-
Effects of rotation and surface forcing on deep stellar convection zones
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä
Abstract:
The canonical undestanding of stellar convection has recently been put under doubt due to helioseismic results and global 3D convection simulations. This "convective conundrum" is manifested by much higher velocity amplitudes in simulations at large scales in comparison to helioseismic results, and the difficulty in reproducing the solar differential rotation and dynamo with global 3D simulations.…
▽ More
The canonical undestanding of stellar convection has recently been put under doubt due to helioseismic results and global 3D convection simulations. This "convective conundrum" is manifested by much higher velocity amplitudes in simulations at large scales in comparison to helioseismic results, and the difficulty in reproducing the solar differential rotation and dynamo with global 3D simulations. Here some aspects of this conundrum are discussed from the viewpoint of hydrodynamic Cartesian 3D simulations targeted at testing the rotational influence and surface forcing on deep convection. More specifically, the dominant scale of convection and the depths of the convection zone and the weakly subadiabatic -- yet convecting -- Deardorff zone are discussed in detail.
△ Less
Submitted 15 November, 2023;
originally announced November 2023.
-
Turbulent Prandtl number from isotropically forced turbulence
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä,
Nishant K. Singh
Abstract:
Turbulent motions enhance the diffusion of large-scale flows and temperature gradients. Such diffusion is often parameterized by coefficients of turbulent viscosity ($ν_{\rm t}$) and turbulent thermal diffusivity ($χ_{\rm t}$) that are analogous to their microscopic counterparts. We compute the turbulent diffusion coefficients by imposing large-scale velocity and temperature gradients on a turbule…
▽ More
Turbulent motions enhance the diffusion of large-scale flows and temperature gradients. Such diffusion is often parameterized by coefficients of turbulent viscosity ($ν_{\rm t}$) and turbulent thermal diffusivity ($χ_{\rm t}$) that are analogous to their microscopic counterparts. We compute the turbulent diffusion coefficients by imposing large-scale velocity and temperature gradients on a turbulent flow and measuring the response of the system. We also confirm our results using experiments where the imposed gradients are allowed to decay. To achieve this, we use weakly compressible three-dimensional hydrodynamic simulations of isotropically forced homogeneous turbulence. We find that the turbulent viscosity and thermal diffusion, as well as their ratio the turbulent Prandtl number, ${\rm Pr}_{\rm t} = ν_{\rm t}/χ_{\rm t}$, approach asymptotic values at sufficiently high Reynolds and Peclét numbers. We also do not find a significant dependence of ${\rm Pr}_{\rm t}$ on the microscopic Prandtl number ${\rm Pr} = ν/χ$. These findings are in stark contrast to results from the $k-ε$ model which suggests that ${\rm Pr}_{\rm t}$ increases monotonically with decreasing ${\rm Pr}$. The current results are relevant for the ongoing debate of, for example, the nature of the turbulent flows in the very low ${\rm Pr}$ regimes of stellar convection zones.
△ Less
Submitted 21 July, 2022;
originally announced July 2022.
-
Prandtl number dependence of compressible convection: Flow statistics and convective energy transport
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä
Abstract:
(abridged) Context: The ratio of kinematic viscosity to thermal diffusivity, the Prandtl number, is much smaller than unity in stellar convection zones. Aims: To study the statistics of convective flows and energy transport as functions of the Prandtl number. Methods: Three-dimensional numerical simulations convection in Cartesian geometry are used. The convection zone (CZ) is embedded between two…
▽ More
(abridged) Context: The ratio of kinematic viscosity to thermal diffusivity, the Prandtl number, is much smaller than unity in stellar convection zones. Aims: To study the statistics of convective flows and energy transport as functions of the Prandtl number. Methods: Three-dimensional numerical simulations convection in Cartesian geometry are used. The convection zone (CZ) is embedded between two stably stratified layers. Statistics and transport properties of up- and downflows are studied separately. Results: The rms velocity increases with decreasing Prandtl number. At the same time the filling factor of downflows decreases and leads to stronger downflows at lower Prandtl numbers, and to a strong dependence of overshooting on the Prandtl number. Velocity power spectra do not show marked changes as a function of Prandtl number. At the highest Reynolds numbers the velocity power spectra are compatible with the Bolgiano-Obukhov $k^{-11/5}$ scaling. The horizontally averaged convected energy flux ($\overline{F}_{\rm conv}$) is independent of the Prandtl number within the CZ. However, the upflows (downflows) are the dominant contribution to the convected flux at low (high) Prandtl number. These results are similar to those from Rayleigh-Benárd convection in the low Prandtl number regime where convection is vigorously turbulent but inefficient at transporting energy. Conclusions: The current results indicate a strong dependence of convective overshooting and energy flux on the Prandtl number. Numerical simulations of astrophysical convection often use Prandtl number of unity. The current results suggest that this can lead to misleading results and that the astrophysically relevant low Prandtl number regime is qualitatively different from the parameters regimes explored in typical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 18 May, 2021;
originally announced May 2021.
-
Generation of mean flows in rotating anisotropic turbulence: The case of solar near-surface shear layer
Authors:
A. Barekat,
M. J. Käpylä,
P. J. Käpylä,
E. P. Gilson,
H. Ji
Abstract:
The radial gradient of the rotation rate in the near-surface shear layer (NSSL) of the Sun is independent of latitude and radius. Theoretical mean-field models have been successful in explaining this property of the solar NSSL, while global direct convection models have been unsuccessful. We investigate reason for this discrepancy by measuring the mean flows, Reynolds stress, and turbulent transpo…
▽ More
The radial gradient of the rotation rate in the near-surface shear layer (NSSL) of the Sun is independent of latitude and radius. Theoretical mean-field models have been successful in explaining this property of the solar NSSL, while global direct convection models have been unsuccessful. We investigate reason for this discrepancy by measuring the mean flows, Reynolds stress, and turbulent transport coefficients under NSSL conditions. Simulations have minimal ingredients. These ingredients are inhomogeneity due to boundaries, anisotropic turbulence, and rotation. Parameters of the simulations are chosen such they match the weakly rotationally constrained NSSL. The simulations probe locally Cartesian patches of the star at a given depth and latitude. The depth of the patch is varied by changing the rotation rate such that the resulting Coriolis numbers<1. We measure the turbulent transport coefficient relevant for the non-diffusive and diffusive parts of the Reynolds stress and compare them with predictions of current mean-field theories. A negative radial gradient of mean flow similar to the solar NSSL is generated only at the equator where meridional flows are absent. At other latitudes the meridional flow is comparable to the mean flow corresponding to differential rotation. We also find that meridional components of the Reynolds stress cannot be ignored. Additionally, we find that the turbulent viscosity is quenched by rotation by about 50\% from the surface to the bottom of the NSSL. Our local simulations do not validate the explanation for the generation of the NSSL from mean-field theory where meridional stresses are neglected. However, the rotational dependence of turbulent viscosity in our simulations is in good agreement with theoretical prediction. Our results are in qualitative agreement with global convection simulations in that a NSSL obtained near the equator.
△ Less
Submitted 10 December, 2020;
originally announced December 2020.
-
The Pencil Code, a modular MPI code for partial differential equations and particles: multipurpose and multiuser-maintained
Authors:
A. Brandenburg,
A. Johansen,
P. A. Bourdin,
W. Dobler,
W. Lyra,
M. Rheinhardt,
S. Bingert,
N. E. L. Haugen,
A. Mee,
F. Gent,
N. Babkovskaia,
C. -C. Yang,
T. Heinemann,
B. Dintrans,
D. Mitra,
S. Candelaresi,
J. Warnecke,
P. J. Käpylä,
A. Schreiber,
P. Chatterjee,
M. J. Käpylä,
X. -Y. Li,
J. Krüger,
J. R. Aarnes,
G. R. Sarson
, et al. (12 additional authors not shown)
Abstract:
The Pencil Code is a highly modular physics-oriented simulation code that can be adapted to a wide range of applications. It is primarily designed to solve partial differential equations (PDEs) of compressible hydrodynamics and has lots of add-ons ranging from astrophysical magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) to meteorological cloud microphysics and engineering applications in combustion. Nevertheless, the…
▽ More
The Pencil Code is a highly modular physics-oriented simulation code that can be adapted to a wide range of applications. It is primarily designed to solve partial differential equations (PDEs) of compressible hydrodynamics and has lots of add-ons ranging from astrophysical magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) to meteorological cloud microphysics and engineering applications in combustion. Nevertheless, the framework is general and can also be applied to situations not related to hydrodynamics or even PDEs, for example when just the message passing interface or input/output strategies of the code are to be used. The code can also evolve Lagrangian (inertial and noninertial) particles, their coagulation and condensation, as well as their interaction with the fluid.
△ Less
Submitted 17 September, 2020;
originally announced September 2020.
-
Electrodynamics of turbulent fluids with fluctuating electric conductivity
Authors:
G. Rüdiger,
M. Küker,
P. J. Käpylä
Abstract:
The influence of fluctuating conductivity on the coefficients known from the mean-field electrodynamics is considered. If the conductivity fluctuations are assumed as uncorrelated with the turbulent velocity field then only the effective magnetic diffusivity of the fluid is reduced and the decay time of a large-scale magnetic field is increased. If the fluctuations of conductivity and flow are cor…
▽ More
The influence of fluctuating conductivity on the coefficients known from the mean-field electrodynamics is considered. If the conductivity fluctuations are assumed as uncorrelated with the turbulent velocity field then only the effective magnetic diffusivity of the fluid is reduced and the decay time of a large-scale magnetic field is increased. If the fluctuations of conductivity and flow are correlated in a certain direction then an additional diamagnetic pum** effect results transporting magnetic field in opposite direction to the resistivity flux vector $\langle η'\vec{u}'\rangle$. Even for homogeneous turbulence fields in the presence of rotation an alpha effect appears. With the characteristic values of the outer core of the Earth or the solar convection zone, however, the dynamo number of the alpha effect never reaches supercritical values to operate as an $α^2$-dynamo.
△ Less
Submitted 19 June, 2020; v1 submitted 31 October, 2019;
originally announced November 2019.
-
Effects of small-scale dynamo and compressibility on the $Λ$ effect
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä
Abstract:
The $Λ$ effect describes a rotation-induced non-diffusive contribution to the Reynolds stress. It is commonly held responsible for maintaining the observed differential rotation of the Sun and other late-type stars. Here the sensitivity of the $Λ$ effect to small-scale magnetic fields and compressibility is studied by means of forced turbulence simulations either with anisotropic forcing in fully…
▽ More
The $Λ$ effect describes a rotation-induced non-diffusive contribution to the Reynolds stress. It is commonly held responsible for maintaining the observed differential rotation of the Sun and other late-type stars. Here the sensitivity of the $Λ$ effect to small-scale magnetic fields and compressibility is studied by means of forced turbulence simulations either with anisotropic forcing in fully periodic cubes or in density-stratified domains with isotropic forcing. Effects of small-scale magnetic fields are studied in cases where the magnetic fields are self-consistently generated by a small-scale dynamo. The results show that small-scale magnetic fields lead to a quenching of the $Λ$ effect which is milder than in cases where also a large-scale field is present. The effect of compressibility on the $Λ$ effect is negligible in the range of Mach numbers from 0.015 to 0.8. Density stratification induces a marked anisotropy in the turbulence and a vertical $Λ$ effect if the forcing scale is roughly two times larger than the density scale height.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2020; v1 submitted 11 March, 2019;
originally announced March 2019.
-
Turbulent viscosity and effective magnetic Prandtl number from simulations of isotropically forced turbulence
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä,
Matthias Rheinhardt,
Axel Brandenburg,
Maarit J. Käpylä
Abstract:
(abridged) Context: Turbulent diffusion of large-scale flows and magnetic fields play major roles in many astrophysical systems. Aims: Our goal is to compute turbulent viscosity and magnetic diffusivity, relevant for diffusing large-scale flows and magnetic fields, respectively, and their ratio, the turbulent magnetic Prandtl number, ${\rm Pm}_{\rm t}$, for isotropically forced homogeneous turbule…
▽ More
(abridged) Context: Turbulent diffusion of large-scale flows and magnetic fields play major roles in many astrophysical systems. Aims: Our goal is to compute turbulent viscosity and magnetic diffusivity, relevant for diffusing large-scale flows and magnetic fields, respectively, and their ratio, the turbulent magnetic Prandtl number, ${\rm Pm}_{\rm t}$, for isotropically forced homogeneous turbulence. Methods: We use simulations of forced turbulence in fully periodic cubes composed of isothermal gas with an imposed large-scale sinusoidal shear flow. Turbulent viscosity is computed either from the resulting Reynolds stress or from the decay rate of the large-scale flow. Turbulent magnetic diffusivity is computed using the test-field method. The scale dependence of the coefficients is studied by varying the wavenumber of the imposed sinusoidal shear and test fields. Results: We find that turbulent viscosity and magnetic diffusivity are in general of the same order of magnitude. Furthermore, the turbulent viscosity depends on the fluid Reynolds number (${\rm Re}$) and scale separation ratio of turbulence. The scale dependence of the turbulent viscosity is found to be well approximated by a Lorentzian. The results for the turbulent transport coefficients appear to converge at sufficiently high values of ${\rm Re}$ and the scale separation ratio. However, a weak decreasing trend is found even at the largest values of ${\rm Re}$. The turbulent magnetic Prandtl number converges to a value that is slightly below unity for large ${\rm Re}$ whereas for small ${\rm Re}$, we find values between 0.5 and 0.6. Conclusions: The turbulent magnetic diffusivity is in general consistently higher than the turbulent viscosity. The actual value of ${\rm Pm}_{\rm t}$ found from the simulations ($\approx0.9\ldots0.95$) at large ${\rm Re}$ and scale separation ratio is higher than any of the analytic predictions.
△ Less
Submitted 17 February, 2020; v1 submitted 3 January, 2019;
originally announced January 2019.
-
Small-scale dynamos in simulations of stratified turbulent convection
Authors:
Petri J. Käpylä,
Maarit J. Käpylä,
Axel Brandenburg
Abstract:
Small-scale dynamo action is often held responsible for the generation of quiet-Sun magnetic fields. We aim to determine the excitation conditions and saturation level of small-scale dynamos in non-rotating turbulent convection at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. We use high resolution direct numerical simulations of weakly stratified turbulent convection. We find that the critical magnetic Reynolds…
▽ More
Small-scale dynamo action is often held responsible for the generation of quiet-Sun magnetic fields. We aim to determine the excitation conditions and saturation level of small-scale dynamos in non-rotating turbulent convection at low magnetic Prandtl numbers. We use high resolution direct numerical simulations of weakly stratified turbulent convection. We find that the critical magnetic Reynolds number for dynamo excitation increases as the magnetic Prandtl number is decreased, which might suggest that small-scale dynamo action is not automatically evident in bodies with small magnetic Prandtl numbers as the Sun. As a function of the magnetic Reynolds number (${\rm Rm}$), the growth rate of the dynamo is consistent with an ${\rm Rm}^{1/2}$ scaling. No evidence for a logarithmic increase of the growth rate with ${\rm Rm}$ is found.
△ Less
Submitted 26 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.
-
Large-scale dynamos in rapidly rotating plane layer convection
Authors:
P. J. Bushby,
P. J. Käpylä,
Y. Masada,
A. Brandenburg,
B. Favier,
C. Guervilly,
M. J. Käpylä
Abstract:
Context: Convectively-driven flows play a crucial role in the dynamo processes that are responsible for producing magnetic activity in stars and planets. It is still not fully understood why many astrophysical magnetic fields have a significant large-scale component. Aims: Our aim is to investigate the dynamo properties of compressible convection in a rapidly rotating Cartesian domain, focusing up…
▽ More
Context: Convectively-driven flows play a crucial role in the dynamo processes that are responsible for producing magnetic activity in stars and planets. It is still not fully understood why many astrophysical magnetic fields have a significant large-scale component. Aims: Our aim is to investigate the dynamo properties of compressible convection in a rapidly rotating Cartesian domain, focusing upon a parameter regime in which the underlying hydrodynamic flow is known to be unstable to a large-scale vortex instability. Methods: The governing equations of three-dimensional nonlinear magnetohydrodynamics (MHD) are solved numerically. Different numerical schemes are compared and we propose a possible benchmark case for other similar codes. Results: In kee** with previous related studies, we find that convection in this parameter regime can drive a large-scale dynamo. The components of the mean horizontal magnetic field oscillate, leading to a continuous overall rotation of the mean field. Whilst the large-scale vortex instability dominates the early evolution of the system, it is suppressed by the magnetic field and makes a negligible contribution to the mean electromotive force that is responsible for driving the large-scale dynamo. The cycle period of the dynamo is comparable to the ohmic decay time, with longer cycles for dynamos in convective systems that are closer to onset. In these particular simulations, large-scale dynamo action is found only when vertical magnetic field boundary conditions are adopted at the upper and lower boundaries. Strongly modulated large-scale dynamos are found at higher Rayleigh numbers, with periods of reduced activity ("grand minima"-like events) occurring during transient phases in which the large-scale vortex temporarily re-establishes itself, before being suppressed again by the magnetic field.
△ Less
Submitted 15 January, 2018; v1 submitted 9 October, 2017;
originally announced October 2017.
-
Methods for compressible fluid simulation on GPUs using high-order finite differences
Authors:
Johannes Pekkilä,
Miikka S. Väisälä,
Maarit J. Käpylä,
Petri J. Käpylä,
Omer Anjum
Abstract:
We focus on implementing and optimizing a sixth-order finite-difference solver for simulating compressible fluids on a GPU using third-order Runge-Kutta integration. Since graphics processing units perform well in data-parallel tasks, this makes them an attractive platform for fluid simulation. However, high-order stencil computation is memory-intensive with respect to both main memory and the cac…
▽ More
We focus on implementing and optimizing a sixth-order finite-difference solver for simulating compressible fluids on a GPU using third-order Runge-Kutta integration. Since graphics processing units perform well in data-parallel tasks, this makes them an attractive platform for fluid simulation. However, high-order stencil computation is memory-intensive with respect to both main memory and the caches of the GPU. We present two approaches for simulating compressible fluids using 55-point and 19-point stencils. We seek to reduce the requirements for memory bandwidth and cache size in our methods by using cache blocking and decomposing a latency-bound kernel into several bandwidth-bound kernels. Our fastest implementation is bandwidth-bound and integrates $343$ million grid points per second on a Tesla K40t GPU, achieving a $3.6 \times$ speedup over a comparable hydrodynamics solver benchmarked on two Intel Xeon E5-2690v3 processors. Our alternative GPU implementation is latency-bound and achieves the rate of $168$ million updates per second.
△ Less
Submitted 27 July, 2017;
originally announced July 2017.
-
Robustness of oscillatory $α^2$ dynamos in spherical wedges
Authors:
E. Cole,
A. Brandenburg,
P. J. Käpylä,
M. J. Käpylä
Abstract:
We study the connection between spherical wedge and full spherical shell geometries using simple mean-field $α^2$ dynamos. We solve the equations for a one-dimensional time-dependent mean-field dynamo to examine the effects of varying the polar angle $θ_0$ between the latitudinal boundaries and the poles in spherical coordinates. We investigate the effects of turbulent magnetic diffusivity and…
▽ More
We study the connection between spherical wedge and full spherical shell geometries using simple mean-field $α^2$ dynamos. We solve the equations for a one-dimensional time-dependent mean-field dynamo to examine the effects of varying the polar angle $θ_0$ between the latitudinal boundaries and the poles in spherical coordinates. We investigate the effects of turbulent magnetic diffusivity and $α$ effect profiles as well as different latitudinal boundary conditions to isolate parameter regimes where oscillatory solutions are found. Finally, we add shear along with a dam** term mimicking radial gradients to study the resulting dynamo regimes. We find that the commonly used perfect conductor boundary condition leads to oscillatory $α^2$ dynamo solutions only if the wedge boundary is at least one degree away from the poles. Other boundary conditions always produce stationary solutions. By varying the profile of the turbulent magnetic diffusivity alone, oscillatory solutions are achieved with models extending to the poles, but the magnetic field is strongly concentrated near the poles and the oscillation period is very long. By introducing radial shear and a dam** term mimicking radial gradients, we again see oscillatory dynamos, and the direction of drift follows the Parker--Yoshimura rule. Oscillatory solutions in the weak shear regime are found only in the wedge case with $θ_0 = 1^\circ$ and perfect conductor boundaries. A reduced $α$ effect near the poles with a turbulent diffusivity concentrated toward the equator yields oscillatory dynamos with equatorward migration and reproduces best the solutions in spherical wedges.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2016;
originally announced January 2016.
-
Mean-field closure parameters for passive scalar turbulence
Authors:
J. E. Snellman,
M. Rheinhardt,
P. J. Käpylä,
M. J. Mantere,
A. Brandenburg
Abstract:
Direct numerical simulations of isotropically forced homogeneous stationary turbulence with an imposed passive scalar concentration gradient are compared with an analytical closure model which provides evolution equations for the mean passive scalar flux and variance. Triple correlations of fluctuations appearing in these equations are described in terms of relaxation terms proportional to the qua…
▽ More
Direct numerical simulations of isotropically forced homogeneous stationary turbulence with an imposed passive scalar concentration gradient are compared with an analytical closure model which provides evolution equations for the mean passive scalar flux and variance. Triple correlations of fluctuations appearing in these equations are described in terms of relaxation terms proportional to the quadratic correlations. Three methods are used to extract the relaxation timescales tau_i from direct numerical simulations. Firstly, we insert the closure ansatz into our equations, assume stationarity, and solve for tau_i. Secondly, we use only the closure ansatz itself and obtain tau_i from the ratio of quadratic and triple correlations. Thirdly we remove the imposed passive scalar gradient and fit an exponential decay law to the solution.
We vary the Reynolds (Re) and Péclet (Pe) numbers while kee** their ratio at unity and the degree of scale separation and find for large Re fair correspondence between the different methods. The ratio of the turbulent relaxation time of passive scalar flux to the turnover time of turbulent eddies is of the order of three, which is in remarkable agreement with earlier work. Finally we make an effort to extract the relaxation timescales relevant for the viscous and diffusive effects. We find two regimes which are valid for small and large Re, respectively, but the dependence of the parameters on scale separation suggests that they are not universal.
△ Less
Submitted 20 December, 2011;
originally announced December 2011.
-
Lambda-effect from forced turbulence simulations
Authors:
P. J. Käpylä,
A. Brandenburg
Abstract:
Aims: We determine the components of the $Λ$-effect tensor that quantifies the contributions to the turbulent momentum transport even for uniform rotation. Methods: Three-dimensional numerical simulations are used to study turbulent transport in triply periodic cubes under the influence of rotation and anisotropic forcing. Comparison is made with analytical results obtained via the so-called min…
▽ More
Aims: We determine the components of the $Λ$-effect tensor that quantifies the contributions to the turbulent momentum transport even for uniform rotation. Methods: Three-dimensional numerical simulations are used to study turbulent transport in triply periodic cubes under the influence of rotation and anisotropic forcing. Comparison is made with analytical results obtained via the so-called minimal tau-approximation. Results: In the case where the turbulence intensity in the vertical direction dominates, the vertical stress is always negative. This situation is expected to occur in stellar convection zones. The horizontal component of the stress is weaker and exhibits a maximum at latitude 30 degrees - regardless of how rapid the rotation is. The minimal tau-approximation captures many of the qualitative features of the numerical results, provided the relaxation time tau is close to the turnover time, i.e. the Strouhal number is of order unity.
△ Less
Submitted 24 June, 2008;
originally announced June 2008.
