-
Microscale torsion resonators for short-range gravity experiments
Authors:
J. Manley,
C. A. Condos,
S. Schlamminger,
J. R. Pratt,
D. J. Wilson,
W. A. Terrano
Abstract:
Measuring gravitational interactions on sub-100-$μ$m length scales offers a window into physics beyond the Standard Model. However, short-range gravity experiments are limited by the ability to position sufficiently massive objects to within small separation distances. Here we propose mass-loaded silicon nitride ribbons as a platform for testing the gravitational inverse square law at separations…
▽ More
Measuring gravitational interactions on sub-100-$μ$m length scales offers a window into physics beyond the Standard Model. However, short-range gravity experiments are limited by the ability to position sufficiently massive objects to within small separation distances. Here we propose mass-loaded silicon nitride ribbons as a platform for testing the gravitational inverse square law at separations currently inaccessible with traditional torsion balances. These microscale torsion resonators benefit from low thermal noise due to strain-induced dissipation dilution while maintaining compact size (<100$\,μ$g) to allow close approach. Considering an experiment combining a 40$\,μ$g torsion resonator with a source mass of comparable size (130$\,μ$g) at separations down to 25$\,μ$m, and including limits from thermomechanical noise and systematic uncertainty, we predict these devices can set novel constraints on Yukawa interactions within the 1-100$\,μ$m range.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Flexures for Kibble balances: Minimizing the effects of anelastic relaxation
Authors:
Lorenz Keck,
Stephan Schlamminger,
René Theska,
Frank Seifert,
Darine Haddad
Abstract:
We studied the anelastic aftereffect of a flexure being used in a Kibble balance, where the flexure is subjected to a large excursion in velocity mode after which a high-precision force comparison is performed. We investigated the effect of a constant and a sinusoidal excursion on the force comparison. We explored theoretically and experimentally a simple erasing procedure, i.e., bending the flexu…
▽ More
We studied the anelastic aftereffect of a flexure being used in a Kibble balance, where the flexure is subjected to a large excursion in velocity mode after which a high-precision force comparison is performed. We investigated the effect of a constant and a sinusoidal excursion on the force comparison. We explored theoretically and experimentally a simple erasing procedure, i.e., bending the flexure in the opposite direction for a given amplitude and time. We found that the erasing procedure reduced the time-dependent force by about 30%. The investigation was performed with an analytical model and verified experimentally with our new Kibble balance at the National Institute of Standards and Technology employing flexures made from precipitation-hardened Copper Beryllium alloy C17200.
Our experimental determination of the modulus defect of the flexure yields 1.2E-4. This result is about a factor of two higher than previously reported from experiments. We additionally found a static shift of the flexure's internal equilibrium after a change in the stress and strain state. These static shifts, although measurable, are small and deemed uncritical for our Kibble balance application at present.
During this investigation, we discovered magic flexures that promise to have very little anelastic relaxation. In these magic flexures, the mechanism causing anelastic relaxation is compensated for by properly sha** and loading a flexure with a non-constant cross-section in the region of bending.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2024; v1 submitted 20 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Calculation of magnetic forces and torques on the Kibble coil
Authors:
Stephan Schlamminger,
Lorenz Keck,
Frank Seifert,
Leon S. Chao,
Darine Haddad,
Shisong Li
Abstract:
Analytically the forces and torques on a coil in a field of magnetic flux density can be calculated one of two ways. The line integral can be conducted along the coil's wire, summing up the differential force contribution. For each differential line segment, the force is obtained as a cross product with the magnetic flux density. Alternatively, the coil's energy in the field is the current times t…
▽ More
Analytically the forces and torques on a coil in a field of magnetic flux density can be calculated one of two ways. The line integral can be conducted along the coil's wire, summing up the differential force contribution. For each differential line segment, the force is obtained as a cross product with the magnetic flux density. Alternatively, the coil's energy in the field is the current times the flux threading the coil. Hence, the energy is obtained by executing a surface integral over the coil's open surface. Here, a dot product of the differential surface element with the magnetic flux density is executed under the integral sign. The forces and torques can then be obtained from the negative derivative of the energy with respect to the appropriate coordinate. For yoke-based Kibble balances, the latter method is much simpler since most of the flux is contained in the inner yoke of the magnet and can be written as a simple equation. Here, we use this method to provide simple equations and their results for finding the torques and forces that act on a coil in a yoke-based magnet system. We further introduce a simple method that allows the calculation of the position and orientation difference between the coil and the magnet from three measurements.
△ Less
Submitted 19 September, 2022; v1 submitted 25 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Conception of an enhanced mechanism for a new Kibble balance directly traceable to the quantum SI
Authors:
Lorenz Keck,
Frank Seifert,
David Newell,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Rene Thesk,
Darine Haddad
Abstract:
The ``Quantum Electro-Mechanical Metrology Suite'' (QEMMS) is being designed and built at the National Institute of Standards and Technology. It includes a Kibble balance, a Graphene quantum Hall resistance array and a Josephson voltage system, so that it is a new primary standard for the unit of mass, the kilogram, directly traceable to the International System of Units (SI) based on quantum cons…
▽ More
The ``Quantum Electro-Mechanical Metrology Suite'' (QEMMS) is being designed and built at the National Institute of Standards and Technology. It includes a Kibble balance, a Graphene quantum Hall resistance array and a Josephson voltage system, so that it is a new primary standard for the unit of mass, the kilogram, directly traceable to the International System of Units (SI) based on quantum constants. We are targeting a measurement range of 10 g to 200 g and optimize the design for a relative combined uncertainty of $2\times 10^{-8}$ for masses of 100 g. QEMMS will be developed as an open hardware and software design. In this article, we explain the design of the moving and weighing mechanism in the QEMMS.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Design of electrostatic feedback for an experiment to measure $G$
Authors:
Stephan Schlamminger,
Leon Chao,
Vincent Lee,
David B. Newell,
Clive C. Speake
Abstract:
The torsion pendulum at the heart of the apparatus to measure the gravitational constant, $G$ at the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM) is used to measure the gravitational torque between source and test-mass assemblies with two methods. In the Cavendish method, the pendulum moves freely. In the electrostatic-servo method, the pendulum is maintained at a constant angle by applying an…
▽ More
The torsion pendulum at the heart of the apparatus to measure the gravitational constant, $G$ at the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM) is used to measure the gravitational torque between source and test-mass assemblies with two methods. In the Cavendish method, the pendulum moves freely. In the electrostatic-servo method, the pendulum is maintained at a constant angle by applying an electrostatic torque equal and opposite to any gravitational torque on the pendulum. The electrostatic torque is generated by a servo. This article describes the design and implementation of this servo at the National Institute of Standards and Technology. We use a digital servo loop with a Kalman filter to achieve measurement performance comparable to the one in an open loop. We show that it is possible to achieve small measurement uncertainty with an experiment that uses three electrodes for feedback control.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Magnetic Uncertainties for Compact Kibble Balances: An Investigation
Authors:
Shisong Li,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
The Kibble balance has become one of the major instruments for realizing the mass unit, the kilogram, in the revised international system of units (SI). Researchers at about a dozen national metrology institutes are actively working with Kibble balances that are capable of weighing masses with nominal values from 10g to 1kg. In the future, the design of smaller Kibble balances will play a more sig…
▽ More
The Kibble balance has become one of the major instruments for realizing the mass unit, the kilogram, in the revised international system of units (SI). Researchers at about a dozen national metrology institutes are actively working with Kibble balances that are capable of weighing masses with nominal values from 10g to 1kg. In the future, the design of smaller Kibble balances will play a more significant role. Smaller Kibble balances require smaller magnet systems, and here we investigate the scaling of systematic uncertainties with the size of the magnet system. We describe the size dependence of three magnetic effects: the coil-inductance effect, the yoke nonlinear effect, and the thermal effect. The analysis shows that the relative systematic effects become increasingly larger with smaller sizes. For small magnets the thermal effects become dominant and, hence, a good thermal design is imperative.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
The kilogram: inertial or gravitational mass?
Authors:
Giovanni Mana,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
With the redefinition of the international system of units, the value of the Planck constant was fixed, similarly to the values of the unperturbed ground state hyperfine transition frequency of the $^{133}$Cs atom, speed of light in vacuum. Theoretically and differently from the past, the kilogram is now explicitly defined as the unit of inertial mass. Experimentally, the kilogram is realized by a…
▽ More
With the redefinition of the international system of units, the value of the Planck constant was fixed, similarly to the values of the unperturbed ground state hyperfine transition frequency of the $^{133}$Cs atom, speed of light in vacuum. Theoretically and differently from the past, the kilogram is now explicitly defined as the unit of inertial mass. Experimentally, the kilogram is realized by atom count or the Kibble balance. We show that only the former method measures the inertial mass without assuming the universality of free fall. Therefore, the agreement between the two measures can be interpreted as a test of the equivalence principle.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2022; v1 submitted 17 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Nanoscale torsional dissipation dilution for quantum experiments and precision measurement
Authors:
Jon R. Pratt,
Aman R. Agrawal,
Charles A. Condos,
Christian M. Pluchar,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Dalziel J. Wilson
Abstract:
We show that torsion resonators can experience massive dissipation dilution due to nanoscale strain, and draw a connection to a century-old theory from the torsion balance community which suggests that a simple torsion ribbon is naturally soft-clamped. By disrupting a commonly held belief in the nanomechanics community, our findings invite a rethinking of strategies towards quantum experiments and…
▽ More
We show that torsion resonators can experience massive dissipation dilution due to nanoscale strain, and draw a connection to a century-old theory from the torsion balance community which suggests that a simple torsion ribbon is naturally soft-clamped. By disrupting a commonly held belief in the nanomechanics community, our findings invite a rethinking of strategies towards quantum experiments and precision measurement with nanomechanical resonators. For example, we revisit the optical lever technique for monitoring displacement, and find that the rotation of a strained nanobeam can be resolved with an imprecision smaller than the zero-point motion of its fundamental torsional mode, without the use of a cavity or interferometric stability. We also find that a strained torsion ribbon can be mass-loaded without changing its $Q$ factor. We use this strategy to engineer a chip-scale torsion balance whose resonance frequency is sensitive to micro-$g$ fluctuations of the local gravitational field. Enabling both these advances is the fabrication of high-stress Si$_3$N$_4$ nanobeams with width-to-thickness ratios of $10^4$ and the recognition that their torsional modes have $Q$ factors scaling as their width-to-thickness ratio squared, yielding $Q$ factors as high as $10^8$ and $Q$-frequency products as high as $10^{13}$ Hz.
△ Less
Submitted 15 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
The irony of the magnet system for Kibble balances -- a review
Authors:
Shisong Li,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
The magnet system is an essential component of the Kibble balance, a device that is used to realize the unit of mass. It is the source of the magnetic flux, and its importance is captured in the geometric factor $Bl$. Ironically, the $Bl$ factor cancels out and does not appear in the final Kibble equation. Nevertheless, care must be taken to design and build the magnet system because the cancellat…
▽ More
The magnet system is an essential component of the Kibble balance, a device that is used to realize the unit of mass. It is the source of the magnetic flux, and its importance is captured in the geometric factor $Bl$. Ironically, the $Bl$ factor cancels out and does not appear in the final Kibble equation. Nevertheless, care must be taken to design and build the magnet system because the cancellation is perfect only if the $Bl$ is the same in both modes: the weighing and velocity mode. This review provides the knowledge necessary to build a magnetic circuit for the Kibble balance. In addition, this article discusses the design considerations, parameter optimizations, practical adjustments to the finished product, and an assessment of systematic uncertainties associated with the magnet system.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
Design of an electrostatic balance mechanism to measure optical power of 100 kW
Authors:
Lorenz Keck,
Gordon Shaw,
René Theska,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
A new instrument is required to accommodate the need for increased portability and accuracy in laser power measurement above 100 W. Reflection and absorption of laser light provide a measurable force from photon momentum exchange that is directly proportional to laser power, which can be measured with an electrostatic balance traceable to the SI. We aim for a relative uncertainty of $10^{-3}$ with…
▽ More
A new instrument is required to accommodate the need for increased portability and accuracy in laser power measurement above 100 W. Reflection and absorption of laser light provide a measurable force from photon momentum exchange that is directly proportional to laser power, which can be measured with an electrostatic balance traceable to the SI. We aim for a relative uncertainty of $10^{-3}$ with coverage factor $k=2$. For this purpose, we have designed a monolithic parallelogram 4-bar linkage incorporating elastic circular notch flexure hinges. The design is optimized to address the main factors driving force measurement uncertainty from the balance mechanism: corner loading errors, balance stiffness, stress in the flexure hinges, sensitivity to vibration, and sensitivity to thermal gradients. Parasitic rotations in the free end of the 4-bar linkage during arcuate motion are constrained by machining tolerances. An analytical model shows this affects the force measurement less than 0.01 percent. Incorporating an inverted pendulum reduces the stiffness of the system without unduly increasing tilt sensitivity. Finite element modeling of the flexures is used to determine the hinge orientation that minimizes stress which is therefore expected to minimize hysteresis. Thermal effects are mitigated using an external enclosure to minimize temperature gradients, although a quantitative analysis of this effect is not carried out. These analyses show the optimized mechanism is expected to contribute less than $10^{-3}$ relative uncertainty in the final laser power measurement.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2021;
originally announced February 2021.
-
Resolution of the paradox of the diamagnetic effect on the Kibble coil
Authors:
Shisong Li,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Rafael Marangoni,
Qing Wang,
Darine Haddad,
Frank Seifert,
Leon Chao,
David Newell,
Wei Zhao
Abstract:
Employing very simple electro-mechanical principles known from classical physics, the Kibble balance establishes a very precise and absolute link between quantum electrical standards and macroscopic mass or force measurements. The success of the Kibble balance, in both determining fundamental constants ($h$, $N_A$, $e$) and realizing a quasi-quantum mass in the 2019 newly revised International Sys…
▽ More
Employing very simple electro-mechanical principles known from classical physics, the Kibble balance establishes a very precise and absolute link between quantum electrical standards and macroscopic mass or force measurements. The success of the Kibble balance, in both determining fundamental constants ($h$, $N_A$, $e$) and realizing a quasi-quantum mass in the 2019 newly revised International System of Units, relies on the perfection of Maxwell's equations and the symmetry they describe between Lorentz's force and Faraday's induction, a principle and a symmetry stunningly demonstrated in the weighing and velocity modes of Kibble balances to within $1\times10^{-8}$, with nothing but imperfect wires and magnets. However, recent advances in the understanding of the current effect in Kibble balances reveal a troubling paradox. A diamagnetic effect, a force that does not cancel between mass-on and mass-off measurement, is challenging balance maker's assumptions of symmetry at levels that are almost two orders of magnitude larger than the reported uncertainties. The diamagnetic effect, if it exists, shows up in weighing mode without a readily apparent reciprocal effect in the velocity mode, begging questions about systematic errors at the very foundation of the new measurement system. The hypothetical force is caused by the coil current changing the magnetic field, producing an unaccounted force that is systematically modulated with the weighing current. Here we show that this diamagnetic force exists, but the additional force does not change the equivalence between weighing and velocity measurements. We reveal the unexpected way that symmetry is preserved and show that for typical materials and geometries the total relative effect on the measurement is $\approx 1\times10^{-9}$.
△ Less
Submitted 6 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
A Simple Improvement for Permanent Magnet Systems for Kibble Balances: More Flat Field at Almost No Cost
Authors:
Shisong Li,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Qing Wang
Abstract:
Permanent magnets together with yokes to concentrate the magnetic flux into a cylindrical air-gap are widely employed in Kibble balances. These experiments require a uniform magnetic flux density along a vertical path, typically a substantial fraction of the length of the air-gap. Fringe fields that are present at both ends of the air-gap limit the region where the flux density does not change mor…
▽ More
Permanent magnets together with yokes to concentrate the magnetic flux into a cylindrical air-gap are widely employed in Kibble balances. These experiments require a uniform magnetic flux density along a vertical path, typically a substantial fraction of the length of the air-gap. Fringe fields that are present at both ends of the air-gap limit the region where the flux density does not change more than a certain relative fraction (here: $5\times 10^{-4}$) of the flux density in the center of the magnet system. By simply adding an iron ring with a rectangular cross-section to the inner yoke at each end of the air gap, the effects of the fringe fields can be counteracted, and, hence, the length of the region, where the flux density remains within a given tolerance band is increased. Compared to the alternative, employing a taller magnet, the proposed method yields a magnet system with an extended region of a uniform field without significantly increasing the mass of the magnet system. Potential applications include compact and table-top Kibble balances. We investigate possible adverse effects on the performance of the magnet system caused by the additional rings: magnetic field strength, coil-current effect, and a dependence of the radial field on the radial position in the field. No substantial disadvantage was found. Instead, the method presented here outperformed previously suggested methods to improve the radial dependence of the radial field, e.g., shorter outer yoke. In summary, adding rings to the inner yoke improves the uniformity of the field without a detrimental effect to function, cost, and form factor of the magnet system.
△ Less
Submitted 8 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Magnet system for the Quantum Electro-Mechanical Metrology Suite
Authors:
Rafael R. Marangoni,
Darine Haddad,
Frank Seifert,
Leon S. Chao,
David B. Newell,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
The design of the permanent magnet system for the new Quantum Electro-Mechanical Metrology Suite (QEMMS) is described. The QEMMS, developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), consists of a Kibble balance, a programmable Josephson voltage standard, and a quantum Hall resistance standard. It will be used to measure masses up to $100\,\mathrm{g}$ with relative uncertainties…
▽ More
The design of the permanent magnet system for the new Quantum Electro-Mechanical Metrology Suite (QEMMS) is described. The QEMMS, developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST), consists of a Kibble balance, a programmable Josephson voltage standard, and a quantum Hall resistance standard. It will be used to measure masses up to $100\,\mathrm{g}$ with relative uncertainties below $2\times 10^{-8}$. The magnet system is based on the design of the NIST-4 magnet system with significant changes to adopt to a smaller Kibble balance and to overcome known practical limitations. Analytical models are provided to describe the coil-current effect and model the forces required to split the magnet in two parts to install the coil. Both models are compared to simulation results obtained with finite element analysis and measurement results. Other aspects, such as the coil design and flatness of $Bl$ profile are considered.
△ Less
Submitted 26 December, 2019; v1 submitted 10 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The Performance of the KIBB-g1 Tabletop Kibble Balance at NIST
Authors:
Leon Chao,
Frank Seifert,
Darine Haddad,
Jon Pratt,
David Newell,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
A tabletop-sized Kibble balance (KIBB-g1) designed to directly realize mass at the gram-level range with uncertainties on the order of parts in 10$^6$ has been developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). The masses of a nominally 5\,g and 1\,g weight were determined with 1-$σ$ standard uncertainties of 9.0\,$\upmu$g and 6.7\,$\upmu$g, respectively. The corresponding rel…
▽ More
A tabletop-sized Kibble balance (KIBB-g1) designed to directly realize mass at the gram-level range with uncertainties on the order of parts in 10$^6$ has been developed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). The masses of a nominally 5\,g and 1\,g weight were determined with 1-$σ$ standard uncertainties of 9.0\,$\upmu$g and 6.7\,$\upmu$g, respectively. The corresponding relative uncertainties are $1.8\times 10^{-6}$ and $6.3\times 10^{-6}$. The construction of the instrument, capabilities, and full uncertainty budgets are presented in this manuscript.
△ Less
Submitted 21 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Shades of Dark Uncertainty and Consensus Value for the Newtonian Constant of Gravitation
Authors:
Christos Merkatas,
Blaza Toman,
Antonio Possolo,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
The Newtonian constant of gravitation, $G$, stands out in the landscape of the most common fundamental constants owing to its surprisingly large relative uncertainty, which is attributable mostly to the dispersion of the values measured for it in different experiments.
This study focuses on a set of measurements of $G$ that are mutually inconsistent, in the sense that the dispersion of the measu…
▽ More
The Newtonian constant of gravitation, $G$, stands out in the landscape of the most common fundamental constants owing to its surprisingly large relative uncertainty, which is attributable mostly to the dispersion of the values measured for it in different experiments.
This study focuses on a set of measurements of $G$ that are mutually inconsistent, in the sense that the dispersion of the measured values is significantly larger than what their reported uncertainties suggest that it should be. Furthermore, there is a loosely defined group of measured values that lie fairly close to a consensus value that may be derived from all the measurement results, and then there are one or more groups with measured values farther away from the consensus value, some higher, others lower.
This same general pattern is often observed in many interlaboratory studies and meta-analyses. In the conventional treatments of such data, the mutual inconsistency is addressed by inflating the reported uncertainties, either multiplicatively, or by the addition of random effects, both reflecting the presence of dark uncertainty. The former approach is often used by CODATA and by the Particle Data Group, and the latter is common in medical meta-analysis and in metrology.
We propose a new procedure for consensus building that models the results using latent clusters with different shades of dark uncertainty, which assigns a customized amount of dark uncertainty to each measured value, as a mixture of those shades, and does so taking into account both the placement of the measured values relative to the consensus value, and the reported uncertainties. We demonstrate this procedure by deriving a new estimate for $G$, as a consensus value $G = 6.67408 \times 10^{-11} \,\text{m}^{-3} \, \text{kg}^{-1} \, \text{s}^{-2}$, with $u(G) = 0.00024 \times 10^{-11} \,\text{m}^{-3} \, \text{kg}^{-1} \, \text{s}^{-2}$.
△ Less
Submitted 23 May, 2019;
originally announced May 2019.
-
Measurement of the Planck constant at the National Institute of Standards and Technology from 2015 to 2017
Authors:
D. Haddad,
F. Seifert,
L. S. Chao,
A. Possolo,
D. B. Newell,
J. R. Pratt,
C. J. Williams,
S. Schlamminger
Abstract:
Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology(NIST) have measured the value of the Planck constant to be $h =6.626\,069\,934(89)\times 10^{-34}\,$J$\,$s (relative standard uncertainty $13\times 10^{-9}$). The result is based on over 10$\,$000 weighings of masses with nominal values ranging from 0.5$\,$kg to 2$\,$kg with the Kibble balance NIST-4. The uncertainty has been reduce…
▽ More
Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology(NIST) have measured the value of the Planck constant to be $h =6.626\,069\,934(89)\times 10^{-34}\,$J$\,$s (relative standard uncertainty $13\times 10^{-9}$). The result is based on over 10$\,$000 weighings of masses with nominal values ranging from 0.5$\,$kg to 2$\,$kg with the Kibble balance NIST-4. The uncertainty has been reduced by more than twofold relative to a previous determination because of three factors: (1) a much larger data set than previously available, allowing a more realistic, and smaller, Type A evaluation; (2) a more comprehensive measurement of the back action of the weighing current on the magnet by weighing masses up to 2$\,$kg, decreasing the uncertainty associated with magnet non-linearity; (3) a rigorous investigation of the dependence of the geometric factor on the coil velocity reducing the uncertainty assigned to time-dependent leakage of current in the coil.
△ Less
Submitted 8 August, 2017;
originally announced August 2017.
-
Recent measurements of the gravitational constant as a function of time
Authors:
S. Schlamminger,
J. H. Gundlach,
R. D. Newman
Abstract:
A recent publication (J.D. Anderson et. al., EPL 110, 1002) presented a strong correlation between the measured values of the gravitational constant $G$ and the 5.9-year oscillation of the length of day. Here, we provide a compilation of all published measurements of $G$ taken over the last 35 years. A least squares regression to a sine with a period of 5.9 years still yields a better fit than a s…
▽ More
A recent publication (J.D. Anderson et. al., EPL 110, 1002) presented a strong correlation between the measured values of the gravitational constant $G$ and the 5.9-year oscillation of the length of day. Here, we provide a compilation of all published measurements of $G$ taken over the last 35 years. A least squares regression to a sine with a period of 5.9 years still yields a better fit than a straight line. However, our additions and corrections to the G data reported by Anderson {\it et al.} significantly weaken the correlation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 May, 2015; v1 submitted 7 May, 2015;
originally announced May 2015.
-
First measurements of the flux integral with the NIST-4 watt balance
Authors:
D. Haddad,
F. Seifert,
L. S. Chao,
A. Cao,
G. Sineriz,
J. R. Pratt,
D. B. Newell,
S. Schlamminger
Abstract:
In early 2014, construction of a new watt balance, named NIST-4, has started at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). In a watt balance, the gravitational force of an unknown mass is compensated by an electromagnetic force produced by a coil in a magnet system. The electromagnetic force depends on the current in the coil and the magnetic flux integral. Most watt balances featu…
▽ More
In early 2014, construction of a new watt balance, named NIST-4, has started at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). In a watt balance, the gravitational force of an unknown mass is compensated by an electromagnetic force produced by a coil in a magnet system. The electromagnetic force depends on the current in the coil and the magnetic flux integral. Most watt balances feature an additional calibration mode, referred to as velocity mode, which allows one to measure the magnetic flux integral to high precision. In this article we describe first measurements of the flux integral in the new watt balance. We introduce measurement and data analysis techniques to assess the quality of the measurements and the adverse effects of vibrations on the instrument.
△ Less
Submitted 16 March, 2015;
originally announced March 2015.
-
A summary of the Planck constant measurements using a watt balance with a superconducting solenoid at NIST
Authors:
S. Schlamminger,
R. L. Steiner,
D. Haddad,
D. B. Newell,
F. Seifert,
L. S. Chao,
R. Liu,
E. R. Williams,
J. R. Pratt
Abstract:
Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology have been using a watt balance, NIST-3, to measure the Planck constant $h$ for over ten years. Two recently published values disagree by more than one standard uncertainty. The motivation for the present manuscript is twofold. First, we correct the latest published number to take into account a recently discovered systematic error i…
▽ More
Researchers at the National Institute of Standards and Technology have been using a watt balance, NIST-3, to measure the Planck constant $h$ for over ten years. Two recently published values disagree by more than one standard uncertainty. The motivation for the present manuscript is twofold. First, we correct the latest published number to take into account a recently discovered systematic error in mass dissemination at the Bureau International des Poids et Mesures (BIPM). Second, we provide guidance on how to combine the two numbers into one final result. In order to adequately reflect the discrepancy, we added an additional systematic uncertainty to the published uncertainty budgets. The final value of $h$ measured with NIST-3 is $h = 6.626\,069\,36(37)\times 10^{-34}\,\mbox{J\,s}$. This result is $77(57) \times 10^{-9}$ fractionally higher than $h_{\mathrm{90}}$. Each number in parentheses gives the value of the standard uncertainty in the last two digits of the respective value and $h_{\mathrm{90}}$ is the conventional value of the Planck constant given by $h_{\mathrm{90}}\equiv 4 /( K_{\mathrm{J-90}}^2 R_{\mathrm{K-90}})$, where $K_{\mathrm{J-90}}$ and $R_{\mathrm{K-90}}$ denote the conventional values of the Josephson and von Klitzing constants, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 27 January, 2015;
originally announced January 2015.
-
A determination of the local acceleration of gravity for the NIST-4 watt balance
Authors:
E. J. Leaman,
D. Haddad,
F. Seifert,
L. S. Chao,
A. Cao,
J. R. Pratt,
S. Schlamminger,
D. B. Newell
Abstract:
A new watt balance is being constructed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in preparation for the redefinition of the International System of Units and the realization of mass through an exact value of the Planck constant. The total relative uncertainty goal for this instrument of a few parts in $10^{8}$ requires that the local acceleration due to gravity be known at the…
▽ More
A new watt balance is being constructed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) in preparation for the redefinition of the International System of Units and the realization of mass through an exact value of the Planck constant. The total relative uncertainty goal for this instrument of a few parts in $10^{8}$ requires that the local acceleration due to gravity be known at the location of a test mass with a relative uncertainty on the order of only a few parts in $10^{9}$. To make this determination, both the horizontal and vertical gradients of gravity must be known such that gravity may be tied from an absolute reference in the laboratory to the precise mass location. We describe the procedures used to model and measure gravity variations throughout the laboratory and give our results.
△ Less
Submitted 12 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
A LEGO Watt Balance: An apparatus to determine a mass based on the new SI
Authors:
L. S. Chao,
S. Schlamminger,
D. B. Newell,
J. R. Pratt,
F. Seifert,
X. Zhang,
G. Sineriz,
M. Liu,
D. Haddad
Abstract:
A global effort to redefine our International System of Units (SI) is underway and the change to the new system is expected to occur in 2018. Within the newly redefined SI, the present base units will still exist but be derived from fixed numerical values of seven reference constants. More specifically, the unit of mass, the kilogram, will be realized through a fixed value of the Planck constant…
▽ More
A global effort to redefine our International System of Units (SI) is underway and the change to the new system is expected to occur in 2018. Within the newly redefined SI, the present base units will still exist but be derived from fixed numerical values of seven reference constants. More specifically, the unit of mass, the kilogram, will be realized through a fixed value of the Planck constant $h$. For instance, a watt balance can be used to realize the kilogram unit of mass within a few parts in $10^8$. Such a balance has been designed and constructed at the National Institute of Standards and Technology. For educational outreach and to demonstrate the principle, we have constructed a LEGO tabletop watt balance capable of measuring a gram size mass to 1 % relative uncertainty. This article presents the design, construction, and performance of the LEGO watt balance and its ability to determine $h$
△ Less
Submitted 7 August, 2015; v1 submitted 4 December, 2014;
originally announced December 2014.
-
Reflections on a Measurement of the Gravitational Constant Using a Beam Balance and 13 Tons of Mercury
Authors:
S. Schlamminger,
R. E. Pixley,
F. Nolting,
J. Schurr,
U. Straumann
Abstract:
In 2006, a final result of a measurement of the gravitational constant $G$ performed by researchers at the University of Zürich was published. A value of $G=6.674\,252(122)\times 10^{-11}\,\mbox{m}^3\,\mbox{kg}^{-1}\,\mbox{s}^{-2}$ was obtained after an experimental effort that lasted over one decade. Here, we briefly summarize the measurement and discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this appro…
▽ More
In 2006, a final result of a measurement of the gravitational constant $G$ performed by researchers at the University of Zürich was published. A value of $G=6.674\,252(122)\times 10^{-11}\,\mbox{m}^3\,\mbox{kg}^{-1}\,\mbox{s}^{-2}$ was obtained after an experimental effort that lasted over one decade. Here, we briefly summarize the measurement and discuss the strengths and weaknesses of this approach.
△ Less
Submitted 19 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
A nonlinearity in permanent-magnet systems used in watt balances
Authors:
Shisong Li,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Jon Pratt
Abstract:
Watt balances are used to measure the Planck constant and will be used in the future to realize mass at the kilogram level. They increasingly rely on permanent magnet systems to generate the magnetic flux. It has been known that the weighing current might effect the magnetization state of the permanent magnetic system used in these systems causing a systematic bias that can lead to an error in the…
▽ More
Watt balances are used to measure the Planck constant and will be used in the future to realize mass at the kilogram level. They increasingly rely on permanent magnet systems to generate the magnetic flux. It has been known that the weighing current might effect the magnetization state of the permanent magnetic system used in these systems causing a systematic bias that can lead to an error in the result if not accounted for. In this article a simple model explaining the effect of the weighing current on the yoke of the magnet is developed. This model leads to a nonlinear dependence of the magnetic flux density in the gap that is proportional to the squared value of the coil current. The effect arises from changing the reluctance of the yoke by the additional field produced by the coil. Our analysis shows that the effect depends on the width of the air gap, the magnetic flux density in the air gap, and the $BH$ curve of the yoke material. Suggestions to reduce the nonlinear effect are discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Construction, Measurement, Shimming, and Performance of the NIST-4 Magnet System
Authors:
Frank Seifert,
Alireza Panna,
Shisong Li,
Bing Han,
Leon Chao,
Austin Cao,
Darine Haddad,
Heeju Choi,
Lori Haley,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
The magnet system is one of the key elements of a watt balance. For the new watt balance currently under construction at the National Institute of Standards and Technology, a permanent magnet system was chosen. We describe the detailed construction of the magnet system, first measurements of the field profile, and shimming techniques that were used to achieve a flat field profile. The relative cha…
▽ More
The magnet system is one of the key elements of a watt balance. For the new watt balance currently under construction at the National Institute of Standards and Technology, a permanent magnet system was chosen. We describe the detailed construction of the magnet system, first measurements of the field profile, and shimming techniques that were used to achieve a flat field profile. The relative change of the radial magnetic flux density is less than $10^{-4}$ over a range of 5 cm. We further characterize the most important aspects of the magnet and give order of magnitude estimates for several systematic effects that originate from the magnet system.
△ Less
Submitted 24 December, 2014; v1 submitted 6 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
-
Determination of the Planck constant using a watt balance with a superconducting magnet system at the National Institute of Standards and Technology
Authors:
Stephan Schlamminger,
Darine Haddad,
Frank Seifert,
Leon S Chao,
David B Newell,
Ruimin Liu,
Richard L Steiner,
Jon R Pratt
Abstract:
For the past two years, measurements have been performed with a watt balance at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) to determine the Planck constant. A detailed analysis of these measurements and their uncertainties has led to the value $h=6.626\,069\,79(30)\times 10^{-34}\,$J$\,$s. The relative standard uncertainty is $ 45\times 10^{-9}$. This result is $141\times 10^{-9}$ f…
▽ More
For the past two years, measurements have been performed with a watt balance at the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) to determine the Planck constant. A detailed analysis of these measurements and their uncertainties has led to the value $h=6.626\,069\,79(30)\times 10^{-34}\,$J$\,$s. The relative standard uncertainty is $ 45\times 10^{-9}$. This result is $141\times 10^{-9}$ fractionally higher than $h_{90}$. Here $h_{90}$ is the conventional value of the Planck constant given by $h_{90}\equiv 4 /( K_{\mathrm{J-90}}^2R_{\mathrm{K-90}})$, where $K_{\mathrm{J-90}}$ and $R_{\mathrm{K-90}}$ denote the conventional values of the Josephson and von Klitzing constants, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2014; v1 submitted 31 January, 2014;
originally announced January 2014.
-
A reference-beam autocollimator with nanoradian sensitivity from mHz to kHz and dynamic range of 10^7
Authors:
T. B. Arp,
C. A. Hagedorn,
S. Schlamminger,
J. H. Gundlach
Abstract:
We describe an autocollimating optical angle sensor with a dynamic range of 9 mrad and nrad/sqrt(Hz) sensitivity at frequencies from 5 mHz to 3 kHz. This work improves the standard multi-slit autocollimator design by adding two optical components, a reference mirror and a condensing lens. This autocollimator makes a differential measurement between a reference mirror and a target mirror, suppressi…
▽ More
We describe an autocollimating optical angle sensor with a dynamic range of 9 mrad and nrad/sqrt(Hz) sensitivity at frequencies from 5 mHz to 3 kHz. This work improves the standard multi-slit autocollimator design by adding two optical components, a reference mirror and a condensing lens. This autocollimator makes a differential measurement between a reference mirror and a target mirror, suppressing common-mode noise sources. The condensing lens reduces optical aberrations, increases intensity, and improves image quality. To further improve the stability of the device at low frequencies the body of the autocollimator is designed to reduce temperature variations and their effects. A new data processing technique was developed in order to suppress the effects of imperfections in the CCD.
△ Less
Submitted 18 September, 2013;
originally announced September 2013.
-
Brownian force noise from molecular collisions and the sensitivity of advanced gravitational wave observatories
Authors:
R. Dolesi,
M. Hueller,
D. Nicolodi,
D. Tombolato,
S. Vitale,
P. J. Wass,
W. J. Weber,
M. Evans,
P. Fritschel,
R. Weiss,
J. H. Gundlach,
C. A. Hagedorn,
S. Schlamminger,
G. Ciani,
A. Cavalleri
Abstract:
We present an analysis of Brownian force noise from residual gas dam** of reference test masses as a fundamental sensitivity limit in small force experiments. The resulting acceleration noise increases significantly when the distance of the test mass to the surrounding experimental apparatus is smaller than the dimension of the test mass itself. For the Advanced LIGO interferometric gravitationa…
▽ More
We present an analysis of Brownian force noise from residual gas dam** of reference test masses as a fundamental sensitivity limit in small force experiments. The resulting acceleration noise increases significantly when the distance of the test mass to the surrounding experimental apparatus is smaller than the dimension of the test mass itself. For the Advanced LIGO interferometric gravitational wave observatory, where the relevant test mass is a suspended 340 mm diameter cylindrical end mirror, the force noise power is increased by roughly a factor 40 by the presence of a similarly shaped reaction mass at a nominal separation of 5 mm. The force noise, of order 20 fN\rthz\ for $2 \times 10^{-6}$ Pa of residual H$_2$ gas, rivals quantum optical fluctuations as the dominant noise source between 10 and 30 Hz. We present here a numerical and analytical analysis for the gas dam** force noise for Advanced LIGO, backed up by experimental evidence from several recent measurements. Finally, we discuss the impact of residual gas dam** on the gravitational wave sensitivity and possible mitigation strategies.
△ Less
Submitted 30 September, 2011; v1 submitted 16 August, 2011;
originally announced August 2011.
-
Picoradian deflection measurement with an interferometric quasi-autocollimator using weak value amplification
Authors:
Matthew D. Turner,
Charles A. Hagedorn,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Jens H. Gundlach
Abstract:
We present an "interferometric quasi-autocollimator" that employs weak value amplification to measure angular deflections of a target mirror. The device has been designed to be insensitive to all translations of the target. We present a conceptual explanation of the amplification effect used by the device. An implementation of the device demonstrates sensitivities better than 10 picoradians per ro…
▽ More
We present an "interferometric quasi-autocollimator" that employs weak value amplification to measure angular deflections of a target mirror. The device has been designed to be insensitive to all translations of the target. We present a conceptual explanation of the amplification effect used by the device. An implementation of the device demonstrates sensitivities better than 10 picoradians per root hertz between 10 and 200 hertz.
△ Less
Submitted 22 March, 2011;
originally announced March 2011.
-
Removal of zero-point drift from AB data and the statistical cost
Authors:
H Erik Swanson,
Stephan Schlamminger
Abstract:
Often the result of a scientific experiment is given by the difference of measurements in two configurations, denoted by A and B. Since the measurements are not obtained simultaneously, drift of the zero-point can bias the result. In practice measurement patterns are used to minimize this bias. The time sequence AB followed by BA, for example, would cancel a linear drift in the average difference…
▽ More
Often the result of a scientific experiment is given by the difference of measurements in two configurations, denoted by A and B. Since the measurements are not obtained simultaneously, drift of the zero-point can bias the result. In practice measurement patterns are used to minimize this bias. The time sequence AB followed by BA, for example, would cancel a linear drift in the average difference A-B. We propose taking data with an alternating series ABAB.., and removing drift with a post-hoc analysis. We present an analysis method that removes bias from the result for drift up to polynomial order p. A statistical cost function c(N) is introduced to compare the uncertainty in the end result with that from using a raw data average. For a data set size N>30 the statistical cost is negligible. For N<30 the cost is plotted as a function of N and filter order p and the trade off between the size of the data set and p is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 9 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
-
Indirect Evidence for Lévy Walks in Squeeze Film Dam**
Authors:
Stephan Schlamminger,
Charles A. Hagedorn,
Jens H. Gundlach
Abstract:
Molecular flow gas dam** of mechanical motion in confined geometries, and its associated noise, is important in a variety of fields, including precision measurement, gravitational wave detection, and MEMS devices. We used two torsion balance instruments to measure the strength and distance-dependence of `squeeze film' dam**. Measured quality factors derived from free decay of oscillation are c…
▽ More
Molecular flow gas dam** of mechanical motion in confined geometries, and its associated noise, is important in a variety of fields, including precision measurement, gravitational wave detection, and MEMS devices. We used two torsion balance instruments to measure the strength and distance-dependence of `squeeze film' dam**. Measured quality factors derived from free decay of oscillation are consistent with gas particle superdiffusion in Lévy walks and inconsistent with those expected from traditional Gaussian random walk particle motion. The distance-dependence of squeeze film dam** observed in our experiments is in agreement with a parameter-free Monte Carlo simulation. The squeeze film dam** of the motion of a plate suspended a distance d away from a parallel surface scales with a fractional power between 1/d and 1/d^2.
△ Less
Submitted 29 May, 2010; v1 submitted 26 May, 2010;
originally announced May 2010.
-
Temporal Extent of Surface Potentials between Closely Spaced Metals
Authors:
Scott E Pollack,
Stephan Schlamminger,
Jens Gundlach
Abstract:
Variations in the electrostatic surface potential between the proof mass and electrode housing in the space-based gravitational wave mission LISA is one of the largest contributors of noise at frequencies below a few mHz. Torsion balances provide an ideal testbed for investigating these effects in conditions emulative of LISA. Our apparatus consists of a Au coated Cu plate brought near a Au coat…
▽ More
Variations in the electrostatic surface potential between the proof mass and electrode housing in the space-based gravitational wave mission LISA is one of the largest contributors of noise at frequencies below a few mHz. Torsion balances provide an ideal testbed for investigating these effects in conditions emulative of LISA. Our apparatus consists of a Au coated Cu plate brought near a Au coated Si plate pendulum suspended from a thin W wire. We have measured a white noise level of $30, \uVhz$ above approximately 0.1, mHz, rising at lower frequencies, for the surface potential variations between these two closely spaced metals.
△ Less
Submitted 29 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
