-
The minimal seed for transition to convective turbulence in heated pipe flow
Authors:
Shijun Chu,
Ashley P. Willis,
Elena Marensi
Abstract:
It is well known that buoyancy suppresses, and can even laminarise turbulence in upward heated pipe flow. Heat transfer seriously deteriorates in this case. Through a new DNS model, we confirm that the deteriorated heat transfer within convective turbulence is related to a lack of near-wall rolls, which leads to a weak mixing between the flow near the wall and centre of pipe. Having surveyed the f…
▽ More
It is well known that buoyancy suppresses, and can even laminarise turbulence in upward heated pipe flow. Heat transfer seriously deteriorates in this case. Through a new DNS model, we confirm that the deteriorated heat transfer within convective turbulence is related to a lack of near-wall rolls, which leads to a weak mixing between the flow near the wall and centre of pipe. Having surveyed the fundamental properties of the system, we perform a nonlinear nonmodal stability analysis. it is found that, the minimal seed becomes thinner and closer to the wall, with increase of buoyancy number C. Most importantly, we show that the critical initial energy required to trigger shear-driven turbulence keeps increasing, implying that attempts to artificially trigger it may not be an efficient means to improve heat transfer at larger C. The new minimal seed, found at C=6, is localised in streamwise direction and is active in the centre of pipe. To find this branch of optimal, we took advantage of a window of linear stability. While the nonlinear optimal causes transition to convective turbulence directly at this and larger C, transition via the linear instability passes via a travelling wave or periodic orbit solutions. Detailed analysis of the periodic solution reveals three stages: growth of the unstable eigenfunction, the formation of streaks, and the decay of streaks due to suppression of the instability. Flow visualization at C up to 10 also show similar features, suggesting that convective turbulence is sustained by these three typical processes.
△ Less
Submitted 13 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Discontinuous transition to shear flow turbulence
Authors:
Yi Zhuang,
Bowen Yang,
Vasudevan Mukund,
Elena Marensi,
Björn Hof
Abstract:
Depending on the type of flow the transition to turbulence can take one of two forms, either turbulence arises from a sequence of instabilities, or from the spatial proliferation of transiently chaotic domains, a process analogous to directed percolation. Both scenarios are inherently continuous and hence the transformation from ordered laminar to fully turbulent fluid motion is only accomplished…
▽ More
Depending on the type of flow the transition to turbulence can take one of two forms, either turbulence arises from a sequence of instabilities, or from the spatial proliferation of transiently chaotic domains, a process analogous to directed percolation. Both scenarios are inherently continuous and hence the transformation from ordered laminar to fully turbulent fluid motion is only accomplished gradually with flow speed. Here we show that these established transition types do not account for the more general setting of shear flows subject to body forces. By attenuating spatial coupling and energy transfer, spatio-temporal intermittency is suppressed and with forcing amplitude the transition becomes increasingly sharp and eventually discontinuous. We argue that the suppression of the continuous range and the approach towards a first order, discontinuous scenario applies to a wide range of situations where in addition to shear, flows are subject to e.g. gravitational, centrifugal or electromagnetic forces.
△ Less
Submitted 19 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Dynamics and proliferation of turbulent stripes in plane-Poiseuille and plane-Couette flows
Authors:
Elena Marensi,
Gökhan Yalnız,
Björn Hof
Abstract:
The first long-lived turbulent structures observable in planar shear flows take the form of localized stripes, inclined with respect to the mean flow direction. The dynamics of these stripes are central to transition, and recent studies proposed an analogy to directed percolation where the stripes' proliferation is ultimately responsible for turbulence to become sustained. In the present study we…
▽ More
The first long-lived turbulent structures observable in planar shear flows take the form of localized stripes, inclined with respect to the mean flow direction. The dynamics of these stripes are central to transition, and recent studies proposed an analogy to directed percolation where the stripes' proliferation is ultimately responsible for turbulence to become sustained. In the present study we focus on the internal stripe dynamics as well as on the eventual stripe expansion, and we compare the underlying mechanisms in pressure and shear driven planar flows, respectively plane-Poiseuille and plane-Couette flow. Despite the similarities of the overall laminar-turbulence patterns, the stripe proliferation processes in the two cases are fundamentally different. Starting from the growth and sustenance of individual stripes, we find that in plane-Couette flow new streaks are created stochastically throughout the stripe whereas in plane-Poiseuille flow streak creation is deterministic and occurs locally at the downstream tip. Because of the up/downstream symmetry, Couette stripes, in contrast to Poiseuille stripes, have two weak and two strong laminar turbulent interfaces. These differences in symmetry as well as in internal growth give rise to two fundamentally different stripe splitting mechanisms. In plane-Poiseuille flow splitting is connected to the elongational growth of the original stripe, and it results from a break-off / shedding of the stripe's tail. In plane-Couette flow splitting follows from a broadening of the original stripe and a division along the stripe into two slimmer stripes.
△ Less
Submitted 6 November, 2023; v1 submitted 23 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Symmetry-reduced Dynamic Mode Decomposition of Near-wall Turbulence
Authors:
Elena Marensi,
Gökhan Yalnız,
Björn Hof,
Nazmi Burak Budanur
Abstract:
Data-driven dimensionality reduction methods such as proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) have proven to be useful for exploring complex phenomena within fluid dynamics and beyond. A well-known challenge for these techniques is posed by the continuous symmetries, e.g. translations and rotations, of the system under consideration as drifts in the data dominate…
▽ More
Data-driven dimensionality reduction methods such as proper orthogonal decomposition (POD) and dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) have proven to be useful for exploring complex phenomena within fluid dynamics and beyond. A well-known challenge for these techniques is posed by the continuous symmetries, e.g. translations and rotations, of the system under consideration as drifts in the data dominate the modal expansions without providing an insight into the dynamics of the problem. In the present study, we address this issue for fluid flows in rectangular channels by formulating a continuous symmetry reduction method that eliminates the translations in the streamwise and spanwise directions simultaneously. We demonstrate our method by computing the symmetry-reduced dynamic mode decomposition (SRDMD) of sliding windows of data obtained from the transitional plane-Couette and turbulent plane-Poiseuille flow simulations. In the former setting, SRDMD captures the dynamics in the vicinity of the invariant solutions with translation symmetries, i.e. travelling waves and relative periodic orbits, whereas in the latter, our calculations reveal episodes of turbulent time evolution that can be approximated by a low-dimensional linear expansion.
△ Less
Submitted 28 November, 2022; v1 submitted 19 January, 2021;
originally announced January 2021.
-
Suppression of turbulence and travelling waves in a vertical heated pipe
Authors:
Elena Marensi,
Shuisheng He,
Ashley P. Willis
Abstract:
Turbulence in the flow of fluid through a pipe can be suppressed by buoyancy forces. As the suppression of turbulence leads to severe heat transfer deterioration, this is an important and undesirable phenomenon in both heating and cooling applications. Vertical flow is often considered, as the axial buoyancy force can help drive the flow. With heating measured by the buoyancy parameter $C$, our DN…
▽ More
Turbulence in the flow of fluid through a pipe can be suppressed by buoyancy forces. As the suppression of turbulence leads to severe heat transfer deterioration, this is an important and undesirable phenomenon in both heating and cooling applications. Vertical flow is often considered, as the axial buoyancy force can help drive the flow. With heating measured by the buoyancy parameter $C$, our DNS show that shear-driven turbulence may either be completely laminarised or transitions to a relatively quiescent convection-driven state. Buoyancy forces cause a flattening of the base flow profile, which in isothermal pipe flow has recently been linked to complete suppression of turbulence (Kühnen et al. Nat. Phys., 2018), and the flattened laminar base profile has enhanced nonlinear stability (Marensi et al. JFM, 2019). In agreement with these findings, the nonlinear lower-branch travelling-wave solution analysed here, which is believed to mediate transition to turbulence in isothermal pipe flow, is shown to be suppressed by buoyancy. A linear instability of the laminar base flow is responsible for the appearance of the relatively quiescent convection driven state for $C\gtrsim 4$ across the range of Reynolds numbers considered. In the suppression of turbulence, however, i.e. in the transition from turbulence, we find clearer association with the analysis of He et al. (JFM, 2016) than with the above dynamical systems approach, which describes better the transition to turbulence. The laminarisation criterion He et al. propose, based on an apparent Reynolds number of the flow as measured by its driving pressure gradient, is found to capture the critical $C=C_{cr}(Re)$ above which the flow will be laminarised or switch to the convection-driven type. Our analysis suggests that it is the weakened rolls, rather than the streaks, which appear to be critical for laminarisation.
△ Less
Submitted 8 June, 2021; v1 submitted 31 August, 2020;
originally announced August 2020.
-
Designing a minimal baffle to destabilise turbulence in pipe flows
Authors:
Elena Marensi,
Zi**g Ding,
Ashley P. Willis,
Rich R. Kerswell
Abstract:
Motivated by the results of recent experiments (Kühnen et al., Flow Turb. Combust., vol. 100, 2018, pp. 919-943), we consider the problem of designing a baffle (an obstacle to the flow) to relaminarise turbulence in pipe flows. Modelling the baffle as a spatial distribution of linear drag $\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{x},t)=-χ(\mathbf{x})\mathbf{u}_{tot}(\mathbf{x},t)$ within the flow ($\mathbf{u}_{tot}$ is…
▽ More
Motivated by the results of recent experiments (Kühnen et al., Flow Turb. Combust., vol. 100, 2018, pp. 919-943), we consider the problem of designing a baffle (an obstacle to the flow) to relaminarise turbulence in pipe flows. Modelling the baffle as a spatial distribution of linear drag $\mathbf{f}(\mathbf{x},t)=-χ(\mathbf{x})\mathbf{u}_{tot}(\mathbf{x},t)$ within the flow ($\mathbf{u}_{tot}$ is the total velocity field and $χ\ge 0$ a scalar field), two different optimisation problems are considered to design $χ$ at a Reynolds number $Re=3000$. In the first, the smallest baffle defined in terms of a $L_1 $ norm of $χ$ is sought which minimises the viscous dissipation rate of the flow. In the second, a baffle which minimises the total energy consumption of the flow is treated. Both problems indicate that the baffle should be axisymmetric and radially localised near the pipe wall, but struggle to predict the optimal streamwise extent. A manual search finds an optimal baffle one radius long which is then used to study how the amplitude for relaminarisation varies with $Re$ up to $15\,000$. Large stress reduction is found at the pipe wall, but at the expense of an increased pressure drop across the baffle. Estimates are then made of the break even point downstream of the baffle where the stress reduction at the wall due to the relaminarised flow compensates for the extra drag produced by the baffle.
△ Less
Submitted 21 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
Upper edge of chaos and the energetics of transition in pipe flow
Authors:
Nazmi Burak Budanur,
Elena Marensi,
Ashley P. Willis,
Björn Hof
Abstract:
In the past two decades, our understanding of the transition to turbulence in shear flows with linearly stable laminar solutions has greatly improved. Regarding the susceptibility of the laminar flow, two concepts have been particularly useful: the edge states and the minimal seeds. In this nonlinear picture of the transition, the basin boundary of turbulence is set by the edge state's stable mani…
▽ More
In the past two decades, our understanding of the transition to turbulence in shear flows with linearly stable laminar solutions has greatly improved. Regarding the susceptibility of the laminar flow, two concepts have been particularly useful: the edge states and the minimal seeds. In this nonlinear picture of the transition, the basin boundary of turbulence is set by the edge state's stable manifold and this manifold comes closest in energy to the laminar equilibrium at the minimal seed. We begin this paper by presenting numerical experiments in which three-dimensional perturbations are too energetic to trigger turbulence in pipe flow but they do lead to turbulence when their amplitude is reduced. We show that this seemingly counter-intuitive observation is in fact consistent with the fully nonlinear description of the transition mediated by the edge state. In order to understand the physical mechanisms behind this process, we measure the turbulent kinetic energy production and dissipation rates as a function of the radial coordinate. Our main observation is that the transition to turbulence relies on the energy amplification away from the wall, as opposed to the turbulence itself, whose energy is predominantly produced near the wall. This observation is further supported by the similar analyses on the minimal seeds and the edge states. Furthermore, we show that the time-evolution of production-over-dissipation curves provide a clear distinction between the different initial amplification stages of the transition to turbulence from the minimal seed.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Stabilisation and drag reduction of pipe flows by flattening the base profile
Authors:
E. Marensi,
A. P. Willis,
R. R. Kerswell
Abstract:
Recent experimental observations (Kuehnen et al., 2018) have shown that flattening a turbulent streamwise velocity profile in pipe flow destabilises the turbulence so that the flow relaminarises. We show that a similar phenomenon exists for laminar pipe flow profiles in the sense that the nonlinear stability of the laminar state is enhanced as the profile becomes more flattened. Significant drag r…
▽ More
Recent experimental observations (Kuehnen et al., 2018) have shown that flattening a turbulent streamwise velocity profile in pipe flow destabilises the turbulence so that the flow relaminarises. We show that a similar phenomenon exists for laminar pipe flow profiles in the sense that the nonlinear stability of the laminar state is enhanced as the profile becomes more flattened. Significant drag reduction is also observed for the turbulent flow when triggered by sufficiently large disturbances. The flattening is produced by an artificial body force designed to mimick a baffle used in the experiments of Kuehnen et al. (2018) and the nonlinear stability measured by the size of the energy of the initial perturbations needed to trigger transition. In order to make the latter computation more efficient, we examine how indicative the minimal seed for transition is in measuring transition thresholds. We first show that the minimal seed is relatively robust to base profile changes and spectral filtering. We then compare the (unforced) transition behaviour of the minimal seed with several forms of randomised initial conditions in the range of Reynolds numbers Re=2400 to 10000 and find that the energy of the minimal seed after the Orr and oblique phases of its evolution is close to that of a localised random disturbance. In this sense, the minimal seed at the end of the oblique phase can be regarded as a good proxy for typical disturbances (here taken to be the localised random ones) and is thus used as initial condition in the simulations with the body force. The enhanced nonlinear stability and drag reduction predicted in the present study are an encouraging first step in modelling the experiments of Kuehnen et al. and should motivate future developments to fully exploit the benefits of this promising direction for flow control.
△ Less
Submitted 14 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.