Showing 1–35 of 35 results for author: Schneider, T M

Natural convection in a vertical channel. Part 1. Wavenumber interaction and Eckhaus instability in a narrow domain

Authors: Zheng Zheng, Laurette S. Tuckerman, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Convection in a vertical channel subjected to a horizontal temperature gradient is numerically investigated. Previous numerical simulations reveal a variety of behaviors: steady, time-periodic and chaotic. We extend previous numerical investigations by constructing stable and unstable branches of equilibria and periodic orbits of the underlying Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations by parametric continuat… ▽ More Convection in a vertical channel subjected to a horizontal temperature gradient is numerically investigated. Previous numerical simulations reveal a variety of behaviors: steady, time-periodic and chaotic. We extend previous numerical investigations by constructing stable and unstable branches of equilibria and periodic orbits of the underlying Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations by parametric continuation. In a narrow domain of vertical aspect ratio ten, the observed flow structures are dominated by the competition between three and four co-rotating rolls. We identify the invariant solution branches underlying the observed flow dynamics, characterize the bifurcations creating those branches and link the observed bifurcation scenarios to the symmetries of the primary branches. Specifically, we show that D4 symmetry dictates that several intermediate branches bifurcate simultaneously from the four-roll branch, while D3 symmetry requires that the intersection of these intermediate branches with the three-roll branch be transcritical. We observe other manifestations of the competition between three and four rolls, in which the symmetry in time or in the transverse direction is broken, leading to limit cycles or wavy rolls, respectively. Our work highlights the interest of combining numerical simulations, bifurcation theory, and group theory, in order to understand the transitions between and origin of flow patterns. △ Less

Submitted 28 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Natural convection in a vertical channel. Part 2. Oblique solutions and global bifurcations in a spanwise-extended domain

Authors: Zheng Zheng, Laurette S. Tuckerman, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Vertical thermal convection is a non-equilibrium system in which both buoyancy and shear forces play a role in driving the convective flow. Beyond the onset of convection, the driven dissipative system exhibits chaotic dynamics and turbulence. In a three-dimensional domain extended in both the vertical and the transverse dimensions, Gao et al. (2018) have observed a variety of convection patterns… ▽ More Vertical thermal convection is a non-equilibrium system in which both buoyancy and shear forces play a role in driving the convective flow. Beyond the onset of convection, the driven dissipative system exhibits chaotic dynamics and turbulence. In a three-dimensional domain extended in both the vertical and the transverse dimensions, Gao et al. (2018) have observed a variety of convection patterns which are not described by linear stability analysis. We investigate the fully non-linear dynamics of vertical convection using a dynamical-systems approach based on the Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations. We compute the invariant solutions of these equations and the bifurcations that are responsible for the creation and termination of various branches. We map out a sequence of local bifurcations from the laminar base state, including simultaneous bifurcations involving patterned steady states with different symmetries. This atypical phenomenon of multiple branches simultaneously bifurcating from a single parent branch is explained by the role of D4 symmetry. In addition, two global bifurcations are identified: first, a homoclinic cycle from modulated transverse rolls and second, a robust heteroclinic cycle linking two symmetry-related diamond-roll patterns. These are confirmed by phase space projections as well as the functional form of the divergence of the period close to the bifurcation points. The intricacy of this bifurcation diagram highlights the essential role played by dynamical systems theory and computation in hydrodynamic configurations. △ Less

Submitted 27 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Following marginal stability manifolds in quasilinear dynamical reductions of multiscale flows in two space dimensions

Authors: Alessia Ferraro, Gregory P. Chini, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: A two-dimensional extension of a recently developed formalism for slow-fast quasilinear (QL) systems subject to fast instabilities is derived. Prior work has demonstrated that the emergent dynamics of these systems is characterized by a slow evolution of mean fields coupled to marginally stable, fast fluctuation fields. By exploiting this emergent behavior, an efficient fast-eigenvalue/slow-initia… ▽ More A two-dimensional extension of a recently developed formalism for slow-fast quasilinear (QL) systems subject to fast instabilities is derived. Prior work has demonstrated that the emergent dynamics of these systems is characterized by a slow evolution of mean fields coupled to marginally stable, fast fluctuation fields. By exploiting this emergent behavior, an efficient fast-eigenvalue/slow-initial-value solution algorithm can be developed in which the amplitude of the fast fluctuations is slaved to the slowly evolving mean fields to ensure marginal stability (and temporal scale separation) is maintained. For 2D systems that are spatially-extended in one direction, the fluctuation eigenfunctions are labeled by their wavenumbers characterizing spatial variability in that direction, and the marginal mode(s) also must coincide with the fastest-growing mode(s) over all admissible wavenumbers. Here, we introduce two equivalent procedures for deriving an ordinary differential equation governing the slow evolution of the wavenumber of the fastest-growing fluctuation mode that simultaneously must be slaved to the mean dynamics to ensure the mode has zero growth rate. We illustrate the procedure in the context of a 2D model partial differential equation that shares certain attributes with the equations governing strongly stratified shear flows. The slaved evolution follows one or more marginal stability manifolds, which constitute select state-space structures that are not invariant under the full flow dynamics yet capture quasi-coherent states in physical space in a manner analogous to invariant solutions identified in, e.g., transitionally-turbulent shear flows. Accordingly, we propose that marginal stability manifolds are central organizing structures in a dynamical systems description of certain classes of multiscale flows where scale separation justifies a QL approximation of the dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 20 March, 2024; originally announced March 2024.

Identifying invariant solutions of wall-bounded three-dimensional shear flows using robust adjoint-based variational techniques

Authors: Omid Ashtari, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations play an important role in the spatiotemporally chaotic dynamics of turbulent shear flows. Despite the significance of these solutions, their identification remains a computational challenge, rendering many solutions inaccessible and thus hindering progress towards a dynamical description of turbulence in terms of invariant solutions. We compute eq… ▽ More Invariant solutions of the Navier-Stokes equations play an important role in the spatiotemporally chaotic dynamics of turbulent shear flows. Despite the significance of these solutions, their identification remains a computational challenge, rendering many solutions inaccessible and thus hindering progress towards a dynamical description of turbulence in terms of invariant solutions. We compute equilibria of three-dimensional wall-bounded shear flows using an adjoint-based matrix-free variational approach. To address the challenge of computing pressure in the presence of solid walls, we develop a formulation that circumvents the explicit construction of pressure and instead employs the influence matrix method. Together with a data-driven convergence acceleration technique based on dynamic mode decomposition, this yields a practically feasible alternative to state-of-the-art Newton methods for converging equilibrium solutions. We compute multiple equilibria of plane Couette flow starting from inaccurate guesses extracted from a turbulent time series. The variational method outperforms Newton(-hookstep) iterations in successfully converging from poor initial guesses, suggesting a larger convergence radius. △ Less

Submitted 10 October, 2023; v1 submitted 31 May, 2023; originally announced June 2023.

Jacobian-Free Variational Method for Constructing Connecting Orbits in Nonlinear Dynamical Systems

Authors: Omid Ashtari, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: In a dynamical systems description of spatiotemporally chaotic PDEs including those describing turbulence, chaos is viewed as a trajectory evolving within a network of non-chaotic, dynamically unstable, time-invariant solutions embedded in the chaotic attractor of the system. While equilibria, periodic orbits and invariant tori can be constructed using existing methods, computations of heteroclini… ▽ More In a dynamical systems description of spatiotemporally chaotic PDEs including those describing turbulence, chaos is viewed as a trajectory evolving within a network of non-chaotic, dynamically unstable, time-invariant solutions embedded in the chaotic attractor of the system. While equilibria, periodic orbits and invariant tori can be constructed using existing methods, computations of heteroclinic and homoclinic connections mediating the evolution between the former invariant solutions remain challenging. We propose a robust matrix-free variational method for computing connecting orbits between equilibrium solutions of a dynamical system that can be applied to high-dimensional problems. Instead of a common shooting-based approach, we define a minimization problem in the space of smooth state space curves that connect the two equilibria with a cost function measuring the deviation of a connecting curve from an integral curve of the vector field. Minimization deforms a trial curve until, at a global minimum, a connecting orbit is obtained. The method is robust, has no limitation on the dimension of the unstable manifold at the origin equilibrium, and does not suffer from exponential error amplification associated with time-marching a chaotic system. Owing to adjoint-based minimization techniques, no Jacobian matrices need to be constructed and the memory requirement scales linearly with the size of the problem. The robustness of the method is demonstrated for the one-dimensional Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation. △ Less

Submitted 27 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Predicting chaotic statistics with unstable invariant tori

Authors: Jeremy P. Parker, Omid Ashtari, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: It has recently been speculated that statistical properties of chaos may be captured by weighted sums over unstable invariant tori embedded in the chaotic attractor of hyperchaotic dissipative systems; analogous to sums over periodic orbits formalized within periodic orbit theory. Using a novel numerical method for converging unstable invariant 2-tori in a chaotic PDE, we identify many quasiperiod… ▽ More It has recently been speculated that statistical properties of chaos may be captured by weighted sums over unstable invariant tori embedded in the chaotic attractor of hyperchaotic dissipative systems; analogous to sums over periodic orbits formalized within periodic orbit theory. Using a novel numerical method for converging unstable invariant 2-tori in a chaotic PDE, we identify many quasiperiodic, unstable, invariant 2-torus solutions of a modified Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation exhibiting hyperchaotic dynamics with two positive Lyapunov exponents. The set of tori covers significant parts of the chaotic attractor and weighted averages of the properties of the tori -- with weights computed based on their respective stability eigenvalues -- approximate statistics for the chaotic dynamics. These results are a step towards including higher-dimensional invariant sets in a generalized periodic orbit theory for hyperchaotic systems including spatio-temporally chaotic PDEs. △ Less

Submitted 25 January, 2023; originally announced January 2023.

Variational methods for finding periodic orbits in the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations

Authors: Jeremy P Parker, Tobias M Schneider

Abstract: Unstable periodic orbits are believed to underpin the dynamics of turbulence, but by their nature are hard to find computationally. We present a family of methods to converge such unstable periodic orbits for the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, based on variations of an integral objective functional, and using traditional gradient-based optimisation strategies. Different approaches for han… ▽ More Unstable periodic orbits are believed to underpin the dynamics of turbulence, but by their nature are hard to find computationally. We present a family of methods to converge such unstable periodic orbits for the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations, based on variations of an integral objective functional, and using traditional gradient-based optimisation strategies. Different approaches for handling the incompressibility condition are considered. The variational methods are applied to the specific case of periodic, two-dimensional Kolmogorov flow and compared against existing Newton iteration-based shooting methods. While computationally slow, our methods converge from very inaccurate initial guesses. △ Less

Submitted 4 April, 2022; v1 submitted 27 August, 2021; originally announced August 2021.

Nondestructive Prediction of the Buckling Load of Imperfect Shells

Authors: Anais Abramian, Emmanuel Virot, Emilio Lozano, Shmuel M. Rubinstein, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: From soda cans to space rockets, thin-walled cylindrical shells are abundant, offering exceptional load carrying capacity at relatively low weight. However, the actual load at which any shell buckles and collapses is very sensitive to imperceptible defects and can not be predicted, which challenges the reliable design of such structures. Consequently, probabilistic descriptions in terms of empiric… ▽ More From soda cans to space rockets, thin-walled cylindrical shells are abundant, offering exceptional load carrying capacity at relatively low weight. However, the actual load at which any shell buckles and collapses is very sensitive to imperceptible defects and can not be predicted, which challenges the reliable design of such structures. Consequently, probabilistic descriptions in terms of empirical design rules are used and reliable design requires to be very conservative. We introduce a nonlinear description where finite-amplitude perturbations trigger buckling. Drawing from the analogy between imperfect shells which buckle and imperfect pipe flow which becomes turbulent, we experimentally show that lateral probing of cylindrical shells reveals their strength non-destructively. A new ridge-tracking method is applied to commercial cylinders with a hole showing that when the location where buckling is nucleated is known we can accurately predict the buckling load of each individual shell, within $\pm 5\%$. Our study provides a new promising framework to understand shell buckling, and more generally, imperfection-sensitive instabilities. △ Less

Submitted 25 November, 2020; originally announced November 2020.

Journal ref: Physical Review Letters 125, 225504 (2020)

Interaction and breakup of droplet pairs in a microchannel Y-junction

Authors: Simon Schütz, Jian Wei Khor, Sindy K. Y. Tang, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: We combine theory, numerical simulation and experiments to investigate the breakup of two identical droplets entering a Y-junction with controlled spatial offset by which the second droplet trails the first. Based on fully resolved 3D simulations, we describe the flow physics leading to breakup. Scaling arguments, numerical simulation and experiments consistently show that for small initial offset… ▽ More We combine theory, numerical simulation and experiments to investigate the breakup of two identical droplets entering a Y-junction with controlled spatial offset by which the second droplet trails the first. Based on fully resolved 3D simulations, we describe the flow physics leading to breakup. Scaling arguments, numerical simulation and experiments consistently show that for small initial offset, breakup always occurs with the droplet fragment volume depending linearly on the offset. Above a critical offset, which increases with the capillary number, the droplets enter the constriction sequentially without breakup. Our results are relevant for understanding the breakup behavior in a dense emulsion flowing through a linearly converging channel leading to a constriction. Such geometry is commonly used for the serial interrogation of droplet content in droplet microfluidic applications, where droplet breakup can limit the maximum throughput for such process. For capillary numbers up to $Ca\simeq10^{-2}$, the results from the two-droplet system in a Y-junction are consistent with breakup observations in dense emulsions flowing through a linearly converging channel. The deterministic relation between initial offset and resulting breakup in the two-droplet system suggests that the stochasticity that is observed in the breakup of a dense emulsion arises from multi-droplet interactions. The numerical value of the prefactor in the linear relation between initial offset and droplet fragment volume determined from experiments differs slightly from the one extracted from fully resolved numerical simulations. This discrepancy suggests that even at very high bulk surfactant concentrations, the rate-limiting surfactant adsorption kinetics allows for Marangoni stresses to develop and modify the droplet dynamics. △ Less

Submitted 3 August, 2020; originally announced August 2020.

Superspreading events suggest aerosol transmission of SARS-CoV-2 by accumulation in enclosed spaces

Authors: John M. Kolinski, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Viral transmission pathways have profound implications for public safety; it is thus imperative to establish a complete understanding of viable infectious avenues. Mounting evidence suggests SARS-CoV-2 can be transmitted via the air; however, this has not yet been demonstrated. Here we quantitatively analyze virion accumulation by accounting for aerosolized virion emission and destabilization. Rep… ▽ More Viral transmission pathways have profound implications for public safety; it is thus imperative to establish a complete understanding of viable infectious avenues. Mounting evidence suggests SARS-CoV-2 can be transmitted via the air; however, this has not yet been demonstrated. Here we quantitatively analyze virion accumulation by accounting for aerosolized virion emission and destabilization. Reported superspreading events analyzed within this framework point towards aerosol mediated transmission of SARS-CoV-2. Virion exposure calculated for these events is found to trace out a single value, suggesting a universal minimum infective dose (MID) via aerosol that is comparable to the MIDs measured for other respiratory viruses; thus, the consistent infectious exposure levels and their commensurability to known aerosol-MIDs establishes the plausibility of aerosol transmission of SARS-CoV-2. Using filtration at a rate exceeding the destabilization rate of aerosolized SARS-CoV-2 can reduce exposure below this infective dose. △ Less

Submitted 4 December, 2020; v1 submitted 29 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Comments: 6 pages, 4 figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 103, 033109 (2021)

Adjoint-based variational method for constructing periodic orbits of high-dimensional chaotic systems

Authors: Sajjad Azimi, Omid Ashtari, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Chaotic dynamics in systems ranging from low-dimensional nonlinear differential equations to high-dimensional spatio-temporal systems including fluid turbulence is supported by non-chaotic, exactly recurring time-periodic solutions of the governing equations. These unstable periodic orbits capture key features of the turbulent dynamics and sufficiently large sets of orbits promise a framework to p… ▽ More Chaotic dynamics in systems ranging from low-dimensional nonlinear differential equations to high-dimensional spatio-temporal systems including fluid turbulence is supported by non-chaotic, exactly recurring time-periodic solutions of the governing equations. These unstable periodic orbits capture key features of the turbulent dynamics and sufficiently large sets of orbits promise a framework to predict the statistics of the chaotic flow. Computing periodic orbits for high-dimensional spatio-temporally chaotic systems remains challenging as known methods either show poor convergence properties because they are based on time-marching of a chaotic system causing exponential error amplification; or they require constructing Jacobian matrices which is prohibitively expensive. We propose a new matrix-free method that is unaffected by exponential error amplification, is globally convergent and can be applied to high-dimensional systems. The adjoint-based variational method constructs an initial value problem in the space of closed loops such that periodic orbits are attracting fixed points for the loop-dynamics. We introduce the method for general autonomous systems. An implementation for the one-dimensional Kuramoto-Sivashinsky equation demonstrates the robust convergence of periodic orbits underlying spatio-temporal chaos. Convergence does not require accurate initial guesses and is independent of the period of the respective orbit. △ Less

Submitted 13 July, 2020; originally announced July 2020.

Self-sustained large-scale motions in the asymptotic suction boundary layer

Authors: Sajjad Azimi, Carlo Cossu, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Large-scale motions, also known as superstructures, are dynamically relevant coherent structures in a wall-bounded turbulent flow, that span the entire domain in wall-normal direction and significantly contribute to the global energy and momentum transport. Recent investigations in channel and Couette flow, suggest that these large-scale motions are self-sustained, implying they are not driven by… ▽ More Large-scale motions, also known as superstructures, are dynamically relevant coherent structures in a wall-bounded turbulent flow, that span the entire domain in wall-normal direction and significantly contribute to the global energy and momentum transport. Recent investigations in channel and Couette flow, suggest that these large-scale motions are self-sustained, implying they are not driven by small-scale motions at the wall. Whether large-scale motions are self-sustained has however not yet been answered for open boundary layers, which are relevant for many applications. Here, using the asymptotic suction boundary layer flow at the friction Reynolds number $Re_τ= 1\,168$ as a testbed, we show that large-scale motions are self-sustained also in boundary layers. Together with the previous investigations in confined flows, this observation provides strong evidence of the robust and general nature of coherent self-sustained processes in turbulent wall-bounded flows. The dynamics of the large-scale self-sustained process involving the growth, breakdown and regeneration of quasi-streamwise coherent streaks and vortices within the boundary layer shows temporal phase relations reminiscent of bursting as observed in buffer layer structures. The dynamics however differs from the quasi-periodic large-scale streak-vortex regeneration cycle observed in confined flows. Based on the similarity of the dynamics of large-scale motions in boundary layers and of small-scale buffer layer structures, we conjecture that the bursting behaviour is associated with the dynamical relevance of only one wall, while two confining walls lead to the quasi-periodic cycle. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Modified snaking in plane Couette flow with wall-normal suction

Authors: Sajjad Azimi, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: A specific family of spanwise-localised invariant solutions of plane Couette flow exhibits homoclinic snaking, a process by which spatially localised invariant solutions of a nonlinear partial differential equation smoothly grow additional structure at their fronts while undergoing a sequence of saddle-node bifurcations. Homoclinic snaking is well understood in the context of simpler pattern formi… ▽ More A specific family of spanwise-localised invariant solutions of plane Couette flow exhibits homoclinic snaking, a process by which spatially localised invariant solutions of a nonlinear partial differential equation smoothly grow additional structure at their fronts while undergoing a sequence of saddle-node bifurcations. Homoclinic snaking is well understood in the context of simpler pattern forming systems such as the one-dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation with cubic-quintic nonlinearity, whose solutions remarkably well resemble the snaking solutions of plane Couette flow. We study the structural stability of the characteristic snakes-and-ladders structure associated with homoclinic snaking for flow modifications that break symmetries of plane Couette flow. We demonstrate that wall-normal suction modifies the bifurcation structure of three-dimensional plane Couette solutions in the same way, a symmetry-breaking quadratic term modifies solutions of the one-dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation. These modifications are related to the breaking of the discrete rotational symmetry. At large amplitudes of the symmetry-breaking wall-normal suction the connected snakes-and-ladders structure is destroyed. Previously unknown solution branches are created and can be parametrically continued to vanishing suction. This yields new localised solutions of plane Couette flow that exist in a wide range of Reynolds number. △ Less

Submitted 31 March, 2020; originally announced April 2020.

Journal ref: J. Fluid Mech. 912 (2021) A47

Periodic orbits exhibit oblique stripe patterns in plane Couette flow

Authors: Florian Reetz, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Spatio-temporally chaotic dynamics of transitional plane Couette flow may give rise to regular turbulent-laminar stripe patterns with a large-scale pattern wavelength and an oblique orientation relative to the laminar flow direction. A recent dynamical systems analysis of the oblique stripe pattern demonstrated that the Navier-Stokes equations have unstable equilibrium solutions that capture the t… ▽ More Spatio-temporally chaotic dynamics of transitional plane Couette flow may give rise to regular turbulent-laminar stripe patterns with a large-scale pattern wavelength and an oblique orientation relative to the laminar flow direction. A recent dynamical systems analysis of the oblique stripe pattern demonstrated that the Navier-Stokes equations have unstable equilibrium solutions that capture the three-dimensional spatial structure of the oblique stripe patterns. Here we identify unstable periodic orbits that not only show oblique large-scale amplitude modulation but also have a characteristic time-evolution, unlike steady equilibrium solutions. The periodic orbits represent standing waves that slowly propagate across wavy velocity streaks in the flow on viscous diffusion time scales. The unstable periodic orbits are embedded in the edge of chaos in a symmetry subspace of plane Couette flow and thereby may mediate transition to and from turbulent flows with oblique patterns. △ Less

Submitted 20 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Self-similar invariant solution in the near-wall region of a turbulent boundary layer at asymptotically high Reynolds numbers

Authors: Sajjad Azimi, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: At sufficiently high Reynolds numbers, shear-flow turbulence close to a wall acquires universal properties. When length and velocity are rescaled by appropriate characteristic scales of the turbulent flow and thereby measured in \emph{inner units}, the statistical properties of the flow become independent of the Reynolds number. We demonstrate the existence of a wall-attached non-chaotic exact inv… ▽ More At sufficiently high Reynolds numbers, shear-flow turbulence close to a wall acquires universal properties. When length and velocity are rescaled by appropriate characteristic scales of the turbulent flow and thereby measured in \emph{inner units}, the statistical properties of the flow become independent of the Reynolds number. We demonstrate the existence of a wall-attached non-chaotic exact invariant solution of the fully nonlinear 3D Navier-Stokes equations for a parallel boundary layer that captures the characteristic self-similar scaling of near-wall turbulent structures. The branch of travelling wave solutions can be followed up to $Re=1,000,000$. Combined theoretical and numerical evidence suggests that the solution is asymptotically self-similar and exactly scales in inner units for Reynolds numbers tending to infinity. Demonstrating the existence of invariant solutions that capture the self-similar scaling properties of turbulence in the near-wall region is a step towards extending the dynamical systems approach to turbulence from the transitional regime to fully developed boundary layers. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2019; originally announced December 2019.

Invariant states in inclined layer convection. Part 2. Bifurcations and connections between branches of invariant states

Authors: Florian Reetz, Priya Subramanian, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Convection in a layer inclined against gravity is a thermally driven non-equilibrium system, in which both buoyancy and shear forces drive spatio-temporally complex flow. As a function of the strength of thermal driving and the angle of inclination, a multitude of convection patterns is observed in experiments and numerical simulations. Several observed patterns have been linked to exact invariant… ▽ More Convection in a layer inclined against gravity is a thermally driven non-equilibrium system, in which both buoyancy and shear forces drive spatio-temporally complex flow. As a function of the strength of thermal driving and the angle of inclination, a multitude of convection patterns is observed in experiments and numerical simulations. Several observed patterns have been linked to exact invariant states of the fully nonlinear 3D Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations. These exact equilibria, traveling waves and periodic orbits reside in state space and, depending on their stability properties, are transiently visited by the dynamics or act as attractors. To explain the dependence of observed convection patterns on control parameters, we study the parameter dependence of the state space structure. Specifically, we identify the bifurcations that modify the existence, stability and connectivity of invariant states. We numerically continue exact invariant states underlying spatially periodic convection patterns at Pr=1.07 under changing control parameters for temperature difference between the walls and inclination angle. The resulting state branches cover various inclinations from horizontal layer convection to vertical layer convection and beyond. The collection of all computed branches represents an extensive bifurcation network connecting 16 different invariant states across control parameter values. Individual bifurcation structures are discussed in detail and related to the observed complex dynamics of individual convection patterns. Together, the bifurcations and associated state branches indicate at what control parameter values which invariant states coexist. This provides a nonlinear framework to explain the multitude of complex flow dynamics arising in inclined layer convection. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2020; v1 submitted 7 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

Invariant states in inclined layer convection. Part 1. Temporal transitions along dynamical connections between invariant states

Authors: Florian Reetz, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Thermal convection in an inclined layer between two parallel walls kept at different fixed temperatures is studied for fixed Prandtl number Pr=1.07. Depending on the angle of inclination and the imposed temperature difference, the flow exhibits a large variety of self-organized spatio-temporal convection patterns. Close to onset, these patterns have been explained in terms of linear stability anal… ▽ More Thermal convection in an inclined layer between two parallel walls kept at different fixed temperatures is studied for fixed Prandtl number Pr=1.07. Depending on the angle of inclination and the imposed temperature difference, the flow exhibits a large variety of self-organized spatio-temporal convection patterns. Close to onset, these patterns have been explained in terms of linear stability analysis of primary and secondary flow states. At larger temperature difference, far beyond onset, experiments and simulations show complex, dynamically evolving patterns that are not described by stability analysis and remain to be explained. Here we employ a dynamical systems approach. We construct stable and unstable exact invariant states, including equilibria and periodic orbits of the fully nonlinear three-dimensional Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations. These invariant states underlie the observed convection patterns beyond their onset. We identify state-space trajectories that, starting from the unstable laminar flow, follow a sequence of dynamical connections between unstable invariant states until the dynamics approaches a stable attractor. Together, the network of dynamically connected invariant states mediates temporal transitions between coexisting invariant states and thereby supports the observed complex time-dependent dynamics in inclined layer convection. △ Less

Submitted 6 March, 2020; v1 submitted 7 November, 2019; originally announced November 2019.

The origin of localized snakes-and-ladders solutions of plane Couette flow

Authors: Matthew Salewski, John F. Gibson, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Spatially localized exact solutions of plane Couette flow are organized in a snakes-and-ladders structure strikingly similar to that observed for simpler pattern-forming partial differential equations. [PRL 104,104501 (2010)]. We demonstrate the mechanism by which these snaking solutions originate from well-known periodic states of the Taylor-Couette system. They are formed by a localized slug of… ▽ More Spatially localized exact solutions of plane Couette flow are organized in a snakes-and-ladders structure strikingly similar to that observed for simpler pattern-forming partial differential equations. [PRL 104,104501 (2010)]. We demonstrate the mechanism by which these snaking solutions originate from well-known periodic states of the Taylor-Couette system. They are formed by a localized slug of Wavy-Vortex flow that emerges from a background of Taylor vortices via a modulational sideband instability. This mechanism suggests a deep connection between pattern-formation theory and Navier-Stokes flow. △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2019; originally announced June 2019.

Comments: 5 pages

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 100, 031102 (2019)

Invariant Solution underlying Oblique Stripe Patterns in Plane Couette Flow

Authors: Florian Reetz, Tobias Kreilos, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: When subcritical shear flows transition to turbulence, laminar and turbulent flow often coexists in space, giving rise to turbulent-laminar patterns. Most prominent are regular stripe patterns with large-scale periodicity and oblique orientation. Oblique stripes are a robust phenomenon, observed in experiments and flow simulations, yet their origin remains unclear. We demonstrate the existence of… ▽ More When subcritical shear flows transition to turbulence, laminar and turbulent flow often coexists in space, giving rise to turbulent-laminar patterns. Most prominent are regular stripe patterns with large-scale periodicity and oblique orientation. Oblique stripes are a robust phenomenon, observed in experiments and flow simulations, yet their origin remains unclear. We demonstrate the existence of an invariant equilibrium solution of the fully nonlinear 3D Navier-Stokes equations that resembles the oblique pattern of turbulent-laminar stripes in plane Couette flow. We uncover the origin of the stripe equilibrium and show how it emerges from the well-studied Nagata equilibrium via two successive symmetry-breaking bifurcations. △ Less

Submitted 8 September, 2018; originally announced September 2018.

Edge states control droplet break-up in sub-critical extensional flows

Authors: Giacomo Gallino, Tobias M. Schneider, François Gallaire

Abstract: A fluid droplet suspended in an extensional flow of moderate intensity may break into pieces, depending on the amplitude of the initial droplet deformation. In subcritical uniaxial extensional flow the non-breaking base state is linearly stable, implying that only a finite amplitude perturbation can trigger break-up. Consequently, the stable base solution is surrounded by its finite basin of attra… ▽ More A fluid droplet suspended in an extensional flow of moderate intensity may break into pieces, depending on the amplitude of the initial droplet deformation. In subcritical uniaxial extensional flow the non-breaking base state is linearly stable, implying that only a finite amplitude perturbation can trigger break-up. Consequently, the stable base solution is surrounded by its finite basin of attraction. The basin boundary, which separates initial droplet shapes returning to the non-breaking base state from those becoming unstable and breaking up, is characterized using edge tracking techniques. We numerically construct the edge state, a dynamically unstable equilibrium whose stable manifold forms the basin boundary. The edge state equilibrium controls if the droplet breaks and selects a unique path towards break-up. This path physically corresponds to the well-known end-pinching mechanism. Our results thereby rationalize the dynamics observed experimentally [Stone & Leal, J. Fluid Mech. 206, 223 (1989)] △ Less

Submitted 14 June, 2018; originally announced June 2018.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Fluids 3, 073603 (2018)

Localized travelling waves in the asymptotic suction boundary layer

Authors: Tobias Kreilos, John F. Gibson, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: We present two spanwise-localized travelling wave solutions in the asymptotic suction boundary layer, obtained by continuation of solutions of plane Couette flow. One of the solutions has the vortical structures located close to the wall, similar to spanwise-localized edge states previously found for this system. The vortical structures of the second solution are located in the free stream far abo… ▽ More We present two spanwise-localized travelling wave solutions in the asymptotic suction boundary layer, obtained by continuation of solutions of plane Couette flow. One of the solutions has the vortical structures located close to the wall, similar to spanwise-localized edge states previously found for this system. The vortical structures of the second solution are located in the free stream far above the laminar boundary layer and are supported by a secondary shear gradient that is created by a large-scale low-speed streak. The dynamically relevant eigenmodes of this solution are concentrated in the free stream, and the departure into turbulence from this solution evolves in the free stream towards the walls. For invariant solutions in free-stream turbulence, this solution thus shows that that the source of energy of the vortical structures can be a dynamical structure of the solution itself, instead of the laminar boundary layer. △ Less

Submitted 2 May, 2016; originally announced May 2016.

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics / Volume 795 / May 2016, R3

Homoclinic snaking in plane Couette flow: bending, skewing, and finite-size effects

Authors: John F. Gibson, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: Invariant solutions of shear flows have recently been extended from spatially periodic solutions in minimal flow units to spatially localized solutions on extended domains. One set of spanwise-localized solutions of plane Couette flow exhibits homoclinic snaking, a process by which steady-state solutions grow additional structure smoothly at their fronts when continued parametrically. Homoclinic s… ▽ More Invariant solutions of shear flows have recently been extended from spatially periodic solutions in minimal flow units to spatially localized solutions on extended domains. One set of spanwise-localized solutions of plane Couette flow exhibits homoclinic snaking, a process by which steady-state solutions grow additional structure smoothly at their fronts when continued parametrically. Homoclinic snaking is well understood mathematically in the context of the one-dimensional Swift-Hohenberg equation. Consequently, the snaking solutions of plane Couette flow form a promising connection between the largely phenomenological study of laminar-turbulent patterns in viscous shear flows and the mathematically well-developed field of pattern-formation theory. In this paper we present a numerical study of the snaking solutions, generalizing beyond the fixed streamwise wavelength of previous studies. We find a number of new solution features, including bending, skewing, and finite-size effects. We show that the finite-size effects result from the shift-reflect symmetry of the traveling wave and establish the parameter regions over which snaking occurs. A new winding solution of plane Couette flow is derived from a strongly skewed localized equilibrium. △ Less

Submitted 28 September, 2015; originally announced September 2015.

Comments: 19 pages, 11 figures

MSC Class: 76E05

Turbulence transition in the asymptotic suction boundary layer

Authors: Tobias Kreilos, Taras Khapko, Tobias M Schneider, Gregor Veble, Yohann Duguet, Philipp Schlatter, Dan S Henningson, Bruno Eckhardt

Abstract: We study the transition to turbulence in the asymptotic suction boundary layer (ASBL) by direct numerical simulation. Tracking the motion of trajectories intermediate between laminar and turbulent states we can identify the invariant object inside the laminar-turbulent boundary, the edge state. In small domains, the flow behaves like a travelling wave over short time intervals. On longer times one… ▽ More We study the transition to turbulence in the asymptotic suction boundary layer (ASBL) by direct numerical simulation. Tracking the motion of trajectories intermediate between laminar and turbulent states we can identify the invariant object inside the laminar-turbulent boundary, the edge state. In small domains, the flow behaves like a travelling wave over short time intervals. On longer times one notes that the energy shows strong bursts at regular time intervals. During the bursts the streak structure is lost, but it reforms, translated in the spanwise direction by half the domain size. Varying the suction velocity allows to embed the flow into a family of flows that interpolate between plane Couette flow and the ASBL. Near the plane Couette limit, the edge state is a travelling wave. Increasing the suction, the travelling wave and a symmetry-related copy of it undergo a saddle-node infinite-period (SNIPER) bifurcation that leads to bursting and discrete-symmetry shifts. In wider domains, the structures localize in the spanwise direction, and the flow in the active region is similar to the one in small domains. There are still periodic bursts at which the flow structures are shifted, but the shift-distance is no longer connected to a discrete symmetry of the flow geometry. Two different states are found by edge tracking techniques, one where structures are shifted to the same side at every burst and one where they are alternatingly shifted to the left and to the right. △ Less

Submitted 31 August, 2015; originally announced August 2015.

Comments: Conference TSFP8, Poitiers 2013. TSFP-8 conference proceedings 2013, http://www.tsfp-conference.org/proceedings/

Spatio-temporal Patterns in Inclined Layer Convection

Authors: Priya Subramanian, Oliver Brausch, Karen E. Daniels, Eberhard Bodenschatz, Tobias M. Schneider, Werner Pesch

Abstract: This paper reports on a theoretical analysis of the rich variety of spatio-temporal patterns observed recently in inclined layer convection at medium Prandtl number when varying the inclination angle $γ$ and the Rayleigh number $R$. The present numerical investigation of the inclined layer convection system is based on the standard Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations. The patterns are shown to originate… ▽ More This paper reports on a theoretical analysis of the rich variety of spatio-temporal patterns observed recently in inclined layer convection at medium Prandtl number when varying the inclination angle $γ$ and the Rayleigh number $R$. The present numerical investigation of the inclined layer convection system is based on the standard Oberbeck-Boussinesq equations. The patterns are shown to originate from a complicated competition of buoyancy-driven and shear-flow driven pattern forming mechanisms. The former are expressed as \rm{longitudinal} convection rolls with their axes oriented parallel to the incline, the latter as perpendicular \rm{transverse} rolls. Along with conventional methods to study roll patterns and their stability, we employ direct numerical simulations in large spatial domains, comparable with the experimental ones. As a result, we determine the phase diagram of the characteristic complex 3D convection patterns above onset of convection in the $γ-R$ plane, and find that it compares very well with the experiments. In particular we demonstrate that interactions of specific Fourier modes, characterized by a resonant interaction of their wavevectors in the layer plane, are key to understanding the pattern morphologies. △ Less

Submitted 26 January, 2016; v1 submitted 7 July, 2015; originally announced July 2015.

Comments: 26 pages, 20 figures, 1 table. Changes in this version: extensive restructuring according to reviewer comments and modification to order of authors

Turbulent-laminar patterns in plane Poiseuille flow

Authors: Laurette S. Tuckerman, Tobias Kreilos, Hecke Schrobsdorff, Tobias M. Schneider, John F. Gibson

Abstract: Turbulent-laminar banded patterns in plane Poiseuille flow are studied via direct numerical simulations in a tilted and translating computational domain using a parallel version of the pseudospectral code Channelflow. 3D visualizations via the streamwise vorticity of an instantaneous and a time-averaged pattern are presented, as well as 2D visualizations of the average velocity field and the turbu… ▽ More Turbulent-laminar banded patterns in plane Poiseuille flow are studied via direct numerical simulations in a tilted and translating computational domain using a parallel version of the pseudospectral code Channelflow. 3D visualizations via the streamwise vorticity of an instantaneous and a time-averaged pattern are presented, as well as 2D visualizations of the average velocity field and the turbulent kinetic energy. Simulations for Reynolds numbers descending from 2300 to 700 show the gradual development from uniform turbulence to a pattern with wavelength 20 half-gaps near Re=1900, to a pattern with wavelength 40 near Re=1300 and finally to laminar flow near Re=800. These transitions are tracked quantitatively via diagnostics using the amplitude and phase of the Fourier transform and its probability distribution. The propagation velocity of the pattern is approximately that of the mean flux and is a decreasing function of Reynolds number. Examination of the time-averaged flow shows that a turbulent band is associated with two counter-rotating cells stacked in the cross-channel direction and that the turbulence is highly concentrated near the walls. Near the walls, the Reynolds stress force accelerates the fluid through a turbulent band while viscosity decelerates it; advection by the laminar profile acts in both directions. In the center, the Reynolds stress force decelerates the fluid through a turbulent band while advection by the laminar profile accelerates it. These characteristics are compared with those of turbulent-laminar banded patterns in plane Couette flow. △ Less

Submitted 18 January, 2015; v1 submitted 5 April, 2014; originally announced April 2014.

Journal ref: Physics of Fluids 26, 114103 (2014)

Increasing lifetimes and the growing saddles of shear flow turbulence

Authors: Tobias Kreilos, Bruno Eckhardt, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: In linearly stable shear flows turbulence spontaneously decays with a characteristic lifetime that varies with Reynolds number. The lifetime sharply increases with Reynolds number so that a possible divergence marking the transition to sustained turbulence at a critical point has been discussed. We present a mechanism by which the lifetimes increase: in the system's state space, turbulent motion i… ▽ More In linearly stable shear flows turbulence spontaneously decays with a characteristic lifetime that varies with Reynolds number. The lifetime sharply increases with Reynolds number so that a possible divergence marking the transition to sustained turbulence at a critical point has been discussed. We present a mechanism by which the lifetimes increase: in the system's state space, turbulent motion is supported by a chaotic saddle. Inside this saddle a locally attracting periodic orbit is created and undergoes a traditional bifurcation sequence generating chaos. The formed new 'turbulent bubble' is initially an attractor supporting persistent chaotic dynamics. Soon after its creation it collides with its own boundary, by which it becomes leaky and dynamically connected with the surrounding structures. The complexity of the chaotic saddle that supports transient turbulence hence increases by incorporating the remnant of a new bubble. As a a result, the time it takes for a trajectory to leave the saddle and decay to the laminar state is increased. We demonstrate this phenomenon in plane Couette flow and show that characteristic lifetimes vary non-smoothly and non-monotonically with Reynolds number. △ Less

Submitted 31 October, 2013; originally announced October 2013.

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 044503, 2014

Studying edge geometry in transiently turbulent shear flows

Authors: Matthew Chantry, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: In linearly stable shear flows at moderate Re, turbulence spontaneously decays despite the existence of a codimension-one manifold, termed the edge of chaos, which separates decaying perturbations from those triggering turbulence. We statistically analyse the decay in plane Couette flow, quantify the breaking of self-sustaining feedback loops and demonstrate the existence of a whole continuum of p… ▽ More In linearly stable shear flows at moderate Re, turbulence spontaneously decays despite the existence of a codimension-one manifold, termed the edge of chaos, which separates decaying perturbations from those triggering turbulence. We statistically analyse the decay in plane Couette flow, quantify the breaking of self-sustaining feedback loops and demonstrate the existence of a whole continuum of possible decay paths. Drawing parallels with low-dimensional models and monitoring the location of the edge relative to decaying trajectories we provide evidence, that the edge of chaos separates state space not globally. It is instead wrapped around the turbulence generating structures and not an independent dynamical structure but part of the chaotic saddle. Thereby, decaying trajectories need not cross the edge, but circumnavigate it while unwrap** from the turbulent saddle. △ Less

Submitted 10 December, 2013; v1 submitted 27 August, 2013; originally announced August 2013.

Comments: 11 pages, 6 figures

Edge states for the turbulence transition in the asymptotic suction boundary layer

Authors: Tobias Kreilos, Gregor Veble, Tobias M. Schneider, Bruno Eckhardt

Abstract: We demonstrate the existence of an exact invariant solution to the Navier-Stokes equations for the asymptotic suction boundary layer. The identified periodic orbit with a very long period of several thousand advective time units is found as a local dynamical attractor embedded in the stability boundary between laminar and turbulent dynamics. Its dynamics captures both the interplay of downstream o… ▽ More We demonstrate the existence of an exact invariant solution to the Navier-Stokes equations for the asymptotic suction boundary layer. The identified periodic orbit with a very long period of several thousand advective time units is found as a local dynamical attractor embedded in the stability boundary between laminar and turbulent dynamics. Its dynamics captures both the interplay of downstream oriented vortex pairs and streaks observed in numerous shear flows as well as the energetic bursting that is characteristic for boundary layers. By embedding the flow into a family of flows that interpolates between plane Couette flow and the boundary layer we demonstrate that the periodic orbit emerges in a saddle-node infinite-period (SNIPER) bifurcation of two symmetry-related travelling wave solutions of plane Couette flow. Physically, the long period is due to a slow streak instability which leads to a violent breakup of a streak associated with the bursting and the reformation of the streak at a different spanwise location. We show that the orbit is structurally stable when varying both the Reynolds number and the domain size. △ Less

Submitted 19 April, 2013; v1 submitted 4 September, 2012; originally announced September 2012.

Comments: Accepted for publication in journal of fluid mechanics

Journal ref: Journal of Fluid Mechanics / Volume 726 / July 2013, pp 100-122

Algorithm for a microfluidic assembly line

Authors: Tobias M. Schneider, Shreyas Mandre, Michael P. Brenner

Abstract: Microfluidic technology has revolutionized the control of flows at small scales giving rise to new possibilities for assembling complex structures on the microscale. We analyze different possible algorithms for assembling arbitrary structures, and demonstrate that a sequential assembly algorithm can manufacture arbitrary 3D structures from identical constituents. We illustrate the algorithm by sho… ▽ More Microfluidic technology has revolutionized the control of flows at small scales giving rise to new possibilities for assembling complex structures on the microscale. We analyze different possible algorithms for assembling arbitrary structures, and demonstrate that a sequential assembly algorithm can manufacture arbitrary 3D structures from identical constituents. We illustrate the algorithm by showing that a modified Hele-Shaw cell with 7 controlled flowrates can be designed to construct the entire English alphabet from particles that irreversibly stick to each other. △ Less

Submitted 19 January, 2011; originally announced January 2011.

Comments: 4 pages

Snakes and ladders: localized solutions of plane Couette flow

Authors: Tobias M. Schneider, John F. Gibson, John Burke

Abstract: We demonstrate the existence of a large number of exact solutions of plane Couette flow, which share the topology of known periodic solutions but are localized in space. Solutions of different size are organized in a snakes-and-ladders structure strikingly similar to that observed for simpler pattern-forming PDE systems. These new solutions are a step towards extending the dynamical systems view… ▽ More We demonstrate the existence of a large number of exact solutions of plane Couette flow, which share the topology of known periodic solutions but are localized in space. Solutions of different size are organized in a snakes-and-ladders structure strikingly similar to that observed for simpler pattern-forming PDE systems. These new solutions are a step towards extending the dynamical systems view of transitional turbulence to spatially extended flows. △ Less

Submitted 14 December, 2009; originally announced December 2009.

Comments: submitted to Physics Review Letters

Laminar-turbulent boundary in plane Couette flow

Authors: Tobias M Schneider, John F Gibson, Maher Lagha, Filippo De Lillo, Bruno Eckhardt

Abstract: We apply the iterated edge state tracking algorithm to study the boundary between laminar and turbulent dynamics in plane Couette flow at Re=400. Perturbations that are not strong enough to become fully turbulent nor weak enough to relaminarize tend towards a hyperbolic coherent structure in state space, termed the edge state, which seems to be unique up to obvious continuous shift symmetries. T… ▽ More We apply the iterated edge state tracking algorithm to study the boundary between laminar and turbulent dynamics in plane Couette flow at Re=400. Perturbations that are not strong enough to become fully turbulent nor weak enough to relaminarize tend towards a hyperbolic coherent structure in state space, termed the edge state, which seems to be unique up to obvious continuous shift symmetries. The results reported here show that in cases where a fixed point has only one unstable direction, as for the lower branch solution in in plane Couette flow, the iterated edge tracking algorithm converges to this state. They also show that choice of initial state is not critical, and that essentially arbitrary initial conditions can be used to find the edge state. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 4 pages, 4 figures

Lifetime statistics in transitional pipe flow

Authors: Tobias M. Schneider, Bruno Eckhardt

Abstract: Several experimental and numerical studies have shown that turbulent motions in circular pipe flow near transitional Reynolds numbers may not persist forever, but may decay. We study the properties of these decaying states within direct numerical simulations for Reynolds numbers up to 2200 and in pipes with lengths equal to 5, 9 and 15 times the diameter. We show that the choice of the ensemble… ▽ More Several experimental and numerical studies have shown that turbulent motions in circular pipe flow near transitional Reynolds numbers may not persist forever, but may decay. We study the properties of these decaying states within direct numerical simulations for Reynolds numbers up to 2200 and in pipes with lengths equal to 5, 9 and 15 times the diameter. We show that the choice of the ensemble of initial conditions affects the short time parts of lifetime distributions, but does not change the characteristic decay rate for long times. Comparing lifetimes for pipes of different length we notice a linear increase in the characteristic lifetime with length, which reproduces the experimental results when extrapolated to 30 diameters, the length of an equilibrium turbulent puff at these Reynolds numbers. △ Less

Submitted 7 May, 2008; originally announced May 2008.

Comments: 10 pages, 11 figures

How does flow in a pipe become turbulent?

Authors: Bruno Eckhardt, Tobias M. Schneider

Abstract: The transition to turbulence in pipe flow does not follow the scenario familiar from Rayleigh-Benard or Taylor-Couette flow since the laminar profile is stable against infinitesimal perturbations for all Reynolds numbers. Moreover, even when the flow speed is high enough and the perturbation sufficiently strong such that turbulent flow is established, it can return to the laminar state without a… ▽ More The transition to turbulence in pipe flow does not follow the scenario familiar from Rayleigh-Benard or Taylor-Couette flow since the laminar profile is stable against infinitesimal perturbations for all Reynolds numbers. Moreover, even when the flow speed is high enough and the perturbation sufficiently strong such that turbulent flow is established, it can return to the laminar state without any indication of the imminent decay. In this parameter range, the lifetimes of perturbations show a sensitive dependence on initial conditions and an exponential distribution. The turbulence seems to be supported by three-dimensional travelling waves which appear transiently in the flow field. The boundary between laminar and turbulent dynamics is formed by the stable manifold of an invariant chaotic state. We will also discuss the relation between observations in short, periodically continued domains, and the dynamics in fully extended puffs. △ Less

Submitted 20 September, 2007; originally announced September 2007.

Comments: for the proceedings of statphys 23

Comment on 'Critical behaviour in the relaminarization of localized turbulence in pipe flow'

Authors: Bjorn Hof, Jerry Westerweel, Tobias M. Schneider, Bruno Eckhardt

Abstract: This is a comment on arXiv:physics/0608292, subsequently published in Phys Rev Lett, 98, 014501 (2007), in which Willis and Kerswell study in direct numerical simulations the statistics of turbulent lifetimes in pipe flow. They suggest that their data for six different Reynolds numbers support a divergence of the lifetime near a Reynolds number of about 1870. However, their conclusion is not com… ▽ More This is a comment on arXiv:physics/0608292, subsequently published in Phys Rev Lett, 98, 014501 (2007), in which Willis and Kerswell study in direct numerical simulations the statistics of turbulent lifetimes in pipe flow. They suggest that their data for six different Reynolds numbers support a divergence of the lifetime near a Reynolds number of about 1870. However, their conclusion is not compelling: a re-analysis of their data shows that it is also compatible with an exponentially increasing lifetime. △ Less

Submitted 18 July, 2007; originally announced July 2007.

Comments: 1 page, 2 figures

Statistical analysis of coherent structures in transitional pipe flow

Authors: Tobias M. Schneider, Bruno Eckhardt, Juergen Vollmer

Abstract: Numerical and experimental studies of transitional pipe flow have shown the prevalence of coherent flow structures that are dominated by downstream vortices. They attract special attention because they contribute predominantly to the increase of the Reynolds stresses in turbulent flow. In the present study we introduce a convenient detector for these coherent states, calculate the fraction of ti… ▽ More Numerical and experimental studies of transitional pipe flow have shown the prevalence of coherent flow structures that are dominated by downstream vortices. They attract special attention because they contribute predominantly to the increase of the Reynolds stresses in turbulent flow. In the present study we introduce a convenient detector for these coherent states, calculate the fraction of time the structures appear in the flow, and present a Markov model for the transition between the structures. The fraction of states that show vortical structures exceeds 24% for a Reynolds number of about Re=2200, and it decreases to about 20% for Re=2500. The Markov model for the transition between these states is in good agreement with the observed fraction of states, and in reasonable agreement with the prediction for their persistence. It provides insight into dominant qualitative changes of the flow when increasing the Reynolds number. △ Less

Submitted 2 November, 2006; originally announced November 2006.

Comments: 11 pages, 26 (sub)figures

Journal ref: Phys. Rev. E 75, 066313 (2007)