Blinding for precision scattering experiments: The MUSE approach as a case study
Authors:
J. C. Bernauer,
E. W. Cline,
H. Atac,
W. J. Briscoe,
A. Christopher Ndukwe,
E. J. Downie,
I. P. Fernando,
T. Gautam,
R. Gilman,
R. Goldin,
M. Kohl,
I. Lavrukhin,
W. Lin,
W. Lorenzon,
P. Mohanmurthy,
S. J. Nazeer,
M. Nicol,
T. Patel,
A. Prosnyakov,
R. D. Ransome,
R. Ratvasky,
H. Reid,
P. E. Reimer,
G. Ron,
T. Rostomyan
, et al. (5 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Human bias is capable of changing the analysis of measured data sufficiently to alter the results of an experiment. It is incumbent upon modern experiments, especially those investigating quantities considered contentious in the broader community, to blind their analysis in an effort to minimize bias. The choice of a blinding model is experiment specific, but should also aim to prevent accidental…
▽ More
Human bias is capable of changing the analysis of measured data sufficiently to alter the results of an experiment. It is incumbent upon modern experiments, especially those investigating quantities considered contentious in the broader community, to blind their analysis in an effort to minimize bias. The choice of a blinding model is experiment specific, but should also aim to prevent accidental release of results before an analysis is finalized. In this paper, we discuss common threats to an unbiased analysis, as well as common quantities that can be blinded in different types of nuclear physics experiments. We use the Muon Scattering Experiment as an example, and detail the blinding scheme used therein.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
Characterization of Muon and Electron Beams in the Paul Scherrer Institute PiM1 Channel for the MUSE Experiment
Authors:
E. Cline,
W. Lin,
P. Roy,
P. E. Reimer,
K. E. Mesick,
A. Akmal,
A. Alie,
H. Atac,
A. Atencio,
C. Ayerbe Gayoso,
N. Benmouna,
F. Benmokhtar,
J. C. Bernauer,
W. J. Briscoe,
J. Campbell,
D. Cohen,
E. O. Cohen,
C. Collicott,
K. Deiters,
S. Dogra,
E. Downie,
I. P. Fernando,
A. Flannery,
T. Gautam,
D. Ghosal
, et al. (35 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The MUon Scattering Experiment, MUSE, at the Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland, investigates the proton charge radius puzzle, lepton universality, and two-photon exchange, via simultaneous measurements of elastic muon-proton and electron-proton scattering. The experiment uses the PiM1 secondary beam channel, which was designed for high precision pion scattering measurements. We review the prope…
▽ More
The MUon Scattering Experiment, MUSE, at the Paul Scherrer Institute, Switzerland, investigates the proton charge radius puzzle, lepton universality, and two-photon exchange, via simultaneous measurements of elastic muon-proton and electron-proton scattering. The experiment uses the PiM1 secondary beam channel, which was designed for high precision pion scattering measurements. We review the properties of the beam line established for pions. We discuss the production processes that generate the electron and muon beams, and the simulations of these processes. Simulations of the $π$/$μ$/$e$ beams through the channel using TURTLE and G4beamline are compared. The G4beamline simulation is then compared to several experimental measurements of the channel, including the momentum dispersion at the IFP and target, the shape of the beam spot at the target, and timing measurements that allow the beam momenta to be determined. We conclude that the PiM1 channel can be used for high precision $π$, $μ$, and $e$ scattering.
△ Less
Submitted 15 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.