-
A multiscale hybrid Maxwellian-Monte-Carlo Coulomb collision algorithm for particle simulations
Authors:
G. Chen,
A. J. Stanier,
L. Chacón,
S. E. Anderson,
B. Philip
Abstract:
Coulomb collisions in particle simulations for weakly coupled plasmas are modeled by the Landau-Fokker-Planck equation, which is typically solved by Monte-Carlo (MC) methods. One of the main disadvantages of MC is the timestep accuracy constraint νΔt << 1 to resolve the collision frequency ν. The constraint becomes extremely stringent for self-collisions in the presence of high charge state specie…
▽ More
Coulomb collisions in particle simulations for weakly coupled plasmas are modeled by the Landau-Fokker-Planck equation, which is typically solved by Monte-Carlo (MC) methods. One of the main disadvantages of MC is the timestep accuracy constraint νΔt << 1 to resolve the collision frequency ν. The constraint becomes extremely stringent for self-collisions in the presence of high charge state species and for inter-species collisions with large mass disparities (such as present in Inertial Confinement Fusion hohlraums), rendering long-time-scale simulations prohibitively expensive or impractical. To overcome these difficulties, we explore a hybrid Maxwellian-MC (HMMC) model for particle simulations. Specifically, we devise a collisional algorithm that describes weakly collisional species with particles, and highly collisional species and fluid components with Maxwellians. We employ the Lemons method for particle-Maxwellian collisions, enhanced with a more careful treatment of low-relative-speed particles, and a five-moment model for Maxwellian-Maxwellian collisions. Particle-particle binary collisions are dealt with classic Takizuka-Abe MC, which we extend to accommodate arbitrary particle weights to deal with large density disparities without compromising conservation properties. HMMC is strictly conservative and significantly outperforms standard MC methods in situations with large mass disparities among species or large charge states, demonstrating orders of magnitude improvement in computational efficiency. We will substantiate the accuracy and performance of the proposed method with several examples of varying complexity, including both zero-dimensional relaxation and one-dimensional transport problems, the latter using a hybrid kinetic-ion/fluid-electron model.
△ Less
Submitted 13 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Earth's Alfvén wings driven by the April 2023 Coronal Mass Ejection
Authors:
Li-Jen Chen,
Daniel Gershman,
Brandon Burkholder,
Yuxi Chen,
Menelaos Sarantos,
Lan Jian,
James Drake,
Chuanfei Dong,
Harsha Gurram,
Jason Shuster,
Daniel Graham,
Olivier Le Contel,
Steven Schwartz,
Stephen Fuselier,
Hadi Madanian,
Craig Pollock,
Haoming Liang,
Matthew Argall,
Richard Denton,
Rachel Rice,
Jason Beedle,
Kevin Genestreti,
Akhtar Ardakani,
Adam Stanier,
Ari Le
, et al. (11 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report a rare regime of Earth's magnetosphere interaction with sub-Alfvénic solar wind in which the windsock-like magnetosphere transforms into one with Alfvén wings. In the magnetic cloud of a Coronal Mass Ejection (CME) on April 24, 2023, NASA's Magnetospheric Multiscale mission distinguishes the following features: (1) unshocked and accelerated cold CME plasma coming directly against Earth's…
▽ More
We report a rare regime of Earth's magnetosphere interaction with sub-Alfvénic solar wind in which the windsock-like magnetosphere transforms into one with Alfvén wings. In the magnetic cloud of a Coronal Mass Ejection (CME) on April 24, 2023, NASA's Magnetospheric Multiscale mission distinguishes the following features: (1) unshocked and accelerated cold CME plasma coming directly against Earth's dayside magnetosphere; (2) dynamical wing filaments representing new channels of magnetic connection between the magnetosphere and foot points of the Sun's erupted flux rope; (3) cold CME ions observed with energized counter-streaming electrons, evidence of CME plasma captured due to reconnection between magnetic-cloud and Alfvén-wing field lines. The reported measurements advance our knowledge of CME interaction with planetary magnetospheres, and open new opportunities to understand how sub-Alfvénic plasma flows impact astrophysical bodies such as Mercury, moons of Jupiter, and exoplanets close to their host stars.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2024; v1 submitted 12 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Intermittent Electron-Only Reconnection at Lunar Mini-Magnetospheres
Authors:
Adam Stanier,
Li-Jen Chen,
Ari Le,
Jasper Halekas,
Rhyan Sawyer
Abstract:
Lunar crustal magnetic anomalies (LCMA) are sub-ion-gyroradius structures that have been shown to stand off the solar wind (SW) plasma from the Moon's surface, forming shock-like discontinuities and reflecting incident SW protons. In this letter, the results of high-resolution, two-dimensional fully kinetic simulations show a bursty electron-only magnetic reconnection in the SW-LCMA interaction re…
▽ More
Lunar crustal magnetic anomalies (LCMA) are sub-ion-gyroradius structures that have been shown to stand off the solar wind (SW) plasma from the Moon's surface, forming shock-like discontinuities and reflecting incident SW protons. In this letter, the results of high-resolution, two-dimensional fully kinetic simulations show a bursty electron-only magnetic reconnection in the SW-LCMA interaction region, characterized by the quasi-periodic formation and ejection of magnetic islands and strong parallel electron flows along the X-point separator lines. The islands are observed to modify the magnetic pressure pile-up and Hall electric field above the LCMA, leading to sharp increases in reflected protons that drive electromagnetic fluctuations downstream and short distances upstream in the SW.
△ Less
Submitted 2 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Hybrid-VPIC: an Open-Source Kinetic/Fluid Hybrid Particle-in-Cell Code
Authors:
Ari Le,
Adam Stanier,
Lin Yin,
Blake Wetherton,
Brett Keenan,
Brian Albright
Abstract:
Hybrid-VPIC is an extension of the open-source high-performance particle-in-cell (PIC) code VPIC incorporating hybrid kinetic ion/fluid electron solvers. This paper describes the models that are available in the code and gives an overview of applications of the code to space and laboratory plasma physics problems. Particular choices in how the hybrid solvers were implemented are documented for ref…
▽ More
Hybrid-VPIC is an extension of the open-source high-performance particle-in-cell (PIC) code VPIC incorporating hybrid kinetic ion/fluid electron solvers. This paper describes the models that are available in the code and gives an overview of applications of the code to space and laboratory plasma physics problems. Particular choices in how the hybrid solvers were implemented are documented for reference by users. A few solutions for handling numerical complications particular to hybrid codes are also described. Special emphasis is given to the computationally taxing problem of modeling mix in collisional high-energy-density regimes, for which more accurate electron fluid transport coefficients have been implemented for the first time in a hybrid PIC code.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Kinetic Simulations Verifying Reconnection Rates Measured in the Laboratory, Spanning the Ion-Coupled to Near Electron-Only Regimes
Authors:
Samuel Greess,
Jan Egedal,
Adam Stanier,
Joseph Olson,
William Daughton,
Ari Lê,
Alex Millet-Ayala,
Cameron Kutcha,
Cary Forest
Abstract:
The rate of reconnection characterizes how quickly flux and mass can move into and out of the reconnection region. In the Terrestrial Reconnection EXperiment (TREX), the rate at which antiparallel asymmetric reconnection occurs is modulated by the presence of a shock and a region of flux pileup in the high-density inflow. Simulations utilizing a generalized Harris-sheet geometry have tentatively s…
▽ More
The rate of reconnection characterizes how quickly flux and mass can move into and out of the reconnection region. In the Terrestrial Reconnection EXperiment (TREX), the rate at which antiparallel asymmetric reconnection occurs is modulated by the presence of a shock and a region of flux pileup in the high-density inflow. Simulations utilizing a generalized Harris-sheet geometry have tentatively shown agreement with TREX's measured reconnection rate scaling relative to system size, which is indicative of the transition from ion-coupled toward electron-only reconnection. Here we present simulations tailored to reproduce the specific TREX geometry, which confirm both the reconnection rate scale as well as the shock jump conditions previously characterized experimentally in TREX. The simulations also establish an interplay between the reconnection layer and the Alfvénic expansions of the background plasma associated with the energization of the TREX drive coils; this interplay has not yet been experimentally observed.
△ Less
Submitted 10 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Hybrid codes (massless electron fluid)
Authors:
D. Winske,
Homa Karimabadi,
Ari Le,
N. Omidi,
Vadim Roytershteyn,
Adam Stanier
Abstract:
Hybrid codes are widely used to model ion-scale phenomena in space plasmas. Hybrid codes differ from full particle (PIC) codes in that the electrons are modeled as a fluid that is usually assumed to be massless, while the electric field is not advanced in time, but instead calculated at the new time level from the advanced ion quantities and the magnetic field. In this chapter we concentrate on su…
▽ More
Hybrid codes are widely used to model ion-scale phenomena in space plasmas. Hybrid codes differ from full particle (PIC) codes in that the electrons are modeled as a fluid that is usually assumed to be massless, while the electric field is not advanced in time, but instead calculated at the new time level from the advanced ion quantities and the magnetic field. In this chapter we concentrate on such hybrid models with massless electrons, beginning with a discussion of the basics of a simple hybrid code algorithm. We then show examples of recent use of hybrid codes for large-scale space plasma simulations of structures formed at planetary bow shock--foreshock systems, magnetic reconnection at the magnetopause, and complex phenomena in the magnetosheath due to the interaction of kinetic processes associated with the bow shock, magnetic reconnection, and turbulence. A discussion then follows of a number of other hybrid codes based on different algorithms that are presently in active use to investigate a variety of plasma processes in space as well as some recent work on the development of new models. We conclude with a few brief comments concerning the future development and use of hybrid codes.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Magnetic reconnection in the era of exascale computing and multiscale experiments
Authors:
Hantao Ji,
William Daughton,
Jonathan Jara-Almonte,
Ari Le,
Adam Stanier,
Jongsoo Yoo
Abstract:
Astrophysical plasmas have the remarkable ability to preserve magnetic topology, which inevitably gives rise to the accumulation of magnetic energy within stressed regions including current sheets. This stored energy is often released explosively through the process of magnetic reconnection, which produces a reconfiguration of the magnetic field, along with high-speed flows, thermal heating, and n…
▽ More
Astrophysical plasmas have the remarkable ability to preserve magnetic topology, which inevitably gives rise to the accumulation of magnetic energy within stressed regions including current sheets. This stored energy is often released explosively through the process of magnetic reconnection, which produces a reconfiguration of the magnetic field, along with high-speed flows, thermal heating, and nonthermal particle acceleration. Either collisional or kinetic dissipation mechanisms are required to overcome the topological constraints, both of which have been predicted by theory and validated with in situ spacecraft observations or laboratory experiments. However, major challenges remain in understanding magnetic reconnection in large systems, such as the solar corona, where the collisionality is weak and the kinetic scales are vanishingly small in comparison to macroscopic scales. The plasmoid instability or formation of multiple plasmoids in long reconnecting current sheets is one possible multiscale solution for bridging this vast range of scales, and new laboratory experiments are poised to study these regimes. In conjunction with these efforts, we anticipate that the coming era of exascale computing, together with the next generation of observational capabilities, will enable new progress on a range of challenging problems, including the energy build-up and onset of reconnection, partially ionized regimes, the influence of magnetic turbulence, and particle acceleration.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Direct measurement of non-thermal electron acceleration from magnetically driven reconnection in a laboratory plasma
Authors:
Abraham Chien,
Lan Gao,
Shu Zhang,
Hantao Ji,
Eric G. Blackman,
William Daughton,
Adam Stanier,
Ari Le,
Fan Guo,
Russ Follett,
Hui Chen,
Gennady Fiksel,
Gabriel Bleotu,
Robert C. Cauble,
Sophia N. Chen,
Alice Fazzini,
Kirk Flippo,
Omar French,
Dustin H. Froula,
Julien Fuchs,
Shinsuke Fujioka,
Kenneth Hill,
Sallee Klein,
Carolyn Kuranz,
Philip Nilson
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Magnetic reconnection is a ubiquitous astrophysical process that rapidly converts magnetic energy into some combination of plasma flow energy, thermal energy, and non-thermal energetic particles, including energetic electrons. Various reconnection acceleration mechanisms in different low-$β$ (plasma-to-magnetic pressure ratio) and collisionless environments have been proposed theoretically and stu…
▽ More
Magnetic reconnection is a ubiquitous astrophysical process that rapidly converts magnetic energy into some combination of plasma flow energy, thermal energy, and non-thermal energetic particles, including energetic electrons. Various reconnection acceleration mechanisms in different low-$β$ (plasma-to-magnetic pressure ratio) and collisionless environments have been proposed theoretically and studied numerically, including first- and second-order Fermi acceleration, betatron acceleration, parallel electric field acceleration along magnetic fields, and direct acceleration by the reconnection electric field. However, none of them have been heretofore confirmed experimentally, as the direct observation of non-thermal particle acceleration in laboratory experiments has been difficult due to short Debye lengths for \textit{in-situ} measurements and short mean free paths for \textit{ex-situ} measurements. Here we report the direct measurement of accelerated non-thermal electrons from low-$β$ magnetically driven reconnection in experiments using a laser-powered capacitor coil platform. We use kiloJoule lasers to drive parallel currents to reconnect MegaGauss-level magnetic fields in a quasi-axisymmetric geometry. The angular dependence of the measured electron energy spectrum and the resulting accelerated energies, supported by particle-in-cell simulations, indicate that the mechanism of direct electric field acceleration by the out-of-plane reconnection electric field is at work. Scaled energies using this mechanism show direct relevance to astrophysical observations. Our results therefore validate one of the proposed acceleration mechanisms by reconnection, and establish a new approach to study reconnection particle acceleration with laboratory experiments in relevant regimes.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Hybrid Paricle-in-Cell Simulations of Electromagnetic Coupling and Waves From Streaming Burst Debris
Authors:
Brett D. Keenan,
Ari Le,
Dan Winske,
Adam Stanier,
Blake Wetherton,
Misa Cowee,
Fan Guo
Abstract:
Various systems can be modeled as a point-like explosion of ionized debris into a magnetized, collisionless background plasma -- including astrophysical examples, active experiments in space, and laser-driven laboratory experiments. Debris streaming from the explosion parallel to the magnetic field may drive multiple resonant and non-resonant ion-ion beam instabilities, some of which can efficient…
▽ More
Various systems can be modeled as a point-like explosion of ionized debris into a magnetized, collisionless background plasma -- including astrophysical examples, active experiments in space, and laser-driven laboratory experiments. Debris streaming from the explosion parallel to the magnetic field may drive multiple resonant and non-resonant ion-ion beam instabilities, some of which can efficiently couple the debris energy to the background and may even support the formation of shocks. We present a large-scale hybrid (kinetic ions + fluid electrons) particle-in-cell (PIC) simulation, extending hundreds of ion inertial lengths from a 3-D explosion, that resolves these instabilities. We show that the character of these instabilities differs notably from the 1-D equivalent by the presence of unique transverse structure. Additional 2-D simulations explore how the debris beam length, width, density, and speed affect debris-background coupling, with implications for the generation of quasi-parallel shocks.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
A conservative implicit-PIC scheme for the hybrid kinetic-ion fluid-electron plasma model on curvilinear meshes
Authors:
A. Stanier,
L. Chacon
Abstract:
The hybrid kinetic-ion fluid-electron plasma model is widely used to study challenging multi-scale problems in space and laboratory plasma physics. Here, a novel conservative scheme for this model employing implicit particle-in-cell techniques is extended to arbitrary coordinate systems via curvilinear maps from logical to physical space. The scheme features a fully non-linear electromagnetic form…
▽ More
The hybrid kinetic-ion fluid-electron plasma model is widely used to study challenging multi-scale problems in space and laboratory plasma physics. Here, a novel conservative scheme for this model employing implicit particle-in-cell techniques is extended to arbitrary coordinate systems via curvilinear maps from logical to physical space. The scheme features a fully non-linear electromagnetic formulation with a multi-rate time advance - including sub-cycling and orbit-averaging for the kinetic ions. By careful choice of compatible particle-based kinetic-ion and mesh-based fluid-electron discretizations in curvilinear coordinates, as well as particle-mesh interpolations and implicit midpoint time advance, the scheme is proven to conserve total energy for arbitrary curvilinear meshes. In the electrostatic limit, the method is also proven to conserve total momentum for arbitrary curvilinear meshes. Although momentum is not conserved for arbitrary curvilinear meshes in the electromagnetic case, it is for an important subset of Cartesian tensor-packed meshes. The scheme and its novel conservation properties are demonstrated for several challenging numerical problems using different curvilinear meshes, including a merging flux-rope simulation for a space weather application, and a helical $m=1$ mode simulation for magnetic fusion energy application.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Astrophysical explosions revisited: collisionless coupling of debris to magnetized plasma
Authors:
Ari Le,
Dan Winske,
Adam Stanier,
William Daughton,
Misa Cowee,
Blake Wetherton,
Fan Guo
Abstract:
The coupling between a rapidly expanding cloud of ionized debris and an ambient magnetized plasma is revisited with a hybrid (kinetic ion/fluid electron) simulation code that allows a study over a wide range of plasma parameters. Over a specified range of hypothetical conditions, simple scaling laws in terms of the total debris mass and explosion speed are derived and verified for the maximal size…
▽ More
The coupling between a rapidly expanding cloud of ionized debris and an ambient magnetized plasma is revisited with a hybrid (kinetic ion/fluid electron) simulation code that allows a study over a wide range of plasma parameters. Over a specified range of hypothetical conditions, simple scaling laws in terms of the total debris mass and explosion speed are derived and verified for the maximal size of the debris cloud and the fraction of debris that free-streams from the burst along the magnetic field. The amount of debris that escapes from the burst with minimal coupling to the background magnetic field increases with the debris gyroradius. Test cases with two different debris species--including a heavy minority species with a relatively large gyroradius--highlight how the collisionless coupling of the debris depends on the single-particle trajectories as well as the overall conservation of energy and momentum.
△ Less
Submitted 1 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Laboratory verification of electron-scale reconnection regions modulated by a three-dimensional instability
Authors:
S. Greess,
J. Egedal,
A. Stanier,
W. Daughton,
J. Olson,
A. Lê,
R. Myers,
A. Millet-Ayala,
M. Clark,
J. Wallace,
D. Endrizzi,
C. Forest
Abstract:
During magnetic reconnection in collisionless space plasma, the electron fluid decouples from the magnetic field within narrow current layers, and theoretical models for this process can be distinguished in terms of their predicted current layer widths. From theory, the off-diagonal stress in the electron pressure tensor is related to thermal non-circular orbit motion of electrons around the magne…
▽ More
During magnetic reconnection in collisionless space plasma, the electron fluid decouples from the magnetic field within narrow current layers, and theoretical models for this process can be distinguished in terms of their predicted current layer widths. From theory, the off-diagonal stress in the electron pressure tensor is related to thermal non-circular orbit motion of electrons around the magnetic field lines. This stress becomes significant when the width of the reconnecting current layer approaches the small characteristic length scale of the electron motion. To aid in situ spacecraft and numerical investigations of reconnection, the structure of the electron diffusion region is here investigated using the Terrestrial Reconnection EXperiment (TREX). In agreement with the closely matched kinetic simulations, laboratory observations reveal the presence of electron-scale current layer widths. Although the layers are modulated by a current-driven instability, 3D simulations demonstrate that it is the off-diagonal stress that is responsible for breaking the frozen-in condition of the electron fluid.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
A drift kinetic model for the expander region of a magnetic mirror
Authors:
Blake A. Wetherton,
Ari Le,
Jan Egedal,
Cary Forest,
William Daughton,
Adam Stanier,
Stanislav Boldyrev
Abstract:
We present a drift kinetic model for the free expansion of a thermal plasma out of a magnetic nozzle. This problem relates to plasma space propulsion systems, natural environments such as the solar wind, and end losses from the expander region of mirror magnetically confined fusion concepts such as the Gas Dynamic Trap. The model incorporates trapped and passing orbit types encountered in the mirr…
▽ More
We present a drift kinetic model for the free expansion of a thermal plasma out of a magnetic nozzle. This problem relates to plasma space propulsion systems, natural environments such as the solar wind, and end losses from the expander region of mirror magnetically confined fusion concepts such as the Gas Dynamic Trap. The model incorporates trapped and passing orbit types encountered in the mirror expander geometry and maps to an upstream thermal distribution. This boundary condition and quasineutrality require the generation of an ambipolar potential drop of $\sim5 T_e/e$, forming a thermal barrier for the electrons. The model for the electron and ion velocity distributions and fluid moments is confirmed with data from a fully kinetic simulation. Finally, the model is extended to account for a population of fast sloshing ions arising from neutral beam heating within a magnetic mirror, again resulting in good agreement with a corresponding kinetic simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 4 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena in Solar and Heliospheric Plasmas
Authors:
H. Ji,
J. Karpen,
A. Alt,
S. Antiochos,
S. Baalrud,
S. Bale,
P. M. Bellan,
M. Begelman,
A. Beresnyak,
A. Bhattacharjee,
E. G. Blackman,
D. Brennan,
M. Brown,
J. Buechner,
J. Burch,
P. Cassak,
B. Chen,
L. -J. Chen,
Y. Chen,
A. Chien,
L. Comisso,
D. Craig,
J. Dahlin,
W. Daughton,
E. DeLuca
, et al. (83 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagen…
▽ More
Magnetic reconnection underlies many explosive phenomena in the heliosphere and in laboratory plasmas. The new research capabilities in theory/simulations, observations, and laboratory experiments provide the opportunity to solve the grand scientific challenges summarized in this whitepaper. Success will require enhanced and sustained investments from relevant funding agencies, increased interagency/international partnerships, and close collaborations of the solar, heliospheric, and laboratory plasma communities. These investments will deliver transformative progress in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena including space weather events.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Major Scientific Challenges and Opportunities in Understanding Magnetic Reconnection and Related Explosive Phenomena throughout the Universe
Authors:
H. Ji,
A. Alt,
S. Antiochos,
S. Baalrud,
S. Bale,
P. M. Bellan,
M. Begelman,
A. Beresnyak,
E. G. Blackman,
D. Brennan,
M. Brown,
J. Buechner,
J. Burch,
P. Cassak,
L. -J. Chen,
Y. Chen,
A. Chien,
D. Craig,
J. Dahlin,
W. Daughton,
E. DeLuca,
C. F. Dong,
S. Dorfman,
J. Drake,
F. Ebrahimi
, et al. (75 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process.
This white paper summarizes major scientific challenges and opportunities in understanding magnetic reconnection and related explosive phenomena as a fundamental plasma process.
△ Less
Submitted 31 March, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
A cancellation problem in hybrid particle-in-cell schemes due to finite particle size
Authors:
A. Stanier,
L. Chacon,
A. Le
Abstract:
The quasi-neutral hybrid particle-in-cell algorithm with kinetic ions and fluid electrons is a popular model to study multi-scale problems in laboratory, space, and astrophysical plasmas. Here, it is shown that the treatment of ions as finite-size particles and electrons as a grid-based fluid can cause significant numerical wave dispersion errors in the magnetohydrodynamic limit ($kd_i \ll 1$, whe…
▽ More
The quasi-neutral hybrid particle-in-cell algorithm with kinetic ions and fluid electrons is a popular model to study multi-scale problems in laboratory, space, and astrophysical plasmas. Here, it is shown that the treatment of ions as finite-size particles and electrons as a grid-based fluid can cause significant numerical wave dispersion errors in the magnetohydrodynamic limit ($kd_i \ll 1$, where $d_i$ is the ion skin-depth). Practical requirements on the mesh spacing $Δx/d_i$ are suggested to bound these errors from above.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Three-Dimensional Stability of Current Sheets Supported by Electron Pressure Anisotropy
Authors:
Ari Le,
Adam Stanier,
Bill Daughton,
Jonathan Ng,
Jan Egedal,
W. Dave Nystrom,
Bob Bird
Abstract:
The stability of electron current sheets embedded within the reconnection exhaust is studied with a 3D fully kinetic particle-in-cell simulation. The electron current layers studied here form self-consistently in a reconnection regime with a moderate guide field, are supported by electron pressure anisotropy with the pressure component parallel to the magnetic field direction larger than the perpe…
▽ More
The stability of electron current sheets embedded within the reconnection exhaust is studied with a 3D fully kinetic particle-in-cell simulation. The electron current layers studied here form self-consistently in a reconnection regime with a moderate guide field, are supported by electron pressure anisotropy with the pressure component parallel to the magnetic field direction larger than the perpendicular components, and extend well beyond electron kinetic scales. In 3D, in addition to drift instabilities common to nearly all reconnection exhausts, the regime considered also exhibits an electromagnetic instability driven by the electron pressure anisotropy. While the fluctuations modulate the current density on small scales, they do not break apart the general structure of the extended electron current layers. The elongated current sheets should therefore persist long enough to be observed both in space observations and in laboratory experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 7 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Formation of Power-law Electron Energy Spectra in Three-dimensional Low-$β$ Magnetic Reconnection
Authors:
Xiaocan Li,
Fan Guo,
Hui Li,
Adam Stanier,
Patrick Kilian
Abstract:
While observations have suggested that power-law electron energy spectra are a common outcome of strong energy release during magnetic reconnection, e.g., in solar flares, kinetic simulations have not been able to provide definite evidence of power-laws in energy spectra of non-relativistic reconnection. By means of 3D large-scale fully kinetic simulations, we study the formation of power-law elec…
▽ More
While observations have suggested that power-law electron energy spectra are a common outcome of strong energy release during magnetic reconnection, e.g., in solar flares, kinetic simulations have not been able to provide definite evidence of power-laws in energy spectra of non-relativistic reconnection. By means of 3D large-scale fully kinetic simulations, we study the formation of power-law electron energy spectra in non-relativistic low-$β$ reconnection. We find that both the global spectrum integrated over the entire domain and local spectra within individual regions of the reconnection layer have power-law tails with a spectral index $p \sim 4$ in the 3D simulation, which persist throughout the non-linear reconnection phase until saturation. In contrast, the spectrum in the 2D simulation rapidly evolves and quickly becomes soft. We show that 3D effects such as self-generated turbulence and chaotic magnetic field lines enable the transport of high-energy electrons across the reconnection layer and allow them to access several main acceleration regions. This leads to a sustained and nearly constant acceleration rate for electrons at different energies. We construct a model that explains the observed power-law spectral index in terms of the dynamical balance between particle acceleration and escape from main acceleration regions, which are defined based upon a threshold for the curvature drift acceleration term. This result could be important for explaining the formation of power-law energy spectrum in solar flares.
△ Less
Submitted 4 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
Influence of 3D plasmoid dynamics on the transition from collisional to kinetic reconnection
Authors:
A. Stanier,
W. Daughton,
A. Le,
X. Li,
R. Bird
Abstract:
Within the resistive magnetohydrodynamic model, high-Lundquist number reconnection layers are unstable to the plasmoid instability, leading to a turbulent evolution where the reconnection rate can be independent of the underlying resistivity. However, the physical relevance of these results remains questionable for many applications. First, the reconnection electric field is often well above the r…
▽ More
Within the resistive magnetohydrodynamic model, high-Lundquist number reconnection layers are unstable to the plasmoid instability, leading to a turbulent evolution where the reconnection rate can be independent of the underlying resistivity. However, the physical relevance of these results remains questionable for many applications. First, the reconnection electric field is often well above the runaway limit, implying that collisional resistivity is invalid. Furthermore, both theory and simulations suggest that plasmoid formation may rapidly induce a transition to kinetic scales, due to the formation of thin current sheets. Here, this problem is studied for the first time using a first-principles kinetic simulation with a Fokker-Planck collision operator in 3D. The low-$β$ reconnecting current layer thins rapidly due to Joule heating before onset of the oblique plasmoid instability. Linear growth rates for standard ($k_y = 0$) tearing modes agree with semi-collisional boundary layer theory, but the angular spectrum of oblique ($|k_y|>0$) modes is significantly narrower than predicted. In the non-linear regime, flux-ropes formed by the instability undergo complex interactions as they are advected and rotated by the reconnection outflow jets, leading to a turbulent state with stochastic magnetic field. In a manner similar to previous 2D results, super-Dreicer fields induce a transition to kinetic reconnection in thin current layers that form between flux-ropes. These results may be testable within new laboratory experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 11 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Wavelet Methods for Studying the Onset of Strong Plasma Turbulence
Authors:
Ari Le,
Vadim Roytershteyn,
Homa Karimabadi,
Adam Stanier,
Luis Chacon,
Kai Schneider
Abstract:
Wavelet basis functions are a natural tool for analyzing turbulent flows containing localized coherent structures of different spatial scales. Here, wavelets are used to study the onset and subsequent transition to fully developed turbulence from a laminar state. Originally applied to neutral fluid turbulence, an iterative wavelet technique decomposes the field into coherent and incoherent contrib…
▽ More
Wavelet basis functions are a natural tool for analyzing turbulent flows containing localized coherent structures of different spatial scales. Here, wavelets are used to study the onset and subsequent transition to fully developed turbulence from a laminar state. Originally applied to neutral fluid turbulence, an iterative wavelet technique decomposes the field into coherent and incoherent contributions. In contrast to Fourier power spectra, finite time Lyapunov exponents (FTLE), and simple measures of intermittency such as non-Gaussian statistics of field increments, the wavelet technique is found to provide a quantitative measure for the onset of turbulence and to track the transition to fully developed turbulence. The wavelet method makes no assumptions about the structure of the coherent current sheets or the underlying plasma model. Temporal evolution of the coherent and incoherent wavelet fluctuations is found to be highly correlated with the magnetic field energy and plasma thermal energy, respectively. The onset of turbulence is identified with the rapid growth of a background of incoherent fluctuations spreading across a range of scales and a corresponding drop in the coherent components. This is suggestive of the interpretation of the coherent and incoherent wavelet fluctuations as measures of coherent structures (e.g., current sheets) and dissipation, respectively. The ratio of the incoherent to coherent fluctuations $R_{ic}$ is found to be fairly uniform across different plasma models and provides an empirical threshold for turbulence onset. The technique is illustrated through examples. First, it is applied to the Kelvin--Helmholtz instability from different simulation models including fully kinetic, hybrid (kinetic ion/fluid electron), and Hall MHD simulations. Second, it is applied to the development of turbulence downstream of the bowshock in a magnetosphere simulation.
△ Less
Submitted 3 December, 2018;
originally announced December 2018.
-
Plasma Energization in Colliding Magnetic Flux Ropes
Authors:
Senbei Du,
Fan Guo,
Gary P. Zank,
Xiaocan Li,
Adam Stanier
Abstract:
Magnetic flux ropes are commonly observed throughout the heliosphere, and recent studies suggest that interacting flux ropes are associated with some energetic particle events. In this work, we carry out 2D particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations to study the coalescence of two magnetic flux ropes (or magnetic islands), and the subsequent plasma energization processes. The simulations are initialized w…
▽ More
Magnetic flux ropes are commonly observed throughout the heliosphere, and recent studies suggest that interacting flux ropes are associated with some energetic particle events. In this work, we carry out 2D particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations to study the coalescence of two magnetic flux ropes (or magnetic islands), and the subsequent plasma energization processes. The simulations are initialized with two magnetic islands embedded in a reconnecting current sheet. The two islands collide and eventually merge into a single island. Particles are accelerated during this process as the magnetic energy is released and converted to the plasma energy, including bulk kinetic energy increase by the ideal electric field, and thermal energy increase by the fluid compression and the non-ideal electric field. We find that contributions from these different energization mechanisms are all important and comparable with each other. Fluid shear and a non-gyrotropic pressure tensor also contribute to the energy conversion process. For simulations with different box sizes ranging from $L_x \sim 25$--$100 d_i$ and ion-to-electron mass ratios $m_i / m_e = 25$, 100 and 400, we find that the general evolution is qualitatively the same for all runs, and the energization depends only weakly on either the system size or the mass ratio. The results may help us understand plasma energization in solar and heliospheric environments.
△ Less
Submitted 21 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
-
A fully implicit, conservative, non-linear, electromagnetic hybrid particle-ion/fluid-electron algorithm
Authors:
A. Stanier,
L. Chacón,
G. Chen
Abstract:
The quasi-neutral hybrid model with kinetic ions and fluid electrons is a promising approach for bridging the inherent multi-scale nature of many problems in space and laboratory plasmas. Here, a novel, implicit, particle-in-cell based scheme for the hybrid model is derived for multi-dimensional electromagnetic problems with multiple ion species, which features global mass, momentum and energy con…
▽ More
The quasi-neutral hybrid model with kinetic ions and fluid electrons is a promising approach for bridging the inherent multi-scale nature of many problems in space and laboratory plasmas. Here, a novel, implicit, particle-in-cell based scheme for the hybrid model is derived for multi-dimensional electromagnetic problems with multiple ion species, which features global mass, momentum and energy conservation. The scheme includes sub-cycling and orbit averaging of the ions, with cell-centered finite differences and implicit midpoint time advance. To reduce discrete particle noise, the scheme allows arbitrary-order shape functions for the particle-mesh interpolations and the application of conservative binomial smoothing. The algorithm is verified for a number of test problems to demonstrate the correctness of the implementation, the unique conservation properties, and the favorable stability properties of the new scheme. In particular, there is no indication of unstable growth of the finite-grid instability for a population of cold ions drifting through a uniform spatial mesh, in a set-up where several commonly used non-conservative schemes are highly unstable.
△ Less
Submitted 19 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
Overview of recent physics results from MAST
Authors:
A Kirk,
J Adamek,
RJ Akers,
S Allan,
L Appel,
F Arese Lucini,
M Barnes,
T Barrett,
N Ben Ayed,
W Boeglin,
J Bradley,
P K Browning,
J Brunner,
P Cahyna,
M Carr,
F Casson,
M Cecconello,
C Challis,
IT Chapman,
S Chapman,
S Conroy,
N Conway,
WA Cooper,
M Cox,
N Crocker
, et al. (138 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
New results from MAST are presented that focus on validating models in order to extrapolate to future devices. Measurements during start-up experiments have shown how the bulk ion temperature rise scales with the square of the reconnecting field. During the current ramp up models are not able to correctly predict the current diffusion. Experiments have been performed looking at edge and core turbu…
▽ More
New results from MAST are presented that focus on validating models in order to extrapolate to future devices. Measurements during start-up experiments have shown how the bulk ion temperature rise scales with the square of the reconnecting field. During the current ramp up models are not able to correctly predict the current diffusion. Experiments have been performed looking at edge and core turbulence. At the edge detailed studies have revealed how filament characteristic are responsible for determining the near and far SOL density profiles. In the core the intrinsic rotation and electron scale turbulence have been measured. The role that the fast ion gradient has on redistributing fast ions through fishbone modes has led to a redesign of the neutral beam injector on MAST Upgrade. In H-mode the turbulence at the pedestal top has been shown to be consistent with being due to electron temperature gradient modes. A reconnection process appears to occur during ELMs and the number of filaments released determines the power profile at the divertor. Resonant magnetic perturbations can mitigate ELMs provided the edge peeling response is maximised and the core kink response minimised. The mitigation of intrinsic error fields with toroidal mode number n>1 has been shown to be important for plasma performance.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
The role of guide field in magnetic reconnection driven by island coalescence
Authors:
A. Stanier,
W. Daughton,
Andrei N. Simakov,
L. Chacon,
A. Le,
H. Karimabadi,
Jonathan Ng,
A. Bhattacharjee
Abstract:
A number of studies have considered how the rate of magnetic reconnection scales in large and weakly collisional systems by the modelling of long reconnecting current sheets. However, this set-up neglects both the formation of the current sheet and the coupling between the diffusion region and a larger system that supplies the magnetic flux. Recent studies of magnetic island merging, which natural…
▽ More
A number of studies have considered how the rate of magnetic reconnection scales in large and weakly collisional systems by the modelling of long reconnecting current sheets. However, this set-up neglects both the formation of the current sheet and the coupling between the diffusion region and a larger system that supplies the magnetic flux. Recent studies of magnetic island merging, which naturally include these features, have found that ion kinetic physics is crucial to describe the reconnection rate and global evolution of such systems. In this paper, the effect of a guide field on reconnection during island merging is considered. In contrast to the earlier current sheet studies, we identify a limited range of guide fields for which the reconnection rate, outflow velocity, and pile-up magnetic field increase in magnitude as the guide field increases. The Hall-MHD fluid model is found to reproduce kinetic reconnection rates only for a sufficiently strong guide field, for which ion inertia breaks the frozen-in condition and the outflow becomes Alfvenic in the kinetic system. The merging of large islands occurs on a longer timescale in the zero guide field limit, which may in part be due to a mirror-like instability that occurs upstream of the reconnection region.
△ Less
Submitted 17 November, 2016;
originally announced November 2016.
-
The island coalescence problem: scaling of reconnection in extended fluid models including higher-order moments
Authors:
Jonathan Ng,
Yi-Min Huang,
Ammar Hakim,
Amitava Bhattacharjee,
Adam Stanier,
William Daughton,
Liang Wang,
Kai Germaschewski
Abstract:
As modeling of collisionless magnetic reconnection in most space plasmas with realistic parameters is beyond the capability of today's simulations, due to the separation between global and kinetic length scales, it is important to establish scaling relations in model problems so as to extrapolate to realistic scales. Recently, large scale particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations of island coalescence ha…
▽ More
As modeling of collisionless magnetic reconnection in most space plasmas with realistic parameters is beyond the capability of today's simulations, due to the separation between global and kinetic length scales, it is important to establish scaling relations in model problems so as to extrapolate to realistic scales. Recently, large scale particle-in-cell (PIC) simulations of island coalescence have shown that the time averaged reconnection rate decreases with system size, while fluid systems at such large scales in the Hall regime have not been studied. Here we perform the complementary resistive MHD, Hall MHD and two fluid simulations using a ten-moment model with the same geometry. In contrast to the standard Harris sheet reconnection problem, Hall MHD is insufficient to capture the physics of the reconnection region. Additionally, motivated by the results of a recent set of hybrid simulations which show the importance of ion kinetics in this geometry, we evaluate the efficacy of the ten-moment model in reproducing such results.
△ Less
Submitted 2 November, 2015;
originally announced November 2015.
-
Two-fluid and magnetohydrodynamic modelling of magnetic reconnection in the MAST spherical tokamak and the solar corona
Authors:
P. K. Browning,
S. Cardnell,
M. Evans,
F. Arese Lucini,
V. S. Lukin,
K. G. McClements,
A. Stanier
Abstract:
Twisted magnetic flux ropes are ubiquitous in space and laboratory plasmas, and the merging of such flux ropes through magnetic reconnection is an important mechanism for restructuring magnetic fields and releasing free magnetic energy. The merging-compression scenario is one possible start up scheme for spherical tokamaks, which has been used on the Mega Amp Spherical Tokamak MAST. Two current-ca…
▽ More
Twisted magnetic flux ropes are ubiquitous in space and laboratory plasmas, and the merging of such flux ropes through magnetic reconnection is an important mechanism for restructuring magnetic fields and releasing free magnetic energy. The merging-compression scenario is one possible start up scheme for spherical tokamaks, which has been used on the Mega Amp Spherical Tokamak MAST. Two current-carrying plasma rings, or flux ropes, approach each other through the mutual attraction of their like currents, and merge, through magnetic reconnection, into a single plasma torus, with substantial plasma heating. 2D resistive MHD and Hall MHD simulations of this process are reported, and new results for the temperature distribution of ions and electrons are presented. A model of the based on relaxation theory is also described, which is now extended to tight aspect ratio geometry. This model allows prediction of the final merged state and the heating. The implications of the relaxation model for heating of the solar corona are also discussed, and a model of the merger of two or more twisted coronal flux ropes is presented, allowing for different senses of twist.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2015;
originally announced July 2015.
-
Fluid vs. kinetic magnetic reconnection with strong guide-fields
Authors:
A. Stanier,
Andrei N. Simakov,
L. Chacon,
W. Daughton
Abstract:
The fast rates of magnetic reconnection found in both nature and experiments are important to understand theoretically. Recently, it was demonstrated that two-fluid magnetic reconnection remains fast in the strong guide field regime, regardless of the presence of fast-dispersive waves. This conclusion is in agreement with recent results from kinetic simulations, and is in contradiction to the find…
▽ More
The fast rates of magnetic reconnection found in both nature and experiments are important to understand theoretically. Recently, it was demonstrated that two-fluid magnetic reconnection remains fast in the strong guide field regime, regardless of the presence of fast-dispersive waves. This conclusion is in agreement with recent results from kinetic simulations, and is in contradiction to the findings in an earlier two-fluid study, where it was suggested that fast-dispersive waves are necessary for fast reconnection. In this paper, we give a more detailed derivation of the analytic model presented in a recent letter, and present additional simulation results to support the conclusions that the magnetic reconnection rate in this regime is independent of both collisional dissipation and system-size. In particular, we present a detailed comparison between fluid and kinetic simulations, finding good agreement in both the reconnection rate and overall length of the current layer. Finally, we revisit the earlier two-fluid study, which arrived at different conclusions, and suggest an alternative interpretation for the numerical results presented therein.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
Two-fluid simulations of driven reconnection in the Mega-Ampere Spherical Tokamak
Authors:
A. Stanier,
P. Browning,
M. Gordovskyy,
K. G. McClements,
M. P. Gryaznevich,
V. S. Lukin
Abstract:
In the merging-compression method of plasma start-up, two flux-ropes with parallel toroidal current are formed around in-vessel poloidal field coils, before merging to form a spherical tokamak plasma. This start-up method, used in the Mega-Ampere Spherical Tokamak (MAST), is studied as a high Lundquist number and low plasma-beta magnetic reconnection experiment.
In this paper, 2D fluid simulatio…
▽ More
In the merging-compression method of plasma start-up, two flux-ropes with parallel toroidal current are formed around in-vessel poloidal field coils, before merging to form a spherical tokamak plasma. This start-up method, used in the Mega-Ampere Spherical Tokamak (MAST), is studied as a high Lundquist number and low plasma-beta magnetic reconnection experiment.
In this paper, 2D fluid simulations are presented of this merging process in order to understand the underlying physics, and better interpret the experimental data. These simulations examine the individual and combined effects of tight-aspect ratio geometry and two-fluid physics on the merging. The ideal self-driven flux-rope dynamics are coupled to the diffusion layer physics, resulting in a large range of phenomena. For resistive MHD simulations, the flux-ropes enter the sloshing regime for normalised resistivity eta < 1E-5. In Hall-MHD three regimes are found for the qualitative behaviour of the current sheet, depending on the ratio of the current sheet width to the ion-sound radius. These are a stable collisional regime, an open X-point regime, and an intermediate regime that is highly unstable to tearing-type instabilities.
In toroidal axisymmetric geometry, the final state after merging is a MAST-like spherical tokamak with nested flux-surfaces. It is also shown that the evolution of simulated 1D radial density profiles closely resembles the Thomson scattering electron density measurements in MAST. An intuitive explanation for the origin of the measured density structures is proposed, based upon the results of the toroidal Hall-MHD simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 13 August, 2013;
originally announced August 2013.
