent terror attacks and the diversity of apparent motives, highlight the importance of understanding the online trajectories that individuals follow prior to develo** high levels of extremist support. Here we show that the physics of stochastic walks, with and without temporal correlation, provides a unifying description of these online trajectories. Our unique…
▽ More
The 'out of the blue' nature of recent terror attacks and the diversity of apparent motives, highlight the importance of understanding the online trajectories that individuals follow prior to develo** high levels of extremist support. Here we show that the physics of stochastic walks, with and without temporal correlation, provides a unifying description of these online trajectories. Our unique dataset comprising all users of a global social media site, reveals universal characteristics in individuals' online lifetimes. Our accompanying theory generates analytical and numerical solutions that describe the characteristics shown by individuals that go on to develop high levels of extremist support, and those that do not. The existence of these temporal and also many-body correlations suggests that existing physics machinery can be used to quantify and perhaps mitigate the risk of future events.
△ Less
Submitted 20 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Dynamical patterns in individual trajectories toward extremism
Authors:
Z. Cao,
M. Zheng,
Y. Vorobyeva,
C. Song,
N. F. Johnson
Abstract:
Society faces a fundamental global problem of understanding which individuals are currently develo** strong support for some extremist entity such as ISIS (Islamic State) -- even if they never end up doing anything in the real world. The importance of online connectivity in develo** intent has been confirmed by recent case-studies of already convicted terrorists. Here we identify dynamical pat…
▽ More
Society faces a fundamental global problem of understanding which individuals are currently develo** strong support for some extremist entity such as ISIS (Islamic State) -- even if they never end up doing anything in the real world. The importance of online connectivity in develo** intent has been confirmed by recent case-studies of already convicted terrorists. Here we identify dynamical patterns in the online trajectories that individuals take toward develo** a high level of extremist support -- specifically, for ISIS. Strong memory effects emerge among individuals whose transition is fastest, and hence may become 'out of the blue' threats in the real world. A generalization of diagrammatic expansion theory helps quantify these characteristics, including the impact of changes in geographical location, and can facilitate prediction of future risks. By quantifying the trajectories that individuals follow on their journey toward expressing high levels of pro-ISIS support -- irrespective of whether they then carry out a real-world attack or not -- our findings can help move safety debates beyond reliance on static watch-list identifiers such as ethnic background or immigration status, and/or post-fact interviews with already-convicted individuals. Given the broad commonality of social media platforms, our results likely apply quite generally: for example, even on Telegram where (like Twitter) there is no built-in group feature as in our study, individuals tend to collectively build and pass through so-called super-group accounts.
△ Less
Submitted 5 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
Multiscale dynamical network mechanisms underlying aging from birth to death
Authors:
M. Zheng,
Z. Cao,
Y. Vorobyeva,
P. Manrique,
C. Song,
N. F. Johnson
Abstract:
How self-organized networks develop, mature and degenerate is a key question for sociotechnical, cyberphysical and biological systems with potential applications from tackling violent extremism through to neurological diseases. So far, it has proved impossible to measure the continuous-time evolution of any in vivo organism network from birth to death. Here we provide such a study which crosses al…
▽ More
How self-organized networks develop, mature and degenerate is a key question for sociotechnical, cyberphysical and biological systems with potential applications from tackling violent extremism through to neurological diseases. So far, it has proved impossible to measure the continuous-time evolution of any in vivo organism network from birth to death. Here we provide such a study which crosses all organizational and temporal scales, from individual components (10^1) through to the mesoscopic (10^3) and entire system scale (10^6). These continuous-time data reveal a lifespan driven by punctuated, real-time co-evolution of the structural and functional networks. Aging sees these structural and functional networks gradually diverge in terms of their small-worldness and eventually their connectivity. Dying emerges as an extended process associated with the formation of large but disjoint functional sub-networks together with an increasingly detached core. Our mathematical model quantifies the very different impacts that interventions will have on the overall lifetime, period of initial growth, peak of potency, and duration of old age, depending on when and how they are administered. In addition to their direct relevance to online extremism, our findings offer fresh insight into aging in any network system of comparable complexity for which extensive in vivo data is not yet available.
△ Less
Submitted 2 June, 2017;
originally announced June 2017.
-
New Online Ecology of Adversarial Aggregates: ISIS and beyond
Authors:
N. F. Johnson,
M. Zheng,
Y. Vorobyeva,
A. Gabriel,
H. Qi,
N. Velasquez,
P. Manrique,
D. Johnson,
E. Restrepo,
C. Song,
S. Wuchty
Abstract:
Support for extremist entities - whether from the far right, or far left - often manages to survive globally online despite significant external pressure, and may ultimately inspire violent acts by individuals having no obvious prior history of extremism. Examining longitudinal records of extremist online activity, we uncovered an ecology evolving on a daily timescale that drives online support, a…
▽ More
Support for extremist entities - whether from the far right, or far left - often manages to survive globally online despite significant external pressure, and may ultimately inspire violent acts by individuals having no obvious prior history of extremism. Examining longitudinal records of extremist online activity, we uncovered an ecology evolving on a daily timescale that drives online support, and we provide a mathematical theory that describes it. The ecology features self-organized aggregates (online groups such as on Facebook or another social media analog) that proliferate preceding the onset of recent real-world campaigns, and adopt novel adaptive mechanisms to enhance their survival. One of the predictions is that development of large, potentially potent online groups can be thwarted by targeting smaller ones.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2017; v1 submitted 30 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
