-
Improved pressure-gradient sensor for the prediction of separation onset in RANS models
Authors:
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Ganesh Vijayakumar,
Ashesh Sharma,
Michael A. Sprague
Abstract:
We improve upon two key aspects of the Menter shear stress transport (SST) turbulence model: (1) We propose a more robust adverse pressure gradient sensor based on the strength of the pressure gradient in the direction of the local mean flow; (2) We propose two alternative eddy viscosity models to be used in the adverse pressure gradient regions identified by our sensor. Direct numerical simulatio…
▽ More
We improve upon two key aspects of the Menter shear stress transport (SST) turbulence model: (1) We propose a more robust adverse pressure gradient sensor based on the strength of the pressure gradient in the direction of the local mean flow; (2) We propose two alternative eddy viscosity models to be used in the adverse pressure gradient regions identified by our sensor. Direct numerical simulations of the Boeing Gaussian bump are used to identify the terms in the baseline SST model that need correction, and a posteriori Reynolds-averaged Navier-Stokes calculations are used to calibrate coefficient values, leading to a model that is both physics driven and data informed. The two sensor-equipped models are applied to two thick airfoils representative of modern wind turbine applications, the FFA-W3-301 and the DU00-W-212, with maximum thicknesses of 30% and 20% of their chord lengths, respectively. While the baseline SST model predicts stall (onset of separation) $3^\circ$ to $5^\circ$ late for all cases considered, the proposed models predict stall within the margins of experimental uncertainty, which greatly improves the prediction of the maximum lift generated. For the FFA airfoil, the models also improve the prediction of the linear region of the lift curve likely due to their improved prediction of a pressure-side separation at low angles of attack. The models are shown to generalize well across the two airfoil geometries (despite their difference in thickness) and across almost a factor of 10 in variations in chord-based Reynolds numbers from $1.6\times10^6$ to $1.5\times10^7$.
△ Less
Submitted 29 April, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
Adaptive Computing for Scale-up Problems
Authors:
Hilary Egan,
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Marc T. Henry de Frahan,
Juliane Mueller,
Deepthi Vaidhynatha,
Dylan Wald,
Rohit Chintala,
Olga A. Doronina,
Ryan King,
Jibonananda Sanyal,
Marc Day
Abstract:
Adaptive Computing is an application-agnostic outer loop framework to strategically deploy simulations and experiments to guide decision making for scale-up analysis. Resources are allocated over successive batches, which makes the allocation adaptive to some objective such as optimization or model training. The framework enables the characterization and management of uncertainties associated with…
▽ More
Adaptive Computing is an application-agnostic outer loop framework to strategically deploy simulations and experiments to guide decision making for scale-up analysis. Resources are allocated over successive batches, which makes the allocation adaptive to some objective such as optimization or model training. The framework enables the characterization and management of uncertainties associated with predictive models of complex systems when scale-up questions lead to significant model extrapolation. A key feature of this framework is the ability to explicitly utilize user-specified uncertainty priors, which we call model-specific local trust estimates, that are provided directly together with the problem specification and exploited in adaptive sampling strategies. A multi-fidelity model hierarchy is supported to allow trade-offs in accuracy and data acquisition cost while exploring the search space given a specified budget of potentially distributed, heterogeneous resources. We discuss application of this framework to problems in the renewable energy space, including biofuels production, material synthesis, perovskite crystal growth, and building electrical loads.
△ Less
Submitted 25 March, 2024;
originally announced April 2024.
-
An extension of Thwaites method for turbulent boundary layers
Authors:
Rahul Agrawal,
Sanjeeb T. Bose,
Kevin P. Griffin,
Parviz Moin
Abstract:
Thwaites (1949) developed an approximate method for determining the evolution of laminar boundary layers. The approximation follows from an assumption that the growth of a laminar boundary layer in the presence of pressure gradients could be parameterized solely as a function of a flow parameter, $m = θ^2/ν\frac{dU_e}{ds}$, thus reducing the von Karman momentum integral to a first-order ordinary d…
▽ More
Thwaites (1949) developed an approximate method for determining the evolution of laminar boundary layers. The approximation follows from an assumption that the growth of a laminar boundary layer in the presence of pressure gradients could be parameterized solely as a function of a flow parameter, $m = θ^2/ν\frac{dU_e}{ds}$, thus reducing the von Karman momentum integral to a first-order ordinary differential equation. This method is useful for the analysis of laminar flows, and in computational potential flow solvers to account for the viscous effects. However, for turbulent flows, a similar approximation for turbulent boundary layers subjected to pressure gradients does not yet exist. In this work, an approximate method for determining the momentum thickness of a two-dimensional, turbulent boundary layer is proposed. It is shown that the method provides good estimates of the momentum thickness, when compared to available high-fidelity simulation data, for multiple boundary layers including both favorable and adverse pressure gradient effects, up to the point of separation. In the limit of high Reynolds numbers, it is possible to derive a criterion for the onset of separation from the proposed model which is shown to be in agreement with prior empirical observations (Alber, \textit{$9^{th}$ Aerospace Sciences Meeting, 1971}). The sensitivity of the separation location with respect to upstream perturbations is also analyzed through this model for the NASA/Boeing speed bump and the transonic Bachalo-Johnson bump
△ Less
Submitted 24 October, 2023;
originally announced October 2023.
-
Near-wall model for compressible turbulent boundary layers based on an inverse velocity transformation
Authors:
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Lin Fu,
Parviz Moin
Abstract:
In this work, a near-wall model, which couples the inverse of a recently developed compressible velocity transformation [Griffin, Fu, & Moin, PNAS, 118:34, 2021] and an algebraic temperature-velocity relation, is developed for high-speed turbulent boundary layers. As input, the model requires the mean flow state at one wall-normal height in the inner layer of the boundary layer and at the boundary…
▽ More
In this work, a near-wall model, which couples the inverse of a recently developed compressible velocity transformation [Griffin, Fu, & Moin, PNAS, 118:34, 2021] and an algebraic temperature-velocity relation, is developed for high-speed turbulent boundary layers. As input, the model requires the mean flow state at one wall-normal height in the inner layer of the boundary layer and at the boundary-layer edge. As output, the model can predict mean temperature and velocity profiles across the entire inner layer, as well as the wall shear stress and heat flux. The model is tested in an a priori sense using a wide database of direct numerical simulation high-Mach-number turbulent channel flows, pipe flows, and boundary layers (48 cases with edge Mach numbers in the range of 0.77--11 and semi-local friction Reynolds numbers in the range of 170--5700). The present model is significantly more accurate than the classical ordinary differential equation (ODE) model for all cases tested. The model is deployed as a wall model for large-eddy simulations in channel flows with bulk Mach numbers in the range of 0.7--4 and friction Reynolds numbers in the range of 320--1800. When compared to the classical framework, in the a posteriori sense, the present method greatly improves the predicted heat flux, wall stress, and temperature and velocity profiles, especially in cases with strong heat transfer. In addition, the present model solves one ODE instead of two and has a similar computational cost and implementation complexity as the commonly used ODE model.
△ Less
Submitted 10 July, 2023;
originally announced July 2023.
-
Multi-agent reinforcement learning for wall modeling in LES of flow over periodic hills
Authors:
Di Zhou,
Michael P. Whitmore,
Kevin P. Griffin,
H. Jane Bae
Abstract:
We develop a wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) that takes into account various pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). The model is trained using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills with agents distributed on the wall along the computational grid points. The model utilizes a wall eddy-viscosity formulation as the boundary condition, which is sho…
▽ More
We develop a wall model for large-eddy simulation (LES) that takes into account various pressure-gradient effects using multi-agent reinforcement learning (MARL). The model is trained using low-Reynolds-number flow over periodic hills with agents distributed on the wall along the computational grid points. The model utilizes a wall eddy-viscosity formulation as the boundary condition, which is shown to provide better predictions of the mean velocity field, rather than the typical wall-shear stress formulation. Each agent receives states based on local instantaneous flow quantities at an off-wall location, computes a reward based on the estimated wall-shear stress, and provides an action to update the wall eddy viscosity at each time step. The trained wall model is validated in wall-modeled LES (WMLES) of flow over periodic hills at higher Reynolds numbers, and the results show the effectiveness of the model on flow with pressure gradients. The analysis of the trained model indicates that the model is capable of distinguishing between the various pressure gradient regimes present in the flow.
△ Less
Submitted 29 November, 2022;
originally announced November 2022.
-
Compressible Velocity Transformations for Various Noncanonical Wall-Bounded Turbulent Flows
Authors:
Tianyi Bai,
Kevin P. Griffin,
Lin Fu
Abstract:
This work assesses several popular transformations for the velocity profile through their application to several types of non-canonical compressible wall-bounded turbulent flows. Specifically, this work explores DNS databases of high-enthalpy boundary layers with dissociation and vibrational excitation, supercritical channel and boundary-layer flows, and adiabatic boundary layers with pressure gra…
▽ More
This work assesses several popular transformations for the velocity profile through their application to several types of non-canonical compressible wall-bounded turbulent flows. Specifically, this work explores DNS databases of high-enthalpy boundary layers with dissociation and vibrational excitation, supercritical channel and boundary-layer flows, and adiabatic boundary layers with pressure gradients. The transformations considered include the van Driest [Van Driest, J. Aeronaut. Sci., 18(1951):145-216], Zhang et al. [Zhang et al., Phys. Rev. Lett., 109(2012):054502], Trettel-Larsson [Trettel and Larsson, Phys. Fluids, 28(2016):026102], data-driven [Volpiani et al., Phys. Rev. Fluids, 5(2020):052602], and total-stress-based [Griffin et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., 118(2021):e2111144118] transformations. The Trettel-Larsson transformation collapses velocity profiles of high-enthalpy temporal boundary layers but not the spatial boundary layers considered. For supercritical channel flows, the Trettel-Larsson transformation also performs well over the entire inner layer. None of the transformations above works for supercritical boundary layers. For all the considered methods, the transformed velocity profiles of boundary layers with weak pressure gradients coincide well with the universal incompressible law of the wall. In summary, all these popular methods fail to deliver uniform performance for non-canonical compressible wall-bounded flows in the logarithmic region, and a more sophisticated version, which accounts for these different physics, is needed. The data-driven and total-stress-based transformations perform well in the viscous sublayer for all the considered flows.
△ Less
Submitted 2 May, 2022; v1 submitted 2 April, 2022;
originally announced April 2022.
-
Non-Boussinesq subgrid-scale model with dynamic tensorial coefficients
Authors:
Rahul Agrawal,
Michael P. Whitmore,
Kevin P. Griffin,
Sanjeeb T. Bose,
Parviz Moin
Abstract:
A major drawback of Boussinesq-type subgrid-scale stress models used in large-eddy simulations is the inherent assumption of alignment between large-scale strain rates and filtered subgrid-stresses. A priori analyses using direct numerical simulation (DNS) data has shown that this assumption is invalid locally as subgrid-scale stresses are poorly correlated with the large-scale strain rates [Bardi…
▽ More
A major drawback of Boussinesq-type subgrid-scale stress models used in large-eddy simulations is the inherent assumption of alignment between large-scale strain rates and filtered subgrid-stresses. A priori analyses using direct numerical simulation (DNS) data has shown that this assumption is invalid locally as subgrid-scale stresses are poorly correlated with the large-scale strain rates [Bardina et al., AIAA 1980; Meneveau and Liu, Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech. 2002]. In the present work, a new, non-Boussinesq subgrid-scale model is presented where the model coefficients are computed dynamically. Some previous non-Boussinesq models have observed issues in providing adequate dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy [e.g.: Bardina et al., AIAA 1980; Clark et al. J. Fluid Mech., 1979; Stolz and Adams, Phys. of Fluids, 1999]; however, the present model is shown to provide sufficient dissipation using dynamic coefficients. Modeled subgrid-scale Reynolds stresses satisfy the consistency requirements of the governing equations for LES, vanish in laminar flow and at solid boundaries, and have the correct asymptotic behavior in the near-wall region of a turbulent boundary layer.
The new model, referred to as the dynamic tensor-coefficient Smagorinsky model (DTCSM), has been tested in simulations of canonical flows: decaying and forced homogeneous isotropic turbulence (HIT), and wall-modeled turbulent channel flow at high Reynolds numbers; the results show favorable agreement with DNS data. In order to assess the performance of DTCSM in more complex flows, wall-modeled simulations of high Reynolds number flow over a Gaussian bump exhibiting smooth-body flow separation are performed. Predictions of surface pressure and skin friction, compared against DNS and experimental data, show improved accuracy from DTCSM in comparison to the existing static coefficient (Vreman) and dynamic Smagorinsky model.
△ Less
Submitted 3 May, 2022; v1 submitted 11 February, 2022;
originally announced February 2022.
-
Velocity transformation for compressible wall-bounded turbulent flows with and without heat transfer
Authors:
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Lin Fu,
Parviz Moin
Abstract:
In this work, a transformation, which maps the mean velocity profiles of compressible wall-bounded turbulent flows to the incompressible law of the wall is proposed. Unlike existing approaches, the proposed transformation successfully collapses, without specific tuning, numerical simulation data from fully developed channel and pipe flows, and boundary layers with or without heat transfer. In all…
▽ More
In this work, a transformation, which maps the mean velocity profiles of compressible wall-bounded turbulent flows to the incompressible law of the wall is proposed. Unlike existing approaches, the proposed transformation successfully collapses, without specific tuning, numerical simulation data from fully developed channel and pipe flows, and boundary layers with or without heat transfer. In all these cases, the transformation is successful across the entire inner layer of the boundary layer (including the viscous sublayer, buffer layer, and logarithmic layer), recovers the asymptotically exact near-wall behavior in the viscous sublayer, and is consistent with the near balance of turbulence production and dissipation in the logarithmic region of the boundary layer. The performance of the transformation is verified for compressible wall-bounded flows with edge Mach numbers ranging from 0 to 15 and friction Reynolds numbers ranging from 200 to 2000. Based on physical arguments, we show that such a general transformation exists for compressible wall-bounded turbulence regardless of the wall thermal condition.
△ Less
Submitted 16 August, 2021;
originally announced August 2021.
-
Grid-point and time-step requirements for direct numerical simulation and large-eddy simulation
Authors:
Xiang I. A. Yang,
Kevin Patrick Griffin
Abstract:
We revisit the grid-point requirement estimates in Choi and Moin [Phys. Fluid, 24, 011702 (2012)] and establish more general grid-point requirements for direct numerical simulations (DNS) and large-eddy simulations (LES) of a spatially develo** turbulent boundary layer. We show that, by allowing the local grid spacing to scale with the local Kolmogorov length scale, the grid-point requirement fo…
▽ More
We revisit the grid-point requirement estimates in Choi and Moin [Phys. Fluid, 24, 011702 (2012)] and establish more general grid-point requirements for direct numerical simulations (DNS) and large-eddy simulations (LES) of a spatially develo** turbulent boundary layer. We show that, by allowing the local grid spacing to scale with the local Kolmogorov length scale, the grid-point requirement for DNS of a spatially develo** turbulent boundary layer is $N\sim Re_{L_x}^{2.05}$ rather than $N\sim Re_{L_x}^{2.64}$ as suggested by Choi and Moin, where $N$ is the number of grid points and $L_x$ is the length of the plate. In addition to the grid-point requirement, we estimate the time-step requirement for DNS and LES. We show that, for a code that treats the convective term explicitly, the time steps required to get converged statistics are $N_t\sim Re_{L_x}/Re_{x_0}^{6/7}$ for wall-modeled LES and $N_t\sim Re_{L_x}/Re_{x_0}^{1/7}$ for wall-resolved LES and DNS (with different prefactors), where $Re_{x_0}$ is the inlet Reynolds number. The grid-point and time-step requirement estimates allow us to estimate the overall cost of DNS and LES. According to present estimates, the costs of DNS, wall-resolved LES and wall-modeled LES scale as $Re_{L_x}^{2.91}$, $Re_{L_x}^{2.72}$, and $Re_{L_x}^{1.14}$.
△ Less
Submitted 11 January, 2021; v1 submitted 28 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
General method for determining the boundary layer thickness in nonequilibrium flows
Authors:
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Lin Fu,
Parviz Moin
Abstract:
While the computation of the boundary-layer thickness is straightforward for canonical equilibrium flows, there are no established definitions for general non-equilibrium flows. In this work, a method is developed based on a local reconstruction of the "inviscid" velocity profile $U_I[y]$ resulting from the application of the Bernoulli equation in the wall-normal direction. The boundary-layer thic…
▽ More
While the computation of the boundary-layer thickness is straightforward for canonical equilibrium flows, there are no established definitions for general non-equilibrium flows. In this work, a method is developed based on a local reconstruction of the "inviscid" velocity profile $U_I[y]$ resulting from the application of the Bernoulli equation in the wall-normal direction. The boundary-layer thickness $δ_{99}$ is then defined as the location where $U/U_I = 0.99$, which is consistent with its classical definition for the zero-pressure-gradient boundary layers (ZPGBLs). The proposed local-reconstruction method is parameter free and can be deployed for both internal and external flows without resorting to an iterative procedure, numerical integration, or numerical differentiation. The superior performance of the local-reconstruction method over various existing methods is demonstrated by applying the methods to laminar and turbulent boundary layers and two flows over airfoils. Numerical experiments reveal that the local-reconstruction method is more accurate and more robust than existing methods, and it is applicable for flows over a wide range of Reynolds numbers.
△ Less
Submitted 19 February, 2021; v1 submitted 27 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
A new ODE-based turbulence wall model accounting for pressure gradient and Reynolds number effects
Authors:
Kevin Patrick Griffin,
Lin Fu
Abstract:
In wall-modeled large-eddy simulations (WMLES), the near-wall model plays a significant role in predicting the skin friction, although the majority of the boundary layer is resolved by the outer large-eddy simulation (LES) solver. In this work, we aim at develo** a new ordinary differential equation (ODE)-based wall model, which is as simple as the classical equilibrium model yet capable of capt…
▽ More
In wall-modeled large-eddy simulations (WMLES), the near-wall model plays a significant role in predicting the skin friction, although the majority of the boundary layer is resolved by the outer large-eddy simulation (LES) solver. In this work, we aim at develo** a new ordinary differential equation (ODE)-based wall model, which is as simple as the classical equilibrium model yet capable of capturing non-equilibrium effects and low Reynolds number effects. The proposed model reformulates the classical equilibrium model by introducing a new non-dimensional mixing-length function. The new mixing-length function is parameterized in terms of the boundary layer shape factor instead of the commonly used pressure-gradient parameters. As a result, the newly introduced mixing-length function exhibits great universality within the viscous sublayer, the buffer layer, and the log region (i.e., $0 < y < 0.1δ$, where the wall model is typically deployed in a WMLES setup). The performance of the new model is validated by predicting a wide range of canonical flows with the friction Reynolds number between 200 and 5200, and the Clauser pressure-gradient parameter between -0.3 and 4. Compared to the classical equilibrium wall model, remarkable error reduction in terms of the skin friction prediction is obtained by the new model. Moreover, since the new model is ODE-based, it is straightforward to be deployed for predicting flows with complex geometries and therefore promising for a wide range of applications.
△ Less
Submitted 8 October, 2020;
originally announced October 2020.
-
Control of long-range correlations in turbulence
Authors:
Kevin P. Griffin,
Nathaniel J. Wei,
Eberhard Bodenschatz,
Gregory P. Bewley
Abstract:
The character of turbulence depends on where it develops. Turbulence near boundaries, for instance, is different than in a free stream. To elucidate the differences between flows, it is instructive to vary the structure of turbulence systematically, but there are few ways of stirring turbulence that make this possible. In other words, an experiment typically examines either a boundary layer or a f…
▽ More
The character of turbulence depends on where it develops. Turbulence near boundaries, for instance, is different than in a free stream. To elucidate the differences between flows, it is instructive to vary the structure of turbulence systematically, but there are few ways of stirring turbulence that make this possible. In other words, an experiment typically examines either a boundary layer or a free stream, say, and the structure of the turbulence is fixed by the geometry of the experiment. We introduce a new active grid with many more degrees of freedom than previous active grids. The additional degrees of freedom make it possible to control various properties of the turbulence. We show how long-range correlations in the turbulent velocity fluctuations can be shaped by changing the way the active grid moves. Specifically, we show how not only the correlation length but also the detailed shape of the correlation function depends on the correlations imposed in the motions of the grid. Until now, large-scale structure had not been adjustable in experiments. This new capability makes possible new systematic investigations into turbulence dissipation and dispersion, for example, and perhaps in flows that mimic features of boundary layers, free streams, and flows of intermediate character.
△ Less
Submitted 8 February, 2019; v1 submitted 13 September, 2018;
originally announced September 2018.
