-
Highest Fusion Performance without Harmful Edge Energy Bursts in Tokamak
Authors:
SangKyeun Kim,
Ricardo Shousha,
SeongMoo Yang,
Qiming Hu,
SangHee Hahn,
Azarakhsh Jalalvand,
Jong-Kyu Park,
Nikolas Christopher Logan,
Andrew Oakleigh Nelson,
Yong-Su Na,
Raffi Nazikian,
Robert Wilcox,
Rongjie Hong,
Terry Rhodes,
Carlos Paz-Soldan,
YoungMu Jeon,
MinWoo Kim,
WongHa Ko,
JongHa Lee,
Alexander Battey,
Alessandro Bortolon,
Joseph Snipes,
Egemen Kolemen
Abstract:
The path of tokamak fusion and ITER is maintaining high-performance plasma to produce sufficient fusion power. This effort is hindered by the transient energy burst arising from the instabilities at the boundary of high-confinement plasmas. The application of 3D magnetic perturbations is the method in ITER and possibly in future fusion power plants to suppress this instability and avoid energy bus…
▽ More
The path of tokamak fusion and ITER is maintaining high-performance plasma to produce sufficient fusion power. This effort is hindered by the transient energy burst arising from the instabilities at the boundary of high-confinement plasmas. The application of 3D magnetic perturbations is the method in ITER and possibly in future fusion power plants to suppress this instability and avoid energy busts damaging the device. Unfortunately, the conventional use of the 3D field in tokamaks typically leads to degraded fusion performance and an increased risk of other plasma instabilities, two severe issues for reactor implementation. In this work, we present an innovative 3D field optimization, exploiting machine learning, real-time adaptability, and multi-device capabilities to overcome these limitations. This integrated scheme is successfully deployed on DIII-D and KSTAR tokamaks, consistently achieving reactor-relevant core confinement and the highest fusion performance without triggering damaging instabilities or bursts while demonstrating ITER-relevant automated 3D optimization for the first time. This is enabled both by advances in the physics understanding of self-organized transport in the plasma edge and by advances in machine-learning technology, which is used to optimize the 3D field spectrum for automated management of a volatile and complex system. These findings establish real-time adaptive 3D field optimization as a crucial tool for ITER and future reactors to maximize fusion performance while simultaneously minimizing damage to machine components.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
Quantification of locked mode instability triggered by a change in confinement
Authors:
M. Peterka,
J. Seidl,
T. Markovic,
A. Loarte,
N. C. Logan,
J. -K. Park,
P. Cahyna,
J. Havlicek,
M. Imrisek,
L. Kripner,
R. Panek,
M. Sos,
P. Bilkova,
K. Bogar,
P. Bohm,
A. Casolari,
Y. Gribov,
O. Grover,
P. Hacek,
M. Hron,
K. Kovarik,
M. Tomes,
D. Tskhakaya,
J. Varju,
P. Vondracek
, et al. (2 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
This work presents the first analysis of the disruptive locked mode (LM) triggered by the dynamics of a confinement change. It shows that, under certain conditions, the LM threshold during the transient is significantly lower than expected from steady states. We investigate the sensitivity to a controlled $n = 1$ error field (EF) activated prior to the L-H transition in the COMPASS tokamak, at…
▽ More
This work presents the first analysis of the disruptive locked mode (LM) triggered by the dynamics of a confinement change. It shows that, under certain conditions, the LM threshold during the transient is significantly lower than expected from steady states. We investigate the sensitivity to a controlled $n = 1$ error field (EF) activated prior to the L-H transition in the COMPASS tokamak, at $q_{95} \approx 3$, $β_N \approx 1$, and using EF coils on the high-field side of the vessel. A threshold for EF penetration subsequent to the L-H transition is identified, which shows no significant trend with density or applied torque, and is an apparent consequence of the reduced intrinsic rotation of the 2/1 mode during this transient phase. This finding challenges the assumption made in theoretical and empirical works that natural mode rotation can be predicted by global plasma parameters and urges against using any parametric EF penetration scaling derived from steady-state experiments to define the error field correction strategy in the entire discharge. Furthermore, even at EFs below the identified penetration threshold, disruptive locking of sawtooth-seeded 2/1 tearing modes is observed after about 30% of L-H transitions without external torque.
△ Less
Submitted 17 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Operational Space and Plasma Performance with an RMP-ELM Suppressed Edge
Authors:
C. Paz-Soldan,
S. Gu,
N. Leuthold,
P. Lunia,
P. Xie,
M. W. Kim,
S. K. Kim,
N. C. Logan,
J. -K. Park,
W. Suttrop,
Y. Sun,
D. B. Weisberg,
M. Willensdorfer,
the ASDEX-Upgrade,
DIII-D,
EAST,
KSTAR Teams
Abstract:
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are foun…
▽ More
The operational space and global performance of plasmas with edge-localized modes (ELMs) suppressed by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) are surveyed by comparing AUG, DIII-D, EAST, and KSTAR stationary operating points. RMP-ELM suppression is achieved over a range of plasma currents, toroidal fields, and RMP toroidal mode numbers. Consistent operational windows in edge safety factor are found across devices, while windows in plasma sha** parameters are distinct. Accessed pedestal parameters reveal a quantitatively similar pedestal-top density limit for RMP-ELM suppression in all devices of just over 3x1019 m-3. This is surprising given the wide variance of many engineering parameters and edge collisionalities, and poses a challenge to extrapolation of the regime. Wide ranges in input power, confinement time, and stored energy are observed, with the achieved triple product found to scale like the product of current, field, and radius. Observed energy confinement scaling with engineering parameters for RMP-ELM suppressed plasmas are presented and compared with expectations from established H and L-mode scalings, including treatment of uncertainty analysis. Different scaling exponents for individual engineering parameters are found as compared to the established scalings. However, extrapolation to next-step tokamaks ITER and SPARC find overall consistency within uncertainties with the established scalings, finding no obvious performance penalty when extrapolating from the assembled multi-device RMP-ELM suppressed database. Overall this work identifies common physics for RMP-ELM suppression and highlights the need to pursue this no-ELM regime at higher magnetic field and different plasma physical size.
△ Less
Submitted 6 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Flexible, integrated modeling of tokamak stability, transport, equilibrium, and pedestal physics
Authors:
B. C. Lyons,
J. McClenaghan,
T. Slendebroek,
O. Meneghini,
T. F. Neiser,
S. P. Smith,
D. B. Weisberg,
E. A. Belli,
J. Candy,
J. M. Hanson,
L. L. Lao,
N. C. Logan,
S. Saarelma,
O. Sauter,
P. B. Snyder,
G. M. Staebler,
K. E. Thome,
A. D. Turnbull
Abstract:
The STEP (Stability, Transport, Equilibrium, and Pedestal) integrated-modeling tool has been developed in OMFIT to predict stable, tokamak equilibria self-consistently with core-transport and pedestal calculations. STEP couples theory-based codes to integrate a variety of physics, including MHD stability, transport, equilibrium, pedestal formation, and current-drive, heating, and fueling. The inpu…
▽ More
The STEP (Stability, Transport, Equilibrium, and Pedestal) integrated-modeling tool has been developed in OMFIT to predict stable, tokamak equilibria self-consistently with core-transport and pedestal calculations. STEP couples theory-based codes to integrate a variety of physics, including MHD stability, transport, equilibrium, pedestal formation, and current-drive, heating, and fueling. The input/output of each code is interfaced with a centralized ITER-IMAS data structure, allowing codes to be run in any order and enabling open-loop, feedback, and optimization workflows. This paradigm simplifies the integration of new codes, making STEP highly extensible. STEP has been verified against a published benchmark of six different integrated models. Core-pedestal calculations with STEP have been successfully validated against individual DIII-D H-mode discharges and across more than 500 discharges of the $H_{98,y2}$ database, with a mean error in confinement time from experiment less than 19%. STEP has also reproduced results in less conventional DIII-D scenarios, including negative-central-shear and negative-triangularity plasmas. Predictive STEP modeling has been used to assess performance in several tokamak reactors. Simulations of a high-field, large-aspect-ratio reactor show significantly lower fusion power than predicted by a zero-dimensional study, demonstrating the limitations of scaling-law extrapolations. STEP predictions have found promising EXCITE scenarios, including a high-pressure, 80%-bootstrap-fraction plasma. ITER modeling with STEP has shown that pellet fueling enhances fusion gain in both the baseline and advanced-inductive scenarios. Finally, STEP predictions for the SPARC baseline scenario are in good agreement with published results from the physics basis.
△ Less
Submitted 12 May, 2023;
originally announced May 2023.
-
Implementation of AI/Deep Learning Disruption Predictor into a Plasma Control System
Authors:
William Tang,
Ge Dong,
Jayson Barr,
Keith Erickson,
Rory Conlin,
M. Dan Boyer,
Julian Kates-Harbeck,
Kyle Felker,
Cristina Rea,
Nikolas C. Logan,
Alexey Svyatkovskiy,
Eliot Feibush,
Joseph Abbatte,
Mitchell Clement,
Brian Grierson,
Raffi Nazikian,
Zhihong Lin,
David Eldon,
Auna Moser,
Mikhail Maslov
Abstract:
This paper reports on advances to the state-of-the-art deep-learning disruption prediction models based on the Fusion Recurrent Neural Network (FRNN) originally introduced a 2019 Nature publication. In particular, the predictor now features not only the disruption score, as an indicator of the probability of an imminent disruption, but also a sensitivity score in real-time to indicate the underlyi…
▽ More
This paper reports on advances to the state-of-the-art deep-learning disruption prediction models based on the Fusion Recurrent Neural Network (FRNN) originally introduced a 2019 Nature publication. In particular, the predictor now features not only the disruption score, as an indicator of the probability of an imminent disruption, but also a sensitivity score in real-time to indicate the underlying reasons for the imminent disruption. This adds valuable physics-interpretability for the deep-learning model and can provide helpful guidance for control actuators now that it is fully implemented into a modern Plasma Control System (PCS). The advance is a significant step forward in moving from modern deep-learning disruption prediction to real-time control and brings novel AI-enabled capabilities relevant for application to the future burning plasma ITER system. Our analyses use large amounts of data from JET and DIII-D vetted in the earlier NATURE publication. In addition to when a shot is predicted to disrupt, this paper addresses reasons why by carrying out sensitivity studies. FRNN is accordingly extended to use many more channels of information, including measured DIII-D signals such as (i) the n1rms signal that is correlated with the n =1 modes with finite frequency, including neoclassical tearing mode and sawtooth dynamics, (ii) the bolometer data indicative of plasma impurity content, and (iii) q-min, the minimum value of the safety factor relevant to the key physics of kink modes. The additional channels and interpretability features expand the ability of the deep learning FRNN software to provide information about disruption subcategories as well as more precise and direct guidance for the actuators in a plasma control system.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Wide operational windows of edge-localized mode suppression by resonant magnetic perturbations in the DIII-D tokamak
Authors:
Q. M. Hu,
R. Nazikian,
B. A. Grierson,
N. C. Logan,
D. M. Orlov,
C. Paz-Soldan,
Q. Yu
Abstract:
Edge-Localized-Mode (ELM) suppression by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) generally occurs over very narrow ranges of the plasma current (or magnetic safety factor q95) in the DIII-D tokamak. However, wide q95 ranges of ELM suppression are needed for the safety and operational flexibility of ITER and future reactors. In DIII-D ITER Similar Shape (ISS) plasmas with n=3 RMPs, the range of q95…
▽ More
Edge-Localized-Mode (ELM) suppression by resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) generally occurs over very narrow ranges of the plasma current (or magnetic safety factor q95) in the DIII-D tokamak. However, wide q95 ranges of ELM suppression are needed for the safety and operational flexibility of ITER and future reactors. In DIII-D ITER Similar Shape (ISS) plasmas with n=3 RMPs, the range of q95 for ELM suppression is found to increase with decreasing electron density. Nonlinear two-fluid MHD simulations reproduce the observed q95 windows of ELM suppression and the dependence on plasma density, based on the conditions for resonant field penetration at the top of the pedestal. When the RMP amplitude is close to the threshold for resonant field penetration, only narrow isolated magnetic islands form near the top of the pedestal, leading to narrow q95 windows of ELM suppression. However, as the threshold for field penetration decreases with decreasing density, resonant field penetration can take place over a wider range of q95. For sufficiently low density (penetration threshold) multiple magnetic islands form near the top of the pedestal giving rise to continuous q95 windows of ELM suppression. The model predicts that wide q95 windows of ELM suppression can be achieved at substantially higher pedestal pressure in DIII-D by shifting to higher toroidal mode number (n=4) RMPs.
△ Less
Submitted 30 June, 2020; v1 submitted 13 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
The Density Dependence of Edge-Localized-Mode Suppression and Pump-out by Resonant Magnetic Perturbations in the DIII-D Tokamak
Authors:
Q. M. Hu,
R. Nazikian,
B. Grierson,
N. C. Logan,
J-K. Park,
C. Paz-Soldan,
Q. Yu
Abstract:
The density dependence of edge-localized-mode (ELM) suppression and density pump-out (density reduction) by n = 2 resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) is consistent with the effects of narrow well-separated magnetic islands at the top and bottom of the H-mode pedestal in DIII-D low-collisionality plasmas. Nonlinear two-fluid MHD simulations for DIII-D ITER Similar Shape (ISS) discharges show tha…
▽ More
The density dependence of edge-localized-mode (ELM) suppression and density pump-out (density reduction) by n = 2 resonant magnetic perturbations (RMPs) is consistent with the effects of narrow well-separated magnetic islands at the top and bottom of the H-mode pedestal in DIII-D low-collisionality plasmas. Nonlinear two-fluid MHD simulations for DIII-D ITER Similar Shape (ISS) discharges show that, at low collisionality, low pedestal density is required for resonant field penetration at the pedestal top, consistent with the ubiquitous low density requirement for ELM suppression in these DIII-D plasmas. The simulations predict a drop in the pedestal pressure due to parallel transport across these narrow width (0.02) magnetic islands at the top of the pedestal that is stabilizing to Peeling-Ballooning-Modes (PBMs), and comparable to the pedestal pressure reduction observed in experiment at the onset of ELM suppression. The simulations predict density pump-out at experimentally relevant levels (-20%) at low pedestal collisionality due to very narrow (~0.01-0.02) RMP driven magnetic islands at the pedestal foot at ~0.99. The simulations show decreasing pump-out with increasing density, consistent with experiment, resulting from the inverse dependence of parallel particle transport on resistivity at the foot of the pedestal. The robust screening of resonant fields is predicted between the top and bottom of the pedestal during density pump-out and ELM suppression, consistent with the preservation of strong temperature gradients in the edge transport barrier as seen in experiment.
△ Less
Submitted 13 December, 2019; v1 submitted 30 October, 2019;
originally announced October 2019.
