-
Reduction of detection limit and quantification uncertainty due to interferent by neural classification with abstention
Authors:
Alex Hagen,
Ken Jarman,
Jesse Ward,
Greg Eiden,
Charles Barinaga,
Emily Mace,
Craig Aalseth,
Anthony Carado
Abstract:
Many measurements in the physical sciences can be cast as counting experiments, where the number of occurrences of a physical phenomenon informs the prevalence of the phenomenon's source. Often, detection of the physical phenomenon (termed signal) is difficult to distinguish from naturally occurring phenomena (termed background). In this case, the discrimination of signal events from background ca…
▽ More
Many measurements in the physical sciences can be cast as counting experiments, where the number of occurrences of a physical phenomenon informs the prevalence of the phenomenon's source. Often, detection of the physical phenomenon (termed signal) is difficult to distinguish from naturally occurring phenomena (termed background). In this case, the discrimination of signal events from background can be performed using classifiers, and they may range from simple, threshold-based classifiers to sophisticated neural networks. These classifiers are often trained and validated to obtain optimal accuracy, however we show that the optimal accuracy classifier does not generally coincide with a classifier that provides the lowest detection limit, nor the lowest quantification uncertainty. We present a derivation of the detection limit and quantification uncertainty in the classifier-based counting experiment case. We also present a novel abstention mechanism to minimize the detection limit or quantification uncertainty \emph{a posteriori}. We illustrate the method on two data sets from the physical sciences, discriminating Ar-37 and Ar-39 radioactive decay from non-radioactive events in a gas proportional counter, and discriminating neutrons from photons in an inorganic scintillator and report results therefrom.
△ Less
Submitted 22 April, 2022;
originally announced May 2022.
-
Cosmogenic production of $^{39}$Ar and $^{37}$Ar in argon
Authors:
R. Saldanha,
H. O. Back,
R. H. M. Tsang,
T. Alexander,
S. R. Elliott,
S. Ferrara,
E. Mace,
C. Overman,
M. Zalavadia
Abstract:
We have experimentally determined the production rate of $^{39}$Ar and $^{37}$Ar from cosmic ray neutron interactions in argon at sea level. Understanding these production rates is important for argon-based dark matter experiments that plan to utilize argon extracted from deep underground because it is imperative to know what the ingrowth of $^{39}$Ar will be during the production, transport, and…
▽ More
We have experimentally determined the production rate of $^{39}$Ar and $^{37}$Ar from cosmic ray neutron interactions in argon at sea level. Understanding these production rates is important for argon-based dark matter experiments that plan to utilize argon extracted from deep underground because it is imperative to know what the ingrowth of $^{39}$Ar will be during the production, transport, and storage of the underground argon. These measurements also allow for the prediction of $^{39}$Ar and $^{37}$Ar concentrations in the atmosphere which can be used to determine the presence of other sources of these isotopes. Through controlled irradiation with a neutron beam that mimics the cosmic ray neutron spectrum, followed by direct counting of $^{39}$Ar and $^{37}$Ar decays with sensitive ultra-low background proportional counters, we determined that the production rate from cosmic ray neutrons at sea-level is expected to be $(759 \pm 128)$ atoms/kg$_\text{Ar}$/day for $^{39}$Ar, and $(51.0 \pm 7.4)$ atoms/kg$_\text{Ar}$/day for $^{37}$Ar. We also performed a survey of the alternate production mechanisms based on the state-of-knowledge of the associated cross-sections to obtain a total sea-level cosmic ray production rate of $(1048 \pm 133)$ atoms/kg$_\text{Ar}$/day for $^{39}$Ar, $(56.7 \pm 7.5)$ atoms/kg$_\text{Ar}$/day for $^{37}$Ar in underground argon, and $(92 \pm 13)$ atoms/kg$_\text{Ar}$/day for $^{37}$Ar in atmospheric argon.
△ Less
Submitted 26 August, 2019; v1 submitted 24 February, 2019;
originally announced February 2019.
-
The Low-Radioactivity Underground Argon Workshop: A workshop synopsis
Authors:
Thomas Alexander,
Henning O. Back,
Walter Bonivento,
Mark Boulay,
Philippe Collon,
Zhongyi Feng,
Michael Foxe,
Pablo García Abia,
Pietro Giampa,
Christopher Jackson,
Christine Johnson,
Emily Mace,
Peter Mueller,
László Palcsu,
Walter Pettus,
Roland Purtschert,
Andrew Renshaw,
Richard Saldanha,
Kate Scholberg,
Marino Simeone,
Ondřej Šrámek,
Rex Tayloe,
Ward TeGrotenhuis,
Signe White,
Richard Williams
Abstract:
In response to the growing need for low-radioactivity argon, community experts and interested parties came together for a 2-day workshop to discuss the worldwide low-radioactivity argon needs and the challenges associated with its production and characterization. Several topics were covered: experimental needs and requirements for low-radioactivity argon, the sources of low-radioactivity argon and…
▽ More
In response to the growing need for low-radioactivity argon, community experts and interested parties came together for a 2-day workshop to discuss the worldwide low-radioactivity argon needs and the challenges associated with its production and characterization. Several topics were covered: experimental needs and requirements for low-radioactivity argon, the sources of low-radioactivity argon and its production, how long-lived argon radionuclides are created in nature, measuring argon radionuclides, and other applicable topics. The Low-Radioactivity Underground Argon (LRUA) workshop took place on March 19-20, 2018 at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in Richland Washington, USA. This paper is a synopsis of the workshop with the associated abstracts from the talks.
△ Less
Submitted 29 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Development of a low-level Ar-37 calibration standard
Authors:
R. M. Williams,
C. E. Aalseth,
T. W. Bowyer,
A. R. Day,
E. S. Fuller,
D. A. Haas,
J. C. Hayes,
E. W. Hoppe,
P. H. Humble,
M. E. Keillor,
B. D. LaFerriere,
E. K. Mace,
J. I. McIntyre,
H. S. Miley,
A. W. Myers,
J. L. Orrell,
C. T. Overman,
M. E. Panisko,
A. Seifert
Abstract:
Argon-37 is an environmental signature of an underground nuclear explosion. Producing and quantifying low-level Ar-37 standards is an important step in the development of sensitive field measurement instruments. This paper describes progress at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in develo** a process to generate and quantify low-level Ar-37 standards, which can be used to calibrate sensitive…
▽ More
Argon-37 is an environmental signature of an underground nuclear explosion. Producing and quantifying low-level Ar-37 standards is an important step in the development of sensitive field measurement instruments. This paper describes progress at Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in develo** a process to generate and quantify low-level Ar-37 standards, which can be used to calibrate sensitive field systems at activities consistent with soil background levels. This paper presents a discussion of the measurement analysis, along with assumptions and uncertainty estimates.
△ Less
Submitted 4 March, 2016;
originally announced March 2016.
-
Shielding concepts for low-background proportional counter arrays in surface laboratories
Authors:
Craig E. Aalseth,
Paul H. Humble,
Emily K. Mace,
John L. Orrell,
Allen Seifert,
Richard M. Williams
Abstract:
Development of ultra low background gas proportional counters has made the contribution from naturally occurring radioactive isotopes -- primarily $α$ and $β$ activity in the uranium and thorium decay chains -- inconsequential to instrumental sensitivity levels when measurements are performed in above ground surface laboratories. Simple lead shielding is enough to mitigate against gamma rays as ga…
▽ More
Development of ultra low background gas proportional counters has made the contribution from naturally occurring radioactive isotopes -- primarily $α$ and $β$ activity in the uranium and thorium decay chains -- inconsequential to instrumental sensitivity levels when measurements are performed in above ground surface laboratories. Simple lead shielding is enough to mitigate against gamma rays as gas proportional counters are already relatively insensitive to naturally occurring gamma radiation. The dominant background in these surface laboratory measurements using ultra low background gas proportional counters is due to cosmic ray generated muons, neutrons, and protons. Studies of measurements with ultra low background gas proportional counters in surface and underground laboratories as well as radiation transport Monte Carlo simulations suggest a preferred conceptual design to achieve the highest possible sensitivity from an array of low background gas proportional counters when operated in a surface laboratory. The basis for a low background gas proportional counter array and the preferred shielding configuration is reported, especially in relation to measurements of radioactive gases having low energy decays such as $^{37}$Ar.
△ Less
Submitted 23 December, 2015;
originally announced December 2015.
