-
Blinding for precision scattering experiments: The MUSE approach as a case study
Authors:
J. C. Bernauer,
E. W. Cline,
H. Atac,
W. J. Briscoe,
A. Christopher Ndukwe,
E. J. Downie,
I. P. Fernando,
T. Gautam,
R. Gilman,
R. Goldin,
M. Kohl,
I. Lavrukhin,
W. Lin,
W. Lorenzon,
P. Mohanmurthy,
S. J. Nazeer,
M. Nicol,
T. Patel,
A. Prosnyakov,
R. D. Ransome,
R. Ratvasky,
H. Reid,
P. E. Reimer,
G. Ron,
T. Rostomyan
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Human bias is capable of changing the analysis of measured data sufficiently to alter the results of an experiment. It is incumbent upon modern experiments, especially those investigating quantities considered contentious in the broader community, to blind their analysis in an effort to minimize bias. The choice of a blinding model is experiment specific, but should also aim to prevent accidental…
▽ More
Human bias is capable of changing the analysis of measured data sufficiently to alter the results of an experiment. It is incumbent upon modern experiments, especially those investigating quantities considered contentious in the broader community, to blind their analysis in an effort to minimize bias. The choice of a blinding model is experiment specific, but should also aim to prevent accidental release of results before an analysis is finalized. In this paper, we discuss common threats to an unbiased analysis, as well as common quantities that can be blinded in different types of nuclear physics experiments. We use the Muon Scattering Experiment as an example, and detail the blinding scheme used therein.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Characterization of Muon and Electron Beams in the Paul Scherrer Institute PiM1 Channel for the MUSE Experiment
Authors:
E. Cline,
W. Lin,
P. Roy,
P. E. Reimer,
K. E. Mesick,
A. Akmal,
A. Alie,
H. Atac,
A. Atencio,
C. Ayerbe Gayoso,
N. Benmouna,
F. Benmokhtar,
J. C. Bernauer,
W. J. Briscoe,
J. Campbell,
D. Cohen,
E. O. Cohen,
C. Collicott,
K. Deiters,
S. Dogra,
E. Downie,
I. P. Fernando,
A. Flannery,
T. Gautam,
D. Ghosal
, et al. (35 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The MUon Scattering Experiment, MUSE, at the Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland, investigates the proton charge radius puzzle, lepton universality, and two-photon exchange, via simultaneous measurements of elastic muon-proton and electron-proton scattering. The experiment uses the PiM1 secondary beam channel, which was designed for high precision pion scattering measurements. We review the prope…
▽ More
The MUon Scattering Experiment, MUSE, at the Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland, investigates the proton charge radius puzzle, lepton universality, and two-photon exchange, via simultaneous measurements of elastic muon-proton and electron-proton scattering. The experiment uses the PiM1 secondary beam channel, which was designed for high precision pion scattering measurements. We review the properties of the beam line established for pions. We discuss the production processes that generate the electron and muon beams, and the simulations of these processes. Simulations of the $π$/$μ$/$e$ beams through the channel using TURTLE and G4beamline are compared. The G4beamline simulation is then compared to several experimental measurements of the channel, including the momentum dispersion at the IFP and target, the shape of the beam spot at the target, and timing measurements that allow the beam momenta to be determined. We conclude that the PiM1 channel can be used for high precision $π$, $μ$, and $e$ scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Time resolution of BC422 plastic scintillator read out by a SiPM
Authors:
Alexey Stoykov,
Tigran Rostomyan
Abstract:
Plastic scintillators are widely used in particle detectors when precise timing information is required. As a basis for comparing different detectors we use such a characteristic as the time resolution per 1MeV detected energy, i.e. the expected time resolution assuming the deposited energy in the scintillator equals to 1MeV and all the scintillation light is collected to the photosensor. In this…
▽ More
Plastic scintillators are widely used in particle detectors when precise timing information is required. As a basis for comparing different detectors we use such a characteristic as the time resolution per 1MeV detected energy, i.e. the expected time resolution assuming the deposited energy in the scintillator equals to 1MeV and all the scintillation light is collected to the photosensor. In this work we measure this parameter with BC422 plastic scintillator read out by different SiPMs. The best obtained value is about 6ps, which is almost a factor of 3 better compared to our earlier result from 2012. Such an improvement represents the progress in the development of SiPMs made over these years and, driven by this progress, an improved knowledge and know-how on such detectors.
△ Less
Submitted 13 June, 2021; v1 submitted 21 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
Timing Detectors with SiPM read-out for the MUSE Experiment at PSI
Authors:
Tigran Rostomyan,
Ethan Cline,
Ievgen Lavrukhin,
Hamza Atac,
Ariella Atencio,
Jan C. Bernauer,
William J. Briscoe,
Dan Cohen,
Erez O. Cohen,
Cristina Collicott,
Konrad Deiters,
Shraddha Dogra,
Evangeline Downie,
Werner Erni,
Ishara P. Fernando,
Anne Flannery,
Thir Gautam,
Debdeep Ghosal,
Ronald Gilman,
Alexander Golossanov,
Jack Hirschman,
Minjung Kim,
Michael Kohl,
Bernd Krusche,
Lin Li
, et al. (18 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Muon Scattering Experiment at the Paul Scherrer Institut uses a mixed beam of electrons, muons, and pions, necessitating precise timing to identify the beam particles and reactions they cause. We describe the design and performance of three timing detectors using plastic scintillator read out with silicon photomultipliers that have been built for the experiment. The Beam Hodoscope, upstream of…
▽ More
The Muon Scattering Experiment at the Paul Scherrer Institut uses a mixed beam of electrons, muons, and pions, necessitating precise timing to identify the beam particles and reactions they cause. We describe the design and performance of three timing detectors using plastic scintillator read out with silicon photomultipliers that have been built for the experiment. The Beam Hodoscope, upstream of the scattering target, counts the beam flux and precisely times beam particles both to identify species and provide a starting time for time-of-flight measurements. The Beam Monitor, downstream of the scattering target, counts the unscattered beam flux, helps identify background in scattering events, and precisely times beam particles for time-of-flight measurements. The Beam Focus Monitor, mounted on the target ladder under the liquid hydrogen target inside the target vacuum chamber, is used in dedicated runs to sample the beam spot at three points near the target center, where the beam should be focused.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2020; v1 submitted 23 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
The BGOOD experimental setup at ELSA
Authors:
S. Alef,
P. Bauer,
D. Bayadilov,
R. Beck,
M. Becker,
A. Bella,
J. Bieling,
S. Boese,
A. Braghieri,
K. -Th. Brinkmann,
P. Cole,
R. Di Salvo,
D. Elsner,
A. Fantini,
O. Freyermuth,
F. Frommberger,
G. Gervino,
F. Ghio,
S. Goertz,
A. Gridnev,
E. Gutz,
D. Hammann,
J. Hannappel,
W. Hillert,
O. Jahn
, et al. (36 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The BGOOD experiment at the ELSA facility in Bonn has been commissioned within the framework of an international collaboration. The experiment pursues a systematic investigation of non-strange and strange meson photoproduction, in particular $t$-channel processes at low momentum transfer. The setup uniquely combines a central almost $4π$ acceptance BGO crystal calorimeter with a large aperture for…
▽ More
The BGOOD experiment at the ELSA facility in Bonn has been commissioned within the framework of an international collaboration. The experiment pursues a systematic investigation of non-strange and strange meson photoproduction, in particular $t$-channel processes at low momentum transfer. The setup uniquely combines a central almost $4π$ acceptance BGO crystal calorimeter with a large aperture forward magnetic spectrometer providing excellent detection of both neutral and charged particles, complementary to other setups such as Crystal Barrel, Crystal Ball, LEPS and CLAS.
△ Less
Submitted 18 February, 2020; v1 submitted 24 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
A Liquid Hydrogen Target for the MUSE Experiment at PSI
Authors:
P. Roy,
S. Corsetti,
M. Dimond,
M. Kim,
L. Le Pottier,
W. Lorenzon,
R. Raymond,
H. Reid,
N. Steinberg,
N. Wuerfel,
K. Deiters,
W. J. Briscoe,
A. Golossanov,
T. Rostomyan
Abstract:
A 280 ml liquid hydrogen target has been constructed and tested for the MUSE experiment at PSI to investigate the proton charge radius via simultaneous measurement of elastic muon-proton and elastic electron-proton scattering. To control systematic uncertainties at a sub-percent level, strong constraints were put on the amount of material surrounding the target and on its temperature stability. Th…
▽ More
A 280 ml liquid hydrogen target has been constructed and tested for the MUSE experiment at PSI to investigate the proton charge radius via simultaneous measurement of elastic muon-proton and elastic electron-proton scattering. To control systematic uncertainties at a sub-percent level, strong constraints were put on the amount of material surrounding the target and on its temperature stability. The target cell wall is made of $120\,μ$m-thick Kapton, while the beam entrance and exit windows are made of $125\,μ$m-thick aluminized Kapton. The side exit windows are made of Mylar laminated on aramid fabric with an areal density of $368\,$g/m$^2$. The target system was successfully operated during a commissioning run at PSI at the end of 2018. The target temperature was stable at the 0.01 K level. This suggests a density stability at the $0.02\,$% level, which is about a factor of ten better than required.
△ Less
Submitted 5 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Technical Design Report for the Paul Scherrer Institute Experiment R-12-01.1: Studying the Proton "Radius" Puzzle with μp Elastic Scattering
Authors:
R. Gilman,
E. J. Downie,
G. Ron,
S. Strauch,
A. Afanasev,
A. Akmal,
J. Arrington,
H. Atac,
C. Ayerbe-Gayoso,
F. Benmokhtar,
N. Benmouna,
J. Bernauer,
A. Blomberg,
W. J. Briscoe,
D. Cioffi,
E. Cline,
D. Cohen,
E. O. Cohen,
C. Collicott,
K. Deiters,
J. Diefenbach,
B. Dongwi,
D. Ghosal,
A. Golossanov,
R. Gothe
, et al. (34 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The difference in proton radii measured with $μp$ atoms and with $ep$ atoms and scattering remains an unexplained puzzle. The PSI MUSE proposal is to measure $μp$ and $e p$ scattering in the same experiment at the same time. The experiment will determine cross sections, two-photon effects, form factors, and radii independently for the two reactions, and will allow $μp$ and $ep$ results to be compa…
▽ More
The difference in proton radii measured with $μp$ atoms and with $ep$ atoms and scattering remains an unexplained puzzle. The PSI MUSE proposal is to measure $μp$ and $e p$ scattering in the same experiment at the same time. The experiment will determine cross sections, two-photon effects, form factors, and radii independently for the two reactions, and will allow $μp$ and $ep$ results to be compared with reduced systematic uncertainties. These data should provide the best test of lepton universality in a scattering experiment to date, about an order of magnitude improvement over previous tests. Measuring scattering with both particle polarities will allow a test of two-photon exchange at the sub-percent level, about a factor of four improvement on uncertainties and over an order of magnitude more data points than previous low momentum transfer determinations, and similar to the current generation of higher momentum transfer electron experiments. The experiment has the potential to demonstrate whether the $μp$ and $ep$ interactions are consistent or different, and whether any difference results from novel physics or two-photon exchange. The uncertainties are such that if the discrepancy is real it should be confirmed with $\approx$5$σ$ significance, similar to that already established between the regular and muonic hydrogen Lamb shift.
△ Less
Submitted 27 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
A new measurement of the neutron detection efficiency for the NaI Crystal Ball detector
Authors:
M. Martemianov,
V. Kulikov,
B. T. Demissie,
Z. Marinides,
C. S. Akondi,
J. R. M. Annand,
H. J. Arends,
R. Beck,
N. Borisov,
A. Braghieri,
W. J. Briscoe,
S. Cherepnya,
C. Collicott,
S. Costanza,
E. J. Downie,
M. Dieterle,
M. I. Ferretti Bondy,
L. V. Filkov,
S. Garni,
D. I. Glazier,
D. Glowa,
W. Gradl,
G. Gurevich,
D. Hornidge,
G. M. Huber
, et al. (46 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
We report on a measurement of the neutron detection efficiency in NaI crystals in the Crystal Ball detector obtained from a study of single p0 photoproduction on deuterium using the tagged photon beam at the Mainz Microtron. The results were obtained up to a neutron energy of 400 MeV. They are compared to previous measurements made more than 15 years ago at the pion beam at the BNL AGS.
We report on a measurement of the neutron detection efficiency in NaI crystals in the Crystal Ball detector obtained from a study of single p0 photoproduction on deuterium using the tagged photon beam at the Mainz Microtron. The results were obtained up to a neutron energy of 400 MeV. They are compared to previous measurements made more than 15 years ago at the pion beam at the BNL AGS.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
