-
Spin(ing) into the classroom: Quantum spin activities for Year 6-10 physics
Authors:
Kyla Adams,
Anastasia Lonshakova,
David Blair,
David Treagust,
Te**der Kaur
Abstract:
Quantum science is in the news daily and engages student interest and curiosity. A fundamental quantum science concept that underpins medical imaging, quantum computing and many future technologies is quantum spin. Quantum spin can explain many physical phenomena that are in the lower secondary school curriculum, such as magnetism and light, making its inclusion a great motivator for students. Her…
▽ More
Quantum science is in the news daily and engages student interest and curiosity. A fundamental quantum science concept that underpins medical imaging, quantum computing and many future technologies is quantum spin. Quantum spin can explain many physical phenomena that are in the lower secondary school curriculum, such as magnetism and light, making its inclusion a great motivator for students. Here we present an activity sequence for teaching quantum spin in the classroom using spinning tops and gyroscopes to highlight the common properties of classical angular momentum and quantum spin. These toys can provide an easily understood window to the quantum world for lower secondary school students. Students who have engaged in these activities reported enjoying the content and appreciating its relevance.
△ Less
Submitted 8 May, 2024;
originally announced May 2024.
-
On the effectiveness of the early introduction of modern physics in school curriculum: the case of the structure of atom versus wave-particle duality
Authors:
Somya Swarnkar,
Rittick Roy,
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair
Abstract:
The dual nature of matter and radiation and the concept of the structure of an atom share a number of key conceptual elements from quantum mechanics. Despite the similarities, we find that the concept of the structure of an atom is well understood by students, in contrast to the wave-particle duality. The study analyzes students' comprehension of these two concepts by conducting a semi-structured…
▽ More
The dual nature of matter and radiation and the concept of the structure of an atom share a number of key conceptual elements from quantum mechanics. Despite the similarities, we find that the concept of the structure of an atom is well understood by students, in contrast to the wave-particle duality. The study analyzes students' comprehension of these two concepts by conducting a semi-structured focus group interview and questionnaire. Through students' performance in the questionnaire and their descriptive responses, we find that the difficulties in their learning and understandings reflect the treatment of the respective topic in the curriculum. The introduction of the structure of an atom is early and repeated, whereas the dual nature of matter and radiation is introduced late and abruptly. Based on our findings, we propose reforms in the present curriculum that are necessary for an improved way of introducing the concept of modern physics, like wave particle duality, to Indian students.
△ Less
Submitted 5 January, 2024; v1 submitted 28 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Develo** and implementing an Einsteinian science curriculum from Years 3 to 10: Part B Teacher upskilling: response to training and teacher's classroom experience
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
Magdalena Kersting,
Kyla Adams,
David Blair,
David Treagust,
Anastasia Popkova,
Shon Boublil,
Jesse Santoso,
Li Ju,
Marjan Zadnik,
David Wood,
Elaine Horne,
Darren McGoran,
Susan Scott,
Grady Venville
Abstract:
Recent years have seen a growing interest in modernizing physics and science curricula around the world. While many science educators and curriculum developers design instructional resources to successfully introduce topics of Einsteinian physics to young learners, it is clear that successful curriculum development needs to rest on successful teacher professional development.Teachers with or witho…
▽ More
Recent years have seen a growing interest in modernizing physics and science curricula around the world. While many science educators and curriculum developers design instructional resources to successfully introduce topics of Einsteinian physics to young learners, it is clear that successful curriculum development needs to rest on successful teacher professional development.Teachers with or without science backgrounds were trained in short professional learning workshops or completed micro-credential courses. The courses enabled teachers to gain knowledge and confidence to deliver the Einstein-First program. Detailed lesson plans and instructional videos for teachers define the lessons. Questionnaires were used to collect data, and teacher interviews were conducted following the various teacher training programs. The research results show that teachers effectively deliver the Einsteinian physics programs and that their subject matter and pedagogical content knowledge increased. In addition, teacher attitudes were favorable towards modernizing the physics curriculum. We conclude that it is feasible to upskill teachers from diverse backgrounds in Einsteinian physics and break the cycle that has inhibited the modernization of school curricula.
△ Less
Submitted 19 December, 2023; v1 submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Develo** and implementing an Einsteinian science curriculum from Years 3 to 10 : Part A Concepts, rationale and learning outcomes
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
Magdalena Kersting,
David Blair,
Kyla Adams,
David Treagust,
Jesse Santoso,
Anastasia Popkova,
Shon Boublil,
Marjan Zadnik,
Li Ju,
David Wood,
Elaine Horne,
Darren McGoran
Abstract:
There has been a growing realisation that school science curricula do not adequately reflect the revolutionary changes in our scientific understanding of the 20th century. This discrepancy between current school education and our modern scientific understanding has led to calls for the modernisation of the science curriculum. Although there have been attempts to introduce topics of Einsteinian phy…
▽ More
There has been a growing realisation that school science curricula do not adequately reflect the revolutionary changes in our scientific understanding of the 20th century. This discrepancy between current school education and our modern scientific understanding has led to calls for the modernisation of the science curriculum. Although there have been attempts to introduce topics of Einsteinian physics (i.e., quantum physics and relativity) to school education, often at the secondary level, we still lack a seamless curriculum in which modern science concepts are gradually introduced in primary and middle schools. Guided by the Model of Educational Reconstruction and following a mixed-methods research design, the Einstein-First project aims to address this gap. Einstein-First has developed and implemented an Einsteinian curriculum from Years 3 to 10 (students aged 7- 16) that resolves the disconnect between science in schools and the modern world. This paper presents the concepts, rationale, and learning outcomes of the curriculum implementation in six Australian schools with 315 students across Years 3 to 10. Our findings lay the foundation for informed curriculum development towards a school education that can enhance students' understanding and appreciation of the fundamental concepts of modern science and its impact on our society.
△ Less
Submitted 21 November, 2023; v1 submitted 29 June, 2023;
originally announced June 2023.
-
Can 8-Year-Olds understand concepts of Einsteinian physics?
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
Aishwarya Banavathu,
David Blair,
Rahul Choudhary,
Alex Foppolli
Abstract:
This paper reports the first study on the ability of Year 3 students (ages 7 to 8) to conceptualize Einsteinian concepts. This paper reports that children aged 7-8 are not too young to learn key Einsteinian concepts, and the benefits of reinforcement indicate that longer programs are needed for ideas to be consolidated.
This paper reports the first study on the ability of Year 3 students (ages 7 to 8) to conceptualize Einsteinian concepts. This paper reports that children aged 7-8 are not too young to learn key Einsteinian concepts, and the benefits of reinforcement indicate that longer programs are needed for ideas to be consolidated.
△ Less
Submitted 5 December, 2023; v1 submitted 1 March, 2022;
originally announced March 2022.
-
Generating sustained coherence in a quantum memory for retrieval at the times of quantum revival
Authors:
Tavshabad Kaur,
Maninder Kaur,
Arvind,
Bindiya Arora
Abstract:
We study the time degradation of quantum information stored in a quantum memory device under a dissipative environment in a parameter range which is experimentally relevant. The quantum memory under consideration comprises of an optomechanical system with additional Kerr non-linearity in the optical mode and an anharmonic mechanical oscillator with quadratic non-linearity. Time degradation is moni…
▽ More
We study the time degradation of quantum information stored in a quantum memory device under a dissipative environment in a parameter range which is experimentally relevant. The quantum memory under consideration comprises of an optomechanical system with additional Kerr non-linearity in the optical mode and an anharmonic mechanical oscillator with quadratic non-linearity. Time degradation is monitored, both in terms of loss of coherence which is analyzed with the help of Wigner functions, as well as in terms of loss of amplitude of the original state studied as a function of time. While our time trajectories explore the degree to which the stored information degrades depending upon the variation in values of various parameters involved, we suggest a set of parameters for which the original information can be retrieved without degradation. We come across a highly attention seeking situation where the role played by the non-linearity is insignificant and the system behaves as if the information is stored in a linear medium. For this case, the information retrieval is independent of the coherence revival time and can be retrieved at any instant during the time evolution.
△ Less
Submitted 18 January, 2022;
originally announced January 2022.
-
Long-term impact of a primary school intervention on aspects of Einsteinian physics
Authors:
Kyla Adams,
Roshan Dattatri,
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair
Abstract:
The physics that underpins modern technology is based on Einstein's theories of relativity and quantum mechanics. Most school students complete their compulsory science education without being taught any of these Einsteinian concepts. Only those who take a specialised physics course have the opportunity to learn modern physics. In 2011, the first study of a modern physics teaching intervention wit…
▽ More
The physics that underpins modern technology is based on Einstein's theories of relativity and quantum mechanics. Most school students complete their compulsory science education without being taught any of these Einsteinian concepts. Only those who take a specialised physics course have the opportunity to learn modern physics. In 2011, the first study of a modern physics teaching intervention with an Australian upper primary (aged 10{11) class was conducted. The initial intervention was the first step of the Einstein-First collaboration towards challenging the current paradigm of Newtonian teaching in schools. It was found that modern physics concepts could be taught to these students. In 2020, 11 participants of the initial study (out of a total of 26) were contacted for a follow-up questionnaire and interview to investigate any long-term impact. The results of the follow-up indicate that the intervention maintained a positive impression on participants. The models and analogies used during the six-week intervention were highly memorable. The participants indicated that they found the intervention to be beneficial to their future learning. Even close to ten years after the intervention, the participants remembered several key concepts (such as curved space-time). The long-term follow-up indicates that Einsteinian physics can be taught at the upper primary level and be recalled several years later.
△ Less
Submitted 8 July, 2021; v1 submitted 20 April, 2021;
originally announced April 2021.
-
Can a short intervention focused on gravitational waves and quantum physics improve students' understanding and attitude?
Authors:
Rahul K. Choudhary,
Alexander Foppoli,
Te**der Kaur,
David G. Blair,
Marjan Zadnik,
Richard Meagher
Abstract:
The decline in student interest in science and technology is a major concern in the western world. One approach to reversing this decline is to introduce modern physics concepts much earlier in the school curriculum. We have used the context of the recent discoveries of gravitational waves to test benefits of one-day interventions, in which students are introduced to the ongoing nature of scientif…
▽ More
The decline in student interest in science and technology is a major concern in the western world. One approach to reversing this decline is to introduce modern physics concepts much earlier in the school curriculum. We have used the context of the recent discoveries of gravitational waves to test benefits of one-day interventions, in which students are introduced to the ongoing nature of scientific discovery, as well as the fundamental concepts of quantum physics and gravitation, which underpin these discoveries. Our innovative approach combines role-playing, model demonstrations, single photon interference and gravitational wave detection, plus simple experiments designed to emphasize the quantum interpretation of interference. We compare understanding and attitudes through pre and post testing on four age groups (school years 7, 8, 9 and 10), and compare results with those of longer interventions with Year 9. Results indicate that neither prior knowledge nor age are significant factors in student understanding of the core concepts of Einsteinian physics. However we find that the short interventions are insufficient to enable students to comprehend more derived concepts.
△ Less
Submitted 9 July, 2018;
originally announced July 2018.
-
Public and Teacher Response to Einsteinian Physics in Schools
Authors:
Alexander Foppoli,
Rahul Choudhary,
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
Marjan Zadnik,
John Moschilla
Abstract:
Einsteinian physics represents a distinct paradigm shift compared to Newtonian physics. There is worldwide interest in introducing Einsteinian physics concepts early in school curriculum and trials have demonstrated that this is feasible. However introducing Einsteinian concepts from an early age requires more than suitable curriculum and teaching resources - it also requires teacher training and…
▽ More
Einsteinian physics represents a distinct paradigm shift compared to Newtonian physics. There is worldwide interest in introducing Einsteinian physics concepts early in school curriculum and trials have demonstrated that this is feasible. However introducing Einsteinian concepts from an early age requires more than suitable curriculum and teaching resources - it also requires teacher training and public support. This paper describes a pilot study used in an attempt to gauge public and teacher support. This entailed giving teachers, who included the entire staff of a primary school, and self-selected family groups an in-depth understanding of proposed curriculum content through public outreach and professional development workshops. We assessed their attitudes through questionnaires. Comments and opinions from the public were also collected from online resources. Results show overwhelming support from both teachers and the public. We assessed attitudes of children as well as adults and obtained opinions regarding the appropriate age at which to begin to introduce Einsteinian concepts.
△ Less
Submitted 28 June, 2018;
originally announced June 2018.
-
Gender response to Einsteinian physics interventions in School
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
Rahul Kumar Choudhary,
Yohanes Sudarmo Dua,
Alexander Foppoli,
Marjan Zadnik
Abstract:
There is growing interest in the introduction of Einsteinian concepts of space, time, light and gravity across the entire school curriculum. We have developed intervention programs and measured their effectiveness in terms of student attitudes to physics and ability to understand the concepts with classes from Years 6 to 10. In all cases we observe significant levels of conceptual understanding an…
▽ More
There is growing interest in the introduction of Einsteinian concepts of space, time, light and gravity across the entire school curriculum. We have developed intervention programs and measured their effectiveness in terms of student attitudes to physics and ability to understand the concepts with classes from Years 6 to 10. In all cases we observe significant levels of conceptual understanding and improvement in student attitudes, although the magnitude of the improvement depends on age group and program duration. This paper reports an unexpected outcome in regard to gender effects. We have compared male and female outcomes. In most cases, independent of age group, academic stream and culture (including one intervention in Indonesia), we find that females enter our programmes with substantially lower attitude scores than males, while on completion their attitudes are comparable to the boys. This provides a strong case for widespread implementation of Einsteinian conceptual learning across the school curriculum. We discuss possible reasons for this effect.
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2019; v1 submitted 18 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Evaluation of 14 to 15 Year Old Students' Understanding and Attitude towards Learning Einsteinian Physics
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
Ron Burman,
Warren Stannard,
David Treagust,
Grady Venville,
Marjan Zadnik,
Warwick Mathews,
Dana Perks
Abstract:
There is an increasing recognition regarding of the importance of introducing modern Einsteinian concepts early in science education. This study investigates the efficacy of an innovative educational programme "Einstein-First", which focuses on teaching Einsteinian physics at an earlier age than usual through the incorporation of appropriate hands-on activities. This paper presents an analysis of…
▽ More
There is an increasing recognition regarding of the importance of introducing modern Einsteinian concepts early in science education. This study investigates the efficacy of an innovative educational programme "Einstein-First", which focuses on teaching Einsteinian physics at an earlier age than usual through the incorporation of appropriate hands-on activities. This paper presents an analysis of 14 to 15-year-old students' conceptualisation of Einsteinian physics and their attitudes towards science as a result of this programme. We have investigated the students' understanding of modern physics concept after a term of 20 lessons. We report on two such 20-lesson programmes, one delivered in 2013 and a second, improved programme delivered in 2014; each to 50-60 students across two classes designated by the participating high school as "academically talented" students. We found, as expected, that the students' possessed little prior knowledge of Einsteinian physics. the significant improvement in the students' knowledge, as tested before and after the course, showed that they could comprehend Einsteinian physics at the level it was given. The findings also showed that the short programme improved students' attitude towards physics.While the male students initially showed greater interest in physics compared to their female counterparts, the female students showed a significantly increased interest in physics after the programme. Also, students' memory retention of Einsteinian physics concepts was tested in two different years, one class was tested after one year of the programmes and the other was tested after three years of the programme. The results show that the Einstein-First programme had a lasting impact on the students involved in the study.
△ Less
Submitted 6 December, 2017;
originally announced December 2017.
-
Teaching Einsteinian Physics at Schools: Part 3, Review of Research Outcomes
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
John Moschilla,
Warren Stannard,
Marjan Zadnik
Abstract:
This paper reviews research results obtained from Einsteinian physics programs run by different instructors with Years 6, 9, 10 and 11 students using the models and analogies described in Parts 1 and 2. The research aimed to determine whether it is possible to teach Einsteinian physics and to measure the changes in students attitudes to physics engendered by introducing the modern concepts that un…
▽ More
This paper reviews research results obtained from Einsteinian physics programs run by different instructors with Years 6, 9, 10 and 11 students using the models and analogies described in Parts 1 and 2. The research aimed to determine whether it is possible to teach Einsteinian physics and to measure the changes in students attitudes to physics engendered by introducing the modern concepts that underpin technology today. Results showed that students easily coped with the concepts of Einsteinian physics, and considered that they were not too young for the material presented. Importantly, in all groups, girls improved their attitude to physics considerably more than the boys, generally achieving near parity with the boys.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2017; v1 submitted 5 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Teaching Einsteinian Physics at Schools: Part 2, Models and Analogies for Quantum Physics
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
John Moschilla,
Marjan Zadnik
Abstract:
The Einstein-First project approaches the teaching of Einsteinian physics through the use of physical models and analogies. This paper presents an approach to the teaching of quantum physics which begins by emphasising the particle-nature of light through the use of toy projectiles to represent photons. This allows key concepts including the spacing between photons, and photon momentum to be intro…
▽ More
The Einstein-First project approaches the teaching of Einsteinian physics through the use of physical models and analogies. This paper presents an approach to the teaching of quantum physics which begins by emphasising the particle-nature of light through the use of toy projectiles to represent photons. This allows key concepts including the spacing between photons, and photon momentum to be introduced. This in-turn allows an intuitive understanding of the uncertainty principle. We present optical interference in the context of individual photons, using actual videos showing the development of images one at a time This enables simple laser interference experiments to be interpreted through the statistical arrival of photons. The wave aspects of quantum phenomenon are interpreted in terms of the wavelike nature of the arrival probabilities.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2017; v1 submitted 5 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Teaching Einsteinian Physics at Schools: Part 1, Models and Analogies for Relativity
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
John Moschilla,
Warren Stannard,
Marjan Zadnik
Abstract:
The Einstein-First project aims to change the paradigm of school science teaching through the introduction of modern Einsteinian concepts of space and time, gravity and quanta at an early age. These concepts are rarely taught to school students despite their central importance to modern science and technology. The key to implementing the Einstein-First curriculum is the development of appropriate…
▽ More
The Einstein-First project aims to change the paradigm of school science teaching through the introduction of modern Einsteinian concepts of space and time, gravity and quanta at an early age. These concepts are rarely taught to school students despite their central importance to modern science and technology. The key to implementing the Einstein-First curriculum is the development of appropriate models and analogies. This paper is the first part of a three-paper series. It presents the conceptual foundation of our approach, based on simple physical models and analogies, followed by a detailed description of the models and analogies used to teach concepts of general and special relativity. Two accompanying papers address the teaching of quantum physics (Part 2) and research outcomes (Part 3).
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2017; v1 submitted 6 April, 2017;
originally announced April 2017.
-
Teaching the Einsteinian gravity paradigm
Authors:
Te**der Kaur,
David Blair,
Ron Burman,
Graeme Gower,
Elaine Horne,
Douglas Mitchell,
John Moschilla,
Warren Stannard,
David Treagust,
Grady Venville,
Marjan Zadnik
Abstract:
While Newtonian gravity is an adequate model for current geophysical exploration, Einsteinian gravity, based on the connection between free fall and warped time, has superseded Newtonian gravity as our best understanding of the universe. Einsteinian gravity is fundamental to GPS navigation and is a useful tool for geodesy. The Einstein-First Project is pioneering new curriculum material that seeks…
▽ More
While Newtonian gravity is an adequate model for current geophysical exploration, Einsteinian gravity, based on the connection between free fall and warped time, has superseded Newtonian gravity as our best understanding of the universe. Einsteinian gravity is fundamental to GPS navigation and is a useful tool for geodesy. The Einstein-First Project is pioneering new curriculum material that seeks to teach students, from ages 11 upwards, the Einsteinian paradigm for gravity. By develo** models, analogies and classroom activity based learning, we have found that students are fascinated and easily cope with concepts that adults, indoctrinated with Euclidean-Newtonian concepts, find difficult and confusing. This paper reviews the Einstein-First program, its methods and results of studies with students. We show that the majority of students demonstrate improved conceptual understanding and improved attitude to physics and that female students who enter the program with lower scores than male students, increase their performance to be level with the male students.
△ Less
Submitted 1 March, 2017;
originally announced March 2017.
-
Calibration of the Advanced LIGO detectors for the discovery of the binary black-hole merger GW150914
Authors:
The LIGO Scientific Collaboration,
B. P. Abbott,
R. Abbott,
T. D. Abbott,
M. R. Abernathy,
K. Ackley,
C. Adams,
P. Addesso,
R. X. Adhikari,
V. B. Adya,
C. Affeldt,
N. Aggarwal,
O. D. Aguiar,
A. Ain,
P. Ajith,
B. Allen,
P. A. Altin,
D. V. Amariutei,
S. B. Anderson,
W. G. Anderson,
K. Arai,
M. C. Araya,
C. C. Arceneaux,
J. S. Areeda,
K. G. Arun
, et al. (702 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
In Advanced LIGO, detection and astrophysical source parameter estimation of the binary black hole merger GW150914 requires a calibrated estimate of the gravitational-wave strain sensed by the detectors. Producing an estimate from each detector's differential arm length control loop readout signals requires applying time domain filters, which are designed from a frequency domain model of the detec…
▽ More
In Advanced LIGO, detection and astrophysical source parameter estimation of the binary black hole merger GW150914 requires a calibrated estimate of the gravitational-wave strain sensed by the detectors. Producing an estimate from each detector's differential arm length control loop readout signals requires applying time domain filters, which are designed from a frequency domain model of the detector's gravitational-wave response. The gravitational-wave response model is determined by the detector's opto-mechanical response and the properties of its feedback control system. The measurements used to validate the model and characterize its uncertainty are derived primarily from a dedicated photon radiation pressure actuator, with cross-checks provided by optical and radio frequency references. We describe how the gravitational-wave readout signal is calibrated into equivalent gravitational-wave-induced strain and how the statistical uncertainties and systematic errors are assessed. Detector data collected over 38 calendar days, from September 12 to October 20, 2015, contain the event GW150914 and approximately 16 of coincident data used to estimate the event false alarm probability. The calibration uncertainty is less than 10% in magnitude and 10 degrees in phase across the relevant frequency band 20 Hz to 1 kHz.
△ Less
Submitted 28 February, 2017; v1 submitted 11 February, 2016;
originally announced February 2016.
