-
Revisiting a drag partition model for canopy-like roughness elements
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Davide Vettori,
Davide Poggi,
Costantino Manes
Abstract:
Turbulent flows over a large surface area (S) covered by n obstacles experience an overall drag due to the presence of the ground and the protruding obstacles into the flow. The drag partition between the roughness obstacles and the ground is analyzed using an analytical model proposed by Raupach (1992) and is hereafter referred to as R92. The R92 is based on the premise that the wake behind an is…
▽ More
Turbulent flows over a large surface area (S) covered by n obstacles experience an overall drag due to the presence of the ground and the protruding obstacles into the flow. The drag partition between the roughness obstacles and the ground is analyzed using an analytical model proposed by Raupach (1992) and is hereafter referred to as R92. The R92 is based on the premise that the wake behind an isolated roughness element can be described by a shelter area A and a shelter volume V. The individual sizes of A and V without any interference from other obstacles can be determined from scaling analysis for the spread of wakes. To upscale from an individual roughness element to n/S elements where wakes may interact, R92 adopted a background stress re-normalizing instead of reducing A or V with each element addition. This work shows that R92's approach only converges to a linear reduction in A and V for small n/S where wakes have low probability of interacting with one another. This probabilistic nature suggests that up-scaling from individual to multiple roughness elements can be re-formulated using stochastic averaging methods proposed here. The two approaches are shown to recover R92 under plausible conditions. Comparisons between R92 and available data on blocks and vegetation-like roughness elements confirm the practical utility of R92 and its potential use in large-scale models provided the relevant parameters accommodate certain features of the roughness element type (cube versus vegetation-like) and, to a lesser extent, their configuration throughout S.
△ Less
Submitted 11 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
The advancing wave front on a slo** channel covered by a rod canopy following an instantaneous dam break
Authors:
Elia Buono,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Davide Poggi
Abstract:
The drag coefficient $C_d$ for a rigid and uniformly distributed rod canopy covering a slo** channel following the instantaneous collapse of a dam was examined using flume experiments. The measurements included space $x$ and time $t$ high resolution images of the water surface $h(x,t)$ for multiple channel bed slopes $S_o$ and water depths behind the dam $H_o$ along with drag estimates provided…
▽ More
The drag coefficient $C_d$ for a rigid and uniformly distributed rod canopy covering a slo** channel following the instantaneous collapse of a dam was examined using flume experiments. The measurements included space $x$ and time $t$ high resolution images of the water surface $h(x,t)$ for multiple channel bed slopes $S_o$ and water depths behind the dam $H_o$ along with drag estimates provided by sequential load cells. Analysis of the Saint-Venant Equation (SVE) for the front speed using the diffusive wave approximation lead to a front velocity $U_f=\sqrt{Γ_h 2 g φ_v'/(C_d m D)}$, where $Γ_h=-\partial h/\partial x$, $g$ is the gravitational acceleration, $φ_v'=1-φ_v$ is fluid volume fraction per ground area, $φ_v=m πD^2/4$ is the solid volume fraction per ground area, $m$ is the number of rods per ground area, and $D$ is the rod diameter. An inferred $C_d=0.4$ from the $h(x,t)$ data near the advancing front region, also confirmed by load cell measurements, is much reduced relative to its independently measured steady-uniform flow case. This finding suggests that drag reduction mechanisms associated with transients and flow disturbances are more likely to play a dominant role when compared to conventional sheltering or blocking effects on $C_d$ examined in uniform flow. The increased air volume entrained into the advancing wave front region as determined from an inflow-outflow volume balance partly explains the $C_d$ reduction from unity.
△ Less
Submitted 18 March, 2024;
originally announced March 2024.
-
Estimating scalar turbulent fluxes with slow response sensors in the stable atmospheric boundary layer
Authors:
Mohammad Allouche,
Vladislav I. Sevostianov,
Einara Zahn,
Mark Zondlo,
Nelson Luís Dias,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Jose D. Fuentes,
Elie Bou-Zeid
Abstract:
Conventional and recently developed approaches for estimating turbulent scalar fluxes under stable conditions are evaluated. The focus is on methods that do not require fast scalar sensors such as the relaxed eddy accumulation (REA) approach, the disjunct eddy-covariance (DEC) approach, and a novel mixing length parametrization labelled as A22. Using high-frequency measurements collected from two…
▽ More
Conventional and recently developed approaches for estimating turbulent scalar fluxes under stable conditions are evaluated. The focus is on methods that do not require fast scalar sensors such as the relaxed eddy accumulation (REA) approach, the disjunct eddy-covariance (DEC) approach, and a novel mixing length parametrization labelled as A22. Using high-frequency measurements collected from two contrasting sites (Utqiagvik, Alaska and Wendell, Idaho "during winter"), it is shown that the REA and A22 models outperform the conventional Monin-Obukhov Similarity Theory (MOST) utilized in Earth System Models. With slow trace gas sensors used in disjunct eddy-covariance (DEC) approaches and the more complex signal filtering associated with REA devices (here simulated using filtered signals from fast-response sensors), A22 outperforms REA and DEC in predicting the observed unfiltered (total) eddy-covariance (EC) fluxes. However, REA and DEC can still capture the observed filtered EC fluxes computed with the filtered scalar signal. This finding motivates the development of a correction, blending the REA and DEC methods, for the underestimated net averaged fluxes to incorporate the effect of sensor filtering. The only needed parameter for this correction is the mean velocity at the instrument height, a surrogate of the advective timescale.
△ Less
Submitted 22 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Logarithmic scaling of higher-order temperature moments in the atmospheric surface layer
Authors:
Kelly Y. Huang,
Matt K. Fu,
Clayton P. Byers,
Andrew D. Bragg,
Gabriel G. Katul
Abstract:
A generalized logarithmic law for high-order moments of passive scalars is proposed for turbulent boundary layers. This law is analogous to the generalized log law that has been proposed for high-order moments of the turbulent longitudinal velocity and is derived by combining the random swee** decorrelation hypothesis with a spectral model informed by the attached eddy hypothesis. The proposed t…
▽ More
A generalized logarithmic law for high-order moments of passive scalars is proposed for turbulent boundary layers. This law is analogous to the generalized log law that has been proposed for high-order moments of the turbulent longitudinal velocity and is derived by combining the random swee** decorrelation hypothesis with a spectral model informed by the attached eddy hypothesis. The proposed theory predicts that the high-order moments of passive scalar fluctuations within the inertial sublayer will vary logarithmically with wall-normal distance ($z$). The proposed theory is evaluated using high frequency time-series measurements of temperature and streamwise velocity fluctuations obtained in the first meter of the atmospheric surface layer (ASL) under near-neutral thermal stratification. The logarithmic dependence with $z$ within the inertial sublayer is observed in both the air temperature and velocity moments, with good agreement to the predictions from the proposed theory. Surprisingly, the proposed theory appears to be as, if not more, valid for transported passive scalars than for the longitudinal velocity.
△ Less
Submitted 9 December, 2022;
originally announced December 2022.
-
Turbulence organization and mean profile shapes in the stably stratified boundary layer: zones of uniform momentum and air temperature
Authors:
Michael Heisel,
Peter P Sullivan,
Gabriel G Katul,
Marcelo Chamecki
Abstract:
A persistent spatial organization of eddies is identified in the lowest portion of the stably-stratified planetary boundary layer. The analysis uses flow realizations from published large-eddy simulations (Sullivan et al., J Atmos Sci 73(4):1815-1840, 2016) ranging in stability from neutral to nearly z-less stratification. The coherent turbulent structure is well approximated as a series of unifor…
▽ More
A persistent spatial organization of eddies is identified in the lowest portion of the stably-stratified planetary boundary layer. The analysis uses flow realizations from published large-eddy simulations (Sullivan et al., J Atmos Sci 73(4):1815-1840, 2016) ranging in stability from neutral to nearly z-less stratification. The coherent turbulent structure is well approximated as a series of uniform momentum zones (UMZs) and uniform temperature zones (UTZs) separated by thin layers of intense gradients that are significantly greater than the mean. This pattern yields stairstep-like instantaneous flow profiles whose shape is distinct from the mean profiles that emerge from long-term averaging. However, the scaling of the stairstep organization is closely related to the resulting mean profiles. The differences in velocity and temperature across the thin gradient layers remain proportional to the surface momentum and heat flux conditions regardless of stratification. The vertical thickness of UMZs and UTZs is proportional to height above the surface for neutral and weak stratification, but becomes thinner and less dependent on height as the stability increases. Deviations from the logarithmic mean profiles for velocity and temperature observed under neutral conditions are therefore predominately due to the reduction in zone size with increasing stratification, which is empirically captured by existing Monin-Obukhov similarity relations for momentum and heat. The zone properties are additionally used to explain trends in the turbulent Prandtl number, thus providing a connection between the eddy organization, mean profiles, and turbulent diffusivity in stably stratified conditions.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Self-similar geometries within the inertial subrange of scales in boundary layer turbulence
Authors:
Michael Heisel,
Charitha M. de Silva,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Marcelo Chamecki
Abstract:
The inertial subrange of turbulent scales is commonly reflected by a power law signature in ensemble statistics such as the energy spectrum and structure functions - both in theory and from observations. Despite promising findings on the topic of fractal geometries in turbulence, there is no accepted image for the physical flow features corresponding to this statistical signature in the inertial s…
▽ More
The inertial subrange of turbulent scales is commonly reflected by a power law signature in ensemble statistics such as the energy spectrum and structure functions - both in theory and from observations. Despite promising findings on the topic of fractal geometries in turbulence, there is no accepted image for the physical flow features corresponding to this statistical signature in the inertial subrange. The present study uses boundary layer turbulence measurements to evaluate the self-similar geometric properties of velocity isosurfaces and investigate their influence on statistics for the velocity signal. The fractal dimension of streamwise velocity isosurfaces, indicating statistical self-similarity in the size of "wrinkles" along each isosurface, is shown to be constant only within the inertial subrange of scales. For the transition between the inertial subrange and production range, it is inferred that the largest wrinkles become increasingly confined by the overall size of large-scale coherent velocity regions such as uniform momentum zones. The self-similarity of isosurfaces yields power law trends in subsequent one-dimensional statistics. For instance, the theoretical 2/3 power law exponent for the structure function can be recovered by considering the collective behavior of numerous isosurface level sets. The results suggest that the physical presence of inertial subrange eddies is manifested in the self-similar wrinkles of isosurfaces.
△ Less
Submitted 5 May, 2022; v1 submitted 29 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
The speed of breaking waves controls sea surface drag
Authors:
Alex Ayet,
Bertrand Chapron,
Peter Sutherland,
Gabriel G. Katul
Abstract:
The coupling between wind-waves and atmospheric surface layer turbulence sets surface drag. This coupling is however usually represented through a roughness length. Originally suggested on purely dimensional grounds, this roughness length does not directly correspond to a measurable physical quantity of the wind-and-wave system. Here, to go beyond this representation, we formalize ideas underlying…
▽ More
The coupling between wind-waves and atmospheric surface layer turbulence sets surface drag. This coupling is however usually represented through a roughness length. Originally suggested on purely dimensional grounds, this roughness length does not directly correspond to a measurable physical quantity of the wind-and-wave system. Here, to go beyond this representation, we formalize ideas underlying the Beaufort scale by quantifying the velocity of breaking short waves that are the most coupled to near-surface wind. This velocity increases with wind speed, reflecting the fact that stronger winds can be visually identified by longer (and faster) breakers becoming predominant on the sea surface. A phenomenological turbulence model further shows that this velocity is associated with breaking waves that impede the most the formation of turbulent eddies. Scales of such eddies are then constrained inside a so-called roughness sub-layer. Unlike previous theoretical developments, the proposed breaker velocity is a directly measurable quantity, which could be used to characterize the coupling between wind and waves using remote sensing techniques. This work provides a physical framework for new formulations of air-sea momentum exchange in which the effects of surface currents and slicks on surface drag can also be incorporated. Finally, it provides a long-sought physical explanation for the Beaufort scale: a universal link between wave breaking, wind speed and surface drag.
△ Less
Submitted 11 March, 2021;
originally announced March 2021.
-
First passage time statistics of Brownian motion with purely time dependent drift and diffusion
Authors:
Annalisa Molini,
Peter Talkner,
Gabriel G. Katul,
Amilcare Porporato
Abstract:
Systems where resource availability approaches a critical threshold are common to many engineering and scientific applications and often necessitate the estimation of first passage time statistics of a Brownian motion (Bm) driven by time-dependent drift and diffusion coefficients. Modeling such systems requires solving the associated Fokker-Planck equation subject to an absorbing barrier. Transiti…
▽ More
Systems where resource availability approaches a critical threshold are common to many engineering and scientific applications and often necessitate the estimation of first passage time statistics of a Brownian motion (Bm) driven by time-dependent drift and diffusion coefficients. Modeling such systems requires solving the associated Fokker-Planck equation subject to an absorbing barrier. Transitional probabilities are derived via the method of images, whose applicability to time dependent problems is shown to be limited to state-independent drift and diffusion coefficients that only depend on time and are proportional to each other. First passage time statistics, such as the survival probabilities and first passage time densities are obtained analytically. The analysis includes the study of different functional forms of the time dependent drift and diffusion, including power-law time dependence and different periodic drivers. As a case study of these theoretical results, a stochastic model for water availability from surface runoff in snowmelt dominated regions is presented, where both temperature effects and snow-precipitation input are incorporated.
△ Less
Submitted 4 April, 2011; v1 submitted 2 September, 2010;
originally announced September 2010.
