-
A Beam Monitor for Ion Beam Therapy based on HV-CMOS Pixel Detectors
Authors:
Matthias Balzer,
Alexander Dierlamm,
Felix Ehrler,
Ulrich Husemann,
Roland Koppenhöfer,
Ivan Perić,
Martin Pittermann,
Bogdan Topko,
Alena Weber,
Stephan Brons,
Jürgen Debus,
Nicole Grau,
Thomas Hansmann,
Oliver Jäkel,
Sebastian Klüter,
Jakob Naumann
Abstract:
Particle therapy is a well established clinical treatment of tumors. More than one hundred particle therapy centers are in operation world wide. The advantage of using hadrons like protons or carbon ions as particles for tumor irradiation is the distinct peak in the depth dependent energy deposition, which can be exploited to accurately deposit dose in the tumor cells. To guarantee this, high accu…
▽ More
Particle therapy is a well established clinical treatment of tumors. More than one hundred particle therapy centers are in operation world wide. The advantage of using hadrons like protons or carbon ions as particles for tumor irradiation is the distinct peak in the depth dependent energy deposition, which can be exploited to accurately deposit dose in the tumor cells. To guarantee this, high accuracy of monitoring and control of the particle beam is of utmost importance. Before the particle beam enters the patient, it traverses a monitoring system which has to give fast feedback to the beam control system on position and dose rate of the beam while minimally interacting with the beam. The multi-wire chambers mostly used as beam position monitor have their limitations when fast response time is required (drift time). Future developments like MRI-guided ion beam therapy pose additional challenges for the beam monitoring system like tolerance of magnetic fields and acoustic noise (vibrations). Solid-state detectors promise to overcome these limitations and the higher resolution they offer can create additional benefits. This article presents the evaluation of an HV-CMOS detector for beam monitoring, provides results from feasibility studies in a therapeutic beam and summarizes the concepts towards the final large-scale assembly and readout system.
△ Less
Submitted 11 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Multivariate error modeling and uncertainty quantification using importance (re-)weighting for Monte Carlo simulations in particle transport
Authors:
Pia Stammer,
Lucas Burigo,
Oliver Jäkel,
Martin Frank,
Niklas Wahl
Abstract:
Fast and accurate predictions of uncertainties in the computed dose are crucial for the determination of robust treatment plans in radiation therapy. This requires the solution of particle transport problems with uncertain parameters or initial conditions. Monte Carlo methods are often used to solve transport problems especially for applications which require high accuracy. In these cases, common…
▽ More
Fast and accurate predictions of uncertainties in the computed dose are crucial for the determination of robust treatment plans in radiation therapy. This requires the solution of particle transport problems with uncertain parameters or initial conditions. Monte Carlo methods are often used to solve transport problems especially for applications which require high accuracy. In these cases, common non-intrusive solution strategies that involve repeated simulations of the problem at different points in the parameter space quickly become infeasible due to their long run-times. Intrusive methods however limit the usability in combination with proprietary simulation engines. In our previous paper [51], we demonstrated the application of a new non-intrusive uncertainty quantification approach for Monte Carlo simulations in proton dose calculations with normally distributed errors on realistic patient data. In this paper, we introduce a generalized formulation and focus on a more in-depth theoretical analysis of this method concerning bias, error and convergence of the estimates. The multivariate input model of the proposed approach further supports almost arbitrary error correlation models. We demonstrate how this framework can be used to model and efficiently quantify complex auto-correlated and time-dependent errors.
△ Less
Submitted 15 February, 2022; v1 submitted 21 January, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Efficient uncertainty quantification for Monte Carlo dose calculations using importance (re-)weighting
Authors:
Pia Stammer,
Lucas Burigo,
Oliver Jäkel,
Martin Frank,
Niklas Wahl
Abstract:
The high precision and conformity of intensity-modulated particle therapy (IMPT) comes at the cost of susceptibility to treatment uncertainties in particle range and patient set-up. Dose uncertainty quantification and mitigation, which is usually based on sampled error scenarios, however becomes challenging when computing the dose with computationally expensive but accurate Monte Carlo (MC) simula…
▽ More
The high precision and conformity of intensity-modulated particle therapy (IMPT) comes at the cost of susceptibility to treatment uncertainties in particle range and patient set-up. Dose uncertainty quantification and mitigation, which is usually based on sampled error scenarios, however becomes challenging when computing the dose with computationally expensive but accurate Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. This paper introduces an importance (re-)weighting method in MC history scoring to concurrently construct estimates for error scenarios, the expected dose and its variance from a single set of MC simulated particle histories. The approach relies on a multivariate Gaussian input and uncertainty model, which assigns probabilities to the initial phase space sample, enabling the use of different correlation models. Exploring and adapting bivariate emittance parametrizations for the beam shape, accuracy can be traded between that of the uncertainty or the nominal dose estimate. The method was implemented using the MC code TOPAS and tested for proton IMPT plan delivery in comparison to a reference scenario estimate. We achieve accurate results for set-up uncertainties ($γ_{3mm/3\%} \geq 99.99\%$) and expectedly lower but still sufficient agreement for range uncertainties, which are approximated with uncertainty over the energy distribution ($γ_{3 mm/3\%} \geq 99.50\%$ ($E[\boldsymbol{d}]$), $γ_{3mm/3\%} \geq 91.69\%$ ($σ(\boldsymbol{d})$) ). Initial experiments on a water phantom, a prostate and a liver case show that the re-weighting approach lowers the CPU time by more than an order of magnitude. Further, we show that uncertainty induced by interplay and other dynamic influences may be approximated using suitable error correlation models.
△ Less
Submitted 22 June, 2021;
originally announced June 2021.
-
Quantitative read-out of Al2O3:C,Mg-based fluorescent nuclear track detectors using a commercial confocal microscope
Authors:
Steffen Greilich,
Julia-Maria Osinga,
Martin Niklas,
Florian Lauer,
Felix Bestvater,
Oliver Jäkel
Abstract:
Fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTD) show great potential for applications in ion-beam therapy research, such as dosimetry, advanced beam characterization, in-vivo use or as radiobiological assay. A essential feature of FNTDs is their ability to assess the energy loss of single ions yielding for example LET estimations. This article describes the basic characterisations of FNTDs and our read…
▽ More
Fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTD) show great potential for applications in ion-beam therapy research, such as dosimetry, advanced beam characterization, in-vivo use or as radiobiological assay. A essential feature of FNTDs is their ability to assess the energy loss of single ions yielding for example LET estimations. This article describes the basic characterisations of FNTDs and our read-out system (a Zeiss LSM710 confocal laser scanning microscope) to enable quantative measurements of energy loss.
△ Less
Submitted 3 July, 2014;
originally announced July 2014.
-
Single track coincidence measurements of fluorescent and plastic nuclear track detectors in therapeutic carbon beams
Authors:
J. -M. Osinga,
I. Ambrožová,
K. Pachnerová Brabcová,
M. S. Akselrod,
O. Jäkel,
M. Davídková,
S. Greilich
Abstract:
In this paper we present a method for single track coincidence measurements using two different track detector materials. We employed plastic and fluorescent nuclear track detectors (PNTDs and FNTDs) in the entrance channel of a monoenergetic carbon ion beam covering the therapeutically useful energy range from 80 to 425 MeV/u. About 99 % of all primary particle tracks detected by both detectors w…
▽ More
In this paper we present a method for single track coincidence measurements using two different track detector materials. We employed plastic and fluorescent nuclear track detectors (PNTDs and FNTDs) in the entrance channel of a monoenergetic carbon ion beam covering the therapeutically useful energy range from 80 to 425 MeV/u. About 99 % of all primary particle tracks detected by both detectors were successfully matched, while 1 % of the particles were only detected by the FNTDs because of their superior spatial resolution. We conclude that both PNTDs and FNTDs are suitable for clinical carbon beam dosimetry with a detection efficiency of at least 98.82 % and 99.83 % respectively, if irradiations are performed with low fluence in the entrance channel of the ion beam. The investigated method can be adapted to other nuclear track detectors and offers the possibility to characterize new track detector materials against well-known detectors. Further, by combining two detectors with a restricted working range in the presented way a hybrid-detector system can be created with an extended and optimized working range.
△ Less
Submitted 24 January, 2014; v1 submitted 11 October, 2013;
originally announced October 2013.
-
Ion track reconstruction in 3D using alumina-based fluorescent nuclear track detectors
Authors:
Martin Niklas,
James A. Bartz,
Mark S. Akselrod,
Amir Abollahi,
Oliver Jäkel,
Steffen Greilich
Abstract:
Fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTDs) based on Al2O3:C,Mg single crystal combined with confocal microscopy provide 3D information on ion tracks with a resolution only limited by light diffraction. FNTDs are also ideal substrates to be coated with cells to engineer cell-fluorescent ion track hybrid detectors. This radiobiological tool enables a novel platform linking cell responses to physica…
▽ More
Fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTDs) based on Al2O3:C,Mg single crystal combined with confocal microscopy provide 3D information on ion tracks with a resolution only limited by light diffraction. FNTDs are also ideal substrates to be coated with cells to engineer cell-fluorescent ion track hybrid detectors. This radiobiological tool enables a novel platform linking cell responses to physical dose deposition on a sub-cellular level in proton and heavy ion therapies. To achieve spatial correlation between single ion hits in the cell coating and its biological response the ion traversals have to be reconstructed in 3D using the depth information gained by the FNTD read-out. FNTDs were coated with a confluent human lung adenocarcinoma epithelial cell layer. Carbon ion irradiation of the hybrid detector was performed perpendicular and angular to the detector surface. In-situ imaging of the fluorescently labeled cell layer and the FNTD was performed in a sequential read-out. Making use of the trajectory information provided by the FNTD the accuracy of 3D track reconstruction of single particles traversing the hybrid detector was studied. The accuracy is strongly influenced by the irradiation angle and therefore by complexity of the FNTD signal. Perpendicular irradiation results in highest accuracy with error of smaller than 0.10°. The ability of FNTD technology to provide accurate 3D ion track reconstruction makes it a powerful tool for radiobiological investigations in clinical ion beams, either being used as a substrate to be coated with living tissue or being implanted in vivo.
△ Less
Submitted 10 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Absorbed Dose in Ion Beams: Comparison of Ionisation and Fluence-based Measurements
Authors:
Julia-Maria Osinga,
Stephan Brons,
James A. Bartz,
Mark S. Akselrod,
Oliver Jäkel,
Steffen Greilich
Abstract:
A direct comparison measurement of fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTDs) and a thimble ionisation chamber is presented. Irradiations were performed using monoenergetic protons (142.66 MeV, 3*10^6 1/cm2) and carbon ions (270.55 MeV/u, 3*10^6 1/cm2). It was found that absorbed dose to water values as determined by fluence measurements using FNTDs are, in case of protons, in good agreement (2.4…
▽ More
A direct comparison measurement of fluorescent nuclear track detectors (FNTDs) and a thimble ionisation chamber is presented. Irradiations were performed using monoenergetic protons (142.66 MeV, 3*10^6 1/cm2) and carbon ions (270.55 MeV/u, 3*10^6 1/cm2). It was found that absorbed dose to water values as determined by fluence measurements using FNTDs are, in case of protons, in good agreement (2.4 %) with ionization chamber measurements, if slower protons and Helium secondaries were accounted for by an effective stop** power. For carbon, however, a significant discrepancy of 4.5 % was seen, which could not be explained by fragmentation, uncertainties or experimental design. The results rather suggest a W-value of 32.10 eV +/- 2.6 %. Additionally, the abundance of secondary protons expected from Monte-Carlo transport simulation was not observed.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2014; v1 submitted 6 June, 2013;
originally announced June 2013.
-
Analytical expressions for stop**-power ratios relevant for accurate dosimetry in particle therapy
Authors:
Armin Lühr,
David C. Hansen,
Oliver Jäkel,
Nikolai Sobolevsky,
Niels Bassler
Abstract:
In particle therapy, knowledge of the stop**-power ratios (STPRs) of the ion beam for air and water is necessary for accurate ionization chamber dosimetry. Earlier work has investigated the STPRs for pristine carbon ion beams, but here we expand the calculations to a range of ions (1 <= z <= 18) as well as spread out Bragg peaks (SOBPs) and provide a theoretical in-depth study with a special foc…
▽ More
In particle therapy, knowledge of the stop**-power ratios (STPRs) of the ion beam for air and water is necessary for accurate ionization chamber dosimetry. Earlier work has investigated the STPRs for pristine carbon ion beams, but here we expand the calculations to a range of ions (1 <= z <= 18) as well as spread out Bragg peaks (SOBPs) and provide a theoretical in-depth study with a special focus on the parameter regime relevant for particle therapy. The Monte Carlo transport code SHIELD-HIT is used to calculate complete particle-fluence spectra which are required for determining STPRs according to the recommendations of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA).
We confirm that the STPR depends primarily on the current energy of the ions rather than on their charge z or absolute position in the medium. However, STPRs for different sets of stop**-power data for water and air recommended by the International Commission on Radiation Units & Measurements (ICRU) are compared, including also the recently revised data for water, yielding deviations up to 2% in the plateau region. In comparison, the influence of the secondary particle spectra on the STPR is about two orders of magnitude smaller in the whole region up till the practical range. The gained insights enable us to propose an analytic approximation for the STPR for both pristine and SOBPs as a function of penetration depth, which parametrically depend only on the initial energy and the residual range of the ion, respectively.
△ Less
Submitted 22 December, 2010; v1 submitted 26 October, 2010;
originally announced October 2010.
