-
First application of the failure forecast method to the GPS horizontal displacement data collected in the Campi Flegrei caldera (Italy) in 2011-2020
Authors:
Andrea Bevilacqua,
Abani Patra,
E. Bruce Pitman,
Marcus Bursik,
Prospero De Martino,
Flora Giudicepietro,
Giovanni Macedonio,
Stefano Vitale,
Franco Flandoli,
Barry Voight,
Augusto Neri
Abstract:
Using the failure forecast method we describe a first assessment of failure time on present-day unrest signals at Campi Flegrei caldera (Italy) based on the horizontal deformation data collected in [2011, 2020] at eleven GPS stations.
Using the failure forecast method we describe a first assessment of failure time on present-day unrest signals at Campi Flegrei caldera (Italy) based on the horizontal deformation data collected in [2011, 2020] at eleven GPS stations.
△ Less
Submitted 6 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
A new method to identify the source vent location of tephra fall deposits: development and testing, and application to key Quaternary eruptions of Western North America
Authors:
Qingyuan Yang,
Marcus Bursik,
E Bruce Pitman
Abstract:
A new method to identify the source vent location of tephra fall deposits based on thickness or maximum clast size measurements is presented in this work. It couples a first-order gradient descent method with either one of two commonly-used semi-empirical models of tephra thickness distribution. The method is successfully applied to three tephra thickness and one maximum clast size datasets of the…
▽ More
A new method to identify the source vent location of tephra fall deposits based on thickness or maximum clast size measurements is presented in this work. It couples a first-order gradient descent method with either one of two commonly-used semi-empirical models of tephra thickness distribution. The method is successfully applied to three tephra thickness and one maximum clast size datasets of the North Mono and Fogo A tephra deposits. Randomly selected and localized subsets of these datasets are used as input to evaluate its performance in cases of sparse observations. The results suggest that estimating the dispersal axis is a more robust way to constrain the source vent location with sparse observations. Bootstrap aggregating and examining the surface of the cost function are proposed to characterize the uncertainty of the method. Distinctions between the two adopted semi-empirical models of tephra thickness distribution are discussed. Results from applying the method to thickness datasets of the Trego Hot Springs and Rockland tephras are consistent with previous studies, which also provide new estimates on their total volume. The method is then applied to a series of well-correlated tephra sub-units preserved within the Wilson Creek Formation to estimate their vent location and total volume. The simplicity and flexibility of the method make it a potentially useful and powerful tool for the study of tephra fall deposits of different characteristics.
△ Less
Submitted 7 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Comparative analysis of the structures and outcomes of geophysical flow models and modeling assumptions using uncertainty quantification
Authors:
Abani K. Patra,
Andrea Bevilacqua,
Ali Akhavan-Safaei,
E. Bruce Pitman,
Marcus I. Bursik,
David Hyman
Abstract:
We present a new statistically driven method for analyzing the modeling of geophysical flows. Many models have been advocated by different modelers for such flows incorporating different modeling assumptions. Limited and sparse observational data on the modeled phenomena usually does not permit a clean discrimination among models for fitness of purpose, and, heuristic choices are usually made, esp…
▽ More
We present a new statistically driven method for analyzing the modeling of geophysical flows. Many models have been advocated by different modelers for such flows incorporating different modeling assumptions. Limited and sparse observational data on the modeled phenomena usually does not permit a clean discrimination among models for fitness of purpose, and, heuristic choices are usually made, especially for critical predictions of behavior that has not been experienced. We advocate here a methodology for characterizing models and the modeling assumptions they represent, using a statistical approach over the full range of applicability of the models. Such a characterization may then be used to decide the appropriateness of a model and modeling assumption for use. We present our method by comparing three different models arising from different rheology assumptions, and the data show unambiguously the performance of the models across a wide range of possible flow regimes. This comparison is facilitated by the recent development of the new release of our TITAN2D mass flow code that allows choice of multiple rheologies The quantitative and probabilistic analysis of contributions from different modeling assumptions in the models is particularly illustrative of the impact of the assumptions. Knowledge of which assumptions dominate, and, by how much, is illustrated in two different case studies: a small scale inclined plane with a flat runway, and the large scale topography on the SW slope of Volcán de Colima (MX). A simple model performance evaluation completes the presentation.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2018; v1 submitted 30 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Probabilistic enhancement of the Failure Forecast Method using a stochastic differential equation and application to volcanic eruption forecasts
Authors:
Andrea Bevilacqua,
E. Bruce Pitman,
Abani Patra,
Augusto Neri,
Marcus Bursik,
Barry Voight
Abstract:
We introduce a doubly stochastic method for performing material failure theory based forecasts of volcanic eruptions. The method enhances the well known Failure Forecast Method equation, introducing a new formulation similar to the Hull-White model in financial mathematics. In particular, we incorporate a stochastic noise term in the original equation, and systematically characterize the uncertain…
▽ More
We introduce a doubly stochastic method for performing material failure theory based forecasts of volcanic eruptions. The method enhances the well known Failure Forecast Method equation, introducing a new formulation similar to the Hull-White model in financial mathematics. In particular, we incorporate a stochastic noise term in the original equation, and systematically characterize the uncertainty. The model is a stochastic differential equation with mean reverting paths, where the traditional ordinary differential equation defines the mean solution. Our implementation allows the model to make excursions from the classical solutions, by including uncertainty in the estimation. The doubly stochastic formulation is particularly powerful, in that it provides a complete posterior probability distribution, allowing users to determine a worst case scenario with a specified level of confidence. We apply the new method on historical datasets of precursory signals, across a wide range of possible values of convexity in the solutions and amounts of scattering in the observations. The results show the increased forecasting skill of the doubly stochastic formulation of the equations if compared to statistical regression.
△ Less
Submitted 8 December, 2018; v1 submitted 29 May, 2018;
originally announced May 2018.
-
Refinement on non-hydrostatic shallow granular flow model in a global Cartesian coordinate system
Authors:
L. Yuan,
W. Liu,
J. Zhai,
S. F. Wu,
A. K. Patra,
E. B. Pitman
Abstract:
Current shallow granular flow models suited to arbitrary topography can be divided into two types, those formulated in bed-fitted curvilinear coordinates, and those formulated in global Cartesian coordinates. The shallow granular flow model of Denlinger and Iverson \cite{Denlinger2004} and the Boussinesq-type shallow granular flow theory of Castro-Orgaz \emph{et al}. \cite{Castro2014} are formulat…
▽ More
Current shallow granular flow models suited to arbitrary topography can be divided into two types, those formulated in bed-fitted curvilinear coordinates, and those formulated in global Cartesian coordinates. The shallow granular flow model of Denlinger and Iverson \cite{Denlinger2004} and the Boussinesq-type shallow granular flow theory of Castro-Orgaz \emph{et al}. \cite{Castro2014} are formulated in a Cartesian coordinate system (with $z$ vertical), and both account for the effect of nonzero vertical acceleration on depth-averaged momentum fluxes and stress states. In this paper, we first reformulate the vertical normal stress of Castro-Orgaz \emph{et al}. \cite{Castro2014} in a quadratic polynomial in the relative elevation $η$. This form allows for analytical depth integration of the vertical normal stress. We then calculate the basal normal stress based on the basal friction law and scaling analysis. These calculations, plus certain constitutive relations, lead to a refined full non-hydrostatic shallow granular flow model, which is further rewritten in a form of Boussinesq-type water wave equations for future numerical studies. In the present numerical study, we apply the open-source code TITAN2D to numerical solution of a low-order version of the full model involving only a mean vertical acceleration correction term. To cure the numerical instability associated with discretization of the enhanced gravity, we propose an approximate formula for the enhanced gravity by utilizing the hydrostatic pressure assumption in the bed normal direction. Numerical calculations are conducted for several test cases involving steep slopes. Comparison with a bed-fitted model shows that even the simplified non-hydrostatic Cartesian model can be used to simulate shallow granular flows over arbitrary topography.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2016; v1 submitted 10 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
Forces on Bins - The Effect of Random Friction
Authors:
E. Bruce Pitman
Abstract:
In this note we re-examine the classic Janssen theory for stresses in bins, including a randomness in the friction coefficient. The Janssen analysis relies on assumptions not met in practice; for this reason, we numerically solve the PDEs expressing balance of momentum in a bin, again including randomness in friction.
In this note we re-examine the classic Janssen theory for stresses in bins, including a randomness in the friction coefficient. The Janssen analysis relies on assumptions not met in practice; for this reason, we numerically solve the PDEs expressing balance of momentum in a bin, again including randomness in friction.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 1997; v1 submitted 12 August, 1997;
originally announced August 1997.
