-
Mesoscopic analytical approach in a three state opinion model with continuous internal variable
Authors:
Lucía Pedraza,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Viktoriya Semeshenko,
Pablo Balenzuela
Abstract:
Analytical approaches in models of opinion formation have been extensively studied either for an opinion represented as a discrete or a continuous variable. In this paper, we analyze a model which combines both approaches. The state of an agent is represented with an internal continuous variable (the leaning or propensity), that leads to a discrete public opinion: pro, against or neutral. This mod…
▽ More
Analytical approaches in models of opinion formation have been extensively studied either for an opinion represented as a discrete or a continuous variable. In this paper, we analyze a model which combines both approaches. The state of an agent is represented with an internal continuous variable (the leaning or propensity), that leads to a discrete public opinion: pro, against or neutral. This model can be described by a set of master equations which are a nonlinear coupled system of first order differential equations of hyperbolic type including non-local terms and non-local boundary conditions, which can't be solved analytically. We developed an approximation to tackle this difficulty by deriving a set of master equations for the dynamics of the average leaning of agents with the same opinion, under the hypothesis of a time scale separation in the dynamics of the variables. We show that this simplified model accurately predicts the expected transition between a neutral consensus and a bi-polarized state, and also gives an excellent approximation for the dynamics of the average leaning of agents with the same opinion, even when the time separation scale hypothesis is not completely fulfilled.
△ Less
Submitted 14 November, 2022; v1 submitted 2 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Random multi-player games
Authors:
Natalia L. Kontorovsky,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Federico Vazquez
Abstract:
The study of evolutionary games with pairwise local interactions has been of interest to many different disciplines. Also local interactions with multiple opponents had been considered, although always for a fixed amount of players. In many situations, however, interactions between different numbers of players in each round could take place, and this case can not be reduced to pairwise interaction…
▽ More
The study of evolutionary games with pairwise local interactions has been of interest to many different disciplines. Also local interactions with multiple opponents had been considered, although always for a fixed amount of players. In many situations, however, interactions between different numbers of players in each round could take place, and this case can not be reduced to pairwise interactions. In this work we formalize and generalize the definition of evolutionary stable strategy (ESS) to be able to include a scenario in which the game is played by two players with probability $p$, and by three players with the complementary probability $1-p$. We show the existence of equilibria in pure and mixed strategies depending on the probability $p$, on a concrete example of the duel-truel game. We find a range of $p$ values for which the game has a mixed equilibrium and the proportion of players in each strategy depends on the particular value of $p$. We prove that each of these mixed equilibrium points are ESS. A more realistic way to study this dynamics with high-order interactions is to look at how it evolves in complex networks. We introduce and study an agent-based model on a network with a fixed number of nodes, which evolves as the replicator equation predicts. By studying the dynamics of this model on random networks we find that the phase transitions between the pure and mixed equilibria depend on the probability $p$ and also on the mean degree of the network.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2021;
originally announced December 2021.
-
Analytical formulation for multidimensional continuous opinion models
Authors:
Lucia Pedraza,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Nicolas Saintier,
Pablo Balenzuela
Abstract:
Usually, opinion formation models assume that individuals have an opinion about a given topic which can change due to interactions with others. However, individuals can have different opinions in different topics and therefore n-dimensional models are best suited to deal with these cases. While there have been many efforts to develop analytical models for one dimensional opinion models, less atten…
▽ More
Usually, opinion formation models assume that individuals have an opinion about a given topic which can change due to interactions with others. However, individuals can have different opinions in different topics and therefore n-dimensional models are best suited to deal with these cases. While there have been many efforts to develop analytical models for one dimensional opinion models, less attention has been paid to multidimensional ones. In this work, we develop an analytical approach for multidimensional models of continuous opinions where dimensions can be correlated or uncorrelated. We show that for any generic reciprocal interactions between agents, the mean value of initial opinion distribution is conserved. Moreover, for positive social influence interaction mechanisms, the variance of opinion distributions decreases with time and the system converges to a delta distributed function. In particular, we calculate the convergence time when agents get closer in a discrete quantity after interacting, showing a clear difference between correlated and uncorrelated cases.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
A novel analytical formulation of the Axelrod model
Authors:
Lucía Pedraza,
Sebastián Pinto,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Pablo Balenzuela
Abstract:
The Axelrod model of cultural dissemination has been widely studied in the field of statistical mechanics. The traditional version of this agent-based model is to assign a cultural vector of $F$ components to each agent, where each component can take one of $Q$ cultural trait. In this work, we introduce a novel set of mean field master equations to describe the model for $F=2$ and $F=3$ in complet…
▽ More
The Axelrod model of cultural dissemination has been widely studied in the field of statistical mechanics. The traditional version of this agent-based model is to assign a cultural vector of $F$ components to each agent, where each component can take one of $Q$ cultural trait. In this work, we introduce a novel set of mean field master equations to describe the model for $F=2$ and $F=3$ in complete graphs where all indirect interactions are explicitly calculated. We find that the transition between different macroscopic states is driven by initial conditions (set by parameter $Q$) and the size of the system $N$, who measures the balance between linear and cubic terms in master equations. We also find that this analytical approach fully agrees with simulations where the system does not break up during the dynamics and a scaling relation related to missing links reestablishes the agreement when this happens.
△ Less
Submitted 26 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
A model for the competition between political mono-polarization and bi-polarization
Authors:
Nicolas Saintier,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Federico Vazquez
Abstract:
We investigate the phenomena of political bi-polarization in a population of interacting agents by means of a generalized version of the model introduced in PRE E 101, 012101 (2020) for the dynamics of voting intention. Each agent has a propensity $p$ in $[0,1]$ to vote for one of two political candidates. In an iteration step, two agents $i$ and $j$ with respective propensities $p_i$ and $p_j$ in…
▽ More
We investigate the phenomena of political bi-polarization in a population of interacting agents by means of a generalized version of the model introduced in PRE E 101, 012101 (2020) for the dynamics of voting intention. Each agent has a propensity $p$ in $[0,1]$ to vote for one of two political candidates. In an iteration step, two agents $i$ and $j$ with respective propensities $p_i$ and $p_j$ interact, and then $p_i$ either increases by an amount $h>0$ with a probability that is a nonlinear function of $p_i$ and $p_j$ or decreases by $h$ with the complementary probability. We study the behavior of the system under variations of a parameter $q \ge 0$ that measures the nonlinearity of the propensity update rule. We focus on the stability properties of the two distinct stationary states: mono-polarization in which all agents share the same extreme propensity ($0$ or $1$), and bi-polarization where the population is divided into two groups with opposite and extreme propensities. We find that the bi-polarized state is stable for $q<q_c$, while the mono-polarized state is stable for $q>q_c$, where $q_c$ is a transition value that decreases as $h$ decreases. We develop a rate equation approach whose stability analysis reveals that $q_c$ vanishes when $h$ becomes infinitesimally small. This result is supported by the analysis of a transport equation derived in the continuum $h \to 0$ limit. We also show by Monte Carlo simulations that the mean time $τ$ to reach mono-polarization in a system of size $N$ scales as $τ\sim N^α$ at $q_c$ , where $α(h)$ is a non-universal exponent.
△ Less
Submitted 5 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
The role of voting intention in public opinion polarization
Authors:
Federico Vazquez,
Nicolas Saintier,
Juan Pablo Pinasco
Abstract:
We introduce and study a simple model for the dynamics of voting intention in a population of agents that have to choose between two candidates. The level of indecision of a given agent is modeled by its propensity to vote for one of the two alternatives, represented by a variable $p \in [0,1]$. When an agent $i$ interacts with another agent $j$ with propensity $p_j$, then $i$ either increases its…
▽ More
We introduce and study a simple model for the dynamics of voting intention in a population of agents that have to choose between two candidates. The level of indecision of a given agent is modeled by its propensity to vote for one of the two alternatives, represented by a variable $p \in [0,1]$. When an agent $i$ interacts with another agent $j$ with propensity $p_j$, then $i$ either increases its propensity $p_i$ by $h$ with probability $P_{ij}=ωp_i+(1-ω)p_j$, or decreases $p_i$ by $h$ with probability $1-P_{ij}$, where $h$ is a fixed step. We analyze the system by a rate equation approach and contrast the results with Monte Carlo simulations. We found that the dynamics of propensities depends on the weight $ω$ that an agent assigns to its own propensity. When all the weight is assigned to the interacting partner ($ω=0$), agents' propensities are quickly driven to one of the extreme values $p=0$ or $p=1$, until an extremist absorbing consensus is achieved. However, for $ω>0$ the system first reaches a quasi-stationary state of symmetric polarization where the distribution of propensities has the shape of an inverted Gaussian with a minimum at the center $p=1/2$ and two maxima at the extreme values $p=0,1$, until the symmetry is broken and the system is driven to an extremist consensus. A linear stability analysis shows that the lifetime of the polarized state, estimated by the mean consensus time $τ$, diverges as $τ\sim (1-ω)^{-2} \ln N$ when $ω$ approaches $1$, where $N$ is the system size. Finally, a continuous approximation allows to derive a transport equation whose convection term is compatible with a drift of particles from the center towards the extremes.
△ Less
Submitted 16 September, 2019;
originally announced September 2019.
-
A game theoretic model of wealth distribution
Authors:
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Mauro Rodriguez Cartabia,
Nicolas Saintier
Abstract:
In this work we consider an agent based model in order to study the wealth distribution problem where the interchange is determined with a symmetric zero sum game. Simultaneously, the agents update their way of play trying to learn the optimal one. Here, the agents use mixed strategies. We study this model using both simulations and theoretical tools. We derive the equations for the learning mecha…
▽ More
In this work we consider an agent based model in order to study the wealth distribution problem where the interchange is determined with a symmetric zero sum game. Simultaneously, the agents update their way of play trying to learn the optimal one. Here, the agents use mixed strategies. We study this model using both simulations and theoretical tools. We derive the equations for the learning mechanism, and we show that the mean strategy of the population satisfies an equation close to the classical replicator equation.
Concerning the wealth distribution, there are two interesting situations depending on the equilibrium of the game. If the equilibrium is a pure strategy, the wealth distribution is fixed after some transient time, and those players which are close to optimal strategy are richer. When the game has an equilibrium in mixed strategies, the stationary wealth distribution is close to a Gamma distribution with variance depending on the coefficients of the game matrix. We compute theoretically their second moment in this case.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2017;
originally announced September 2017.
-
Modeling Opinion Dynamics: Theoretical analysis and continuous approximation
Authors:
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Viktoriya Semeshenko,
Pablo Balenzuela
Abstract:
Frequently we revise our first opinions after talking over with other individuals because we get convinced. Argumentation is a verbal and social process aimed at convincing. It includes conversation and persuasion. In this case, the agreement is reached because the new arguments are incorporated. In this paper we deal with a simple model of opinion formation with such persuasion dynamics, and we f…
▽ More
Frequently we revise our first opinions after talking over with other individuals because we get convinced. Argumentation is a verbal and social process aimed at convincing. It includes conversation and persuasion. In this case, the agreement is reached because the new arguments are incorporated. In this paper we deal with a simple model of opinion formation with such persuasion dynamics, and we find the exact analytical solutions for both, long and short range interactions. A novel theoretical approach has been used in order to solve the master equations of the model with non-local kernels. Simulation results demonstrate an excellent agreement with results obtained by the theoretical estimation.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2016; v1 submitted 2 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
The undecided have the key: Interaction-driven opinion dynamics in a three state model
Authors:
Pablo Balenzuela,
Juan Pablo Pinasco,
Viktoriya Semeshenko
Abstract:
The effects of interpersonal interactions on individual's agreements result in a social aggregation process which is reflected in the formation of collective states, as for instance, groups of individuals with a similar opinion about a given issue. This field, which has been a longstanding concern of sociologists and psychologists, has been extended into an area of experimental social psychology,…
▽ More
The effects of interpersonal interactions on individual's agreements result in a social aggregation process which is reflected in the formation of collective states, as for instance, groups of individuals with a similar opinion about a given issue. This field, which has been a longstanding concern of sociologists and psychologists, has been extended into an area of experimental social psychology, and even has attracted the attention of physicists and mathematicians. In this article, we present a novel model of opinion formation in which agents may either have a strict preference for a choice, or be undecided. The opinion shift emerges during interpersonal communications, as a consequence of a cumulative process of conviction for one of the two extremes opinions through repeated interactions. There are two main ingredients which play key roles in determining the steady state: the initial fraction of undecided agents and the conviction's sensitivity in each interaction. As a function of these two parameters, the model presents a wide range of possible solutions, as for instance, consensus of each opinion, bi-polarisation or convergence of undecided individuals. We found that a minimum fraction of undecided agents is crucial not only for reaching consensus of a given opinion, but also to determine a dominant opinion in a polarised situation. In order to gain a deeper comprehension of the dynamics, we also present the theoretical master equations of the model.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.