Showing 1–14 of 14 results for author: Verweij, A

Parallel-in-Time Integration of Transient Phenomena in No-Insulation Superconducting Coils Using Parareal

Authors: Erik Schnaubelt, Mariusz Wozniak, Julien Dular, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Arjan Verweij, Sebastian Schöps

Abstract: High-temperature superconductors (HTS) have the potential to enable magnetic fields beyond the current limits of low-temperature superconductors in applications like accelerator magnets. However, the design of HTS-based magnets requires computationally demanding transient multi-physics simulations with highly non-linear material properties. To reduce the solution time, we propose using Parareal (P… ▽ More High-temperature superconductors (HTS) have the potential to enable magnetic fields beyond the current limits of low-temperature superconductors in applications like accelerator magnets. However, the design of HTS-based magnets requires computationally demanding transient multi-physics simulations with highly non-linear material properties. To reduce the solution time, we propose using Parareal (PR) for parallel-in-time magneto-thermal simulation of magnets based on HTS, particularly, no-insulation coils without turn-to-turn insulation. We propose extending the classical PR method to automatically find a time partitioning using a first coarse adaptive propagator. The proposed PR method is shown to reduce the computing time when fine engineering tolerances are required despite the highly nonlinear character of the problem. The full software stack used is open-source. △ Less

Submitted 20 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: Pre-submission version (preprint). Presented at and submitted to the proceedings of "The 15th International Conference on Scientific Computing in Electrical Engineering" (SCEE 2024), March 4-8, 2024, Darmstadt, Germany

Coupled Axial and Transverse Currents Method for Finite Element Modelling of Periodic Superconductors

Authors: Julien Dular, Fredrik Magnus, Erik Schnaubelt, Arjan Verweij, Mariusz Wozniak

Abstract: In this paper, we propose the Coupled Axial and Transverse currents (I) (CATI) method, as an efficient and accurate finite element approach for modelling the electric and magnetic behavior of periodic composite superconducting conductors. The method consists of a pair of two-dimensional models coupled via circuit equations to account for the conductor geometrical periodicity. This allows to captur… ▽ More In this paper, we propose the Coupled Axial and Transverse currents (I) (CATI) method, as an efficient and accurate finite element approach for modelling the electric and magnetic behavior of periodic composite superconducting conductors. The method consists of a pair of two-dimensional models coupled via circuit equations to account for the conductor geometrical periodicity. This allows to capture three-dimensional effects with two-dimensional models and leads to a significant reduction in computational time compared to conventional three-dimensional models. After presenting the method in detail, we verify it by comparison with reference finite element models, focussing on its application to twisted multifilamentary superconducting strands. In particular, we show that the CATI method captures the transition from uncoupled to coupled filaments, with accurate calculation of the interfilament coupling time constant. We then illustrate the capabilities of the method by generating a detailed loss map and magnetization curves of given strand types for a range of external transverse magnetic field excitations, with and without transport current. △ Less

Submitted 24 June, 2024; v1 submitted 15 April, 2024; originally announced April 2024.

Comments: 18 pages. Updated after peer-review

Magneto-Thermal Thin Shell Approximation for 3D Finite Element Analysis of No-Insulation Coils

Authors: Erik Schnaubelt, Sina Atalay, Mariusz Wozniak, Julien Dular, Christophe Geuzaine, Benoît Vanderheyden, Nicolas Marsic, Arjan Verweij, Sebastian Schöps

Abstract: For finite element (FE) analysis of no-insulation (NI) high-temperature superconducting (HTS) pancake coils, the high aspect ratio of the turn-to-turn contact layer (T2TCL) leads to meshing difficulties which result in either poor quality mesh elements resulting in a decrease of the solution accuracy or a high number of degrees of freedom. We proposed to mitigate this issue by collapsing the T2TCL… ▽ More For finite element (FE) analysis of no-insulation (NI) high-temperature superconducting (HTS) pancake coils, the high aspect ratio of the turn-to-turn contact layer (T2TCL) leads to meshing difficulties which result in either poor quality mesh elements resulting in a decrease of the solution accuracy or a high number of degrees of freedom. We proposed to mitigate this issue by collapsing the T2TCL volume into a surface and using a so-called thin shell approximation (TSA). Previously, two TSA have been introduced, one to solve the heat equation and the other for an $\vec{H}-φ$ magnetodynamic formulation. In this work, we propose to combine the magnetodynamic and thermal TSA to create a coupled magneto-thermal TSA for three-dimensional FE analysis. Particular attention is paid to the detailed derivation of the coupling terms. In the context of NI HTS pancake coils, the TSA represents the electric and thermal contact resistance of the T2TCL. For the HTS coated conductor (CC) itself, an anisotropic homogenization is used which represents its multi-layered structure. In axial and azimuthal direction, it resolves the current sharing between the HTS and other layers of the CC. The coupled TSA formulation is verified against a reference model with volumetric T2TCL. The coupled TSA is shown to significantly reduce the solution time as well as the manual effort required for high-quality meshes of the T2TCL. The implementation is open-source and a reference implementation is made publicly available. △ Less

Submitted 4 October, 2023; originally announced October 2023.

Comments: Presented at EUCAS 2023, Bologna, Italy. This work has been submitted to the IEEE for possible publication. Copyright may be transferred without notice, after which this version may no longer be accessible

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 1-6, May 2024, Art no. 4700406

Towards a Muon Collider

Authors: Carlotta Accettura, Dean Adams, Rohit Agarwal, Claudia Ahdida, Chiara Aimè, Nicola Amapane, David Amorim, Paolo Andreetto, Fabio Anulli, Robert Appleby, Artur Apresyan, Aram Apyan, Sergey Arsenyev, Pouya Asadi, Mohammed Attia Mahmoud, Aleksandr Azatov, John Back, Lorenzo Balconi, Laura Bandiera, Roger Barlow, Nazar Bartosik, Emanuela Barzi, Fabian Batsch, Matteo Bauce, J. Scott Berg , et al. (272 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: A muon collider would enable the big jump ahead in energy reach that is needed for a fruitful exploration of fundamental interactions. The challenges of producing muon collisions at high luminosity and 10 TeV centre of mass energy are being investigated by the recently-formed International Muon Collider Collaboration. This Review summarises the status and the recent advances on muon colliders desi… ▽ More A muon collider would enable the big jump ahead in energy reach that is needed for a fruitful exploration of fundamental interactions. The challenges of producing muon collisions at high luminosity and 10 TeV centre of mass energy are being investigated by the recently-formed International Muon Collider Collaboration. This Review summarises the status and the recent advances on muon colliders design, physics and detector studies. The aim is to provide a global perspective of the field and to outline directions for future work. △ Less

Submitted 27 November, 2023; v1 submitted 15 March, 2023; originally announced March 2023.

Comments: 118 pages, 103 figures

Proof of Concept of High-Temperature Superconducting Screens for Magnetic Field-Error Cancellation in Accelerator Magnets

Authors: L. Bortot, M. Mentink, C. Petrone, J. Van Nugteren, G. Deferne, T. Koettig, G. Kirby, M. Pentella, J. C. Perez, F. O. Pincot, G. De Rijk, S. Russenschuck, A. P. Verweij, S. Schöps

Abstract: Accelerators magnets must have minimal magnetic field imperfections for reducing particle-beam instabilities. In the case of coils made of high-temperature superconducting (HTS) tapes, the field imperfections from persistent currents need to be carefully evaluated. In this paper we study the use of superconducting screens based on HTS tapes for reducing the magnetic field imperfections in accelera… ▽ More Accelerators magnets must have minimal magnetic field imperfections for reducing particle-beam instabilities. In the case of coils made of high-temperature superconducting (HTS) tapes, the field imperfections from persistent currents need to be carefully evaluated. In this paper we study the use of superconducting screens based on HTS tapes for reducing the magnetic field imperfections in accelerator magnets. The screens exploit the magnetization by persistent currents to cancel out the magnetic field error. The screens are aligned with the main field components, such that only the undesired field components are compensated. The screens are passive, self-regulating, and do not require any external source of energy. Measurements in liquid nitrogen at 77 Kelvin show for dipole-field configurations a significant reduction of the magnetic-field error up to a factor of four. The residual error is explained via numerical simulations, accounting for the geometrical imperfections in the HTS screens, thus achieving satisfactory agreement with experimental results. Simulations show that if screens are increased in width and thickness, and operated at 4.5 Kelvin, field errors may be eliminated almost entirely for the typical excitation cycles of accelerator magnets. △ Less

Submitted 26 March, 2021; originally announced March 2021.

Comments: 11 pages, 20 figures

Numerical Analysis of the Screening Current-Induced Magnetic Field in the HTS Insert Dipole Magnet Feather-M2.1-2

Authors: Lorenzo Bortot, Matthias Mentink, Carlo Petrone, Jeroen Van Nugteren, Glyn Kirby, Mariano Pentella, Arjan Verweij, Sebastian Schöps

Abstract: Screening currents are field-induced dynamic phenomena which occur in superconducting materials, leading to persistent magnetization. Such currents are of importance in ReBCO tapes, where the large size of the superconducting filaments gives rise to strong magnetization phenomena. In consequence, superconducting accelerator magnets based on ReBCO tapes might experience a relevant degradation of th… ▽ More Screening currents are field-induced dynamic phenomena which occur in superconducting materials, leading to persistent magnetization. Such currents are of importance in ReBCO tapes, where the large size of the superconducting filaments gives rise to strong magnetization phenomena. In consequence, superconducting accelerator magnets based on ReBCO tapes might experience a relevant degradation of the magnetic field quality in the magnet aperture, eventually leading to particle beam instabilities. Thus, persistent magnetization phenomena need to be accurately evaluated. In this paper, the 2D finite element model of the Feather-M2.1-2 magnet is presented. The model is used to analyze the influence of the screening current-induced magnetic field on the field quality in the magnet aperture. The model relies on a coupled field formulation for eddy current problems in time-domain. The formulation is introduced and verified against theoretical references. Then, the numerical model of the Feather-M2.1-2 magnet is detailed, highlighting the key assumptions and simplifications. The numerical results are discussed and validated with available magnetic measurements. A satisfactory agreement is found, showing the capability of the numerical tool in providing accurate analysis of the dynamic behavior of the Feather-M2.1-2 magnet. △ Less

Submitted 6 January, 2021; v1 submitted 19 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 14 pages, 18 figures

Fast Failures in the LHC and the future High Luminosity LHC*

Authors: B. Lindstrom, P. Bélanger, L. Bortot, R. Denz, M. Mentink, E. Ravaioli, F. Rodriguez Mateos, R. Schmidt, J. Uythoven, M. Valette, A. Verweij, C. Wiesner, D. Wollmann, M. Zerlauth

Abstract: An energy of $362\:\text{MJ}$ is stored in each of the two LHC proton beams for nominal beam parameters. This will be further increased to about $700\:\text{MJ}$ in the future High Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) and uncontrolled beam losses represent a significant hazard for the integrity and safe operation of the machine. In this paper, a number of failure mechanisms that can lead to a fast increase of… ▽ More An energy of $362\:\text{MJ}$ is stored in each of the two LHC proton beams for nominal beam parameters. This will be further increased to about $700\:\text{MJ}$ in the future High Luminosity LHC (HL-LHC) and uncontrolled beam losses represent a significant hazard for the integrity and safe operation of the machine. In this paper, a number of failure mechanisms that can lead to a fast increase of beam losses are analyzed. Most critical are failures in the magnet protection system, namely the quench heaters and a novel protection system called Coupling-Loss Induced Quench (CLIQ). An important outcome is that magnet protection has to be evaluated for its impact on the beam and designed accordingly. In particular, CLIQ, which is to protect the new HL-LHC triplet magnets, constitutes the fastest known failure in the LHC if triggered spuriously. A schematic change of CLIQ to mitigate the hazard is presented. A loss of the Beam-Beam Kick due to the extraction of one beam is another source of beam losses with a fast onset. A significantly stronger impact is expected in the upcoming LHC Run III and HL-LHC as compared to the current LHC, mainly due to the increased bunch intensity. Its criticality and mitigation methods are discussed. It is shown that symmetric quenches in the superconducting magnets for the final focusing triplet can have a significant impact on the beam on short timescales. The impact on the beam due to failures of the Beam-Beam Compensating Wires as well as coherent excitations by the transverse beam damper are also discussed. △ Less

Submitted 12 May, 2020; v1 submitted 9 May, 2020; originally announced May 2020.

Comments: 28 pages, 23 figures. To be published in Physical Review Accelerators and Beams

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 23, 081001 (2020)

A Coupled A-H Formulation for Magneto-Thermal Transients in High-Temperature Superconducting Magnets

Authors: Lorenzo Bortot, Bernhard Auchmann, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Herbert De Gersem, Michał Maciejewski, Matthias Mentink, Sebastian Schöps, Jeroen Van Nugteren, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: The application of high-temperature superconductors to accelerator magnets for future particle colliders is under study. Numerical methods are crucial for an accurate evaluation of the complex dynamical behavior of the magnets, especially concerning the magnetic field quality and thermal behavior. We present a coupled $\textbf{A}$-$\textbf{H}$ field formulation for the analysis of magneto-thermal… ▽ More The application of high-temperature superconductors to accelerator magnets for future particle colliders is under study. Numerical methods are crucial for an accurate evaluation of the complex dynamical behavior of the magnets, especially concerning the magnetic field quality and thermal behavior. We present a coupled $\textbf{A}$-$\textbf{H}$ field formulation for the analysis of magneto-thermal transients in accelerator magnets. The magnetic field strength $\textbf{H}$ accounts for the eddy current problem in the source regions containing the superconducting domains, while the magnetic vector potential $\textbf{A}$ represents the magnetoquasistatic problem in the normal and non-conducting domains. Furthermore, we include a slab approximation for the source regions, making the formulation suitable for large scale models composed of thousands of tapes. In this work, the relevant equations are derived and discussed, with emphasis on the coupling conditions. The weak formulation is derived, and numerical results are provided in order to both, verify the formulation and scale it to the size of an accelerator magnet. △ Less

Submitted 17 January, 2020; v1 submitted 7 September, 2019; originally announced September 2019.

Comments: 10 pages, 11 figures

STEAM: A Hierarchical Co-Simulation Framework for Superconducting Accelerator Magnet Circuits

Authors: Lorenzo Bortot, Bernhard Auchmann, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Alejando M. Fernando Navarro, Michał Maciejewski, Matthias Mentink, Marco Prioli, Emmanuele Ravaioli, Sebastian Schöps, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: Simulating the transient effects occurring in superconducting accelerator magnet circuits requires including the mutual electro-thermo-dynamic interaction among the circuit elements, such as power converters, magnets, and protection systems. Nevertheless, the numerical analysis is traditionally done separately for each element in the circuit, leading to possible non-consistent results. We present… ▽ More Simulating the transient effects occurring in superconducting accelerator magnet circuits requires including the mutual electro-thermo-dynamic interaction among the circuit elements, such as power converters, magnets, and protection systems. Nevertheless, the numerical analysis is traditionally done separately for each element in the circuit, leading to possible non-consistent results. We present STEAM, a hierarchical co-simulation framework featuring the waveform relaxation method. The framework simulates a complex system as a composition of simpler, independent models that exchange information. The convergence of the coupling algorithm ensures the consistency of the solution. The modularity of the framework allows integrating models developed with both proprietary and in-house tools. The framework implements a user-customizable hierarchical algorithm to schedule how models participate to the co-simulation, for the purpose of using computational resources efficiently. As a case study, a quench scenario is co-simulated for the inner triplet circuit for the High Luminosity upgrade of the LHC at CERN. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2018; originally announced January 2018.

Comments: 7 pages, 14 figures

MSC Class: 78M10; 94C99; 74F15 ACM Class: F.2.1; I.6.3; J.2

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 28.3, 2018

Coupling of Magneto-Thermal and Mechanical Superconducting Magnet Models by Means of Mesh-Based Interpolation

Authors: Michał Maciejewski, Pascal Bayrasy, Klaus Wolf, Michał Wilczek, Bernhard Auchmann, Tina Griesemer, Lorenzo Bortot, Marco Prioli, Alejandro Manuel Fernandez Navarro, Sebastian Schöps, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: In this paper we present an algorithm for the coupling of magneto-thermal and mechanical finite element models representing superconducting accelerator magnets. The mechanical models are used during the design of the mechanical structure as well as the optimization of the magnetic field quality under nominal conditions. The magneto-thermal models allow for the analysis of transient phenomena occur… ▽ More In this paper we present an algorithm for the coupling of magneto-thermal and mechanical finite element models representing superconducting accelerator magnets. The mechanical models are used during the design of the mechanical structure as well as the optimization of the magnetic field quality under nominal conditions. The magneto-thermal models allow for the analysis of transient phenomena occurring during quench initiation, propagation, and protection. Mechanical analysis of quenching magnets is of high importance considering the design of new protection systems and the study of new superconductor types. We use field/circuit coupling to determine temperature and electromagnetic force evolution during the magnet discharge. These quantities are provided as a load to existing mechanical models. The models are discretized with different meshes and, therefore, we employ a mesh-based interpolation method to exchange coupled quantities. The coupling algorithm is illustrated with a simulation of a mechanical response of a standalone high-field dipole magnet protected with CLIQ (Coupling-Loss Induced Quench) technology. △ Less

Submitted 29 December, 2017; originally announced December 2017.

Comments: 5 pages, 6 figures

MSC Class: 78M10; 94C99; 74F15 ACM Class: F.2.1; I.6.3; J.2

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Applied Superconductivity 28.3 (Apr. 2018). issn: 1051-8223

A 2-D Finite-Element Model for Electro-Thermal Transients in Accelerator Magnets

Authors: Lorenzo Bortot, Bernhard Auchmann, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Alejandro Manuel Fernandez Navarro, Michal Maciejewski, Marco Prioli, Sebastian Schöps, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: Superconducting accelerator magnets require sophisticated monitoring and means of protection due to the large energy stored in the magnetic field. Numerical simulations play a crucial role in understanding transient phenomena occurring within the magnet, and can, therefore, help to prevent disruptive consequences. We present a 2-D FEM model for the simulation of electro-thermal transients occurrin… ▽ More Superconducting accelerator magnets require sophisticated monitoring and means of protection due to the large energy stored in the magnetic field. Numerical simulations play a crucial role in understanding transient phenomena occurring within the magnet, and can, therefore, help to prevent disruptive consequences. We present a 2-D FEM model for the simulation of electro-thermal transients occurring in superconducting accelerator magnets. The magnetoquasistatic problem is solved with a modified magnetic vector potential formulation, where the cable eddy currents are resolved in terms of their equivalent magnetization. The heat balance equation is then investigated, and the relevant heat sources are discussed. The model implements a two-port component interface and is resolved, as part of an electrical circuit, in a cooperative simulation scheme with a lumped-parameter network. △ Less

Submitted 5 December, 2017; v1 submitted 3 October, 2017; originally announced October 2017.

Comments: 4 pages, 12 figures, approved for publication, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, 2017

Journal ref: IEEE Transactions on Magnetics, Volume 54, Issue 3 , March 2018

Application of the Waveform Relaxation Technique to the Co-Simulation of Power Converter Controller and Electrical Circuit Models

Authors: Michał Maciejewski, Idoia Cortes Garcia, Sebastian Schöps, Bernhard Auchmann, Lorenzo Bortot, Marco Prioli, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: In this paper we present the co-simulation of a PID class power converter controller and an electrical circuit by means of the waveform relaxation technique. The simulation of the controller model is characterized by a fixed-time step** scheme reflecting its digital implementation, whereas a circuit simulation usually employs an adaptive time step** scheme in order to account for a wide range… ▽ More In this paper we present the co-simulation of a PID class power converter controller and an electrical circuit by means of the waveform relaxation technique. The simulation of the controller model is characterized by a fixed-time step** scheme reflecting its digital implementation, whereas a circuit simulation usually employs an adaptive time step** scheme in order to account for a wide range of time constants within the circuit model. In order to maintain the characteristic of both models as well as to facilitate model replacement, we treat them separately by means of input/output relations and propose an application of a waveform relaxation algorithm. Furthermore, the maximum and minimum number of iterations of the proposed algorithm are mathematically analyzed. The concept of controller/circuit coupling is illustrated by an example of the co-simulation of a PI power converter controller and a model of the main dipole circuit of the Large Hadron Collider. △ Less

Submitted 10 April, 2017; originally announced April 2017.

MSC Class: 94C99; 65L80; 49J15 ACM Class: F.2.1; I.2.8; I.6.3; J.2

Journal ref: 2017 22nd International Conference on Methods and Models in Automation and Robotics (MMAR), Miedzyzdroje, Poland, 2017, pp. 837-842

Optimized Field/Circuit Coupling for the Simulation of Quenches in Superconducting Magnets

Authors: Idoia Cortes Garcia, Sebastian Schöps, Michał Maciejewski, Lorenzo Bortot, Marco Prioli, Bernhard Auchmann, Arjan Verweij

Abstract: In this paper, we propose an optimized field/circuit coupling approach for the simulation of magnetothermal transients in superconducting magnets. The approach improves the convergence of the iterative coupling scheme between a magnetothermal partial differential model and an electrical lumped-element circuit. Such a multi-physics, multi-rate and multi-scale problem requires a consistent formulati… ▽ More In this paper, we propose an optimized field/circuit coupling approach for the simulation of magnetothermal transients in superconducting magnets. The approach improves the convergence of the iterative coupling scheme between a magnetothermal partial differential model and an electrical lumped-element circuit. Such a multi-physics, multi-rate and multi-scale problem requires a consistent formulation and a dedicated framework to tackle the challenging transient effects occurring at both circuit and magnet level during normal operation and in case of faults. We derive an equivalent magnet model at the circuit side for the linear and the non-linear settings and discuss the convergence of the overall scheme in the framework of optimized Schwarz methods. The efficiency of the developed approach is illustrated by a numerical example of an accelerator dipole magnet with accompanying protection system. △ Less

Submitted 6 July, 2017; v1 submitted 3 February, 2017; originally announced February 2017.

Comments: 8 pages, 7 figures

MSC Class: 78M10; 94C99; 74F15 ACM Class: F.2.1; I.6.3; J.2

Journal ref: IEEE Journal on Multiscale and Multiphysics Computational Techniques, vol. 2, pp. 97-104 (2017)

Testing Beam-Induced Quench Levels of LHC Superconducting Magnets

Authors: B. Auchmann, T. Baer, M. Bednarek, G. Bellodi, C. Bracco, R. Bruce, F. Cerutti, V. Chetvertkova, B. Dehning, P. P. Granieri, W. Hofle, E. B. Holzer, A. Lechner, E. Nebot Del Busto, A. Priebe, S. Redaelli, B. Salvachua, M. Sapinski, R. Schmidt, N. Shetty, E. Skordis, M. Solfaroli, J. Steckert, D. Valuch, A. Verweij , et al. (3 additional authors not shown)

Abstract: In the years 2009-2013 the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has been operated with the top beam energies of 3.5 TeV and 4 TeV per proton (from 2012) instead of the nominal 7 TeV. The currents in the superconducting magnets were reduced accordingly. To date only seventeen beam-induced quenches have occurred; eight of them during specially designed quench tests, the others during injection. There has not… ▽ More In the years 2009-2013 the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) has been operated with the top beam energies of 3.5 TeV and 4 TeV per proton (from 2012) instead of the nominal 7 TeV. The currents in the superconducting magnets were reduced accordingly. To date only seventeen beam-induced quenches have occurred; eight of them during specially designed quench tests, the others during injection. There has not been a single beam- induced quench during normal collider operation with stored beam. The conditions, however, are expected to become much more challenging after the long LHC shutdown. The magnets will be operating at near nominal currents, and in the presence of high energy and high intensity beams with a stored energy of up to 362 MJ per beam. In this paper we summarize our efforts to understand the quench levels of LHC superconducting magnets. We describe beam-loss events and dedicated experiments with beam, as well as the simulation methods used to reproduce the observable signals. The simulated energy deposition in the coils is compared to the quench levels predicted by electro-thermal models, thus allowing to validate and improve the models which are used to set beam-dump thresholds on beam-loss monitors for Run 2. △ Less

Submitted 26 June, 2015; v1 submitted 18 February, 2015; originally announced February 2015.

Comments: 19 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 18, 061002 (2015)