-
Recoil imaging for directional detection of dark matter, neutrinos, and physics beyond the Standard Model
Authors:
C. A. J. O'Hare,
D. Loomba,
K. Altenmüller,
H. Álvarez-Pol,
F. D. Amaro,
H. M. Araújo,
D. Aristizabal Sierra,
J. Asaadi,
D. Attié,
S. Aune,
C. Awe,
Y. Ayyad,
E. Baracchini,
P. Barbeau,
J. B. R. Battat,
N. F. Bell,
B. Biasuzzi,
L. J. Bignell,
C. Boehm,
I. Bolognino,
F. M. Brunbauer,
M. Caamaño,
C. Cabo,
D. Caratelli,
J. M. Carmona
, et al. (142 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Recoil imaging entails the detection of spatially resolved ionization tracks generated by particle interactions. This is a highly sought-after capability in many classes of detector, with broad applications across particle and astroparticle physics. However, at low energies, where ionization signatures are small in size, recoil imaging only seems to be a practical goal for micro-pattern gas detect…
▽ More
Recoil imaging entails the detection of spatially resolved ionization tracks generated by particle interactions. This is a highly sought-after capability in many classes of detector, with broad applications across particle and astroparticle physics. However, at low energies, where ionization signatures are small in size, recoil imaging only seems to be a practical goal for micro-pattern gas detectors. This white paper outlines the physics case for recoil imaging, and puts forward a decadal plan to advance towards the directional detection of low-energy recoils with sensitivity and resolution close to fundamental performance limits. The science case covered includes: the discovery of dark matter into the neutrino fog, directional detection of sub-MeV solar neutrinos, the precision study of coherent-elastic neutrino-nucleus scattering, the detection of solar axions, the measurement of the Migdal effect, X-ray polarimetry, and several other applied physics goals. We also outline the R&D programs necessary to test concepts that are crucial to advance detector performance towards their fundamental limit: single primary electron sensitivity with full 3D spatial resolution at the $\sim$100 micron-scale. These advancements include: the use of negative ion drift, electron counting with high-definition electronic readout, time projection chambers with optical readout, and the possibility for nuclear recoil tracking in high-density gases such as argon. We also discuss the readout and electronics systems needed to scale-up such detectors to the ton-scale and beyond.
△ Less
Submitted 17 July, 2022; v1 submitted 11 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
A study of DC electrical breakdown in liquid helium through analysis of the empirical breakdown field distributions
Authors:
N. S. Phan,
W. Wei,
B. Beaumont,
N. Bouman,
S. M. Clayton,
S. A. Currie,
T. M. Ito,
J. C. Ramsey,
G. M. Seidel
Abstract:
We report results from a study on electrical breakdown in liquid helium using near-uniform-field stainless steel electrodes with a stressed area of $\sim$0.725 cm$^2$. The distribution of the breakdown field is obtained for temperatures between 1.7 K and 4.0 K, pressures between the saturated vapor pressure and 626 Torr, and with electrodes of different surface polishes. A data-based approach for…
▽ More
We report results from a study on electrical breakdown in liquid helium using near-uniform-field stainless steel electrodes with a stressed area of $\sim$0.725 cm$^2$. The distribution of the breakdown field is obtained for temperatures between 1.7 K and 4.0 K, pressures between the saturated vapor pressure and 626 Torr, and with electrodes of different surface polishes. A data-based approach for determining the electrode-surface-area scaling of the breakdown field is presented. The dependence of the breakdown probability on the field strength as extracted from the breakdown field distribution data is used to show that breakdown is a surface phenomenon closely correlated with Fowler-Nordheim field emission from asperities on the cathode. We show that the results from this analysis provides an explanation for the supposed electrode gap-size effect and also allows for a determination of the breakdown-field distribution for arbitrary shaped electrodes. Most importantly, the analysis method presented in this work can be extended to other noble liquids to explore the dependencies for electrical breakdown in those media.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
CYGNUS: Feasibility of a nuclear recoil observatory with directional sensitivity to dark matter and neutrinos
Authors:
S. E. Vahsen,
C. A. J. O'Hare,
W. A. Lynch,
N. J. C. Spooner,
E. Baracchini,
P. Barbeau,
J. B. R. Battat,
B. Crow,
C. Deaconu,
C. Eldridge,
A. C. Ezeribe,
M. Ghrear,
D. Loomba,
K. J. Mack,
K. Miuchi,
F. M. Mouton,
N. S. Phan,
K. Scholberg,
T. N. Thorpe
Abstract:
Now that conventional weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) dark matter searches are approaching the neutrino floor, there has been a resurgence of interest in detectors with sensitivity to nuclear recoil directions. A large-scale directional detector is attractive in that it would have sensitivity below the neutrino floor, be capable of unambiguously establishing the galactic origin of a pur…
▽ More
Now that conventional weakly interacting massive particle (WIMP) dark matter searches are approaching the neutrino floor, there has been a resurgence of interest in detectors with sensitivity to nuclear recoil directions. A large-scale directional detector is attractive in that it would have sensitivity below the neutrino floor, be capable of unambiguously establishing the galactic origin of a purported dark matter signal, and could serve a dual purpose as a neutrino observatory. We present the first detailed analysis of a 1000 m$^3$-scale detector capable of measuring a directional nuclear recoil signal at low energies. We propose a modular and multi-site observatory consisting of time projection chambers (TPCs) filled with helium and SF$_6$ at atmospheric pressure. Depending on the TPC readout technology, 10-20 helium recoils above 6 keVr or only 3-4 recoils above 20 keVr would suffice to distinguish a 10 GeV WIMP signal from the solar neutrino background. High-resolution charge readout also enables powerful electron background rejection capabilities well below 10 keV. We detail background and site requirements at the 1000 m$^3$-scale, and identify materials that require improved radiopurity. The final experiment, which we name CYGNUS-1000, will be able to observe 10-40 neutrinos from the Sun, depending on the final energy threshold. With the same exposure, the sensitivity to spin independent cross sections will extend into presently unexplored sub-10 GeV parameter space. For spin dependent interactions, already a 10 m$^3$-scale experiment could compete with upcoming generation-two detectors, but CYGNUS-1000 would improve upon this considerably. Larger volumes would bring sensitivity to neutrinos from an even wider range of sources, including galactic supernovae, nuclear reactors, and geological processes.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2020; v1 submitted 28 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Effect of an electric field on liquid helium scintillation produced by fast electrons
Authors:
N. S. Phan,
V. Cianciolo,
S. M. Clayton,
S. A. Currie,
R. Dipert,
T. M. Ito,
S. W. T. MacDonald,
C. M. O'Shaughnessy,
J. C. Ramsey,
G. M. Seidel,
E. Smith,
E. Tang,
Z. Tang,
W. Yao
Abstract:
The dependence on applied electric field ($0 - 40$ kV/cm) of the scintillation light produced by fast electrons and $α$ particles stopped in liquid helium in the temperature range of 0.44 K to 3.12 K is reported. For both types of particles, the reduction in the intensity of the scintillation signal due to the applied field exhibits an apparent temperature dependence. Using an approximate solution…
▽ More
The dependence on applied electric field ($0 - 40$ kV/cm) of the scintillation light produced by fast electrons and $α$ particles stopped in liquid helium in the temperature range of 0.44 K to 3.12 K is reported. For both types of particles, the reduction in the intensity of the scintillation signal due to the applied field exhibits an apparent temperature dependence. Using an approximate solution of the Debye-Smoluchowski equation, we show that the apparent temperature dependence for electrons can be explained by the time required for geminate pairs to recombine relative to the detector signal integration time. This finding indicates that the spatial distribution of secondary electrons with respect to their geminate partners possesses a heavy, non-Gaussian tail at larger separations, and has a dependence on the energy of the primary ionization electron. We discuss the potential application of this result to pulse shape analysis for particle detection and discrimination.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2020; v1 submitted 6 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
A New Cryogenic Apparatus to Search for the Neutron Electric Dipole Moment
Authors:
M. W. Ahmed,
R. Alarcon,
A. Aleksandrova,
S. Baessler,
L. Barron-Palos,
L. M. Bartoszek,
D. H. Beck,
M. Behzadipour,
I. Berkutov,
J. Bessuille,
M. Blatnik,
M. Broering,
L. J. Broussard,
M. Busch,
R. Carr,
V. Cianciolo,
S. M. Clayton,
M. D. Cooper,
C. Crawford,
S. A. Currie,
C. Daurer,
R. Dipert,
K. Dow,
D. Dutta,
Y. Efremenko
, et al. (69 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
A cryogenic apparatus is described that enables a new experiment, nEDM@SNS, with a major improvement in sensitivity compared to the existing limit in the search for a neutron Electric Dipole Moment (EDM). It uses superfluid $^4$He to produce a high density of Ultra-Cold Neutrons (UCN) which are contained in a suitably coated pair of measurement cells. The experiment, to be operated at the Spallati…
▽ More
A cryogenic apparatus is described that enables a new experiment, nEDM@SNS, with a major improvement in sensitivity compared to the existing limit in the search for a neutron Electric Dipole Moment (EDM). It uses superfluid $^4$He to produce a high density of Ultra-Cold Neutrons (UCN) which are contained in a suitably coated pair of measurement cells. The experiment, to be operated at the Spallation Neutron Source at Oak Ridge National Laboratory, uses polarized $^3$He from an Atomic Beam Source injected into the superfluid $^4$He and transported to the measurement cells as a co-magnetometer. The superfluid $^4$He is also used as an insulating medium allowing significantly higher electric fields, compared to previous experiments, to be maintained across the measurement cells. These features provide an ultimate statistical uncertainty for the EDM of $2-3\times 10^{-28}$ e-cm, with anticipated systematic uncertainties below this level.
△ Less
Submitted 20 November, 2019; v1 submitted 26 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
The neutron electric dipole moment experiment at the Spallation Neutron Source
Authors:
K. K. H. Leung,
M. Ahmed,
R. Alarcon,
A. Aleksandrova,
S. Baeßler,
L. Barrón-Palos,
L. Bartoszek,
D. H. Beck,
M. Behzadipour,
J. Bessuille,
M. A. Blatnik,
M. Broering,
L. J. Broussard,
M. Busch,
R. Carr,
P. -H. Chu,
V. Cianciolo,
S. M. Clayton,
M. D. Cooper,
C. Crawford,
S. A. Currie,
C. Daurer,
R. Dipert,
K. Dow,
D. Dutta
, et al. (68 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Novel experimental techniques are required to make the next big leap in neutron electric dipole moment experimental sensitivity, both in terms of statistics and systematic error control. The nEDM experiment at the Spallation Neutron Source (nEDM@SNS) will implement the scheme of Golub & Lamoreaux [Phys. Rep., 237, 1 (1994)]. The unique properties of combining polarized ultracold neutrons, polarize…
▽ More
Novel experimental techniques are required to make the next big leap in neutron electric dipole moment experimental sensitivity, both in terms of statistics and systematic error control. The nEDM experiment at the Spallation Neutron Source (nEDM@SNS) will implement the scheme of Golub & Lamoreaux [Phys. Rep., 237, 1 (1994)]. The unique properties of combining polarized ultracold neutrons, polarized $^3$He, and superfluid $^4$He will be exploited to provide a sensitivity to $\sim 10^{-28}\,e{\rm \,\cdot\, cm}$. Our cryogenic apparatus will deploy two small ($3\,{\rm L}$) measurement cells with a high density of ultracold neutrons produced and spin analyzed in situ. The electric field strength, precession time, magnetic shielding, and detected UCN number will all be enhanced compared to previous room temperature Ramsey measurements. Our $^3$He co-magnetometer offers unique control of systematic effects, in particular the Bloch-Siegert induced false EDM. Furthermore, there will be two distinct measurement modes: free precession and dressed spin. This will provide an important self-check of our results. Following five years of "critical component demonstration," our collaboration transitioned to a "large scale integration" phase in 2018. An overview of our measurement techniques, experimental design, and brief updates are described in these proceedings.
△ Less
Submitted 4 October, 2019; v1 submitted 6 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Imaging $^{55}$Fe Electron Tracks in a GEM-based TPC Using a CCD Readout
Authors:
N. S. Phan,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba
Abstract:
Images of resolved 5.9 keV electron tracks produced from $^{55}$Fe X-ray interactions are presented for the first time using an optical readout time projection chamber (TPC). The corresponding energy spectra are also shown, with the FWHM energy resolution in the 30-40\% range depending on gas pressure and gain. These tracks were produced in low pressure carbon tetrafluoride (CF$_4$) gas, and image…
▽ More
Images of resolved 5.9 keV electron tracks produced from $^{55}$Fe X-ray interactions are presented for the first time using an optical readout time projection chamber (TPC). The corresponding energy spectra are also shown, with the FWHM energy resolution in the 30-40\% range depending on gas pressure and gain. These tracks were produced in low pressure carbon tetrafluoride (CF$_4$) gas, and imaged with a fast lens and low noise CCD camera system using the secondary scintillation produced in GEM/THGEM amplification devices. The GEM/THGEMs provided effective gas gains of $\gtrsim 2 \times 10^5$ in CF$_4$ at low pressures in the 25-100 Torr range. The ability to resolve such low energy particle tracks has important applications in dark matter and other rare event searches, as well as in X-ray polarimetry. A practical application of the optical signal from $^{55}$Fe is that it provides a tool for map** the detector gain spatial uniformity.
△ Less
Submitted 24 April, 2020; v1 submitted 29 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Low Threshold Results and Limits from the DRIFT Directional Dark Matter Detector
Authors:
J. B. R. Battat,
A. C. Ezeribe,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
J. L. Harton,
R. Lafler,
E. Law,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
A. Lumnah,
E. H. Miller,
A. Monte,
F. Mouton,
S. M. Paling,
N. S. Phan,
M. Robinson,
S. W. Sadler,
A. Scarff,
F. G. Schuckman II,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft,
N. J. C. Spooner,
N. Waldram
Abstract:
We present results from a 54.7 live-day shielded run of the DRIFT-IId detector, the world's most sensitive, directional, dark matter detector. Several improvements were made relative to our previous work including a lower threshold for detection, a more robust analysis and a tenfold improvement in our gamma rejection factor. After analysis, no events remain in our fiducial region leading to an exc…
▽ More
We present results from a 54.7 live-day shielded run of the DRIFT-IId detector, the world's most sensitive, directional, dark matter detector. Several improvements were made relative to our previous work including a lower threshold for detection, a more robust analysis and a tenfold improvement in our gamma rejection factor. After analysis, no events remain in our fiducial region leading to an exclusion curve for spin-dependent WIMP-proton interactions which reaches 0.28 pb at 100 GeV/c^2 a fourfold improvement on our previous work. We also present results from a 45.4 live-day unshielded run of the DRIFT-IId detector during which 14 nuclear recoil-like events were observed. We demonstrate that the observed nuclear recoil rate of 0.31+/-0.08 events per day is consistent with detection of ambient, fast neutrons emanating from the walls of the Boulby Underground Science Facility.
△ Less
Submitted 27 March, 2017; v1 submitted 31 December, 2016;
originally announced January 2017.
-
Readout technologies for directional WIMP Dark Matter detection
Authors:
J. B. R. Battat,
I. G. Irastorza,
A. Aleksandrov,
M. Ali Guler,
T. Asada,
E. Baracchini,
J. Billard,
G. Bosson,
O. Bourrion,
J. Bouvier,
A. Buonaura,
K. Burdge,
S. Cebrian,
P. Colas,
L. Consiglio,
T. Dafni,
N. D'Ambrosio,
C. Deaconu,
G. De Lellis,
T. Descombes,
A. Di Crescenzo,
N. Di Marco,
G. Druitt,
R. Eggleston,
E. Ferrer-Ribas
, et al. (68 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The measurement of the direction of WIMP-induced nuclear recoils is a compelling but technologically challenging strategy to provide an unambiguous signature of the detection of Galactic dark matter. Most directional detectors aim to reconstruct the dark-matter-induced nuclear recoil tracks, either in gas or solid targets. The main challenge with directional detection is the need for high spatial…
▽ More
The measurement of the direction of WIMP-induced nuclear recoils is a compelling but technologically challenging strategy to provide an unambiguous signature of the detection of Galactic dark matter. Most directional detectors aim to reconstruct the dark-matter-induced nuclear recoil tracks, either in gas or solid targets. The main challenge with directional detection is the need for high spatial resolution over large volumes, which puts strong requirements on the readout technologies. In this paper we review the various detector readout technologies used by directional detectors. In particular, we summarize the challenges, advantages and drawbacks of each approach, and discuss future prospects for these technologies.
△ Less
Submitted 6 October, 2016;
originally announced October 2016.
-
The novel properties of SF$_6$ for directional dark matter experiments
Authors:
N. S. Phan,
R. Lafler,
R. J. Lauer,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
J. A. J. Matthews,
E. H. Miller
Abstract:
SF$_{6}$ is an inert and electronegative gas that has a long history of use in high voltage insulation and numerous other industrial applications. Although SF$_{6}$ is used as a trace component to introduce stability in tracking chambers, its highly electronegative properties have limited its use in tracking detectors. In this work we present a series of measurements with SF$_{6}$ as the primary g…
▽ More
SF$_{6}$ is an inert and electronegative gas that has a long history of use in high voltage insulation and numerous other industrial applications. Although SF$_{6}$ is used as a trace component to introduce stability in tracking chambers, its highly electronegative properties have limited its use in tracking detectors. In this work we present a series of measurements with SF$_{6}$ as the primary gas in a low pressure Time Projection Chamber (TPC), with a thick GEM used as the avalanche and readout device. The first results of an $^{55}$Fe energy spectrum in SF$_{6}$ are presented. Measurements of the mobility and longitudinal diffusion confirm the negative ion drift of SF$_{6}$. However, the observed waveforms have a peculiar but interesting structure that indicates multiple drift species and a dependence on the reduced field ($E/p$), as well as on the level of water vapor contamination. The discovery of a distinct secondary peak in the waveform, together with its identification and use for fiducializing events in the TPC, are also presented. Our measurements demonstrate that SF$_{6}$ is an ideal gas for directional dark matter detection. In particular, the high fluorine content is desirable for spin-dependent sensitivity, negative ion drift ensures low diffusion over large drift distances, and the multiple species of charge carriers allow for full detector fiducialization.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2016; v1 submitted 16 September, 2016;
originally announced September 2016.
-
First measurement of nuclear recoil head-tail sense in a fiducialised WIMP dark matter detector
Authors:
J. B. R. Battat,
E. Daw,
A. C. Ezeribe,
J. -L. Gauvreau,
J. L. Harton,
R. Lafler,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
A. Lumnah,
E. H. Miller,
F. Mouton,
A. StJ. Murphy,
S. M. Paling,
N. S. Phan,
M. Robinson,
S. W. Sadler,
A. Scarff,
F. G. Schuckman II,
D. P. Snowden-Ifft,
N. J. C. Spooner
Abstract:
Recent computational results suggest that directional dark matter detectors have potential to probe for WIMP dark matter particles below the neutrino floor. The DRIFT-IId detector used in this work is a leading directional WIMP search time projection chamber detector. We report the first measurements of the detection of the directional nuclear recoils in a fully fiducialised low-pressure time proj…
▽ More
Recent computational results suggest that directional dark matter detectors have potential to probe for WIMP dark matter particles below the neutrino floor. The DRIFT-IId detector used in this work is a leading directional WIMP search time projection chamber detector. We report the first measurements of the detection of the directional nuclear recoils in a fully fiducialised low-pressure time projection chamber. In this new operational mode, the distance between each event vertex and the readout plane is determined by the measurement of minority carriers produced by adding a small amount of oxygen to the nominal CS$_{2}$ + CF$_{4}$ target gas mixture. The CS$_2$ + CF$_4$ + O$_2$ mixture has been shown to enable background-free operation at current sensitivities. Sulfur, fluorine, and carbon recoils were generated using neutrons emitted from a $^{252}$Cf source positioned at different locations around the detector. Measurement of the relative energy loss along the recoil tracks allowed the track vector sense, or the so-called head-tail asymmetry parameter, to be deduced. Results show that the previously reported observation of head-tail sensitivity in pure CS$_{2}$ is well retained after the addition of oxygen to the gas mixture.
△ Less
Submitted 24 November, 2016; v1 submitted 16 June, 2016;
originally announced June 2016.
-
A review of the discovery reach of directional Dark Matter detection
Authors:
F. Mayet,
A. M. Green,
J. B. R. Battat,
J. Billard,
N. Bozorgnia,
G. B. Gelmini,
P. Gondolo,
B. J. Kavanagh,
S. K. Lee,
D. Loomba,
J. Monroe,
B. Morgan,
C. A. J. O'Hare,
A. H. G. Peter,
N. S. Phan,
S. E. Vahsen
Abstract:
Cosmological observations indicate that most of the matter in the Universe is Dark Matter. Dark Matter in the form of Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) can be detected directly, via its elastic scattering off target nuclei. Most current direct detection experiments only measure the energy of the recoiling nuclei. However, directional detection experiments are sensitive to the direction…
▽ More
Cosmological observations indicate that most of the matter in the Universe is Dark Matter. Dark Matter in the form of Weakly Interacting Massive Particles (WIMPs) can be detected directly, via its elastic scattering off target nuclei. Most current direct detection experiments only measure the energy of the recoiling nuclei. However, directional detection experiments are sensitive to the direction of the nuclear recoil as well. Due to the Sun's motion with respect to the Galactic rest frame, the directional recoil rate has a dipole feature, peaking around the direction of the Solar motion. This provides a powerful tool for demonstrating the Galactic origin of nuclear recoils and hence unambiguously detecting Dark Matter. Furthermore, the directional recoil distribution depends on the WIMP mass, scattering cross section and local velocity distribution. Therefore, with a large number of recoil events it will be possible to study the physics of Dark Matter in terms of particle and astrophysical properties. We review the potential of directional detectors for detecting and characterizing WIMPs.
△ Less
Submitted 17 March, 2016; v1 submitted 11 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
-
GEM-based TPC with CCD Imaging for Directional Dark Matter Detection
Authors:
N. S. Phan,
R. J. Lauer,
E. R. Lee,
D. Loomba,
J. A. J. Matthews,
E. H. Miller
Abstract:
The world's leading directional dark matter experiments currently all utilize low-pressure gas Time Projection Chamber (TPC) technologies. We discuss some of the challenges for this technology, for which balancing the goal of achieving the best sensitivity with that of cost effective scale-up requires optimization over a large parameter space. Critical for this are the precision measurements of th…
▽ More
The world's leading directional dark matter experiments currently all utilize low-pressure gas Time Projection Chamber (TPC) technologies. We discuss some of the challenges for this technology, for which balancing the goal of achieving the best sensitivity with that of cost effective scale-up requires optimization over a large parameter space. Critical for this are the precision measurements of the fundamental properties of both electron and nuclear recoil tracks down to the lowest detectable energies. Such measurements are necessary to provide a benchmark for background discrimination and directional sensitivity that could be used for future optimization studies for directional dark matter experiments. In this paper we describe a small, high resolution, high signal- to-noise GEM-based TPC with a 2D CCD readout designed for this goal. The performance of the detector was characterized using alpha particles, X-rays, gamma-rays, and neutrons, enabling detailed measurements of electron and nuclear recoil tracks. Stable effective gas gains of greater than $1 \times 10^5$ were obtained in 100 Torr of pure CF$_4$ by a cascade of three standard CERN GEMs each with a 140 $μ$m pitch. The high signal-to-noise and sub-millimeter spatial resolution of the GEM amplification and CCD readout, together with low diffusion, allow for excellent background discrimination between electron and nuclear recoils down below $\sim$10 keVee ($\sim$23 keVr fluorine recoil). Even lower thresholds, necessary for the detection of low mass WIMPs for example, might be achieved by lowering the pressure and utilizing full 3D track reconstruction. These and other paths for improvements are discussed, as are possible fundamental limitations imposed by the physics of energy loss.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2016; v1 submitted 7 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
