-
Political Context of the European Vaccine Debate on Twitter
Authors:
Giordano Paoletti,
Lorenzo Dall'Amico,
Kyriaki Kalimeri,
Jacopo Lenti,
Yelena Mejova,
Daniela Paolotti,
Michele Starnini,
Michele Tizzani
Abstract:
At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, fears grew that making vaccination a political (instead of public health) issue may impact the efficacy of this life-saving intervention, spurring the spread of vaccine-hesitant content. In this study, we examine whether there is a relationship between the political interest of social media users and their exposure to vaccine-hesitant content on Twitter.…
▽ More
At the beginning of the COVID-19 pandemic, fears grew that making vaccination a political (instead of public health) issue may impact the efficacy of this life-saving intervention, spurring the spread of vaccine-hesitant content. In this study, we examine whether there is a relationship between the political interest of social media users and their exposure to vaccine-hesitant content on Twitter. We focus on 17 European countries using a multilingual, longitudinal dataset of tweets spanning the period before COVID, up to the vaccine roll-out. We find that, in most countries, users' endorsement of vaccine-hesitant content is the highest in the early months of the pandemic, around the time of greatest scientific uncertainty. Further, users who follow politicians from right-wing parties, and those associated with authoritarian or anti-EU stances are more likely to endorse vaccine-hesitant content, whereas those following left-wing politicians, more pro-EU or liberal parties, are less likely. Somewhat surprisingly, politicians did not play an outsized role in the vaccine debates of their countries, receiving a similar number of retweets as other similarly popular users. This systematic, multi-country, longitudinal investigation of the connection of politics with vaccine hesitancy has important implications for public health policy and communication.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2024; v1 submitted 6 September, 2023;
originally announced September 2023.
-
Echoes through Time: Evolution of the Italian COVID-19 Vaccination Debate
Authors:
Giuseppe Crupi,
Yelena Mejova,
Michele Tizzani,
Daniela Paolotti,
Andre Panisson
Abstract:
Twitter is one of the most popular social media platforms in the country, but pre-pandemic vaccination debate has been shown to be polarized and siloed into echo chambers. It is thus imperative to understand the nature of this discourse, with a specific focus on the vaccination hesitant individuals, whose healthcare decisions may affect their communities and the country at large. In this study we…
▽ More
Twitter is one of the most popular social media platforms in the country, but pre-pandemic vaccination debate has been shown to be polarized and siloed into echo chambers. It is thus imperative to understand the nature of this discourse, with a specific focus on the vaccination hesitant individuals, whose healthcare decisions may affect their communities and the country at large. In this study we ask, how has the Italian discussion around vaccination changed during the COVID-19 pandemic, and have the unprecedented events of 2020-2021 been able to break the echo chamber around this topic? We use a Twitter dataset spanning September 2019 - November 2021 to examine the state of polarization around vaccination. We propose a hierarchical clustering approach to find the largest communities in the endorsement networks of different time periods, and manually illustrate that it produces communities of users sharing a stance. Examining the structure of these networks, as well as textual content of their interactions, we find the stark division between supporters and hesitant individuals to continue throughout the vaccination campaign. However, we find an increasing commonality in the topical focus of the vaccine supporters and vaccine hesitant, pointing to a possible common set of facts the two sides may agree on. Still, we discover a series of concerns voiced by the hesitant community, ranging from unfounded conspiracies (microchips in vaccines) to public health policy discussion (vaccine passport limitations). We recommend an ongoing surveillance of this debate, especially to uncover concerns around vaccination before the public health decisions and official messaging are made public.
△ Less
Submitted 27 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Using wearable proximity sensors to characterize social contact patterns in a village of rural Malawi
Authors:
Laura Ozella,
Daniela Paolotti,
Guilherme Lichand,
Jorge P. Rodriguez,
Simon Haenni,
John Phuka,
Onicio B. Leal-Neto,
Ciro Cattuto
Abstract:
Measuring close proximity interactions between individuals can provide key information on social contacts in human communities. With the present study, we report the quantitative assessment of contact patterns in a village in rural Malawi, based on proximity sensors technology that allows for high-resolution measurements of social contacts. The system provided information on community structure of…
▽ More
Measuring close proximity interactions between individuals can provide key information on social contacts in human communities. With the present study, we report the quantitative assessment of contact patterns in a village in rural Malawi, based on proximity sensors technology that allows for high-resolution measurements of social contacts. The system provided information on community structure of the village, on social relationships and social assortment between individuals, and on daily contacts activity within the village. Our findings revealed that the social network presented communities that were highly correlated with household membership, thus confirming the importance of family ties within the village. Contacts within households occur mainly between adults and children, and adults and adolescents. This result suggests that the principal role of adults within the family is the care for the youngest. Most of the inter-household interactions occurred among caregivers and among adolescents. We studied the tendency of participants to interact with individuals with whom they shared similar attributes (i.e., assortativity). Age and gender assortativity were observed in inter-household network, showing that individuals not belonging to the same family group prefer to interact with people with whom they share similar age and gender. Age disassortativity is observed in intra-household networks. Family members congregate in the early morning, during lunch time and dinner time. In contrast, individuals not belonging to the same household displayed a growing contact activity from the morning, reaching a maximum in the afternoon. The data collection infrastructure used in this study seems to be very effective to capture the dynamics of contacts by collecting high resolution temporal data and to give access to the level of information needed to understand the social context of the village.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
Link prediction in multiplex networks via triadic closure
Authors:
Alberto Aleta,
Marta Tuninetti,
Daniela Paolotti,
Yamir Moreno,
Michele Starnini
Abstract:
Link prediction algorithms can help to understand the structure and dynamics of complex systems, to reconstruct networks from incomplete data sets and to forecast future interactions in evolving networks. Available algorithms based on similarity between nodes are bounded by the limited amount of links present in these networks. In this work, we reduce this latter intrinsic limitation and show that…
▽ More
Link prediction algorithms can help to understand the structure and dynamics of complex systems, to reconstruct networks from incomplete data sets and to forecast future interactions in evolving networks. Available algorithms based on similarity between nodes are bounded by the limited amount of links present in these networks. In this work, we reduce this latter intrinsic limitation and show that different kind of relational data can be exploited to improve the prediction of new links. To this aim, we propose a novel link prediction algorithm by generalizing the Adamic-Adar method to multiplex networks composed by an arbitrary number of layers, that encode diverse forms of interactions. We show that the new metric outperforms the classical single-layered Adamic-Adar score and other state-of-the-art methods, across several social, biological and technological systems. As a byproduct, the coefficients that maximize the Multiplex Adamic-Adar metric indicate how the information structured in a multiplex network can be optimized for the link prediction task, revealing which layers are redundant. Interestingly, this effect can be asymmetric with respect to predictions in different layers. Our work paves the way for a deeper understanding of the role of different relational data in predicting new interactions and provides a new algorithm for link prediction in multiplex networks that can be applied to a plethora of systems.
△ Less
Submitted 16 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Self-initiated behavioural change and disease resurgence on activity-driven networks
Authors:
Nicolò Gozzi,
Martina Scudeler,
Daniela Paolotti,
Andrea Baronchelli,
Nicola Perra
Abstract:
We consider a population that experienced a first wave of infections, interrupted by strong, top-down, governmental restrictions and did not develop a significant immunity to prevent a second wave (i.e. resurgence). As restrictions are lifted, individuals adapt their social behaviour to minimize the risk of infection. We consider two scenarios. In the first, individuals reduce their overall social…
▽ More
We consider a population that experienced a first wave of infections, interrupted by strong, top-down, governmental restrictions and did not develop a significant immunity to prevent a second wave (i.e. resurgence). As restrictions are lifted, individuals adapt their social behaviour to minimize the risk of infection. We consider two scenarios. In the first, individuals reduce their overall social activity towards the rest of the population. In the second scenario, they maintain a normal social activity within a small community of peers (i.e., social bubble) while reducing social interactions with the rest of the population. In both cases, we consider possible correlations between social activity and behaviour change, reflecting for example the social dimension of certain occupations. We model these scenarios considering a Susceptible-Infected-Recovered epidemic model unfolding on activity-driven networks. Extensive analytical and numerical results show that i) a minority of very active individuals not changing behaviour may nullify the efforts of the large majority of the population, and ii) imperfect social bubbles of normal social activity may be less effective than an overall reduction of social interactions.
△ Less
Submitted 7 November, 2020;
originally announced November 2020.
-
Collective response to the media coverage of COVID-19 Pandemic on Reddit and Wikipedia
Authors:
Nicolò Gozzi,
Michele Tizzani,
Michele Starnini,
Fabio Ciulla,
Daniela Paolotti,
André Panisson,
Nicola Perra
Abstract:
The exposure and consumption of information during epidemic outbreaks may alter risk perception, trigger behavioural changes, and ultimately affect the evolution of the disease. It is thus of the uttermost importance to map information dissemination by mainstream media outlets and public response. However, our understanding of this exposure-response dynamic during COVID-19 pandemic is still limite…
▽ More
The exposure and consumption of information during epidemic outbreaks may alter risk perception, trigger behavioural changes, and ultimately affect the evolution of the disease. It is thus of the uttermost importance to map information dissemination by mainstream media outlets and public response. However, our understanding of this exposure-response dynamic during COVID-19 pandemic is still limited. In this paper, we provide a characterization of media coverage and online collective attention to COVID-19 pandemic in four countries: Italy, United Kingdom, United States, and Canada. For this purpose, we collect an heterogeneous dataset including 227,768 online news articles and 13,448 Youtube videos published by mainstream media, 107,898 users posts and 3,829,309 comments on the social media platform Reddit, and 278,456,892 views to COVID-19 related Wikipedia pages. Our results show that public attention, quantified as users activity on Reddit and active searches on Wikipedia pages, is mainly driven by media coverage and declines rapidly, while news exposure and COVID-19 incidence remain high. Furthermore, by using an unsupervised, dynamical topic modeling approach, we show that while the attention dedicated to different topics by media and online users are in good accordance, interesting deviations emerge in their temporal patterns. Overall, our findings offer an additional key to interpret public perception/response to the current global health emergency and raise questions about the effects of attention saturation on collective awareness, risk perception and thus on tendencies towards behavioural changes.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Prediction of scientific collaborations through multiplex interaction networks
Authors:
Marta Tuninetti,
Alberto Aleta,
Daniela Paolotti,
Yamir Moreno,
Michele Starnini
Abstract:
Link prediction algorithms can help to understand the structure and dynamics of scientific collaborations and the evolution of Science. However, available algorithms based on similarity between nodes of collaboration networks are bounded by the limited amount of links present in these networks. In this work, we reduce the latter intrinsic limitation by generalizing the Adamic-Adar method to multip…
▽ More
Link prediction algorithms can help to understand the structure and dynamics of scientific collaborations and the evolution of Science. However, available algorithms based on similarity between nodes of collaboration networks are bounded by the limited amount of links present in these networks. In this work, we reduce the latter intrinsic limitation by generalizing the Adamic-Adar method to multiplex networks composed by an arbitrary number of layers, that encode diverse forms of scientific interactions. We show that the new metric outperforms other single-layered, similarity-based scores and that scientific credit, represented by citations, and common interests, measured by the usage of common keywords, can be predictive of new collaborations. Our work paves the way for a deeper understanding of the dynamics driving scientific collaborations, and provides a new algorithm for link prediction in multiplex networks that can be applied to a plethora of systems.
△ Less
Submitted 9 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Towards a data-driven characterization of behavioral changes induced by the seasonal flu
Authors:
Nicolò Gozzi,
Daniela Perrotta,
Daniela Paolotti,
Nicola Perra
Abstract:
In this work, we aim to determine the main factors driving behavioral change during the seasonal flu. To this end, we analyze a unique dataset comprised of 599 surveys completed by 434 Italian users of Influweb, a Web platform for participatory surveillance, during the 2017-18 and 2018-19 seasons. The data provide socio-demographic information, level of concerns about the flu, past experience with…
▽ More
In this work, we aim to determine the main factors driving behavioral change during the seasonal flu. To this end, we analyze a unique dataset comprised of 599 surveys completed by 434 Italian users of Influweb, a Web platform for participatory surveillance, during the 2017-18 and 2018-19 seasons. The data provide socio-demographic information, level of concerns about the flu, past experience with illnesses, and the type of behavioral changes implemented by each participant. We describe each response with a set of features and divide them in three target categories. These describe those that report i) no (26 %), ii) only moderately (36 %), iii) significant (38 %) changes in behaviors. In these settings, we adopt machine learning algorithms to investigate the extent to which target variables can be predicted by looking only at the set of features. Notably, $66\%$ of the samples in the category describing more significant changes in behaviors are correctly classified through Gradient Boosted Trees. Furthermore, we investigate the importance of each feature in the classification task and uncover complex relationships between individuals' characteristics and their attitude towards behavioral change. We find that intensity, recency of past illnesses, perceived susceptibility to and perceived severity of an infection are the most significant features in the classification task. Interestingly, the last two match the theoretical constructs suggested by the Health-Belief Model. Overall, the research contributes to the small set of empirical studies devoted to the data-driven characterization of behavioral changes induced by infectious diseases.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2020;
originally announced February 2020.
-
Systemic liquidity contagion in the European interbank market
Authors:
V. Macchiati,
G. Brandi,
G. Cimini,
G. Caldarelli,
D. Paolotti,
T. Di Matteo
Abstract:
Systemic liquidity risk, defined by the IMF as "the risk of simultaneous liquidity difficulties at multiple financial institutions", is a key topic in macroprudential policy and financial stress analysis. Specialized models to simulate funding liquidity risk and contagion are available but they require not only banks' bilateral exposures data but also balance sheet data with sufficient granularity…
▽ More
Systemic liquidity risk, defined by the IMF as "the risk of simultaneous liquidity difficulties at multiple financial institutions", is a key topic in macroprudential policy and financial stress analysis. Specialized models to simulate funding liquidity risk and contagion are available but they require not only banks' bilateral exposures data but also balance sheet data with sufficient granularity, which are hardly available. Alternatively, risk analyses on interbank networks have been done via centrality measures of the underlying graph capturing the most interconnected and hence more prone to risk spreading banks. In this paper, we propose a model which relies on an epidemic model which simulate a contagion on the interbank market using the funding liquidity shortage mechanism as contagion process. The model is enriched with country and bank risk features which take into account the heterogeneity of the interbank market. The proposed model is particularly useful when full set of data necessary to run specialized models is not available. Since the interbank network is not fully available, an economic driven reconstruction method is also proposed to retrieve the interbank network by constraining the standard reconstruction methodology to real financial indicators. We show that the contagion model is able to reproduce systemic liquidity risk across different years and countries. This result suggests that the proposed model can be successfully used as a valid alternative to more complex ones.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2020; v1 submitted 31 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
News and the city: understanding online press consumption patterns through mobile data
Authors:
Salvatore Vilella,
Daniela Paolotti,
Giancarlo Ruffo,
Leo Ferres
Abstract:
The always increasing mobile connectivity affects every aspect of our daily lives, including how and when we keep ourselves informed and consult news media. By studying a DPI (deep packet inspection) dataset, provided by one of the major Chilean telecommunication companies, we investigate how different cohorts of the population of Santiago De Chile consume news media content through their smartpho…
▽ More
The always increasing mobile connectivity affects every aspect of our daily lives, including how and when we keep ourselves informed and consult news media. By studying a DPI (deep packet inspection) dataset, provided by one of the major Chilean telecommunication companies, we investigate how different cohorts of the population of Santiago De Chile consume news media content through their smartphones. We find that some socio-demographic attributes are highly associated to specific news media consumption patterns. In particular, education and age play a significant role in sha** the consumers behaviour even in the digital context, in agreement with a large body of literature on off-line media distribution channels.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2020; v1 submitted 4 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
On the use of multiple compartment epidemiological models to describe the dynamics of influenza in Europe
Authors:
Inbar Seroussi,
Nir Levy,
Daniela Paolotti,
Nir Sochen,
Elad Yom-Tov
Abstract:
We develop a multiple compartment Susceptible-Infected-Recovered (SIR) model to analyze the spread of several infectious diseases through different geographic areas. Additionally, we propose a data-quality sensitive optimization framework for fitting this model to observed data.
We fit the model to the temporal profile of the number of people infected by one of six influenza strains in Europe ov…
▽ More
We develop a multiple compartment Susceptible-Infected-Recovered (SIR) model to analyze the spread of several infectious diseases through different geographic areas. Additionally, we propose a data-quality sensitive optimization framework for fitting this model to observed data.
We fit the model to the temporal profile of the number of people infected by one of six influenza strains in Europe over $7$ influenza seasons. In addition to describing the temporal and spatial spread of influenza, the model provides an estimate of the inter-country and intra-country infection and recovery rates of each strain and in each season. We find that disease parameters remain relatively stable, with a correlation greater than $0.5$ over seasons and stains. Clustering of influenza strains by the inferred disease parameters is consistent with genome sub-types. Surprisingly, our analysis suggests that inter-country human mobility plays a negligible role in the spread of influenza in Europe. Finally, we show that the model allows the estimation of disease load in countries with poor or none existent data from the disease load in adjacent countries.
Our findings reveal information on the spreading mechanism of influenza and on disease parameters. These can be used to assist in disease surveillance and in control of influenza as well as of other infectious pathogens in a heterogenic environment.
△ Less
Submitted 18 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Modeling vaccination campaigns and the Fall/Winter 2009 activity of the new A(H1N1) influenza in the Northern Hemisphere
Authors:
Paolo Bajardi,
Chiara Poletto,
Duygu Balcan,
Hao Hu,
Bruno Goncalves,
Jose J. Ramasco,
Daniela Paolotti,
Nicola Perra,
Michele Tizzoni,
Wouter Van den Broeck,
Vittoria Colizza,
Alessandro Vespignani
Abstract:
The unfolding of pandemic influenza A(H1N1) for Fall 2009 in the Northern Hemisphere is still uncertain. Plans for vaccination campaigns and vaccine trials are underway, with the first batches expected to be available early October. Several studies point to the possibility of an anticipated pandemic peak that could undermine the effectiveness of vaccination strategies. Here we use a structured g…
▽ More
The unfolding of pandemic influenza A(H1N1) for Fall 2009 in the Northern Hemisphere is still uncertain. Plans for vaccination campaigns and vaccine trials are underway, with the first batches expected to be available early October. Several studies point to the possibility of an anticipated pandemic peak that could undermine the effectiveness of vaccination strategies. Here we use a structured global epidemic and mobility metapopulation model to assess the effectiveness of massive vaccination campaigns for the Fall/Winter 2009. Mitigation effects are explored depending on the interplay between the predicted pandemic evolution and the expected delivery of vaccines. The model is calibrated using recent estimates on the transmissibility of the new A(H1N1) influenza. Results show that if additional intervention strategies were not used to delay the time of pandemic peak, vaccination may not be able to considerably reduce the cumulative number of cases, even when the mass vaccination campaign is started as early as mid-October. Prioritized vaccination would be crucial in slowing down the pandemic evolution and reducing its burden.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
-
Seasonal transmission potential and activity peaks of the new influenza A(H1N1): a Monte Carlo likelihood analysis based on human mobility
Authors:
Duygu Balcan,
Hao Hu,
Bruno Goncalves,
Paolo Bajardi,
Chiara Poletto,
Jose J Ramasco,
Daniela Paolotti,
Nicola Perra,
Michele Tizzoni,
Wouter Van den Broeck,
Vittoria Colizza,
Alessandro Vespignani
Abstract:
On 11 June the World Health Organization officially raised the phase of pandemic alert (with regard to the new H1N1 influenza strain) to level 6. We use a global structured metapopulation model integrating mobility and transportation data worldwide in order to estimate the transmission potential and the relevant model parameters we used the data on the chronology of the 2009 novel influenza A(H1…
▽ More
On 11 June the World Health Organization officially raised the phase of pandemic alert (with regard to the new H1N1 influenza strain) to level 6. We use a global structured metapopulation model integrating mobility and transportation data worldwide in order to estimate the transmission potential and the relevant model parameters we used the data on the chronology of the 2009 novel influenza A(H1N1). The method is based on the maximum likelihood analysis of the arrival time distribution generated by the model in 12 countries seeded by Mexico by using 1M computationally simulated epidemics. An extended chronology including 93 countries worldwide seeded before 18 June was used to ascertain the seasonality effects. We found the best estimate R0 = 1.75 (95% CI 1.64 to 1.88) for the basic reproductive number. Correlation analysis allows the selection of the most probable seasonal behavior based on the observed pattern, leading to the identification of plausible scenarios for the future unfolding of the pandemic and the estimate of pandemic activity peaks in the different hemispheres. We provide estimates for the number of hospitalizations and the attack rate for the next wave as well as an extensive sensitivity analysis on the disease parameter values. We also studied the effect of systematic therapeutic use of antiviral drugs on the epidemic timeline. The analysis shows the potential for an early epidemic peak occurring in October/November in the Northern hemisphere, likely before large-scale vaccination campaigns could be carried out. We suggest that the planning of additional mitigation policies such as systematic antiviral treatments might be the key to delay the activity peak inorder to restore the effectiveness of the vaccination programs.
△ Less
Submitted 14 September, 2009;
originally announced September 2009.