-
A stop** criterion for iterative proton CT image reconstruction based on correlated noise properties
Authors:
Ethan A. DeJongh,
Alexander A. Pryanichnikov,
Don F. DeJongh,
Reinhard W. Schulte
Abstract:
Background: Whereas filtered back projection algorithms for voxel-based CT image reconstruction have noise properties defined by the filter, iterative algorithms must stop at some point in their convergence and do not necessarily produce consistent noise properties for images with different degrees of heterogeneity. Purpose: A least-squares iterative algorithm for pCT image reconstruction converge…
▽ More
Background: Whereas filtered back projection algorithms for voxel-based CT image reconstruction have noise properties defined by the filter, iterative algorithms must stop at some point in their convergence and do not necessarily produce consistent noise properties for images with different degrees of heterogeneity. Purpose: A least-squares iterative algorithm for pCT image reconstruction converges toward a unique solution for RSP that optimally fits the protons. We present a stop** criterion that delivers solutions with the property that correlations of RSP noise between voxels are relatively low. This provides a method to produce pCT images with consistent noise properties useful for proton therapy treatment planning, which relies on summing RSP along lines of voxels. Methods: With simulated and real images with varying heterogeneity from a prototype clinical proton imaging system, we calculate average RSP correlations between voxel pairs in uniform regions-of-interest versus distance between voxels. We define a parameter r, the remaining distance to the unique solution relative to estimated RSP noise, and our stop** criterion is based on r falling below a chosen value. Results: We find large correlations between voxels for larger values of r, and anticorrelations for smaller values. For r in the range of 0.5 to 1, voxels are relatively uncorrelated, and compared to smaller values of r have lower noise with only slight loss of spatial resolution. Conclusions: Iterative algorithms not using a specific metric or rationale for stop** iterations may produce images with an unknown and arbitrary level of convergence or smoothing. We resolve this issue by stop** iterations when r reaches the range of 0.5 to 1. This defines a pCT image reconstruction method with consistent statistical properties optimal for clinical use, including for treatment planning with pCT images.
△ Less
Submitted 18 July, 2023; v1 submitted 13 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Developments in Mathematical Algorithms and Computational Tools for Proton CT and Particle Therapy Treatment Planning
Authors:
Yair Censor,
Keith E. Schubert,
Reinhard W. Schulte
Abstract:
We summarize recent results and ongoing activities in mathematical algorithms and computer science methods related to proton computed tomography (pCT) and intensity-modulated particle therapy (IMPT) treatment planning. Proton therapy necessitates a high level of delivery accuracy to exploit the selective targeting imparted by the Bragg peak. For this purpose, pCT utilizes the proton beam itself to…
▽ More
We summarize recent results and ongoing activities in mathematical algorithms and computer science methods related to proton computed tomography (pCT) and intensity-modulated particle therapy (IMPT) treatment planning. Proton therapy necessitates a high level of delivery accuracy to exploit the selective targeting imparted by the Bragg peak. For this purpose, pCT utilizes the proton beam itself to create images. The technique works by sending a low-intensity beam of protons through the patient and measuring the position, direction, and energy loss of each exiting proton. The pCT technique allows reconstruction of the volumetric distribution of the relative stop** power (RSP) of the patient tissues for use in treatment planning and pre-treatment range verification. We have investigated new ways to make the reconstruction both efficient and accurate. Better accuracy of RSP also enables more robust inverse approaches to IMPT. For IMPT, we developed a framework for performing intensity-modulation of the proton pencil beams. We expect that these developments will lead to additional project work in the years to come, which requires a regular exchange between experts in the fields of mathematics, computer science, and medical physics. We have initiated such an exchange by organizing annual workshops on pCT and IMPT algorithm and technology developments. This report is, admittedly, tilted toward our interdisciplinary work and methods. We offer a comprehensive overview of results, problems, and challenges in pCT and IMPT with the aim of making other scientists wanting to tackle such issues and to strengthen their interdisciplinary collaboration by bringing together cutting-edge know-how from medicine, computer science, physics, and mathematics to bear on medical physics problems at hand.
△ Less
Submitted 21 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
A Comparison of Proton Stop** Power Measured with Proton CT and x-ray CT in Fresh Post-Mortem Porcine Structures
Authors:
Don F. DeJongh,
Ethan A. DeJongh,
Victor Rykalin,
Greg DeFillippo,
Mark Pankuch,
Andrew W. Best,
George Coutrakon,
Kirk L. Duffin,
Nicholas T. Karonis,
Caesar E. Ordoñez,
Christina Sarosiek,
Reinhard W. Schulte,
John R. Winans,
Alec M. Block,
Courtney L. Hentz,
James S. Welsh
Abstract:
Purpose: Currently, calculations of proton range in proton therapy patients are based on a conversion of CT Hounsfield Units of patient tissues into proton relative stop** power. Uncertainties in this conversion necessitate larger proximal and distal planned target volume margins. Proton CT can potentially reduce these uncertainties by directly measuring proton stop** power. We aim to demonstr…
▽ More
Purpose: Currently, calculations of proton range in proton therapy patients are based on a conversion of CT Hounsfield Units of patient tissues into proton relative stop** power. Uncertainties in this conversion necessitate larger proximal and distal planned target volume margins. Proton CT can potentially reduce these uncertainties by directly measuring proton stop** power. We aim to demonstrate proton CT imaging with complex porcine samples, to analyze in detail three-dimensional regions of interest, and to compare proton stop** powers directly measured by proton CT to those determined from x-ray CT scans.
Methods: We have used a prototype proton imaging system with single proton tracking to acquire proton radiography and proton CT images of a sample of porcine pectoral girdle and ribs, and a pig's head. We also acquired close in time x-ray CT scans of the same samples, and compared proton stop** power measurements from the two modalities. In the case of the pig's head, we obtained x-ray CT scans from two different scanners, and compared results from high-dose and low-dose settings.
Results: Comparing our reconstructed proton CT images with images derived from x-ray CT scans, we find agreement within 1% to 2% for soft tissues, and discrepancies of up to 6% for compact bone. We also observed large discrepancies, up to 40%, for cavitated regions with mixed content of air, soft tissue, and bone, such as sinus cavities or tympanic bullae.
Conclusions: Our images and findings from a clinically realistic proton CT scanner demonstrate the potential for proton CT to be used for low-dose treatment planning with reduced margins.
△ Less
Submitted 29 October, 2021; v1 submitted 11 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
An Improved Method of Total Variation Superiorization Applied to Reconstruction in Proton Computed Tomography
Authors:
Blake Schultze,
Yair Censor,
Paniz Karbasi,
Keith E. Schubert,
Reinhard W. Schulte
Abstract:
Previous work showed that total variation superiorization (TVS) improves reconstructed image quality in proton computed tomography (pCT). The structure of the TVS algorithm has evolved since then and this work investigated if this new algorithmic structure provides additional benefits to pCT image quality. Structural and parametric changes introduced to the original TVS algorithm included: (1) inc…
▽ More
Previous work showed that total variation superiorization (TVS) improves reconstructed image quality in proton computed tomography (pCT). The structure of the TVS algorithm has evolved since then and this work investigated if this new algorithmic structure provides additional benefits to pCT image quality. Structural and parametric changes introduced to the original TVS algorithm included: (1) inclusion or exclusion of TV reduction requirement, (2) a variable number, $N$, of TV perturbation steps per feasibility-seeking iteration, and (3) introduction of a perturbation kernel $0<α<1$. The structural change of excluding the TV reduction requirement check tended to have a beneficial effect for $3\le N\le 6$ and allows full parallelization of the TVS algorithm. Repeated perturbations per feasibility-seeking iterations reduced total variation (TV) and material dependent standard deviations for $3\le N\le 6$. The perturbation kernel $α$, equivalent to $α=0.5$ in the original TVS algorithm, reduced TV and standard deviations as $α$ was increased beyond $α=0.5$, but negatively impacted reconstructed relative stop** power (RSP) values for $α>0.75$. The reductions in TV and standard deviations allowed feasibility-seeking with a larger relaxation parameter $λ$ than previously used, without the corresponding increases in standard deviations experienced with the original TVS algorithm. This work demonstrates that the modifications related to the evolution of the original TVS algorithm provide benefits in terms of both pCT image quality and computational efficiency for appropriately chosen parameter values.
△ Less
Submitted 17 January, 2019; v1 submitted 3 March, 2018;
originally announced March 2018.
-
A Highly Accelerated Parallel Multi-GPU based Reconstruction Algorithm for Generating Accurate Relative Stop** Powers
Authors:
Paniz Karbasi,
Ritchie Cai,
Blake Schultze,
Hanh Nguyen,
Jones Reed,
Patrick Hall,
Valentina Giacometti,
Vladimir Bashkirov,
Robert Johnson,
Nick Karonis,
Jeffrey Olafsen,
Caesar Ordonez,
Keith E. Schubert,
Reinhard W. Schulte
Abstract:
Low-dose Proton Computed Tomography (pCT) is an evolving imaging modality that is used in proton therapy planning which addresses the range uncertainty problem. The goal of pCT is generating a 3D map of Relative Stop** Power (RSP) measurements with high accuracy within clinically required time frames. Generating accurate RSP values within the shortest amount of time is considered a key goal when…
▽ More
Low-dose Proton Computed Tomography (pCT) is an evolving imaging modality that is used in proton therapy planning which addresses the range uncertainty problem. The goal of pCT is generating a 3D map of Relative Stop** Power (RSP) measurements with high accuracy within clinically required time frames. Generating accurate RSP values within the shortest amount of time is considered a key goal when develo** a pCT software. The existing pCT softwares have successfully met this time frame and even succeeded this time goal, but requiring clusters with hundreds of processors.
This paper describes a novel reconstruction technique using two Graphics Processing Unit (GPU) cores, such as is available on a single Nvidia P100. The proposed reconstruction technique is tested on both simulated and experimental datasets and on two different systems namely Nvidia K40 and P100 GPUs from IBM and Cray. The experimental results demonstrate that our proposed reconstruction method meets both the timing and accuracy with the benefit of having reasonable cost, and efficient use of power.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Results from a Prototype Proton-CT Head Scanner
Authors:
R. P. Johnson,
V. A. Bashkirov,
G. Coutrakon,
V. Giacometti,
P. Karbasi,
N. T. Karonis,
C. E. Ordoñez,
M. Pankuch,
H. F. -W. Sadrozinski,
K. E. Schubert,
R. W. Schulte
Abstract:
We are exploring low-dose proton radiography and computed tomography (pCT) as techniques to improve the accuracy of proton treatment planning and to provide artifact-free images for verification and adaptive therapy at the time of treatment. Here we report on comprehensive beam test results with our prototype pCT head scanner. The detector system and data acquisition attain a sustained rate of mor…
▽ More
We are exploring low-dose proton radiography and computed tomography (pCT) as techniques to improve the accuracy of proton treatment planning and to provide artifact-free images for verification and adaptive therapy at the time of treatment. Here we report on comprehensive beam test results with our prototype pCT head scanner. The detector system and data acquisition attain a sustained rate of more than a million protons individually measured per second, allowing a full CT scan to be completed in six minutes or less of beam time. In order to assess the performance of the scanner for proton radiography as well as computed tomography, we have performed numerous scans of phantoms at the Northwestern Medicine Chicago Proton Center including a custom phantom designed to assess the spatial resolution, a phantom to assess the measurement of relative stop** power, and a dosimetry phantom. Some images, performance, and dosimetry results from those phantom scans are presented together with a description of the instrument, the data acquisition system, and the calibration methods.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Feasibility-Seeking and Superiorization Algorithms Applied to Inverse Treatment Planning in Radiation Therapy
Authors:
R. Davidi,
Y. Censor,
R. W. Schulte,
S. Geneser,
L. Xing
Abstract:
We apply the recently proposed superiorization methodology (SM) to the inverse planning problem in radiation therapy. The inverse planning problem is represented here as a constrained minimization problem of the total variation (TV) of the intensity vector over a large system of linear two-sided inequalities. The SM can be viewed conceptually as lying between feasibility-seeking for the constraint…
▽ More
We apply the recently proposed superiorization methodology (SM) to the inverse planning problem in radiation therapy. The inverse planning problem is represented here as a constrained minimization problem of the total variation (TV) of the intensity vector over a large system of linear two-sided inequalities. The SM can be viewed conceptually as lying between feasibility-seeking for the constraints and full-fledged constrained minimization of the objective function subject to these constraints. It is based on the discovery that many feasibility-seeking algorithms (of the projection methods variety) are perturbation-resilient, and can be proactively steered toward a feasible solution of the constraints with a reduced, thus superiorized, but not necessarily minimal, objective function value.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2014;
originally announced February 2014.
-
Total variation superiorization schemes in proton computed tomography image reconstruction
Authors:
S. N. Penfold,
R. W. Schulte,
Y. Censor,
A. B. Rosenfeld
Abstract:
Purpose: Iterative projection reconstruction algorithms are currently the preferred reconstruction method in proton computed tomography (pCT). However, due to inconsistencies in the measured data arising from proton energy straggling and multiple Coulomb scattering, noise in the reconstructed image increases with successive iterations. In the current work, we investigated the use of total variatio…
▽ More
Purpose: Iterative projection reconstruction algorithms are currently the preferred reconstruction method in proton computed tomography (pCT). However, due to inconsistencies in the measured data arising from proton energy straggling and multiple Coulomb scattering, noise in the reconstructed image increases with successive iterations. In the current work, we investigated the use of total variation superiorization (TVS) schemes that can be applied as an algorithmic add-on to perturbation-resilient iterative projection algorithms for pCT image reconstruction. Methods: The block-iterative diagonally relaxed orthogonal projections (DROP) algorithm was used for reconstructing Geant4 Monte Carlo simulated pCT data sets. Two TVS schemes added on to DROP were investigated; the first carried out the superiorization steps once per cycle and the second once per block. Simplifications of these schemes, involving the elimination of the computationally expensive feasibility proximity checking step of the TVS framework, were also investigated. The modulation transfer function and contrast discrimination function were used to quantify spatial and density resolution, respectively. Results: With both TVS schemes, superior spatial and density resolution was achieved compared to the standard DROP algorithm. Eliminating the feasibility proximity check improved the image quality, in particular image noise, in the once-per-block superiorization, while also halving image reconstruction time. Overall, the greatest image quality was observed when carrying out the superiorization once-per-block and eliminating the feasibility proximity check. Conclusions: The low contrast imaging made possible with TVS holds a promise for its incorporation into our future pCT studies.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.