Spatial scales of COVID-19 transmission in Mexico
Authors:
Brennan Klein,
Harrison Hartle,
Munik Shrestha,
Ana Cecilia Zenteno,
David Barros Sierra Cordera,
José R. Nicolas-Carlock,
Ana I. Bento,
Benjamin M. Althouse,
Bernardo Gutierrez,
Marina Escalera-Zamudio,
Arturo Reyes-Sandoval,
Oliver G. Pybus,
Alessandro Vespignani,
Jose Alberto Diaz-Quiñonez,
Samuel V. Scarpino,
Moritz U. G. Kraemer
Abstract:
During outbreaks of emerging infectious diseases, internationally connected cities often experience large and early outbreaks, while rural regions follow after some delay. This hierarchical structure of disease spread is influenced primarily by the multiscale structure of human mobility. However, during the COVID-19 epidemic, public health responses typically did not take into consideration the ex…
▽ More
During outbreaks of emerging infectious diseases, internationally connected cities often experience large and early outbreaks, while rural regions follow after some delay. This hierarchical structure of disease spread is influenced primarily by the multiscale structure of human mobility. However, during the COVID-19 epidemic, public health responses typically did not take into consideration the explicit spatial structure of human mobility when designing non-pharmaceutical interventions (NPIs). NPIs were applied primarily at national or regional scales. Here we use weekly anonymized and aggregated human mobility data and spatially highly resolved data on COVID-19 cases, deaths and hospitalizations at the municipality level in Mexico to investigate how behavioural changes in response to the pandemic have altered the spatial scales of transmission and interventions during its first wave (March - June 2020). We find that the epidemic dynamics in Mexico were initially driven by SARS-CoV-2 exports from Mexico State and Mexico City, where early outbreaks occurred. The mobility network shifted after the implementation of interventions in late March 2020, and the mobility network communities became more disjointed while epidemics in these communities became increasingly synchronised. Our results provide actionable and dynamic insights into how to use network science and epidemiological modelling to inform the spatial scale at which interventions are most impactful in mitigating the spread of COVID-19 and infectious diseases in general.
△ Less
Submitted 30 January, 2023;
originally announced January 2023.
Characterizing collective physical distancing in the U.S. during the first nine months of the COVID-19 pandemic
Authors:
Brennan Klein,
Timothy LaRock,
Stefan McCabe,
Leo Torres,
Lisa Friedland,
Maciej Kos,
Filippo Privitera,
Brennan Lake,
Moritz U. G. Kraemer,
John S. Brownstein,
Richard Gonzalez,
David Lazer,
Tina Eliassi-Rad,
Samuel V. Scarpino,
Alessandro Vespignani,
Matteo Chinazzi
Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic offers an unprecedented natural experiment providing insights into the emergence of collective behavioral changes of both exogenous (government mandated) and endogenous (spontaneous reaction to infection risks) origin. Here, we characterize collective physical distancing -- mobility reductions, minimization of contacts, shortening of contact duration -- in response to the COV…
▽ More
The COVID-19 pandemic offers an unprecedented natural experiment providing insights into the emergence of collective behavioral changes of both exogenous (government mandated) and endogenous (spontaneous reaction to infection risks) origin. Here, we characterize collective physical distancing -- mobility reductions, minimization of contacts, shortening of contact duration -- in response to the COVID-19 pandemic in the pre-vaccine era by analyzing de-identified, privacy-preserving location data for a panel of over 5.5 million anonymized, opted-in U.S. devices. We define five indicators of users' mobility and proximity to investigate how the emerging collective behavior deviates from the typical pre-pandemic patterns during the first nine months of the COVID-19 pandemic. We analyze both the dramatic changes due to the government mandated mitigation policies and the more spontaneous societal adaptation into a new (physically distanced) normal in the fall 2020. The indicators defined here allow the quantification of behavior changes across the rural/urban divide and highlight the statistical association of mobility and proximity indicators with metrics characterizing the pandemic's social and public health impact such as unemployment and deaths. This study provides a framework to study massive social distancing phenomena with potential uses in analyzing and monitoring the effects of pandemic mitigation plans at the national and international level.
△ Less
Submitted 17 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
