-
The Problem of Marginality in Model Reductions of Turbulence
Authors:
C. Gillot,
G. Dif-Pradalier,
Y. Sarazin,
C. Bourdelle,
Y. Camenen,
J. Citrin,
X. Garbet,
Ph. Ghendrih,
V. Grandgirard,
P. Manas,
F. Widmer
Abstract:
Reduced quasilinear (QL) and nonlinear (gradient-driven) models with scale separations, commonly used to interpret experiments and to forecast turbulent transport levels in magnetised plasmas are tested against nonlinear models without scale separations (flux-driven). Two distinct regimes of turbulence -- either far above threshold or near marginal stability -- are investigated with Boltzmann elec…
▽ More
Reduced quasilinear (QL) and nonlinear (gradient-driven) models with scale separations, commonly used to interpret experiments and to forecast turbulent transport levels in magnetised plasmas are tested against nonlinear models without scale separations (flux-driven). Two distinct regimes of turbulence -- either far above threshold or near marginal stability -- are investigated with Boltzmann electrons. The success of reduced models especially hinges on the reproduction of nonlinear fluxes. Good agreement between models is found above threshold whilst reduced models would significantly underpredict fluxes near marginality, overlooking mesoscale flow organisation and turbulence self-advection. Constructive prescriptions whereby to improve reduced models is discussed.
△ Less
Submitted 8 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Application of Gaussian process regression to plasma turbulent transport model validation via integrated modelling
Authors:
Aaron Ho,
Jonathan Citrin,
Fulvio Auriemma,
Clarisse Bourdelle,
Francis J. Casson,
Hyun-Tae Kim,
Pierre Manas,
Gabor Szepesi,
Henri Weisen,
JET Contributors
Abstract:
This paper outlines an approach towards improved rigour in tokamak turbulence transport model validation within integrated modelling. Gaussian process regression (GPR) techniques were applied for profile fitting during the preparation of integrated modelling simulations allowing for rigourous sensitivity tests of prescribed initial and boundary conditions as both fit and derivative uncertainties a…
▽ More
This paper outlines an approach towards improved rigour in tokamak turbulence transport model validation within integrated modelling. Gaussian process regression (GPR) techniques were applied for profile fitting during the preparation of integrated modelling simulations allowing for rigourous sensitivity tests of prescribed initial and boundary conditions as both fit and derivative uncertainties are provided. This was demonstrated by a JETTO integrated modelling simulation of the JET ITER-like-wall H-mode baseline discharge #92436 with the QuaLiKiz quasilinear turbulent transport model, which is the subject of extrapolation towards a deuterium-tritium plasma. The simulation simultaneously evaluates the time evolution of heat, particle, and momentum fluxes over $\sim10$ confinement times, with a simulation boundary condition at $ρ_{tor} = 0.85$. Routine inclusion of momentum transport prediction in multi-channel flux-driven transport modelling is not standard and is facilitated here by recent developments within the QuaLiKiz model. Excellent agreement was achieved between the fitted and simulated profiles for $n_e$, $T_e$, $T_i$, and $Ω_{tor}$ within $2σ$, but the simulation underpredicts the mid-radius $T_i$ and overpredicts the core $n_e$ and $T_e$ profiles for this discharge. Despite this, it was shown that this approach is capable of deriving reasonable inputs, including derivative quantities, to tokamak models from experimental data. Furthermore, multiple figures-of-merit were defined to quantitatively assess the agreement of integrated modelling predictions to experimental data within the GPR profile fitting framework.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Validation of gyrokinetic modelling of light impurity transport including rotation in ASDEX Upgrade
Authors:
F. J. Casson,
R. M. McDermott,
C. Angioni,
Y. Camenen,
R. Dux,
E. Fable,
R. Fischer,
B. Geiger,
P. Manas,
L. Menchero,
G. Tardini,
ASDEX Upgrade team
Abstract:
Upgraded spectroscopic hardware and an improved impurity concentration calculation allow accurate determination of boron density in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. A database of boron measurements is compared to quasilinear and nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations including Coriolis and centrifugal rotational effects over a range of H-mode plasma regimes. The peaking of the measured boron profiles shows a…
▽ More
Upgraded spectroscopic hardware and an improved impurity concentration calculation allow accurate determination of boron density in the ASDEX Upgrade tokamak. A database of boron measurements is compared to quasilinear and nonlinear gyrokinetic simulations including Coriolis and centrifugal rotational effects over a range of H-mode plasma regimes. The peaking of the measured boron profiles shows a strong anti-correlation with the plasma rotation gradient, via a relationship explained and reproduced by the theory. It is demonstrated that the rotodiffusive impurity flux driven by the rotation gradient is required for the modelling to reproduce the hollow boron profiles at higher rotation gradients. The nonlinear simulations validate the quasilinear approach, and, with the addition of perpendicular flow shear, demonstrate that each symmetry breaking mechanism that causes momentum transport also couples to rotodiffusion. At lower rotation gradients, the parallel compressive convection is required to match the most peaked boron profiles. The sensitivities of both datasets to possible errors is investigated, and quantitative agreement is found within the estimated uncertainties. The approach used can be considered a template for mitigating uncertainty in quantitative comparisons between simulation and experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 19 April, 2013; v1 submitted 30 November, 2012;
originally announced November 2012.
