-
Field investigation of 3D snow settling dynamics under weak atmospheric turbulence
Authors:
Jiaqi Li,
Michele Guala,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
Research on settling dynamics of snow particles, considering their complex morphologies and real atmospheric conditions, remains scarce despite extensive simulations and laboratory studies. Our study bridges the gap through a comprehensive field investigation into the three-dimensional (3D) snow settling dynamics under weak atmospheric turbulence, enabled by a 3D particle tracking velocimetry (PTV…
▽ More
Research on settling dynamics of snow particles, considering their complex morphologies and real atmospheric conditions, remains scarce despite extensive simulations and laboratory studies. Our study bridges the gap through a comprehensive field investigation into the three-dimensional (3D) snow settling dynamics under weak atmospheric turbulence, enabled by a 3D particle tracking velocimetry (PTV) system to record > a million trajectories, coupled with a snow particle analyzer for simultaneous aerodynamic property characterization of four distinct snow types (aggregates, graupels, dendrites, needles). Our findings indicate that while the terminal velocity predicted by the aerodynamic model aligns well with PTV-measured settling velocity for graupels, significant discrepancies arise for non-spherical particles, particularly dendrites, which exhibit higher drag coefficients than predicted. Qualitative observations of 3D settling trajectories highlight pronounced meandering in aggregates and dendrites, in contrast to the subtler meandering observed in needles and graupels, attributable to their smaller frontal areas. This meandering in aggregates and dendrites occurs at lower frequencies compared to that of graupels. Further quantification of trajectory acceleration and curvature suggests that the meandering frequencies in aggregates and dendrites are smaller than that of morphology-induced vortex shedding of disks, likely due to their rotational inertia, and those of graupels align with the small-scale atmospheric turbulence. Moreover, our analysis of vertical acceleration along trajectories elucidates that the orientation changes in dendrites and aggregates enhance their settling velocity. Such insights into settling dynamics refine models of snow settling velocity under weak atmospheric turbulence, with broader implications for more accurately predicting ground snow accumulation.
△ Less
Submitted 12 June, 2024;
originally announced June 2024.
-
Stochastic modelling of the instantaneous velocity profile in rough-wall turbulent boundary layers
Authors:
Roozbeh Ehsani,
Michael Heisel,
Jiaqi Li,
Vaughan Voller,
Jiarong Hong,
Michele Guala
Abstract:
The statistical properties of Uniform Momentum Zones (UMZs) are extracted from laboratory and field measurements in rough wall turbulent boundary layers to formulate a set of stochastic models for the simulation of instantaneous velocity profiles. A spatio-temporally resolved velocity dataset, covering a field of view of $8 \times 9$ m$^2$, was obtained in the atmospheric surface layer using super…
▽ More
The statistical properties of Uniform Momentum Zones (UMZs) are extracted from laboratory and field measurements in rough wall turbulent boundary layers to formulate a set of stochastic models for the simulation of instantaneous velocity profiles. A spatio-temporally resolved velocity dataset, covering a field of view of $8 \times 9$ m$^2$, was obtained in the atmospheric surface layer using super-large-scale particle image velocimetry (SLPIV), as part of the Grand-scale Atmospheric Imaging Apparatus (GAIA). Wind tunnel data from a previous study are included for comparison \citep{heisel2020mixing}. The probability density function of UMZ attributes such as their thickness, modal velocity, and averaged vertical velocity are built at varying elevations and modeled using log-normal and Gaussian distributions. Inverse transform sampling of the distributions is used to generate synthetic step-like velocity profiles that are spatially and temporally uncorrelated. Results show that in the wide range of wall-normal distances and $Re_τ$ up to $ \sim O(10^6)$ investigated here, shear velocity scaling is manifested in the velocity jump across shear interfaces between adjacent UMZs, and attached eddy behavior is observed in the linear proportionality between UMZ thickness and their wall normal location. These very same characteristics are recovered in the generated instantaneous profiles, using both a fully stochastic and a data-driven hybrid stochastic models, which address, in different ways, the coupling between modal velocities and UMZ thickness. Our method provides a stochastic approach for generating an ensemble of instantaneous velocity profiles, consistent with the structural organization of UMZs, where the ensemble reproduces the logarithmic mean velocity profile and recovers significant portions of the Reynolds stresses and thus of the streamwise and vertical velocity variability.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2024;
originally announced January 2024.
-
Imaging-based 3D Particle Tracking System for Field Characterization of Particle Dynamics in Atmospheric Flows
Authors:
Nathaniel Bristow,
Jiaqi Li,
Peter Hartford,
Michele Guala,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
A particle tracking velocimetry apparatus is presented that is capable of measuring three-dimensional particle trajectories across large volumes, of the order of several meters, during natural snowfall events. Field experiments, aimed at understanding snow settling kinematics in atmospheric flows, were conducted during the 2021/2022 winter season using this apparatus, from which we show preliminar…
▽ More
A particle tracking velocimetry apparatus is presented that is capable of measuring three-dimensional particle trajectories across large volumes, of the order of several meters, during natural snowfall events. Field experiments, aimed at understanding snow settling kinematics in atmospheric flows, were conducted during the 2021/2022 winter season using this apparatus, from which we show preliminary results. An overview of the methodology, wherein we use a UAV-based calibration method, is provided, and analysis is conducted of a select dataset to demonstrate the capabilities of the system for studying inertial particle dynamics in atmospheric flows. A modular camera array is used, designed specifically for handling the challenges of field deployment during snowfall. This imaging system is calibrated using synchronized imaging of a UAV-carried target to enable measurements centered 10 m above the ground within approximately a 4 m x 4 m x 6 m volume. Using the measured Lagrangian particle tracks we present data concerning 3D trajectory curvature and acceleration statistics, as well as clustering behavior using Voronoi analysis. The limitations, as well as potential future developments, of such a system are discussed in the context of applications with other inertial particles.
△ Less
Submitted 13 October, 2022;
originally announced October 2022.
-
Snow particle analyzer for simultaneous measurements of snow density and morphology
Authors:
Jiaqi Li,
Michele Guala,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
The detailed characterization of snow particles is critical for understanding the snow settling behavior and modeling the ground snow accumulation for various applications such as prevention of avalanches and snowmelt-caused floods, etc. In this study, we present a snow particle analyzer for simultaneous measurements of various properties of fresh falling snow, including their concentration, size,…
▽ More
The detailed characterization of snow particles is critical for understanding the snow settling behavior and modeling the ground snow accumulation for various applications such as prevention of avalanches and snowmelt-caused floods, etc. In this study, we present a snow particle analyzer for simultaneous measurements of various properties of fresh falling snow, including their concentration, size, shape, type, and density. The analyzer consists of a digital inline holography module for imaging falling snow particles in a sample volume of 88 cm3 and a high-precision scale to measure the weight of the same particles in a synchronized fashion. The holographic images are processed in real-time using a machine learning model and post-processing to determine snow particle concentration, size, shape, and type. Such information is used to obtain the estimated volume, which is subsequently correlated with the weight of snow particles to estimate their density. The performance of the analyzer is assessed using monodispersed spherical glass beads and irregular salt crystals with known density, which shows <5% density measurement errors. In addition, the analyzer was tested in a number of field deployments under different snow and wind conditions. The system is able to achieve measurements of various snow properties at single particle resolution and statistical robustness. The analyzer was also deployed for four hours of operation during a snow event with changing snow and wind conditions, demonstrating its ability for long-term and real-time monitoring of the time-varying snow properties in the field.
△ Less
Submitted 22 September, 2022;
originally announced September 2022.
-
Evidence of preferential swee** during snow settling in atmospheric turbulence
Authors:
Jiaqi Li,
Aliza Abraham,
Michele Guala,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
We present a field study of snow settling dynamics based on simultaneous measurements of the atmospheric flow field and snow particle trajectories. Specifically, a super-large-scale particle image velocimetry (SLPIV) system using natural snow particles as tracers is deployed to quantify the velocity field and identify vortex structures in a 22 m $\times$ 39 m field of view centered 18 m above the…
▽ More
We present a field study of snow settling dynamics based on simultaneous measurements of the atmospheric flow field and snow particle trajectories. Specifically, a super-large-scale particle image velocimetry (SLPIV) system using natural snow particles as tracers is deployed to quantify the velocity field and identify vortex structures in a 22 m $\times$ 39 m field of view centered 18 m above the ground. Simultaneously, we track individual snow particles in a 3 m $\times$ 5 m sample area within the SLPIV using particle tracking velocimetry (PTV). The results reveal the direct linkage among vortex structures in atmospheric turbulence, the spatial distribution of snow particle concentration, and their settling dynamics. In particular, with snow turbulence interaction at near-critical Stokes number, the settling velocity enhancement of snow particles is multifold, and larger than what has been observed in previous field studies. SLPIV measurements show higher concentration of snow particles preferentially located on the downward side of the vortices identified in the atmospheric flow field. PTV, performed on high resolution images around the reconstructed vortices, confirms the latter trend and provides statistical evidence of the acceleration of snow particles, as they move toward the downward side of vortices. Overall, the simultaneous multi-scale particle imaging presented here enables us to directly quantify the salient features of preferential swee**, supporting it as an underlying mechanism of snow settling enhancement in the atmospheric surface layer.
△ Less
Submitted 10 September, 2021;
originally announced September 2021.
-
Settling and Clustering of Snow Particles in Atmospheric Turbulence
Authors:
Cheng Li,
Kaeul Lim,
Tim Berk,
Aliza Abraham,
Michael Heisel,
Michele Guala,
Filippo Coletti,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
The effect of turbulence on snow precipitation is not incorporated into present weather forecasting models. Here we show evidence that turbulence is in fact a key influence on both fall speed and spatial distribution of settling snow. We consider three snowfall events under vastly different levels of atmospheric turbulence. We characterize the size and morphology of the snow particles, and we simu…
▽ More
The effect of turbulence on snow precipitation is not incorporated into present weather forecasting models. Here we show evidence that turbulence is in fact a key influence on both fall speed and spatial distribution of settling snow. We consider three snowfall events under vastly different levels of atmospheric turbulence. We characterize the size and morphology of the snow particles, and we simultaneously image their velocity, acceleration, and relative concentration over vertical planes about 30 m2 in area. We find that turbulence-driven settling enhancement explains otherwise contradictory trends between the particle size and velocity. The estimates of the Stokes number and the correlation between vertical velocity and local concentration indicate that the enhanced settling is rooted in the preferential swee** mechanism. When the snow vertical velocity is large compared to the characteristic turbulence velocity, the crossing trajectories effect results in strong accelerations. When the conditions of preferential swee** are met, the concentration field is highly non-uniform and clustering appears over a wide range of scales. These clusters, identified for the first time in a naturally occurring flow, display the signature features seen in canonical settings: power-law size distribution, fractal-like shape, vertical elongation, and large fall speed that increases with the cluster size. These findings demonstrate that the fundamental phenomenology of particle-laden turbulence can be leveraged towards a better predictive understanding of snow precipitation and ground snow accumulation. They also demonstrate how environmental flows can be used to investigate dispersed multiphase flows at Reynolds numbers not accessible in laboratory experiments or numerical simulations.
△ Less
Submitted 16 June, 2020;
originally announced June 2020.
-
On the mixing length eddies and logarithmic mean velocity profile in wall turbulence
Authors:
Michael Heisel,
Charitha M. de Silva,
Nicholas Hutchins,
Ivan Marusic,
Michele Guala
Abstract:
Since the introduction of the logarithmic law of the wall more than 80 years ago, the equation for the mean velocity profile in turbulent boundary layers has been widely applied to model near-surface processes and parameterise surface drag. Yet the hypothetical turbulent eddies proposed in the original logarithmic law derivation and mixing length theory of Prandtl have never been conclusively link…
▽ More
Since the introduction of the logarithmic law of the wall more than 80 years ago, the equation for the mean velocity profile in turbulent boundary layers has been widely applied to model near-surface processes and parameterise surface drag. Yet the hypothetical turbulent eddies proposed in the original logarithmic law derivation and mixing length theory of Prandtl have never been conclusively linked to physical features in the flow. Here, we present evidence that suggests these eddies correspond to regions of coherent streamwise momentum known as uniform momentum zones (UMZs). The arrangement of UMZs results in a step-like shape for the instantaneous velocity profile, and the smooth mean profile results from the average UMZ properties, which are shown to scale with the friction velocity and wall-normal distance in the logarithmic region. These findings are confirmed across a wide range of Reynolds number and surface roughness conditions from the laboratory scale to the atmospheric surface layer.
△ Less
Submitted 20 January, 2020; v1 submitted 4 December, 2019;
originally announced December 2019.
-
Particle growth in turbulent flow under dynamically critical Stokes conditions
Authors:
Michele Guala,
Jiarong Hong
Abstract:
A simple theory, based on observations of snowflake distribution in a turbulent flow, is proposed to model the growth of inertial particles as a result of dynamic clustering at scales larger than the Kolmogorov length scale. Particles able to stick or coalesce are expected to grow in size in flow regions where preferential concentration is predicted by a critical Stokes number…
▽ More
A simple theory, based on observations of snowflake distribution in a turbulent flow, is proposed to model the growth of inertial particles as a result of dynamic clustering at scales larger than the Kolmogorov length scale. Particles able to stick or coalesce are expected to grow in size in flow regions where preferential concentration is predicted by a critical Stokes number $St=τ_p/τ_f \simeq 1 $. We postulate that, during growth, $St$ remains critical, with the particle response time $τ_p$ evolving according to the specific flow time scale $τ_f$ defined by the vortices around which progressively larger particles end up orbiting. This mechanism leads to the prediction of the limiting size of aggregating particles in a turbulent flow. Such limit is determined by the extent of the turbulent inertial range, which can be formulated as a function of accessible integral-scale quantities. The proposed dynamically critical Stokes growth provides a framework to interpret particle aggregation, size growth and particle cluster growth in various geophysical multi-phase flows.
△ Less
Submitted 15 October, 2015;
originally announced October 2015.
-
Viscous tilting and production of vorticity in homogeneous turbulence
Authors:
M. Holzner,
M. Guala,
B. Lüthi,
A. Liberzon,
N. Nikitin,
W. Kinzelbach,
A. Tsinober
Abstract:
Viscous depletion of vorticity is an essential and well known property of turbulent flows, balancing, in the mean, the net vorticity production associated with the vortex stretching mechanism. In this letter we however demonstrate that viscous effects are not restricted to a mere destruction process, but play a more complex role in vorticity dynamics that is as important as vortex stretching. Ba…
▽ More
Viscous depletion of vorticity is an essential and well known property of turbulent flows, balancing, in the mean, the net vorticity production associated with the vortex stretching mechanism. In this letter we however demonstrate that viscous effects are not restricted to a mere destruction process, but play a more complex role in vorticity dynamics that is as important as vortex stretching. Based on results from particle tracking experiments (3D-PTV) and direct numerical simulation (DNS) of homogeneous and quasi isotropic turbulence, we show that the viscous term in the vorticity equation can also locally induce production of vorticity and changes of its orientation (viscous tilting).
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2010;
originally announced February 2010.
