-
Causal emergence is widespread across measures of causation
Authors:
Renzo Comolatti,
Erik Hoel
Abstract:
Causal emergence is the theory that macroscales can reduce the noise in causal relationships, leading to stronger causes at the macroscale. First identified using the effective information and later the integrated information in model systems, causal emergence has been analyzed in real data across the sciences since. But is it simply a quirk of these original measures? To answer this question we e…
▽ More
Causal emergence is the theory that macroscales can reduce the noise in causal relationships, leading to stronger causes at the macroscale. First identified using the effective information and later the integrated information in model systems, causal emergence has been analyzed in real data across the sciences since. But is it simply a quirk of these original measures? To answer this question we examined over a dozen popular measures of causation, all independently developed and widely used, and spanning different fields from philosophy to statistics to psychology to genetics. All showed cases of causal emergence. This is because, we prove, measures of causation are based on a small set of related "causal primitives." This consilience of independently-developed measures of causation shows that macroscale causation is a general fact about causal relationships, is scientifically detectable, and is not a quirk of any particular measure of causation. This finding sets the science of emergence on firmer ground, opening the door for the detection of intrinsic scales of function in complex systems, as well as assisting with scientific modeling and experimental interventions.
△ Less
Submitted 3 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Causal Geometry
Authors:
Pavel Chvykov,
Erik Hoel
Abstract:
Information geometry has offered a way to formally study the efficacy of scientific models by quantifying the impact of model parameters on the predicted effects. However, there has been little formal investigation of causation in this framework, despite causal models being a fundamental part of science and explanation. Here we introduce causal geometry, which formalizes not only how outcomes are…
▽ More
Information geometry has offered a way to formally study the efficacy of scientific models by quantifying the impact of model parameters on the predicted effects. However, there has been little formal investigation of causation in this framework, despite causal models being a fundamental part of science and explanation. Here we introduce causal geometry, which formalizes not only how outcomes are impacted by parameters, but also how the parameters of a model can be intervened upon. Therefore we introduce a geometric version of "effective information" -- a known measure of the informativeness of a causal relationship. We show that it is given by the matching between the space of effects and the space of interventions, in the form of their geometric congruence. Therefore, given a fixed intervention capability, an effective causal model is one that matches those interventions. This is a consequence of "causal emergence," wherein macroscopic causal relationships may carry more information than "fundamental" microscopic ones. We thus argue that a coarse-grained model may, paradoxically, be more informative than the microscopic one, especially when it better matches the scale of accessible interventions -- as we illustrate on toy examples.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2021; v1 submitted 19 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Finding the right scale of a network: Efficient identification of causal emergence through spectral clustering
Authors:
Ross Griebenow,
Brennan Klein,
Erik Hoel
Abstract:
All networks can be analyzed at multiple scales. A higher scale of a network is made up of macro-nodes: subgraphs that have been grouped into individual nodes. Recasting a network at higher scales can have useful effects, such as decreasing the uncertainty in the movement of random walkers across the network while also decreasing the size of the network. However, the task of finding such a macrosc…
▽ More
All networks can be analyzed at multiple scales. A higher scale of a network is made up of macro-nodes: subgraphs that have been grouped into individual nodes. Recasting a network at higher scales can have useful effects, such as decreasing the uncertainty in the movement of random walkers across the network while also decreasing the size of the network. However, the task of finding such a macroscale representation is computationally difficult, as the set of all possible scales of a network grows exponentially with the number of nodes. Here we compare various methods for finding the most informative scale of preferential attachment networks, discovering that an approach based on spectral analysis outperforms greedy and gradient descent-based methods. We then use this procedure to show how several structural properties of these networks vary across scales. We describe how meso- and macroscale representations of networks can have significant benefits over their underlying microscale in terms of information transmission, which include properties such as increase in determinism, a decrease in degeneracy, a lower entropy rate of random walkers on the network, an increase in global network efficiency, and higher values for a variety of centrality measures than the microscale.
△ Less
Submitted 16 February, 2022; v1 submitted 20 August, 2019;
originally announced August 2019.
-
The emergence of informative higher scales in complex networks
Authors:
Brennan Klein,
Erik Hoel
Abstract:
The connectivity of a network contains information about the relationships between nodes, which can denote interactions, associations, or dependencies. We show that this information can be analyzed by measuring the uncertainty (and certainty) contained in paths along nodes and links in a network. Specifically, we derive from first principles a measure known as effective information and describe it…
▽ More
The connectivity of a network contains information about the relationships between nodes, which can denote interactions, associations, or dependencies. We show that this information can be analyzed by measuring the uncertainty (and certainty) contained in paths along nodes and links in a network. Specifically, we derive from first principles a measure known as effective information and describe its behavior in common network models. Networks with higher effective information contain more information in the relationships between nodes. We show how subgraphs of nodes can be grouped into macro-nodes, reducing the size of a network while increasing its effective information (a phenomenon known as causal emergence). We find that informative higher scales are common in simulated and real networks across biological, social, informational, and technological domains. These results show that the emergence of higher scales in networks can be directly assessed and that these higher scales offer a way to create certainty out of uncertainty.
△ Less
Submitted 21 January, 2020; v1 submitted 8 July, 2019;
originally announced July 2019.
-
Structure-stiffness relation of live mouse brain tissue determined by depth-controlled indentation map**
Authors:
Nelda Antonovaite,
Steven V. Beekmans,
Elly M. Hol,
Wytse J. Wadman,
Davide Iannuzzi
Abstract:
The mechanical properties of brain tissue play a pivotal role in neurodevelopment and neurological disorders. Yet, at present, there is no consensus on how the different structural parts of the tissue contribute to its stiffness variations. Here, we have gathered depth-controlled indentation viscoelasticity maps of the hippocampus of isolated horizontal live mouse brain sections. Our results confi…
▽ More
The mechanical properties of brain tissue play a pivotal role in neurodevelopment and neurological disorders. Yet, at present, there is no consensus on how the different structural parts of the tissue contribute to its stiffness variations. Here, we have gathered depth-controlled indentation viscoelasticity maps of the hippocampus of isolated horizontal live mouse brain sections. Our results confirm the highly viscoelestic nature of the material and clearly show that the mechanical properties correlate with the different morphological layers of the samples investigated. Interestingly, the relative cell nuclei area seems to negatively correlate with the stiffness observed.
△ Less
Submitted 6 February, 2018;
originally announced February 2018.