-
Validation strategy of reduced-order two-fluid flow models based on a hierarchy of direct numerical simulations
Authors:
Pierre Cordesse,
Alberto Remigi,
Benjamin Duret,
Angelo Murrone,
Thibaut Ménard,
François-Xavier Demoulin,
Marc Massot
Abstract:
Whereas direct numerical simulation (DNS) have reached a high level of description in the field of atomization processes, they are not yet able to cope with industrial needs since they lack resolution and are too costly. Predictive simulations relying on reduced order modeling have become mandatory for applications ranging from cryotechnic to aeronautic combustion chamber liquid injection. Two-fl…
▽ More
Whereas direct numerical simulation (DNS) have reached a high level of description in the field of atomization processes, they are not yet able to cope with industrial needs since they lack resolution and are too costly. Predictive simulations relying on reduced order modeling have become mandatory for applications ranging from cryotechnic to aeronautic combustion chamber liquid injection. Two-fluid models provide a good basis in order to conduct such simulations, even if recent advances allow to refine subscale modeling using geometrical variables in order to reach a unified model including separate phases and disperse phase descriptions based on high order moment methods. The simulation of such models has to rely on dedicated numerical methods and still lacks assessment of its predictive capabilities. The present paper constitutes a building block of the investigation of a hierarchy of test-cases designed to be amenable to DNS while close enough to industrial configurations, for which we propose a comparison of two-fluid compressible simulations with DNS data-bases. We focus in the present contribution on an air-assisted water atomization using a planar liquid sheet injector. Qualitative and quantitative comparisons with incompressible DNS allow us to identify and analyze strength and weaknesses of the reduced-order modeling and numerical approach in this specific configuration and set a framework for more refined models since they already provide a very interesting level of comparison on averaged quantities.
△ Less
Submitted 14 May, 2020; v1 submitted 6 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Initiation of a validation strategy of reduced-order two-fluid flow models using direct numerical simulations in the context of jet atomization
Authors:
Pierre Cordesse,
A. Murrone,
T. Ménard,
Marc Massot
Abstract:
In industrial applications, develo** predictive tools relying on numerical simulations using reduced-order models nourish the need of building a validation strategy. In the context of cryogenic atomization, we propose to build a hierarchy of direct numerical simulation test cases to assess qualitatively and quantitatively diffuse interface models. The present work proposes an initiation of the v…
▽ More
In industrial applications, develo** predictive tools relying on numerical simulations using reduced-order models nourish the need of building a validation strategy. In the context of cryogenic atomization, we propose to build a hierarchy of direct numerical simulation test cases to assess qualitatively and quantitatively diffuse interface models. The present work proposes an initiation of the validation strategy with an air-assisted water atomization using a coaxial injector.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
A phase inversion benchmark for multiscale multiphase flows
Authors:
J. -L. Estivalezes,
W. Aniszewski,
F. Auguste,
Y. Ling,
L. Osmar,
J. -P. Caltagirone,
L. Chirco,
A. Pedrono,
S. Popinet,
A. Berlemont,
J. Magnaudet,
T. Menard,
S. Vincent,
S. Zaleski
Abstract:
A series of benchmarks based on the physical situation of "phase inversion" between two immiscible liquids is presented. These benchmarks aim at progressing toward the direct numerical simulation of two-phase flows. Several CFD codes developed in French laboratories and using either Volume-of-Fluid or Level-Set interface tracking methods are used to provide physical solutions of the benchmarks, co…
▽ More
A series of benchmarks based on the physical situation of "phase inversion" between two immiscible liquids is presented. These benchmarks aim at progressing toward the direct numerical simulation of two-phase flows. Several CFD codes developed in French laboratories and using either Volume-of-Fluid or Level-Set interface tracking methods are used to provide physical solutions of the benchmarks, convergence studies and code comparisons. Two typical configurations are retained, with integral scale Reynolds numbers of 13.700 and 433.000, respectively. The physics of the problem are probed through macroscopic quantities such as potential and kinetic energies, or enstrophy. In addition, scaling laws for the temporal decay of the kinetic energy are derived to check the physical relevance of the simulations. Finally the droplet size distribution is probed. Additional test problems are also reported to estimate the influence of viscous effects in the vicinity of the interface.
△ Less
Submitted 17 October, 2021; v1 submitted 6 June, 2019;
originally announced June 2019.
-
Statistical modeling of the gas-liquid interface using geometrical variables: toward a unified description of the disperse and separated phase flows
Authors:
Mohamed Essadki,
Florence Drui,
Stéphane de Chaisemartin,
Adam Larat,
Thibault Ménard,
Marc Massot
Abstract:
In this work, we investigate an original strategy in order to derive a statistical modeling of the interface in gas-liquid two-phase flows through geometrical variables. The con- tribution is two-fold. First it participates in the theoretical design of a unified reduced- order model for the description of two regimes: a disperse phase in a carrier fluid and two separated phases. The first idea is…
▽ More
In this work, we investigate an original strategy in order to derive a statistical modeling of the interface in gas-liquid two-phase flows through geometrical variables. The con- tribution is two-fold. First it participates in the theoretical design of a unified reduced- order model for the description of two regimes: a disperse phase in a carrier fluid and two separated phases. The first idea is to propose a statistical description of the in- terface relying on geometrical properties such as the mean and Gauss curvatures and define a Surface Density Function (SDF). The second main idea consists in using such a formalism in the disperse case, where a clear link is proposed between local statistics of the interface and the statistics on objects, such as the number density function in Williams-Boltzmann equation for droplets. This makes essential the use of topolog- ical invariants in geometry through the Gauss-Bonnet formula and allows to include the works conducted on sprays of spherical droplets. It yields a statistical treatment of populations of non-spherical objects such as ligaments, as long as they are home- omorphic to a sphere. Second, it provides an original angle and algorithm in order to build statistics from DNS data of interfacial flows. From the theoretical approach, we identify a kernel for the spatial averaging of geometrical quantities preserving the topological invariants. Coupled to a new algorithm for the evaluation of curvatures and surface that preserves these invariants, we analyze two sets of DNS results conducted with the ARCHER code from CORIA with and without topological changes and assess the approach.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2017; v1 submitted 12 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Quantitative comparison of fuel spray images obtained using ultrafast coherent and incoherent double-pulsed illumination
Authors:
Harsh Purwar,
Kamel Lounnaci,
Saïd Idlahcen,
Claude Rozé,
Jean-Bernard Blaisot,
Thibault Ménard
Abstract:
We present a quantitative comparison between the high-pressure fuel spray images obtained experimentally using classical imaging with coherent and incoherent ultrafast illuminations recorded using a compatible CMOS camera. The ultrafast, incoherent illumination source was extracted from the supercontinuum generated by tightly focusing the femtosecond laser pulses in water. The average velocity map…
▽ More
We present a quantitative comparison between the high-pressure fuel spray images obtained experimentally using classical imaging with coherent and incoherent ultrafast illuminations recorded using a compatible CMOS camera. The ultrafast, incoherent illumination source was extracted from the supercontinuum generated by tightly focusing the femtosecond laser pulses in water. The average velocity maps computed using time-correlated image-pairs and spray edge complexity computed using the average curvature scale space maps are compared for the spray images obtained with the two illumination techniques and also for the numerically simulated spray using the coupled volume of fluid and level set method for interface tracking (direct numerical simulation or DNS). The spray images obtained with supercontinuum-derived, incoherent, ultrafast illumination are clearer, since the artifacts arising due to laser speckles and multiple diffraction effects are largely reduced and show a better correlation with the DNS results.
△ Less
Submitted 11 February, 2015;
originally announced February 2015.
-
Volume of Fluid (VOF) type advection methods in two-phase flow: a comparative study
Authors:
Wojciech Aniszewski,
Thibaut Ménard,
Maciej Marek
Abstract:
In this paper, four distinct approaches to Volume of Fluid (VOF) computational method are compared. Two of the methods are the 'simplified' VOF formulations, in that they do not require geometrical interface reconstruction. The assessment is made possible by implementing all four approaches into the same code as a switchable options. This allows to rule out possible influence of other parts of num…
▽ More
In this paper, four distinct approaches to Volume of Fluid (VOF) computational method are compared. Two of the methods are the 'simplified' VOF formulations, in that they do not require geometrical interface reconstruction. The assessment is made possible by implementing all four approaches into the same code as a switchable options. This allows to rule out possible influence of other parts of numerical scheme, be it the discretisation of Navier-Stokes equations or chosen approximation of curvature, so that we are left with conclusive arguments because only one factor differs the compared methods. The comparison is done in the framework of CLSVOF (Coupled Level Set Volume of Fluid), so that all four methods are coupled with Level Set interface, which is used to compute pressure jump via the GFM (Ghost-Fluid Method). Results presented include static advections, full N-S solutions in laminar and turbulent flows. The paper is aimed at research groups who are implementing VOF methods in their computations or intend to do it, and might consider a simplified approach as a preliminary measure, since the methods presented differ greatly in complication level, or ease of implementation expressed e.g. in number of code lines.
△ Less
Submitted 20 May, 2014;
originally announced May 2014.
