-
A general mechanism for enhancer-insulator pairing reveals heterogeneous dynamics in long-distant 3D gene regulation
Authors:
Lucas Hedström,
Ralf Metzler,
Ludvig Lizana
Abstract:
Cells regulate fates and complex body plans using spatiotemporal signaling cascades that alter gene expression. Enhancers, short DNA sequences (50-150 base pairs), help coordinate these cascades by attracting regulatory proteins to enhance the transcription of distal genes by binding to promoters. In humans, there are hundreds of thousands of enhancers dispersed across the genome, which poses a ch…
▽ More
Cells regulate fates and complex body plans using spatiotemporal signaling cascades that alter gene expression. Enhancers, short DNA sequences (50-150 base pairs), help coordinate these cascades by attracting regulatory proteins to enhance the transcription of distal genes by binding to promoters. In humans, there are hundreds of thousands of enhancers dispersed across the genome, which poses a challenging coordination task to prevent unintended gene activation. To mitigate this problem, the genome contains additional DNA elements, insulators, that block enhancer-promoter interactions. However, there is an open problem with how the insulation works, especially as enhancer-insulator pairs may be separated by millions of base pairs. Based on recent empirical data from Hi-C experiments, this paper proposes a new mechanism that challenges the common paradigm that rests on specific insulator-insulator interactions. Instead, this paper introduces a stochastic loo** model where enhancers bind weakly to surrounding chromatin. After calibrating the model to experimental data, we use simulations to study the broad distribution of hitting times between an enhancer and a promoter when there are blocking insulators. In some cases, there is a large difference between average and most probable hitting times, making it difficult to assign a typical time scale, hinting at highly defocused regulation times. We also map our computational model onto a resetting problem that allows us to derive several analytical results. Besides offering new insights into enhancer-insulator interactions, our paper advances the understanding of gene regulatory networks and causal connections between genome folding and gene activation.
△ Less
Submitted 14 February, 2024;
originally announced February 2024.
-
Diffusion of intrinsically disordered proteins within viscoelastic membraneless droplets
Authors:
Fuga Watanabe,
Takuma Akimoto,
Robert B. Best,
Kresten Lindorff-Larsen,
Ralf Metzler,
Eiji Yamamoto
Abstract:
In living cells, intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), such as FUS and DDX4, undergo phase separation, forming biomolecular condensates. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we investigate their behavior in their respective homogenous droplets. We find that the proteins exhibit transient subdiffusion due to the viscoelastic nature and confinement effects in the droplets. The conformation and…
▽ More
In living cells, intrinsically disordered proteins (IDPs), such as FUS and DDX4, undergo phase separation, forming biomolecular condensates. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we investigate their behavior in their respective homogenous droplets. We find that the proteins exhibit transient subdiffusion due to the viscoelastic nature and confinement effects in the droplets. The conformation and the instantaneous diffusivity of the proteins significantly vary between the interior and the interface of the droplet, resulting in non-Gaussianity in the displacement distributions. This study highlights key aspects of IDP behavior in biomolecular condensates.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Target search on DNA -- effect of coiling
Authors:
Michael A. Lomholt,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Some proteins can find their targets on DNA faster than by pure diffusion in the three-dimensional cytoplasm, through the process of facilitated diffusion: They can loosely bind to DNA and temporarily slide along it, thus being guided by the DNA molecule itself to the target. This chapter examines this process in mathematical detail with a focus on including the effect of DNA coiling on the search…
▽ More
Some proteins can find their targets on DNA faster than by pure diffusion in the three-dimensional cytoplasm, through the process of facilitated diffusion: They can loosely bind to DNA and temporarily slide along it, thus being guided by the DNA molecule itself to the target. This chapter examines this process in mathematical detail with a focus on including the effect of DNA coiling on the search process.
△ Less
Submitted 25 February, 2024; v1 submitted 10 December, 2023;
originally announced December 2023.
-
Quantitative evaluation of methods to analyze motion changes in single-particle experiments
Authors:
Gorka Muñoz-Gil,
Harshith Bachimanchi,
Jesús Pineda,
Benjamin Midtvedt,
Maciej Lewenstein,
Ralf Metzler,
Diego Krapf,
Giovanni Volpe,
Carlo Manzo
Abstract:
The analysis of live-cell single-molecule imaging experiments can reveal valuable information about the heterogeneity of transport processes and interactions between cell components. These characteristics are seen as motion changes in the particle trajectories. Despite the existence of multiple approaches to carry out this type of analysis, no objective assessment of these methods has been perform…
▽ More
The analysis of live-cell single-molecule imaging experiments can reveal valuable information about the heterogeneity of transport processes and interactions between cell components. These characteristics are seen as motion changes in the particle trajectories. Despite the existence of multiple approaches to carry out this type of analysis, no objective assessment of these methods has been performed so far. Here, we have designed a competition to characterize and rank the performance of these methods when analyzing the dynamic behavior of single molecules. To run this competition, we have implemented a software library to simulate realistic data corresponding to widespread diffusion and interaction models, both in the form of trajectories and videos obtained in typical experimental conditions. The competition will constitute the first assessment of these methods, provide insights into the current limits of the field, foster the development of new approaches, and guide researchers to identify optimal tools for analyzing their experiments.
△ Less
Submitted 19 January, 2024; v1 submitted 29 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Non-Gaussian displacements in active transport on a carpet of motile cells
Authors:
Robert Großmann,
Lara S. Bort,
Ted Moldenhawer,
Setareh Sharifi Panah,
Ralf Metzler,
Carsten Beta
Abstract:
We study the dynamics of micron-sized particles on a layer of motile cells. This cell carpet acts as an active bath that propels passive tracer particles via direct mechanical contact. The resulting nonequilibrium transport shows a crossover from superdiffusive to normal-diffusive dynamics. The particle displacement distribution is distinctly non-Gaussian even in the limit of long measurement time…
▽ More
We study the dynamics of micron-sized particles on a layer of motile cells. This cell carpet acts as an active bath that propels passive tracer particles via direct mechanical contact. The resulting nonequilibrium transport shows a crossover from superdiffusive to normal-diffusive dynamics. The particle displacement distribution is distinctly non-Gaussian even in the limit of long measurement times -- different from typically reported Fickian yet non-Gaussian transport, for which Gaussianity is restored beyond some system-specific correlation time. We obtain the distribution of diffusion coefficients from the experimental data and introduce a model for the displacement distribution that matches the experimentally observed non-Gaussian statistics and argue why similar transport properties are expected for many composite active matter systems.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Machine-Learning Solutions for the Analysis of Single-Particle Diffusion Trajectories
Authors:
Henrik Seckler,
Janusz Szwabinski,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Single-particle traces of the diffusive motion of molecules, cells, or animals are by-now routinely measured, similar to stochastic records of stock prices or weather data. Deciphering the stochastic mechanism behind the recorded dynamics is vital in understanding the observed systems. Typically, the task is to decipher the exact type of diffusion and/or to determine system parameters. The tools u…
▽ More
Single-particle traces of the diffusive motion of molecules, cells, or animals are by-now routinely measured, similar to stochastic records of stock prices or weather data. Deciphering the stochastic mechanism behind the recorded dynamics is vital in understanding the observed systems. Typically, the task is to decipher the exact type of diffusion and/or to determine system parameters. The tools used in this endeavor are currently revolutionized by modern machine-learning techniques. In this Perspective we provide an overview over recently introduced methods in machine-learning for diffusive time series, most notably, those successfully competing in the Anomalous-Diffusion-Challenge. As such methods are often criticized for their lack of interpretability, we focus on means to include uncertainty estimates and feature-based approaches, both improving interpretability and providing concrete insight into the learning process of the machine. We expand the discussion by examining predictions on different out-of-distribution data. We also comment on expected future developments.
△ Less
Submitted 18 August, 2023;
originally announced August 2023.
-
Minimal model of diffusion with time changing Hurst exponent
Authors:
Jakub Slezak,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
We introduce the stochastic process of incremental multifractional Brownian motion (IMFBM), which locally behaves like fractional Brownian motion with a given local Hurst exponent and diffusivity. When these parameters change as function of time the process responds to the evolution gradually: only new increments are governed by the new parameters, while still retaining a power-law dependence on t…
▽ More
We introduce the stochastic process of incremental multifractional Brownian motion (IMFBM), which locally behaves like fractional Brownian motion with a given local Hurst exponent and diffusivity. When these parameters change as function of time the process responds to the evolution gradually: only new increments are governed by the new parameters, while still retaining a power-law dependence on the past of the process. We obtain the mean squared displacement and correlations of IMFBM which are given by elementary formulas. We also provide a comparison with simulations and introduce estimation methods for IMFBM. This mathematically simple process is useful in the description of anomalous diffusion dynamics in changing environments, e.g., in viscoelastic systems, or when an actively moving particle changes its degree of persistence or its mobility.
△ Less
Submitted 26 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Modelling intermittent anomalous diffusion with switching fractional Brownian motion
Authors:
Michał Balcerek,
Agnieszka Wyłomańska,
Krzysztof Burnecki,
Ralf Metzler,
Diego Krapf
Abstract:
The stochastic trajectories of molecules in living cells, as well as the dynamics in many other complex systems, often exhibit memory in their path over long periods of time. In addition, these systems can show dynamic heterogeneities due to which the motion changes along the trajectories. Such effects manifest themselves as spatiotemporal correlations. Despite the broad occurrence of heterogeneou…
▽ More
The stochastic trajectories of molecules in living cells, as well as the dynamics in many other complex systems, often exhibit memory in their path over long periods of time. In addition, these systems can show dynamic heterogeneities due to which the motion changes along the trajectories. Such effects manifest themselves as spatiotemporal correlations. Despite the broad occurrence of heterogeneous complex systems in nature, their analysis is still quite poorly understood and tools to model them are largely missing. We contribute to tackling this problem by employing an integral representation of Mandelbrot's fractional Brownian motion that is compliant with varying motion parameters while maintaining long memory. Two types of switching fractional Brownian motion are analysed, with transitions arising from a Markovian stochastic process and scale-free intermittent processes. We obtain simple formulas for classical statistics of the processes, namely the mean squared displacement and the power spectral density. Further, a method to identify switching fractional Brownian motion based on the distribution of displacements is described. A validation of the model is given for experimental measurements of the motion of quantum dots in the cytoplasm of live mammalian cells that were obtained by single-particle tracking.
△ Less
Submitted 26 September, 2023; v1 submitted 24 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Time-dependent probability density function for partial resetting dynamics
Authors:
C. Di Bello,
A. V. Chechkin,
A. K. Hartmann,
Z. Palmowski,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
Stochastic resetting is a rapidly develo** topic in the field of stochastic processes and their applications. It denotes the occasional reset of a diffusing particle to its starting point and effects, inter alia, optimal first-passage times to a target. Recently the concept of partial resetting, in which the particle is reset to a given fraction of the current value of the process, has been esta…
▽ More
Stochastic resetting is a rapidly develo** topic in the field of stochastic processes and their applications. It denotes the occasional reset of a diffusing particle to its starting point and effects, inter alia, optimal first-passage times to a target. Recently the concept of partial resetting, in which the particle is reset to a given fraction of the current value of the process, has been established and the associated search behaviour analysed. Here we go one step further and we develop a general technique to determine the time-dependent probability density function (PDF) for Markov processes with partial resetting. We obtain an exact representation of the PDF in the case of general symmetric Lévy flights with stable index $0<α\le2$. For Cauchy and Brownian motions (i.e., $α=1,2$), this PDF can be expressed in terms of elementary functions in position space. We also determine the stationary PDF. Our numerical analysis of the PDF demonstrates intricate crossover behaviours as function of time.
△ Less
Submitted 24 May, 2023; v1 submitted 23 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Directedeness, correlations, and daily cycles in springbok motion: from data over stochastic models to movement prediction
Authors:
P. G. Meyer,
A. G. Cherstvy,
H. Seckler,
R. Hering,
N. Blaum,
F. Jeltsch,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
How predictable is the next move of an animal? Specifically, which factors govern the short- and long-term motion patterns and the overall dynamics of landbound, plant-eating animals and ruminants in particular? To answer this question, we here study the movement dynamics of springbok antelopes Antidorcas marsupialis. We propose complementary statistical analysis techniques combined with machine l…
▽ More
How predictable is the next move of an animal? Specifically, which factors govern the short- and long-term motion patterns and the overall dynamics of landbound, plant-eating animals and ruminants in particular? To answer this question, we here study the movement dynamics of springbok antelopes Antidorcas marsupialis. We propose complementary statistical analysis techniques combined with machine learning approaches to analyze, across multiple time scales, the springbok motion recorded in long-term GPS-tracking of collared springboks at a private wildlife reserve in Namibia. As a new result, we are able to predict the springbok movement within the next hour with a certainty of about 20\%. The remaining 80\% are stochastic in nature and are induced by unaccounted factors in the modeling algorithm and by individual behavioral features of springboks. We find that directedness of motion contributes approximately 17\% to this predicted fraction. We find that the measure for directedeness is strongly dependent on the daily cycle. The previously known daily affinity of springboks to their water points, as predicted from our machine learning algorithm, overall accounts for only 3\% of this predicted deterministic component of springbok motion. Moreover, the resting points are found to affect the motion of springboks at least as much as the formally studied effects of water points. The generality of these statements for the motion patterns and their underlying behavioral reasons for other ruminants can be examined on the basis of our statistical analysis tools.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Memory-multi-fractional Brownian motion with continuous correlations
Authors:
Wei Wang,
Michal Balcerek,
Krzysztof Burnecki,
Aleksei V. Chechkin,
Skirmantas Janusonis,
Jakub Slezak,
Thomas Vojta,
Agnieszka Wylomanska,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
We propose a generalization of the widely used fractional Brownian motion (FBM), memory-multi-FBM (MMFBM), to describe viscoelastic or persistent anomalous diffusion with time-dependent memory exponent $α(t)$ in a changing environment. In MMFBM the built-in, long-range memory is continuously modulated by $α(t)$. We derive the essential statistical properties of MMFBM such as response function, mea…
▽ More
We propose a generalization of the widely used fractional Brownian motion (FBM), memory-multi-FBM (MMFBM), to describe viscoelastic or persistent anomalous diffusion with time-dependent memory exponent $α(t)$ in a changing environment. In MMFBM the built-in, long-range memory is continuously modulated by $α(t)$. We derive the essential statistical properties of MMFBM such as response function, mean-squared displacement (MSD), autocovariance function, and Gaussian distribution. In contrast to existing forms of FBM with time-varying memory exponents but reset memory structure, the instantaneous dynamic of MMFBM is influenced by the process history, e.g., we show that after a step-like change of $α(t)$ the scaling exponent of the MSD after the $α$-step may be determined by the value of $α(t)$ before the change. MMFBM is a versatile and useful process for correlated physical systems with non-equilibrium initial conditions in a changing environment.
△ Less
Submitted 3 August, 2023; v1 submitted 2 March, 2023;
originally announced March 2023.
-
Anomalous diffusion, non-Gaussianity, and nonergodicity for subordinated fractional Brownian motion with a drift
Authors:
Yingjie Liang,
Wei Wang,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
The stochastic motion of a particle with long-range correlated increments (the moving phase) which is intermittently interrupted by immobilizations (the tra** phase) in a disordered medium is considered in the presence of an external drift. In particular, we consider trap** events whose times follow a scale-free distribution with diverging mean trap** time. We construct this process in terms…
▽ More
The stochastic motion of a particle with long-range correlated increments (the moving phase) which is intermittently interrupted by immobilizations (the tra** phase) in a disordered medium is considered in the presence of an external drift. In particular, we consider trap** events whose times follow a scale-free distribution with diverging mean trap** time. We construct this process in terms of fractional Brownian motion (FBM) with constant forcing in which the trap** effect is introduced by the subordination technique, connecting "operational time" with observable "real time". We derive the statistical properties of this process such as non-Gaussianity and non-ergodicity, for both ensemble and single-trajectory (time) averages. We demonstrate nice agreement with extensive simulations for the probability density function, skewness, kurtosis, as well as ensemble and time-averaged mean squared displacements. We pay specific emphasis on the comparisons between the cases with and without drift.
△ Less
Submitted 9 February, 2023;
originally announced February 2023.
-
Heterogeneous biological membranes regulate protein partitioning via fluctuating diffusivity
Authors:
Ken Sakamoto,
Takuma Akimoto,
Mayu Muramatsu,
Mark S. P. Sansom,
Ralf Metzler,
Eiji Yamamoto
Abstract:
Cell membranes phase separate into ordered ${\rm L_o}$ and disordered ${\rm L_d}$ domains depending on their compositions. This membrane compartmentalization is heterogeneous and regulates the localization of specific proteins related to cell signaling and trafficking. However, it is unclear how the heterogeneity of the membranes affects the diffusion and localization of proteins in ${\rm L_o}$ an…
▽ More
Cell membranes phase separate into ordered ${\rm L_o}$ and disordered ${\rm L_d}$ domains depending on their compositions. This membrane compartmentalization is heterogeneous and regulates the localization of specific proteins related to cell signaling and trafficking. However, it is unclear how the heterogeneity of the membranes affects the diffusion and localization of proteins in ${\rm L_o}$ and ${\rm L_d}$ domains. Here, using Langevin dynamics simulations coupled with the phase-field (LDPF) method, we investigate several tens of milliseconds-scale diffusion and localization of proteins in heterogeneous biological membrane models showing phase separation into ${\rm L_o}$ and ${\rm L_d}$ domains. The diffusivity of proteins exhibits temporal fluctuations depending on the field composition. Increases in molecular concentrations and domain preference of the molecule induce subdiffusive behavior due to molecular collisions by crowding and confinement effects, respectively. Moreover, we quantitatively demonstrate that the protein partitioning into the ${\rm L_o}$ domain is determined by the difference in molecular diffusivity between domains, molecular preference of domain, and molecular concentration. These results pave the way for understanding how biological reactions caused by molecular partitioning may be controlled in heterogeneous media. Moreover, the methodology proposed here is applicable not only to biological membrane systems but also to the study of diffusion and localization phenomena of molecules in various heterogeneous systems.
△ Less
Submitted 10 August, 2023; v1 submitted 19 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Preface: Characterisation of Physical Processes from Anomalous Diffusion Data
Authors:
Carlo Manzo,
Gorka Muñoz-Gil,
Giovanni Volpe,
Miguel Angel Garcia-March,
Maciej Lewenstein,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Preface to the special issue "Characterisation of Physical Processes from Anomalous Diffusion Data" associated with the Anomalous Diffusion Challenge ( https://andi-challenge.org ) and published in Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical. The list of articles included in the special issue can be accessed at https://iopscience.iop.org/journal/1751-8121/page/Characterisation-of-Physical-P…
▽ More
Preface to the special issue "Characterisation of Physical Processes from Anomalous Diffusion Data" associated with the Anomalous Diffusion Challenge ( https://andi-challenge.org ) and published in Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical. The list of articles included in the special issue can be accessed at https://iopscience.iop.org/journal/1751-8121/page/Characterisation-of-Physical-Processes-from-Anomalous-Diffusion-Data .
△ Less
Submitted 7 January, 2023; v1 submitted 2 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
-
Towards a robust criterion of anomalous diffusion
Authors:
Vittoria Sposini,
Diego Krapf,
Enzo Marinari,
Raimon Sunyer,
Felix Ritort,
Fereydoon Taheri,
Christine Selhuber-Unkel,
Rebecca Benelli,
Matthias Weiss,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
Anomalous-diffusion, the departure of the spreading dynamics of diffusing particles from the traditional law of Brownian-motion, is a signature feature of a large number of complex soft-matter and biological systems. Anomalous-diffusion emerges due to a variety of physical mechanisms, e.g., trap** interactions or the viscoelasticity of the environment. However, sometimes systems dynamics are err…
▽ More
Anomalous-diffusion, the departure of the spreading dynamics of diffusing particles from the traditional law of Brownian-motion, is a signature feature of a large number of complex soft-matter and biological systems. Anomalous-diffusion emerges due to a variety of physical mechanisms, e.g., trap** interactions or the viscoelasticity of the environment. However, sometimes systems dynamics are erroneously claimed to be anomalous, despite the fact that the true motion is Brownian -- or vice versa. This ambiguity in establishing whether the dynamics as normal or anomalous can have far-reaching consequences, e.g., in predictions for reaction- or relaxation-laws. Demonstrating that a system exhibits normal- or anomalous-diffusion is highly desirable for a vast host of applications. Here, we present a criterion for anomalous-diffusion based on the method of power-spectral analysis of single trajectories. The robustness of this criterion is studied for trajectories of fractional-Brownian-motion, a ubiquitous stochastic process for the description of anomalous-diffusion, in the presence of two types of measurement errors. In particular, we find that our criterion is very robust for subdiffusion. Various tests on surrogate data in absence or presence of additional positional noise demonstrate the efficacy of this method in practical contexts. Finally, we provide a proof-of-concept based on diverse experiments exhibiting both normal and anomalous-diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 9 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Bayesian deep learning for error estimation in the analysis of anomalous diffusion
Authors:
Henrik Seckler,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Modern single-particle-tracking techniques produce extensive time-series of diffusive motion in a wide variety of systems, from single-molecule motion in living-cells to movement ecology. The quest is to decipher the physical mechanisms encoded in the data and thus to better understand the probed systems. We here augment recently proposed machine-learning techniques for decoding anomalous-diffusio…
▽ More
Modern single-particle-tracking techniques produce extensive time-series of diffusive motion in a wide variety of systems, from single-molecule motion in living-cells to movement ecology. The quest is to decipher the physical mechanisms encoded in the data and thus to better understand the probed systems. We here augment recently proposed machine-learning techniques for decoding anomalous-diffusion data to include an uncertainty estimate in addition to the predicted output. To avoid the Black-Box-Problem a Bayesian-Deep-Learning technique named Stochastic-Weight-Averaging-Gaussian is used to train models for both the classification of the diffusion model and the regression of the anomalous diffusion exponent of single-particle-trajectories. Evaluating their performance, we find that these models can achieve a well-calibrated error estimate while maintaining high prediction accuracies. In the analysis of the output uncertainty predictions we relate these to properties of the underlying diffusion models, thus providing insights into the learning process of the machine and the relevance of the output.
△ Less
Submitted 13 September, 2023; v1 submitted 9 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Non-Gaussian displacement distributions in models of heterogeneous active particle dynamics
Authors:
Elisabeth Lemaitre,
Igor M. Sokolov,
Ralf Metzler,
Aleksei V. Chechkin
Abstract:
We study the effect of randomly distributed diffusivities and speeds in two models for active particle dynamics with active and passive fluctuations. We demonstrate how non-Gaussian displacement distributions emerge in these models in the long time limit, including Cauchy-type and exponential (Laplace) shapes. Notably the resulting shapes of the displacement distributions with distributed diffusiv…
▽ More
We study the effect of randomly distributed diffusivities and speeds in two models for active particle dynamics with active and passive fluctuations. We demonstrate how non-Gaussian displacement distributions emerge in these models in the long time limit, including Cauchy-type and exponential (Laplace) shapes. Notably the resulting shapes of the displacement distributions with distributed diffusivities for the active models considered here are in striking contrast to passive diffusion models. For the active motion models our discussion points out the differences between active- and passive-noise. Specifically, we demonstrate that the case with active-noise is in nice agreement with measured data for the displacement distribution of social amoeba.
△ Less
Submitted 4 August, 2022;
originally announced August 2022.
-
Local equilibrium properties of ultraslow diffusion in the Sinai model
Authors:
Amin Padash,
Erez Aghion,
Alexander Schulz,
Eli Barkai,
Aleksei V Chechkin,
Ralf Metzler,
Holger Kantz
Abstract:
We perform numerical studies of a thermally driven, overdamped particle in a random quenched force field, known as the Sinai model. We compare the unbounded motion on an infinite 1-dimensional domain to the motion in bounded domains with reflecting boundaries and show that the unbounded motion is at every time close to the equilibrium state of a finite system of growing size. This is due to time s…
▽ More
We perform numerical studies of a thermally driven, overdamped particle in a random quenched force field, known as the Sinai model. We compare the unbounded motion on an infinite 1-dimensional domain to the motion in bounded domains with reflecting boundaries and show that the unbounded motion is at every time close to the equilibrium state of a finite system of growing size. This is due to time scale separation: Inside wells of the random potential, there is relatively fast equilibration, while the motion across major potential barriers is ultraslow. Quantities studied by us are the time dependent mean squared displacement, the time dependent mean energy of an ensemble of particles, and the time dependent entropy of the probability distribution. Using a very fast numerical algorithm, we can explore times up top $10^{17}$ steps and thereby also study finite-time crossover phenomena.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2022; v1 submitted 6 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
First-passage times in conical varying-width channels biased by a transverse gravitational force: Comparison of analytical and numerical results
Authors:
Ivan Pompa-Garcia,
Rodrigo Castilla,
Ralf Metzler,
Leonardo Dagdug
Abstract:
We study the crossing time statistic of diffusing point particles between the two ends of expanding and narrowing two-dimensional conical channels under a transverse external gravitational field. The theoretical expression for the mean first-passage time for such a system is derived under the assumption that the axial diffusion in a two-dimensional channel of smoothly varying geometry can be appro…
▽ More
We study the crossing time statistic of diffusing point particles between the two ends of expanding and narrowing two-dimensional conical channels under a transverse external gravitational field. The theoretical expression for the mean first-passage time for such a system is derived under the assumption that the axial diffusion in a two-dimensional channel of smoothly varying geometry can be approximately described as a one-dimensional diffusion in an entropic potential with position-dependent effective diffusivity in terms of the modified Fick-Jacobs equation. We analyze the channel crossing dynamics in terms of the mean first-passage time, combining our analytical results with extensive two-dimensional Brownian dynamics simulations, allowing us to find the range of applicability of the one-dimensional approximation. We find that the effective particle diffusivity decreases with increasing amplitude of the external potential. Remarkably, the mean first-passage time for crossing the channel is shown to assume a minimum at finite values of the potential amplitude.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Search efficiency in the Adam-Delbrück reduction-of-dimensionality scenario versus direct diffusive search
Authors:
Denis S. Grebenkov,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
The time instant -- the first-passage time (FPT) -- when a diffusive particle (e.g., a ligand such as oxygen or a signalling protein) for the first time reaches an immobile target located on the surface of a bounded three-dimensional domain (e.g., a hemoglobin molecule or the cellular nucleus) is a decisive characteristic time-scale in diverse biophysical and biochemical processes, as well as in i…
▽ More
The time instant -- the first-passage time (FPT) -- when a diffusive particle (e.g., a ligand such as oxygen or a signalling protein) for the first time reaches an immobile target located on the surface of a bounded three-dimensional domain (e.g., a hemoglobin molecule or the cellular nucleus) is a decisive characteristic time-scale in diverse biophysical and biochemical processes, as well as in intermediate stages of various inter- and intra-cellular signal transduction pathways. Adam and Delbrück put forth the reduction-of-dimensionality concept, according to which a ligand first binds non-specifically to any point of the surface on which the target is placed and then diffuses along this surface until it locates the target. In this work, we analyse the efficiency of such a scenario and confront it with the efficiency of a direct search process, in which the target is approached directly from the bulk and not aided by surface diffusion. We consider two situations: (i) a single ligand is launched from a fixed or a random position and searches for the target, and (ii) the case of "amplified" signals when $N$ ligands start either from the same point or from random positions, and the search terminates when the fastest of them arrives to the target. For such settings, we go beyond the conventional analyses, which compare only the mean values of the corresponding FPTs. Instead, we calculate the full probability density function of FPTs for both scenarios and study its integral characteristic -- the "survival" probability of a target up to time $t$. On this basis, we examine how the efficiencies of both scenarios are controlled by a variety of parameters and single out realistic conditions in which the reduction-of-dimensionality scenario outperforms the direct search.
△ Less
Submitted 28 July, 2022; v1 submitted 8 June, 2022;
originally announced June 2022.
-
Steering self-organisation through confinement
Authors:
Nuno A. M. Araújo,
Liesbeth M. C. Janssen,
Thomas Barois,
Guido Boffetta,
Itai Cohen,
Alessandro Corbetta,
Olivier Dauchot,
Marjolein Dijkstra,
William M. Durham,
Audrey Dussutour,
Simon Garnier,
Hanneke Gelderblom,
Ramin Golestanian,
Lucio Isa,
Gijsje H. Koenderink,
Hartmut Löwen,
Ralf Metzler,
Marco Polin,
C. Patrick Royall,
Anđela Šarić,
Anupam Sengupta,
Cécile Sykes,
Vito Trianni,
Idan Tuval,
Nicolas Vogel
, et al. (4 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Self-organisation is the spontaneous emergence of spatio-temporal structures and patterns from the interaction of smaller individual units. Examples are found across many scales in very different systems and scientific disciplines, from physics, materials science and robotics to biology, geophysics and astronomy. Recent research has highlighted how self-organisation can be both mediated and contro…
▽ More
Self-organisation is the spontaneous emergence of spatio-temporal structures and patterns from the interaction of smaller individual units. Examples are found across many scales in very different systems and scientific disciplines, from physics, materials science and robotics to biology, geophysics and astronomy. Recent research has highlighted how self-organisation can be both mediated and controlled by confinement. Confinement occurs through interactions with boundaries, and can function as either a catalyst or inhibitor of self-organisation. It can then become a means to actively steer the emergence or suppression of collective phenomena in space and time. Here, to provide a common framework for future research, we examine the role of confinement in self-organisation and identify overarching scientific challenges across disciplines that need to be addressed to harness its full scientific and technological potential. This framework will not only accelerate the generation of a common deeper understanding of self-organisation but also trigger the development of innovative strategies to steer it through confinement, with impact, e.g., on the design of smarter materials, tissue engineering for biomedicine and crowd management.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Classification of anomalous diffusion in animal movement data using power spectral analysis
Authors:
Ohad Vilk,
Erez Aghion,
Ran Nathan,
Sivan Toledo,
Ralf Metzler,
Michael Assaf
Abstract:
The field of movement ecology has seen a rapid increase in high-resolution data in recent years, leading to the development of numerous statistical and numerical methods to analyse relocation trajectories. Data are often collected at the level of the individual and for long periods that may encompass a range of behaviours. Here, we use the power spectral density (PSD) to characterise the random mo…
▽ More
The field of movement ecology has seen a rapid increase in high-resolution data in recent years, leading to the development of numerous statistical and numerical methods to analyse relocation trajectories. Data are often collected at the level of the individual and for long periods that may encompass a range of behaviours. Here, we use the power spectral density (PSD) to characterise the random movement patterns of a black-winged kite (Elanus caeruleus) and a white stork (Ciconia ciconia). The tracks are first segmented and clustered into different behaviours (movement modes), and for each mode we measure the PSD and the ageing properties of the process. For the foraging kite we find $1/f$ noise, previously reported in ecological systems mainly in the context of population dynamics, but not for movement data. We further suggest plausible models for each of the behavioural modes by comparing both the measured PSD exponents and the distribution of the single-trajectory PSD to known theoretical results and simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Apparent anomalous diffusion and non-Gaussian distributions in a simple mobile-immobile transport model with Poissonian switching
Authors:
T. Doerries,
A. V. Chechkin,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
We analyse mobile-immobile transport of particles that switch between the mobile and immobile phases with finite rates. Despite this seemingly simple assumption of Poissonian switching we unveil a rich transport dynamics including significant transient anomalous diffusion and non-Gaussian displacement distributions. Our discussion is based on experimental parameters for tau proteins in neuronal ce…
▽ More
We analyse mobile-immobile transport of particles that switch between the mobile and immobile phases with finite rates. Despite this seemingly simple assumption of Poissonian switching we unveil a rich transport dynamics including significant transient anomalous diffusion and non-Gaussian displacement distributions. Our discussion is based on experimental parameters for tau proteins in neuronal cells, but the results obtained here are expected to be of relevance for a broad class of processes in complex systems. Concretely, we obtain that when the mean binding time is significantly longer than the mean mobile time, transient anomalous diffusion is observed at short and intermediate time scales, with a strong dependence on the fraction of initially mobile and immobile particles. We unveil a Laplace distribution of particle displacements at relevant intermediate time scales. For any initial fraction of mobile particles, the respective mean squared displacement displays a plateau. Moreover, we demonstrate a short-time cubic time dependence of the mean squared displacement for immobile tracers when initially all particles are immobile.
△ Less
Submitted 24 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Absence of confinement and non-Boltzmann stationary states of fractional Brownian motion in shallow external potentials
Authors:
Tobias Guggenberger,
Aleksei V. Chechkin,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
We study the diffusive motion of a particle in a subharmonic potential of the form $U(x)=|x|^c$ ($0<c<2$) driven by long-range correlated, stationary fractional Gaussian noise $ξ_α(t)$ with $0<α\le2$. In the absence of the potential the particle exhibits free fractional Brownian motion with anomalous diffusion exponent $α$. While for an harmonic external potential the dynamics converges to a Gauss…
▽ More
We study the diffusive motion of a particle in a subharmonic potential of the form $U(x)=|x|^c$ ($0<c<2$) driven by long-range correlated, stationary fractional Gaussian noise $ξ_α(t)$ with $0<α\le2$. In the absence of the potential the particle exhibits free fractional Brownian motion with anomalous diffusion exponent $α$. While for an harmonic external potential the dynamics converges to a Gaussian stationary state, from extensive numerical analysis we here demonstrate that stationary states for shallower than harmonic potentials exist only as long as the relation $c>2(1-1/α)$ holds. We analyse the motion in terms of the mean squared displacement and (when it exists) the stationary probability density function (PDF). Moreover we discuss analogies of non-stationarity of L{é}vy flights in shallow external potentials.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Bayesian inference of scaled versus fractional Brownian motion
Authors:
Samudrajit Thapa,
Seongyu Park,
Yeong** Kim,
Jae-Hyung Jeon,
Ralf Metzler,
Michael A. Lomholt
Abstract:
We present a Bayesian inference scheme for scaled Brownian motion, and investigate its performance on synthetic data for parameter estimation and model selection in a combined inference with fractional Brownian motion. We include the possibility of measurement noise in both models. We find that for trajectories of a few hundred time points the procedure is able to resolve well the true model and p…
▽ More
We present a Bayesian inference scheme for scaled Brownian motion, and investigate its performance on synthetic data for parameter estimation and model selection in a combined inference with fractional Brownian motion. We include the possibility of measurement noise in both models. We find that for trajectories of a few hundred time points the procedure is able to resolve well the true model and parameters. Using the prior of the synthetic data generation process also for the inference, the approach is optimal based on decision theory. We include a comparison with inference using a prior different from the data generating one.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2022; v1 submitted 30 December, 2021;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Distribution of first-reaction times with target regions on boundaries of shell-like domains
Authors:
Denis S. Grebenkov,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
We study the probability density function (PDF) of the first-reaction times between a diffusive ligand and a membrane-bound, immobile imperfect target region in a restricted "onion-shell" geometry bounded by two nested membranes of arbitrary shapes. For such a setting, encountered in diverse molecular signal transduction pathways or in the narrow escape problem with additional steric constraints,…
▽ More
We study the probability density function (PDF) of the first-reaction times between a diffusive ligand and a membrane-bound, immobile imperfect target region in a restricted "onion-shell" geometry bounded by two nested membranes of arbitrary shapes. For such a setting, encountered in diverse molecular signal transduction pathways or in the narrow escape problem with additional steric constraints, we derive an exact spectral form of the PDF, as well as present its approximate form calculated by help of the so-called self-consistent approximation. For a particular case when the nested domains are concentric spheres, we get a fully explicit form of the approximated PDF, assess the accuracy of this approximation, and discuss various facets of the obtained distributions. Our results can be straightforwardly applied to describe the PDF of the terminal reaction event in multi-stage signal transduction processes.
△ Less
Submitted 26 November, 2021;
originally announced November 2021.
-
A molecular relay race: sequential first-passage events to the terminal reaction centre in a cascade of diffusion controlled processes
Authors:
Denis S. Grebenkov,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
We consider a sequential cascade of molecular first-reaction events towards a terminal reaction centre in which each reaction step is controlled by diffusive motion of the particles. The model studied here represents a typical reaction setting encountered in diverse molecular biology systems, in which, e.g., a signal transduction proceeds via a series of consecutive "messengers": the first messeng…
▽ More
We consider a sequential cascade of molecular first-reaction events towards a terminal reaction centre in which each reaction step is controlled by diffusive motion of the particles. The model studied here represents a typical reaction setting encountered in diverse molecular biology systems, in which, e.g., a signal transduction proceeds via a series of consecutive "messengers": the first messenger has to find its respective immobile target site triggering a launch of the second messenger, the second messenger seeks its own target site and provokes a launch of the third messenger and so on, resembling a relay race in human competitions. For such a molecular relay race taking place in infinite one-, two- and three-dimensional systems, we find exact expressions for the probability density function of the time instant of the terminal reaction event, conditioned on preceding successful reaction events on an ordered array of target sites. The obtained expressions pertain to the most general conditions: number of intermediate stages and the corresponding diffusion coefficients, the sizes of the target sites, the distances between them, as well as their reactivities are arbitrary.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2021;
originally announced October 2021.
-
Unravelling the origins of anomalous diffusion: from molecules to migrating storks
Authors:
Ohad Vilk,
Erez Aghion,
Tal Avgar,
Carsten Beta,
Oliver Nagel,
Adal Sabri,
Raphael Sarfati,
Daniel K. Schwartz,
Matthias Weiss,
Diego Krapf,
Ran Nathan,
Ralf Metzler,
Michael Assaf
Abstract:
Anomalous diffusion or, more generally, anomalous transport, with nonlinear dependence of the mean-squared displacement on the measurement time, is ubiquitous in nature. It has been observed in processes ranging from microscopic movement of molecules to macroscopic, large-scale paths of migrating birds. Using data from multiple empirical systems, spanning 12 orders of magnitude in length and 8 ord…
▽ More
Anomalous diffusion or, more generally, anomalous transport, with nonlinear dependence of the mean-squared displacement on the measurement time, is ubiquitous in nature. It has been observed in processes ranging from microscopic movement of molecules to macroscopic, large-scale paths of migrating birds. Using data from multiple empirical systems, spanning 12 orders of magnitude in length and 8 orders of magnitude in time, we employ a method to detect the individual underlying origins of anomalous diffusion and transport in the data. This method decomposes anomalous transport into three primary effects: long-range correlations ("Joseph effect"), fat-tailed probability density of increments ("Noah effect"), and non-stationarity ("Moses effect"). We show that such a decomposition of real-life data allows to infer nontrivial behavioral predictions, and to resolve open questions in the fields of single particle tracking in living cells and movement ecology.
△ Less
Submitted 27 June, 2022; v1 submitted 9 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Objective comparison of methods to decode anomalous diffusion
Authors:
Gorka Muñoz-Gil,
Giovanni Volpe,
Miguel Angel Garcia-March,
Erez Aghion,
Aykut Argun,
Chang Beom Hong,
Tom Bland,
Stefano Bo,
J. Alberto Conejero,
Nicolás Firbas,
Òscar Garibo i Orts,
Alessia Gentili,
Zihan Huang,
Jae-Hyung Jeon,
Hélène Kabbech,
Yeong** Kim,
Patrycja Kowalek,
Diego Krapf,
Hanna Loch-Olszewska,
Michael A. Lomholt,
Jean-Baptiste Masson,
Philipp G. Meyer,
Seongyu Park,
Borja Requena,
Ihor Smal
, et al. (9 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
Deviations from Brownian motion leading to anomalous diffusion are ubiquitously found in transport dynamics, playing a crucial role in phenomena from quantum physics to life sciences. The detection and characterization of anomalous diffusion from the measurement of an individual trajectory are challenging tasks, which traditionally rely on calculating the mean squared displacement of the trajector…
▽ More
Deviations from Brownian motion leading to anomalous diffusion are ubiquitously found in transport dynamics, playing a crucial role in phenomena from quantum physics to life sciences. The detection and characterization of anomalous diffusion from the measurement of an individual trajectory are challenging tasks, which traditionally rely on calculating the mean squared displacement of the trajectory. However, this approach breaks down for cases of important practical interest, e.g., short or noisy trajectories, ensembles of heterogeneous trajectories, or non-ergodic processes. Recently, several new approaches have been proposed, mostly building on the ongoing machine-learning revolution. Aiming to perform an objective comparison of methods, we gathered the community and organized an open competition, the Anomalous Diffusion challenge (AnDi). Participating teams independently applied their own algorithms to a commonly-defined dataset including diverse conditions. Although no single method performed best across all scenarios, the results revealed clear differences between the various approaches, providing practical advice for users and a benchmark for developers.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Stochastic resetting by a random amplitude
Authors:
M. Dahlenburg,
A. V. Chechkin,
R. Schumer,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
Stochastic resetting, a diffusive process whose amplitude is "reset" to the origin at random times, is a vividly studied strategy to optimize encounter dynamics, e.g., in chemical reactions. We here generalize the resetting step by introducing a random resetting amplitude, such that the diffusing particle may be only partially reset towards the trajectory origin, or even overshoot the origin in a…
▽ More
Stochastic resetting, a diffusive process whose amplitude is "reset" to the origin at random times, is a vividly studied strategy to optimize encounter dynamics, e.g., in chemical reactions. We here generalize the resetting step by introducing a random resetting amplitude, such that the diffusing particle may be only partially reset towards the trajectory origin, or even overshoot the origin in a resetting step. We introduce different scenarios for the random-amplitude stochastic resetting process and discuss the resulting dynamics. Direct applications are geophysical layering (stratigraphy) as well as population dynamics or financial markets, as well as generic search processes.
△ Less
Submitted 30 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Universal relation between instantaneous diffusivity and radius of gyration of proteins in aqueous solution
Authors:
Eiji Yamamoto,
Takuma Akimoto,
Ayori Mitsutake,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Protein conformational fluctuations are highly complex and exhibit long-term correlations. Here, molecular dynamics simulations of small proteins demonstrate that these conformational fluctuations directly affect the protein's instantaneous diffusivity $D_I$. We find that the radius of gyration $R_g$ of the proteins exhibits $1/f$ fluctuations, that are synchronous with the fluctuations of $D_I$.…
▽ More
Protein conformational fluctuations are highly complex and exhibit long-term correlations. Here, molecular dynamics simulations of small proteins demonstrate that these conformational fluctuations directly affect the protein's instantaneous diffusivity $D_I$. We find that the radius of gyration $R_g$ of the proteins exhibits $1/f$ fluctuations, that are synchronous with the fluctuations of $D_I$. Our analysis demonstrates the validity of the local Stokes-Einstein type relation $D_I\propto1/(R_g + R_0)$, where $R_0\sim0.3$ nm is assumed to be a hydration layer around the protein. From the analysis of different protein types with both strong and weak conformational fluctuations the validity of the Stokes-Einstein type relation appears to be a general property.
△ Less
Submitted 3 March, 2021; v1 submitted 14 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
From single-particle stochastic kinetics to macroscopic reaction rates: fastest first-passage time of $N$ random walkers
Authors:
Denis S. Grebenkov,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
We consider the first-passage problem for $N$ identical independent particles that are initially released uniformly in a finite domain $Ω$ and then diffuse toward a reactive area $Γ$, which can be part of the outer boundary of $Ω$ or a reaction centre in the interior of $Ω$. For both cases of perfect and partial reactions, we obtain the explicit formulas for the first two moments of the fastest fi…
▽ More
We consider the first-passage problem for $N$ identical independent particles that are initially released uniformly in a finite domain $Ω$ and then diffuse toward a reactive area $Γ$, which can be part of the outer boundary of $Ω$ or a reaction centre in the interior of $Ω$. For both cases of perfect and partial reactions, we obtain the explicit formulas for the first two moments of the fastest first-passage time (fFPT), i.e., the time when the first out of the $N$ particles reacts with $Γ$. Moreover, we investigate the full probability density of the fFPT. We discuss a significant role of the initial condition in the scaling of the average fastest first-passage time with the particle number $N$, namely, a much stronger dependence ($1/N$ and $1/N^2$ for partially and perfectly reactive targets, respectively), in contrast to the well known inverse-logarithmic behaviour found when all particles are released from the same fixed point. We combine analytic solutions with scaling arguments and stochastic simulations to rationalise our results, which open new perspectives for studying the relevance of multiple searchers in various situations of molecular reactions, in particular, in living cells.
△ Less
Submitted 19 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Exact first-passage time distributions for three random diffusivity models
Authors:
D. S. Grebenkov,
V. Sposini,
R. Metzler,
G. Oshanin,
F. Seno
Abstract:
We study the extremal properties of a stochastic process $x_t$ defined by a Langevin equation $\dot{x}_t=\sqrt{2 D_0 V(B_t)}\,ξ_t$, where $ξ_t$ is a Gaussian white noise with zero mean, $D_0$ is a constant scale factor, and $V(B_t)$ is a stochastic "diffusivity" (noise strength), which itself is a functional of independent Brownian motion $B_t$. We derive exact, compact expressions for the probabi…
▽ More
We study the extremal properties of a stochastic process $x_t$ defined by a Langevin equation $\dot{x}_t=\sqrt{2 D_0 V(B_t)}\,ξ_t$, where $ξ_t$ is a Gaussian white noise with zero mean, $D_0$ is a constant scale factor, and $V(B_t)$ is a stochastic "diffusivity" (noise strength), which itself is a functional of independent Brownian motion $B_t$. We derive exact, compact expressions for the probability density functions (PDFs) of the first passage time (FPT) $t$ from a fixed location $x_0$ to the origin for three different realisations of the stochastic diffusivity: a cut-off case $V(B_t) =Θ(B_t)$ (Model I), where $Θ(x)$ is the Heaviside theta function; a Geometric Brownian Motion $V(B_t)=\exp(B_t)$ (Model II); and a case with $V(B_t)=B_t^2$ (Model III). We realise that, rather surprisingly, the FPT PDF has exactly the Lévy-Smirnov form (specific for standard Brownian motion) for Model II, which concurrently exhibits a strongly anomalous diffusion. For Models I and III either the left or right tails (or both) have a different functional dependence on time as compared to the Lévy-Smirnov density. In all cases, the PDFs are broad such that already the first moment does not exist. Similar results are obtained in three dimensions for the FPT PDF to an absorbing spherical target.
△ Less
Submitted 11 July, 2020;
originally announced July 2020.
-
Leveraging large-deviation statistics to decipher the stochastic properties of measured trajectories
Authors:
Samudrajit Thapa,
Agnieszka Wyłomańska,
Grzegorz Sikora,
Caroline E. Wagner,
Diego Krapf,
Holger Kantz,
Aleksei V. Chechkin,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Extensive time-series encoding the position of particles such as viruses, vesicles, or individual proteins are routinely garnered in single-particle tracking experiments or supercomputing studies. They contain vital clues on how viruses spread or drugs may be delivered in biological cells. Similar time-series are being recorded of stock values in financial markets and of climate data. Such time-se…
▽ More
Extensive time-series encoding the position of particles such as viruses, vesicles, or individual proteins are routinely garnered in single-particle tracking experiments or supercomputing studies. They contain vital clues on how viruses spread or drugs may be delivered in biological cells. Similar time-series are being recorded of stock values in financial markets and of climate data. Such time-series are most typically evaluated in terms of time-average mean-squared displacements, which remain random variables for finite measurement times. Their statistical properties are different for different physical stochastic processes, thus allowing us to extract valuable information on the stochastic process itself. To exploit the full potential of the statistical information encoded in measured time-series we here propose an easy-to-implement and computationally inexpensive new methodology, based on deviations of the time-averaged mean-squared displacement from its ensemble average counterpart. Specifically, we use the upper bound of these deviations for Brownian motion to check the applicability of this approach to simulated and real data sets. By comparing the probability of deviations for different data sets, we demonstrate how the theoretical bound for Brownian motion reveals additional information about observed stochastic processes. We apply the large-deviation method to data sets of tracer beads tracked in aqueous solution, tracer beads measured in mucin hydrogels, and of geographic surface temperature anomalies. Our analysis shows how the large-deviation properties can be efficiently used as a simple yet effective routine test to reject the Brownian motion hypothesis and unveil crucial information on statistical properties such as ergodicity breaking and short-time correlations.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
First passage time moments of asymmetric Lévy flights
Authors:
Amin Padash,
Aleksei V. Chechkin,
Bartłomiej Dybiec,
Marcin Magdziarz,
Babak Shokri,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
We investigate the first-passage dynamics of symmetric and asymmetric Lévy flights in a semi-infinite and bounded intervals. By solving the space-fractional diffusion equation, we analyse the fractional-order moments of the first-passage time probability density function for different values of the index of stability and the skewness parameter. A comparison with results using the Langevin approach…
▽ More
We investigate the first-passage dynamics of symmetric and asymmetric Lévy flights in a semi-infinite and bounded intervals. By solving the space-fractional diffusion equation, we analyse the fractional-order moments of the first-passage time probability density function for different values of the index of stability and the skewness parameter. A comparison with results using the Langevin approach to Lévy flights is presented. For the semi-infinite domain, in certain special cases analytic results are derived explicitly, and in bounded intervals a general analytical expression for the mean first-passage time of Lévy flights with arbitrary skewness is presented. These results are complemented with extensive numerical analyses.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Unexpected crossovers in correlated random-diffusivity processes
Authors:
Wei Wang,
Flavio Seno,
Igor M. Sokolov,
Aleksei V. Chechkin,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
The passive and active motion of micron-sized tracer particles in crowded liquids and inside living biological cells is ubiquitously characterised by "viscoelastic" anomalous diffusion, in which the increments of the motion feature long-ranged negative and positive correlations. While viscoelastic anomalous diffusion is typically modelled by a Gaussian process with correlated increments, so-called…
▽ More
The passive and active motion of micron-sized tracer particles in crowded liquids and inside living biological cells is ubiquitously characterised by "viscoelastic" anomalous diffusion, in which the increments of the motion feature long-ranged negative and positive correlations. While viscoelastic anomalous diffusion is typically modelled by a Gaussian process with correlated increments, so-called fractional Gaussian noise, an increasing number of systems are reported, in which viscoelastic anomalous diffusion is paired with non-Gaussian displacement distributions. Following recent advances in Brownian yet non-Gaussian diffusion we here introduce and discuss several possible versions of random-diffusivity models with long-ranged correlations. While all these models show a crossover from non-Gaussian to Gaussian distributions beyond some correlation time, their mean squared displacements exhibit strikingly different behaviours: depending on the model crossovers from anomalous to normal diffusion are observed, as well as unexpected dependencies of the effective diffusion coefficient on the correlation exponent. Our observations of the strong non-universality of random-diffusivity viscoelastic anomalous diffusion are important for the analysis of experiments and a better understanding of the physical origins of "viscoelastic yet non-Gaussian" diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 1 May, 2020;
originally announced May 2020.
-
Lévy walk dynamics in an external harmonic potential
Authors:
Pengbo Xu,
Tian Zhou,
Ralf Metzler,
Weihua Deng
Abstract:
Lévy walks (LWs) are spatiotemporally coupled random-walk processes describing superdiffusive heat conduction in solids, propagation of light in disordered optical materials, motion of molecular motors in living cells, or motion of animals, humans, robots, and viruses. We here investigate a key feature of LWs, their response to an external harmonic potential. In this generic setting for confined m…
▽ More
Lévy walks (LWs) are spatiotemporally coupled random-walk processes describing superdiffusive heat conduction in solids, propagation of light in disordered optical materials, motion of molecular motors in living cells, or motion of animals, humans, robots, and viruses. We here investigate a key feature of LWs, their response to an external harmonic potential. In this generic setting for confined motion we demonstrate that LWs equilibrate exponentially and may assume a bimodal stationary distribution. We also show that the stationary distribution has a horizontal slope next to a reflecting boundary placed at the origin, in contrast to correlated superdiffusive processes. Our results generalize LWs to confining forces and settle some long-standing puzzles around LWs.
△ Less
Submitted 21 April, 2020;
originally announced April 2020.
-
AnDi: The Anomalous Diffusion Challenge
Authors:
Gorka Muñoz-Gil,
Giovanni Volpe,
Miguel Angel Garcia-March,
Ralf Metzler,
Maciej Lewenstein,
Carlo Manzo
Abstract:
The deviation from pure Brownian motion generally referred to as anomalous diffusion has received large attention in the scientific literature to describe many physical scenarios. Several methods, based on classical statistics and machine learning approaches, have been developed to characterize anomalous diffusion from experimental data, which are usually acquired as particle trajectories. With th…
▽ More
The deviation from pure Brownian motion generally referred to as anomalous diffusion has received large attention in the scientific literature to describe many physical scenarios. Several methods, based on classical statistics and machine learning approaches, have been developed to characterize anomalous diffusion from experimental data, which are usually acquired as particle trajectories. With the aim to assess and compare the available methods to characterize anomalous diffusion, we have organized the Anomalous Diffusion (AnDi) Challenge (\url{http://www.andi-challenge.org/}). Specifically, the AnDi Challenge will address three different aspects of anomalous diffusion characterization, namely: (i) Inference of the anomalous diffusion exponent. (ii) Identification of the underlying diffusion model. (iii) Segmentation of trajectories. Each problem includes sub-tasks for different number of dimensions (1D, 2D and 3D). In order to compare the various methods, we have developed a dedicated open-source framework for the simulation of the anomalous diffusion trajectories that are used for the training and test datasets. The challenge was launched on March 1, 2020, and consists of three phases. Currently, the participation to the first phase is open. Submissions will be automatically evaluated and the performance of the top-scoring methods will be thoroughly analyzed and compared in an upcoming article.
△ Less
Submitted 26 March, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Diffusion of antibiotics through a biofilm in the presence of diffusion and absorption barriers
Authors:
Tadeusz Kosztołowicz,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
We propose a model of antibiotic diffusion through a bacterial biofilm when diffusion and/or absorption barriers develop in the biofilm. The idea of this model is: We deduce details of the diffusion process in a medium in which direct experimental study is difficult, based on probing diffusion in external regions. Since a biofilm has a gel-like consistency, we suppose that subdiffusion of particle…
▽ More
We propose a model of antibiotic diffusion through a bacterial biofilm when diffusion and/or absorption barriers develop in the biofilm. The idea of this model is: We deduce details of the diffusion process in a medium in which direct experimental study is difficult, based on probing diffusion in external regions. Since a biofilm has a gel-like consistency, we suppose that subdiffusion of particles in the biofilm may occur. To describe this process we use a fractional subdiffusion-absorption equation with an adjustable anomalous diffusion exponent. The boundary conditions at the boundaries of the biofilm are derived by means of a particle random walk model on a discrete lattice leading to an expression involving a fractional time derivative. We show that the temporal evolution of the total amount of substance that has diffused through the biofilm explicitly depends on whether there is antibiotic absorption in the biofilm. This fact is used to experimentally check for antibiotic absorption in the biofilm and if the biofilm parameters change over time. We propose a four-stage model of antibiotic diffusion in biofilm based on the mentioned above physical characteristics. The biological interpretation of the stages, in particular their relation with the bacterial defence mechanisms, is discussed. Theoretical results are compared with empirical results of ciprofloxacin diffusion through Pseudomonas aeruginosa biofilm, and ciprofloxacin and gentamicin diffusion through Proteus mirabilis biofilm.
△ Less
Submitted 11 May, 2020; v1 submitted 27 February, 2020;
originally announced March 2020.
-
Universal spectral features of different classes of random diffusivity processes
Authors:
V. Sposini,
D. S. Grebenkov,
R. Metzler,
G. Oshanin,
F. Seno
Abstract:
.Stochastic models based on random diffusivities, such as the diffusing-diffusivity approach, are popular concepts for the description of non-Gaussian diffusion in heterogeneous media. Studies of these models typically focus on the moments and the displacement probability density function. Here we develop the complementary power spectral description for a broad class of random diffusivity processe…
▽ More
.Stochastic models based on random diffusivities, such as the diffusing-diffusivity approach, are popular concepts for the description of non-Gaussian diffusion in heterogeneous media. Studies of these models typically focus on the moments and the displacement probability density function. Here we develop the complementary power spectral description for a broad class of random diffusivity processes. In our approach we cater for typical single particle tracking data in which a small number of trajectories with finite duration are garnered. Apart from the diffusing-diffusivity model we study a range of previously unconsidered random diffusivity processes, for which we obtain exact forms of the probability density function. These new processes are different versions of jump processes as well as functionals of Brownian motion. The resulting behaviour subtly depends on the specific model details. Thus, the central part of the probability density function may be Gaussian or non-Gaussian, and the tails may assume Gaussian, exponential, log-normal or even power-law forms. For all these models we derive analytically the moment-generating function for the single-trajectory power spectral density. We establish the generic $1/f^2$-scaling of the power spectral density as function of frequency in all cases. Moreover, we establish the probability density for the amplitudes of the random power spectral density of individual trajectories. The latter functions reflect the very specific properties of the different random diffusivity models considered here. Our exact results are in excellent agreement with extensive numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 2 March, 2020; v1 submitted 26 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Full distribution of first exit times in the narrow escape problem
Authors:
D. S. Grebenkov,
R. Metzler,
G. Oshanin
Abstract:
In the scenario of the narrow escape problem (NEP) a particle diffuses in a finite container and eventually leaves it through a small "escape window" in the otherwise impermeable boundary, once it arrives to this window and over-passes an entropic barrier at the entrance to it. This generic problem is mathematically identical to that of a diffusion-mediated reaction with a partially-reactive site…
▽ More
In the scenario of the narrow escape problem (NEP) a particle diffuses in a finite container and eventually leaves it through a small "escape window" in the otherwise impermeable boundary, once it arrives to this window and over-passes an entropic barrier at the entrance to it. This generic problem is mathematically identical to that of a diffusion-mediated reaction with a partially-reactive site on the container's boundary. Considerable knowledge is available on the dependence of the mean first-reaction time (FRT) on the pertinent parameters. We here go a distinct step further and derive the full FRT distribution for the NEP. We demonstrate that typical FRTs may be orders of magnitude shorter than the mean one, thus resulting in a strong defocusing of characteristic temporal scales. We unveil the geometry-control of the typical times, emphasising the role of the initial distance to the target as a decisive parameter. A crucial finding is the further FRT defocusing due to the barrier, necessitating repeated escape or reaction attempts interspersed with bulk excursions. These results add new perspectives and offer a broad comprehension of various features of the by-now classical NEP that are relevant for numerous biological and technological systems.
△ Less
Submitted 18 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Strong defocusing of molecular reaction times results from an interplay of geometry and reaction control
Authors:
Denis S. Grebenkov,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
Text-book concepts of diffusion- versus kinetic-control are well-defined for reaction-kinetics involving macroscopic concentrations of diffusive reactants that are adequately described by rate-constants -- the inverse of the mean-first-passage-time to the reaction-event. In contradistinction, an open important question is whether the mean-first-passage-time alone is a sufficient measure for bioche…
▽ More
Text-book concepts of diffusion- versus kinetic-control are well-defined for reaction-kinetics involving macroscopic concentrations of diffusive reactants that are adequately described by rate-constants -- the inverse of the mean-first-passage-time to the reaction-event. In contradistinction, an open important question is whether the mean-first-passage-time alone is a sufficient measure for biochemical reactions that involve nanomolar reactant concentrations. Here, using a simple yet generic, exactly-solvable model we study the conspiratory effect of diffusion and chemical reaction-limitations on the full reaction-time distribution. We show that it has a complex structure with four distinct regimes delimited by three characteristic time scales spanning a window of several decades. Consequently, the reaction-times are defocused: no unique time-scale characterises the reaction-process, diffusion- and kinetic-control can no longer be disentangled, and it is imperative to know the full reaction-time distribution. We introduce the concepts of geometry- and reaction-control, and also quantify each regime by calculating the corresponding reaction depth.
△ Less
Submitted 3 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
First passage properties of asymmetric Lévy flights
Authors:
A. Padash,
A. V. Chechkin,
B. Dybiec,
I. Pavlyukevich,
B. Shokri,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
Lévy Flights are paradigmatic generalised random walk processes, in which the independent stationary increments---the "jump lengths"---are drawn from an $α$-stable jump length distribution with long-tailed, power-law asymptote. As a result, the variance of Lévy Flights diverges and the trajectory is characterised by occasional extremely long jumps. Such long jumps significantly decrease the probab…
▽ More
Lévy Flights are paradigmatic generalised random walk processes, in which the independent stationary increments---the "jump lengths"---are drawn from an $α$-stable jump length distribution with long-tailed, power-law asymptote. As a result, the variance of Lévy Flights diverges and the trajectory is characterised by occasional extremely long jumps. Such long jumps significantly decrease the probability to revisit previous points of visitation, rendering Lévy Flights efficient search processes in one and two dimensions. To further quantify their precise property as random search strategies we here study the first-passage time properties of Lévy Flights in one-dimensional semi-infinite and bounded domains for symmetric and asymmetric jump length distributions. To obtain the full probability density function of first-passage times for these cases we employ two complementary methods. One approach is based on the space-fractional diffusion equation for the probability density function, from which the survival probability is obtained for different values of the stable index $α$ and the skewness (asymmetry) parameter $β$. The other approach is based on the stochastic Langevin equation with $α$-stable driving noise. Both methods have their advantages and disadvantages for explicit calculations and numerical evaluation, and the complementary approach involving both methods will be profitable for concrete applications. We also make use of the Skorokhod theorem for processes with independent increments and demonstrate that the numerical results are in good agreement with the analytical expressions for the probability density function of the first-passage times.
△ Less
Submitted 16 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
First-passage and first-hitting times of Levy flights and Levy walks
Authors:
V. V. Palyulin,
G. Blackburn,
M. A. Lomholt,
N. W. Watkins,
R. Metzler,
R. Klages,
A. V. Chechkin
Abstract:
For both Levy flight and Levy walk search processes we analyse the full distribution of first-passage and first-hitting (or first-arrival) times. These are, respectively, the times when the particle moves across a point at some given distance from its initial position for the first time, or when it lands at a given point for the first time. For Levy motions with their propensity for long relocatio…
▽ More
For both Levy flight and Levy walk search processes we analyse the full distribution of first-passage and first-hitting (or first-arrival) times. These are, respectively, the times when the particle moves across a point at some given distance from its initial position for the first time, or when it lands at a given point for the first time. For Levy motions with their propensity for long relocation events and thus the possibility to jump across a given point in space without actually hitting it ("leapovers"), these two definitions lead to significantly different results. We study the first-passage and first-hitting time distributions as functions of the Levy stable index, highlighting the different behaviour for the cases when the first absolute moment of the jump length distribution is finite or infinite. In particular we examine the limits of short and long times. Our results will find their application in the mathematical modelling of random search processes as well as computer algorithms.
△ Less
Submitted 12 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
-
Brownian motion and beyond: first-passage, power spectrum, non-Gaussianity, and anomalous diffusion
Authors:
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Brownian motion is a ubiquitous physical phenomenon across the sciences. After its discovery by Brown and intensive study since the first half of the 20th century, many different aspects of Brownian motion and stochastic processes in general have been addressed in Statistical Physics. In particular, there now exist a very large range of applications of stochastic processes in various disciplines.…
▽ More
Brownian motion is a ubiquitous physical phenomenon across the sciences. After its discovery by Brown and intensive study since the first half of the 20th century, many different aspects of Brownian motion and stochastic processes in general have been addressed in Statistical Physics. In particular, there now exist a very large range of applications of stochastic processes in various disciplines. Here, we highlight some of the advances in stochastic processes prompted by novel experimental methods such as superresolution microscopy. Here we provide a summary of some of the recent developments highlighting both the experimental findings and theoretical frameworks.
△ Less
Submitted 17 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
Random coefficient autoregressive processes describe Brownian yet non-Gaussian diffusion in heterogeneous systems
Authors:
Jakub Ślęzak,
Krzysztof Burnecki,
Ralf Metzler
Abstract:
Many studies on biological and soft matter systems report the joint presence of a linear mean-squared displacement and a non-Gaussian probability density exhibiting, for instance, exponential or stretched-Gaussian tails. This phenomenon is ascribed to the heterogeneity of the medium and is captured by random parameter models such as "superstatistics" or "diffusing diffusivity". Independently, scie…
▽ More
Many studies on biological and soft matter systems report the joint presence of a linear mean-squared displacement and a non-Gaussian probability density exhibiting, for instance, exponential or stretched-Gaussian tails. This phenomenon is ascribed to the heterogeneity of the medium and is captured by random parameter models such as "superstatistics" or "diffusing diffusivity". Independently, scientists working in the area of time series analysis and statistics have studied a class of discrete-time processes with similar properties, namely, random coefficient autoregressive models. In this work we try to reconcile these two approaches and thus provide a bridge between physical stochastic processes and autoregressive models. We start from the basic Langevin equation of motion with time-varying dam** or diffusion coefficients and establish the link to random coefficient autoregressive processes. By exploring that link we gain access to efficient statistical methods which can help to identify data exhibiting Brownian yet non-Gaussian diffusion.
△ Less
Submitted 23 July, 2019; v1 submitted 18 April, 2019;
originally announced April 2019.
-
Codifference can detect ergodicity breaking and non-Gaussianity
Authors:
Jakub Slezak,
Ralf Metzler,
Marcin Magdziarz
Abstract:
We show that the codifference is a useful tool in studying the ergodicity breaking and non-Gaussianity properties of stochastic time series. While the codifference is a measure of dependence that was previously studied mainly in the context of stable processes, we here extend its range of applicability to random-parameter and diffusing-diffusivity models which are important in contemporary physics…
▽ More
We show that the codifference is a useful tool in studying the ergodicity breaking and non-Gaussianity properties of stochastic time series. While the codifference is a measure of dependence that was previously studied mainly in the context of stable processes, we here extend its range of applicability to random-parameter and diffusing-diffusivity models which are important in contemporary physics, biology and financial engineering. We prove that the codifference detects forms of dependence and ergodicity breaking which are not visible from analysing the covariance and correlation functions. We also discuss a related measure of dispersion, which is a non-linear analogue of the mean squared displacement.
△ Less
Submitted 28 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Fractional Brownian motion in a finite interval: correlations effect depletion or accretion zones of particles near boundaries
Authors:
T. Guggenberger,
G. Pagnini,
T. Vojta,
R. Metzler
Abstract:
Fractional Brownian motion is a Gaussian stochastic process with stationary, long-time correlated increments and is frequently used to model anomalous diffusion processes. We study numerically fractional Brownian motion confined to a finite interval with reflecting boundary conditions. The probability density function of this reflected fractional Brownian motion at long times converges to a statio…
▽ More
Fractional Brownian motion is a Gaussian stochastic process with stationary, long-time correlated increments and is frequently used to model anomalous diffusion processes. We study numerically fractional Brownian motion confined to a finite interval with reflecting boundary conditions. The probability density function of this reflected fractional Brownian motion at long times converges to a stationary distribution showing distinct deviations from the fully flat distribution of amplitude $1/L$ in an interval of length $L$ found for reflected normal Brownian motion. While for superdiffusion, corresponding to a mean squared displacement $\langle X^2(t)\rangle\simeq t^α$ with $1<α<2$, the probability density function is lowered in the centre of the interval and rises towards the boundaries, for subdiffusion ($0<α<1$) this behaviour is reversed and the particle density is depleted close to the boundaries. The mean squared displacement in these cases at long times converges to a stationary value, which is, remarkably, monotonically increasing with the anomalous diffusion exponent $α$. Our a priori surprising results may have interesting consequences for the application of fractional Brownian motion for processes such as molecule or tracer diffusion in the confined of living biological cells or organelles, or other viscoelastic environments such as dense liquids in microfluidic chambers.
△ Less
Submitted 21 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Single-trajectory spectral analysis of scaled Brownian motion
Authors:
Vittoria Sposini,
Ralf Metzler,
Gleb Oshanin
Abstract:
A standard approach to study time-dependent stochastic processes is the power spectral density (PSD), an ensemble-averaged property defined as the Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function of the process in the asymptotic limit of long observation times, $T\to\infty$. In many experimental situations one is able to garner only relatively few stochastic time series of finite $T$, such that p…
▽ More
A standard approach to study time-dependent stochastic processes is the power spectral density (PSD), an ensemble-averaged property defined as the Fourier transform of the autocorrelation function of the process in the asymptotic limit of long observation times, $T\to\infty$. In many experimental situations one is able to garner only relatively few stochastic time series of finite $T$, such that practically neither an ensemble average nor the asymptotic limit $T\to\infty$ can be achieved. To accommodate for a meaningful analysis of such finite-length data we here develop the framework of single-trajectory spectral analysis for one of the standard models of anomalous diffusion, scaled Brownian motion. We demonstrate that the frequency dependence of the single-trajectory PSD is exactly the same as for standard Brownian motion, which may lead one to the erroneous conclusion that the observed motion is normal-diffusive. However, a distinctive feature is shown to be provided by the explicit dependence on the measurement time $T$, and this ageing phenomenon can be used to deduce the anomalous diffusion exponent. We also compare our results to the single-trajectory PSD behaviour of another standard anomalous diffusion process, fractional Brownian motion, and work out the commonalities and differences. Our results represent an important step in establishing single-trajectory PSDs as an alternative (or complement) to analyses based on the time-averaged mean squared displacement.
△ Less
Submitted 15 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Spectral content of a single non-Brownian trajectory
Authors:
D. Krapf,
N. Lukat,
E. Marinari,
R. Metzler,
G. Oshanin,
C. Selhuber-Unkel,
A. Squarcini,
L. Stadler,
M. Weiss,
X. Xu
Abstract:
Time-dependent processes are often analysed using the power spectral density (PSD), calculated by taking an appropriate Fourier transform of individual trajectories and finding the associated ensemble-average. Frequently, the available experimental data sets are too small for such ensemble averages, and hence it is of a great conceptual and practical importance to understand to which extent releva…
▽ More
Time-dependent processes are often analysed using the power spectral density (PSD), calculated by taking an appropriate Fourier transform of individual trajectories and finding the associated ensemble-average. Frequently, the available experimental data sets are too small for such ensemble averages, and hence it is of a great conceptual and practical importance to understand to which extent relevant information can be gained from $S(f,T)$, the PSD of a single trajectory. Here we focus on the behavior of this random, realization-dependent variable, parametrized by frequency $f$ and observation-time $T$, for a broad family of anomalous diffusions---fractional Brownian motion (fBm) with Hurst-index $H$---and derive exactly its probability density function. We show that $S(f,T)$ is proportional---up to a random numerical factor whose universal distribution we determine---to the ensemble-averaged PSD. For subdiffusion ($H<1/2$) we find that $S(f,T)\sim A/f^{2H+1}$ with random-amplitude $A$. In sharp contrast, for superdiffusion $(H>1/2)$ $S(f,T)\sim BT^{2H-1}/f^2$ with random amplitude $B$. Remarkably, for $H>1/2$ the PSD exhibits the same frequency-dependence as Brownian motion, a deceptive property that may lead to false conclusions when interpreting experimental data. Notably, for $H>1/2$ the PSD is ageing and is dependent on $T$. Our predictions for both sub- and superdiffusion are confirmed by experiments in live cells and in agarose hydrogels, and by extensive simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 1 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.