-
Value-based optimization of healthcare resource allocation for COVID-19 hot spots
Authors:
Zachary A. Collier,
Jeffrey M. Keisler,
Benjamin D. Trump,
Jeffrey C. Cegan,
Sarah Wolberg,
Igor Linkov
Abstract:
With the emerging COVID-19 crisis, a critical task for public health officials and policy makers is to decide how to prioritize, locate, and allocate scarce resources. To answer these questions, decision makers need to be able to determine the location of the required resources over time based on emerging hot spot locations. Hot spots are defined as concentrated areas with sharp increases in COVID…
▽ More
With the emerging COVID-19 crisis, a critical task for public health officials and policy makers is to decide how to prioritize, locate, and allocate scarce resources. To answer these questions, decision makers need to be able to determine the location of the required resources over time based on emerging hot spot locations. Hot spots are defined as concentrated areas with sharp increases in COVID19 cases. Hot spots place stress on existing healthcare resources, resulting in demand for resources potentially exceeding current capacity. This research will describe a value based resource allocation approach that seeks to coordinate demand, as defined by uncertain epidemiological forecasts, with the value of adding additional resources such as hospital beds. Value is framed as a function of the expected usage of a marginal resource (bed, ventilator, etc). Subject to certain constraints, allocation decisions are operationalized using a nonlinear programming model, allocating new hospital beds over time and across a number of geographical locations. The results of the research show a need for a value based approach to assist decision makers at all levels in making the best possible decisions in the current highly uncertain and dynamic COVID environment.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
The Vaccine Supply Chain: A Call for Resilience Analytics to Support COVID-19 Vaccine Production and Distribution
Authors:
Maureen S. Golan,
Benjamin D. Trump,
Jeffrey C. Cegan,
Igor Linkov
Abstract:
The COVID19 pandemic has highlighted the lack of resilience in supply chains, as global networks fail from disruptions at single nodes and connections. Through an overview of the existing vaccine and pharmaceutical supply chain publications focusing on resilience, as well as recent papers reporting modeling of resilience in supply chains across multiple fields, we find that models for supply chain…
▽ More
The COVID19 pandemic has highlighted the lack of resilience in supply chains, as global networks fail from disruptions at single nodes and connections. Through an overview of the existing vaccine and pharmaceutical supply chain publications focusing on resilience, as well as recent papers reporting modeling of resilience in supply chains across multiple fields, we find that models for supply chain resilience are few and most of them are focused on individual dimensions of resilience rather than on comprehensive strategy necessary for scaling up vaccine production and distribution in emergency settings. We find that COVID19 resulted in a wave of interest to supply chain resilience, but publications from 2020 are narrow in focus and largely qualitative in nature; evidence-based models and measures are rare. Further, publications often focus exclusively on specific portions of the specific supply chain of interest, excluding associated supporting networks, such as transportation, social and command and control (C2) necessary for vaccine production and equitable distribution. This lack of network analysis is a major gap in the literature that needs to be bridged in order to create methods of real-time analysis and decision tools for the COVID19 vaccine supply chain. We conclude that a comprehensive, quantitative approach to network resilience that encompasses the supply chain in the context of other social and physical networks is needed in order to address the emerging challenges of a large-scale COVID-19 vaccination program. We further find that the COVID-19 pandemic underscores the necessity of positioning supply chain resilience within a multi-network context and formally incorporating temporal dimensions into analysis through the NAS definition of resilience, plan, absorb, recover, adapt, to ensure essential needs are met across all dimensions of society.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
The Need to Reconcile Concepts that Characterize Systems Withstanding Threats
Authors:
Stephanie Galaitsi,
Benjamin D. Trump,
Jeffrey M. Keisler,
Igor Linkov
Abstract:
Desirable system performance in the face of threats and disruptions has been characterized by various management concepts. Through semi-structured interviews with editors of journals in the fields of emergency response and systems management, a literature review, and professional judgment, we identified nine related and often interchangeably-used system performance concepts: adaptability, agility,…
▽ More
Desirable system performance in the face of threats and disruptions has been characterized by various management concepts. Through semi-structured interviews with editors of journals in the fields of emergency response and systems management, a literature review, and professional judgment, we identified nine related and often interchangeably-used system performance concepts: adaptability, agility, reliability, resilience, resistance, robustness, safety, security, and sustainability. We analysed expert responses and reviewed the linguistic definitions and mathematical framing of these concepts to understand their applications. We found a lack of consensus on their usage between interview subjects, but using a mathematical framing enriched the linguistic definitions and enabled formulating comparative visualizations and system-specific definitions for the concepts. We propose a conceptual framing to relate the concepts for management purposes. A better understanding of these concepts will allow system planners to pursue management strategies best suited to their unique system dynamics and specific objectives of 'goodness' that all these concepts bring.
△ Less
Submitted 24 August, 2020; v1 submitted 22 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.